Details

  • Last Online: 17 days ago
  • Gender: Female
  • Location: City of Dis
  • Contribution Points: 27 LV1
  • Birthday: June 19
  • Roles:
  • Join Date: May 17, 2011
  • Awards Received: Finger Heart Award1 Flower Award1

vaberella

City of Dis

vaberella

City of Dis
An Inspector Calls hong kong movie review
Completed
An Inspector Calls
0 people found this review helpful
by vaberella
Jul 27, 2017
Completed
Overall 3.0
Story 3.5
Acting/Cast 7.5
Music 1.0
Rewatch Value 1.0
Quick background- I've seen the movie 1982 and 2015 BBC films and listened to the radio recording of the play. It is an extremely serious story that has high relevance on social issues, human responsibility, and common decency; not to mention the selfishness that lives in all people based on jealousy despite wealth, greed, rape, and abuse. Therefore, for me it was an extremely uncomfortable feeling to watch a film that holds such gravitas turn into a comedy; it's awkward. There was nothing comedic about the original story and the way the story was depicted here, even if it was trying to be comedic, seemed forced, trite, OTT, slap-stick, and just childish. It's a pathetic film that's a slap in the face to the intentional message of the original story. It's lost in this nonsense. The acting---I can't say anything about the acting. I mean, it's on point. If we're looking at being slap-stick and stupid, yeah they had it down pat. Donnie Yen was great at it...ridiculous and CGI'd. Han Zhang was a surprise. Everyone else was OTT as they should be. No one was on too serious. They were as a ridiculous comedy should be. Donnie Yen's song was great but out of place--maybe that was the point. It was creepy and kind of gave me a feeling of Twin Peaks there. I just didn't get it's purpose; I figure again it's for comedic effect. I gave it a 1 just for that. I would never rewatch this film nor recommend it. Overall, averaging all of the above components (they made me add a 1, but it's still counted as a zero) this adds up to a pathetic 3, just a waste of time. I'd watch the BBC originals in English over and over and over again. The two television versions and the radio version. They're just great film; short and breathtaking. I cried.
Was this review helpful to you?