Helpless

Helpless (2012)

7.5
Your Rating:
-/10
Ratings: 7.5/10 from 247 users
Reviews: 2 users

Helpless (화차 Hwacha) is a 2012 South Korean film based on the novel "Kasha" (All She Was Worth) by Japanese writer Miyabe Miyuki, who is known as the queen of crime fiction in Japan. The story follows a man whose fiancée vanished without a trace just before their wedding ceremony, and he needs help from his cousin to discover her dark secret. It was previously known as "Help" (헬프, Hel-peu) and "Train".


  • Native title:

    화차
  • Also Known as:

    Train;Help

Add Cast Show More Cast (10)Cast

Write a Review Reviews

NewKDramaAddict
7 of 7 people found this review helpful
Other reviews by this user
Sep 20, 2013
  • Overall 9.0
  • Story 9.0
  • Acting/Cast 9.0
  • Music 8.0
  • Rewatch Value 8.0
You ever watch a movie and are totally shocked by what a person did but as you watch the final 30 minutes you realize just how desperate they were? This is that type of movie. As always, I must warn, this is not for every body. Sure there are elements of romance but the main story is a man's desperate search for his fiancee that he loves deeply. And what happens during read more that search is the story.

Lee Sun Gyun, as usual played his role as Moon Ho exceptionally well. You had no doubts of the deep love and under despair he was feeling as he not only did not know where his fiancee, Seon Yeong, played by Kim Min Hee was but as he researched and followed one lead after another, the story that unfolded turns out to be pretty, pretty...I'm not going to say, you have to watch the movie.

But Min Hee as Seon Yeong was extraordinary. I believe that her love for Moon Ho was genuine; however, her actions only reflected her deep desperation.

Sad movie but very well done. Not too often that I can say: I don't condone but I truly, truly understand.
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No
imfaerae
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
Other reviews by this user
Jun 29, 2015
  • Overall 7.5
  • Story 7.5
  • Acting/Cast 8.0
  • Music 5.0
  • Rewatch Value 6.0
The mystery in this film is done well. The story unfolds at a good pace as the detective gets involved and pieces of the puzzle fall into place. The point of view switches between three main characters and is told in real time as well as in flashback scenes. I sometimes wondered what was real and what wasn’t. The uncertainty of what was actually true grabbed my attention and was best part read more of the movie.

Though the movie focuses on the mystery, I was left wondering about the character development. In several scenes Lee Sun-Kyun’s character shows his frustration but the impact of these scenes felt flat for me. Their relationship as a couple is seen in a few quick scenes and so little is shown of his fiancé in the beginning it was difficult for me to connect emotionally with her disappearance. While I was curious as to why she disappeared, I didn’t feel the angst of it.

The driving force of the movie is the history and motivation of Kim Min-hee’s character. Her portrayal of the fiancé was excellent. Kim Min-hee plays her in such an emotional and multi-layered way I would have liked to have seen more. In particular, there was one flashback scene of Min-hee’s I found riveting. Instead of intense scenes like this, additional time is given to the detective work. The film is based on the Japanese crime novel, All She was Worth by Miyuki Miyabe and as an adaptation of a crime novel this makes sense. While interesting, I would have preferred to watch more than the brief and scattered scenes involving Kim Min-hee and definitely more scenes with her and Lee Sun-Kyun.

Nevertheless, what I believed to be lack of character development may have been artistic license to intensify the mystery. Though you see the fiancé, it is just enough that she becomes an enigmatic figure. Whether this is intentional or the acting abilities of Kim Min-hee were squandered is debatable.

Either way, Helpless is an intricately told mystery with a good mixture of psychological thriller and suspense. It’s a good watch and kept me guessing about the mysterious fiancé and how the story would play out.
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No

Make a Recommendation Recommendations

Both are a little dark, and a study on human's inbred action to seek their ray of light or happiness. Both involve murder(s) and changed of identities.
Recommended by zu_ai_grusz

Create topic See AllRecent Discussions new!

Be the first to create a discussion for Helpless

Comments (3)

  • Login or Register to post comments
  • Reply
    Queen_Makjang Dec 30, 2014

    This movie was amazing. I'm not quite sure what others were looking for, but this I had to watch from start to finish. Love the story, love the actors. 10.

  • Reply
    Taeil Dec 29, 2014

    its alright..

  • Reply
    NewKDramaAddict Sep 20, 2013

    Very good movie! But not for everyone. Remember, this is not a romance; not in the pure sense.

  • Reply
    romnin18 Apr 21, 2013

    I am speechless after see this "helpless" movie

  • Reply
    TheTranquilKnight Jan 27, 2013

    It could have been better, overall very good movie.

  • Reply
    Dream33 Oct 3, 2012

    it's really good movie

  • Reply
    zu_ai_grusz Jul 7, 2012

    A nicely plotted study on human frailty, when the soul is pushed on the edge of helplessness. Its a dark movie with compassion and love breathed into by the skilled Lee Sun Gyun and Kim Min Hee. I think it deserves your time to give it a watch (",

Details

  • Country:

    South Korea
  • Type:

    Movie
  • Release Date:

    Mar 9, 2012
  • Duration:

    1 hr. 57 min.

Statistics

  • Score:

    7.5 (scored by 247 users)
  • Ranked:

    #1564
  • Popularity:

    #5095

Recently Watched By