Details

  • Last Online: 12 hours ago
  • Gender: Female
  • Location: Orlando Florida
  • Contribution Points: 60,292 LV47
  • Birthday: January 20
  • Roles: VIP
  • Join Date: September 2, 2017
  • Awards Received: Finger Heart Award9 Flower Award21 Coin Gift Award3

Old_Anime_Lady

Orlando Florida

Old_Anime_Lady

Orlando Florida
Meteor Garden taiwanese drama review
Completed
Meteor Garden
5 people found this review helpful
by Old_Anime_Lady
Nov 4, 2017
27 of 19 episodes seen
Completed 2
Overall 8.0
Story 8.5
Acting/Cast 7.0
Music 3.5
Rewatch Value 3.0
Please see the other review as I concur with most of its points.  I have seen Hana Yori Dango/Boys over Flowers/Let's Go Watch a Meteor Shower and now Meteor Garden.  I had to space months between each one to even want to ride the emotional rollercoaster again.  I will state this now HanaDan is still my favorite.  There is a new Chinese version coming out in 2018. It may have potential but somehow replacing MatsuJun/InoueMao chemistry on screen has not been recreated yet.

This has 27 episodes in one season and has more time to tell the story, it feel more natural yet the chemistry is not there.  You know he loves her, she hangs out with like 5 other guys while trying to distance herself from Dao Ming Si I am not sure that was in the manga, it sure wasn't in the other three versions.
This version has no amnesia and no "Lost in Snow" Incident which the other three did.

Lei's character (Rui) is ok TBH the Korean version fleshed him out so much better and while I love Oguri Shun as Rui there just wasn't much meat to his story.

Xi Men -The potters son/Tea maker/ who knows what his fathers job is in this, is an interesting story arc, and better done than Hana Dan this couple was my favorite in both BOF and MG.

So here's my recommendation Watch HanaDan for Domiyogi/Makino, watch BOF and MG for other F4 love stories.

Was this review helpful to you?