Kaptan

I am writing all these things for credibility. If you are going to make a simple series, you make it short, you don't bother to cast so many famous actors. You cast simple actors in your simple scenarios.

He may not be able to give the news immediately. He may be in a hurry. I agree. But he may say let me know, I am going there, right? Because you are going to a deserted place with a bodyguard. You are faced with a suspicious situation. Something may have happened to your master. You could not find either the master or his daughter. But hours later, they ask where Su Muzhe did not come and that is how they find out. Why is it not told immediately. This is simplicity. Second; Jin Ran and Zi Jing start searching and find the master's daughter. The master's daughter also says that her father went to the village. Why doesn't he not tell? If you are not going to come to a place where you work every day, shouldn't you not tell? If it is normal, it is normal. If he suspects that his father has been kidnapped, shouldn't he definitely tell? This is simplicity. He wanders around and doesn't stay at home. He doesn't tell either.
House arrest does not mean 24-hour surveillance. It may be. If you give that order, you have to follow it. I didn't make it up. If the scriptwriter wrote it like this, he shouldn't change what he wrote. Now, does he assign someone to watch? Does he put guards at the doors? They know that. But it turns out that there is no control. It's simplified. If you say, was there a prison in the house in this medieval geography, you should ask the scriptwriter about that too. If there is, it definitely needs to be controlled. Can he escape? Yes, he does. You find out and inform him. Now, hours later, Jin Ran, who gave this order, suspects Master Zheng after Su Muzhen doesn't return. I wonder why???? If you were suspicious, why didn't you follow this man. These are simplistic. The man who attempted to kill him, instead of keeping him in custody in prison, they keep him in his house, supposedly the owner and to mind his own business. We saw where he was looking.

The hooded person may have helped. The men may have been his men. However, I did not understand while watching this. The hooded person gives some orders, but the person says he cannot do it. Then you see an ambush in a deserted place and a bunch of black men bury Su Muzhe alive. The one who buried him is Master Zheng. I did not see the hooded person there.
This man is being held in his house as a suspect. A friend explained that there was no such detention at that time. Then the scriptwriter is telling us wrong things. If you are holding a man in his house, you monitor him, put guards on him, etc. The man does his job but he cannot go to kill someone. What kind of contradiction is this? It should not exist.
Second; Su Muzhe goes to a deserted place with a bodyguard to look for Master. Is it normal? It is not. They are supposedly suspicious. Wouldn't a suspicious person get more protection? Why doesn't he inform Jin Ran and Zi Jing. Why does he go himself. He cannot find the Master or his daughter.
However, after a scene, Jin Ran and Zi Jing ask where he is because he didn't come and find out, and they find his daughter, not the master. His daughter says that my father went to the village. Doesn't a glass master notify him if the glass doesn't come to the place he goes to every day, or if he can't come? If the master went, why doesn't the daughter notify him? This is also unclear. If you pay attention, Jin Ran and Zi Jing immediately suspected Master Zheng after the incident. They will find him in the next episode. But the hooded one took the bloody pearl and left. How did they find this? So is Su Muzhe stupid enough to carry this on him? So this episode affected the credibility of the series. I didn't like it. They simplified it. I don't like when the series is spoiled with such things. I don't like this simplicity.

Thank you for your explanations. It was very good, but I did not see these in the series we watched. So what you are saying is, in short, rich and noble people do whatever they want. The law does not apply to them. The darkness of the Middle Ages.

So why does it not apply to him, but to Su Muzhe's rich? Now Su Muzhe has taken Master Zheng's place. He has 3-4 shops. He does not care about money. He took Master Zheng's assets. Master Zheng is like an empty shell, so to speak. He can talk to the servants. He can. Because he has the slavery documents. They can never get rid of him.
However, those who said that I will give a lot of money to the servants in the previous episode and kill Su Muzhe are also saying that we will not kill them. How do they bury him alive in the next episode? Maybe you can answer like this. These are not them. This could be the case too. Someone helped. Other men could hire him and carry out this action. But this is not reflected to us. When it is not reflected, it is not understood what is what.
Let me also tell you another idea. Since Master Zheng wants to kill Su Muzhe. Why did he come to his house two or three times, even made fun of him, threatened him. He talked nonsense. He didn't kill him even though he was angry. They suddenly said, "Let's extend the episode, send him to the deserted roads with a guard, and he will gather 20-30 people, set up an ambush and kill him like that?" It didn't seem convincing to me. What business does Su Muzhe have with one person in the deserted places anyway? He is supposedly looking for his master. The master went to his village, or they kidnapped him. They kidnapped him but his daughter was at his house, Jin Ran and Zi Jing found her later. So why doesn't this girl say that my father went to the village, or that she was kidnapped, or doesn't she inform him. You don't go to a place where you go to make glass every day, you wander around, people are looking for you and finding you, look at your answer. Why is this simplicity? In other words, when you do something, you need to add a little bit of believability. Either when you write your book or a script, people read or watch it. Not everyone is stupid. I wrote like this, it happened like this. It could happen. It is his own opinion. But I did not believe it. My beauty, I could not find such things suitable for the series. If a series was made by looking at your medieval examples, this series we watched would be completely wrong. None of them would exist. Those women would definitely not exist. Even if they did, they would not be able to act like that. You have an answer for everything, the work is nice but it does not comply with the facts. The series does not comply. You made it up there, what will you do with women? There was no name for women in the Middle Ages. Sir, in our history, such and such women did such and such. Only a few. Very rare. It is impossible for things like in the series to happen. Thank you again for researching and finding and answering. But if you can reconcile some things by looking at both the series and reality, I can completely agree with you. But if you say these and such happened. So what will we do with the ones that did not happen? In other words, the series does not comply with the medieval examples.

Nice. You explained it logically. Someone might have helped him and given him his own men. I would understand if it was done like this. But there is no one checking, no one waiting. Zhang Jin Ran should have checked Master Zheng when making this decision. He should have had him check.

The second issue is that Su Muzhe is traveling in deserted places with one person. His own master is missing. He left. It is suspicious. In my opinion, he should have informed Jin Ran and Zi Jing. He should have taken more guards with him. You are both suspicious and traveling with a guard. It was wrong.

The third issue; Su Muzhe cannot find the master's daughter. There is no girl and no master. In the second scene, Jin Ran and Zi Jing find their daughter. My father says he went to his village. Since he did, why don't you inform him? It is very wrong. People who make glass do not come to work every day. Okay, one of them ran away. The other is at home. Wouldn't he say my father left? Or would he say something happened to him? In other words, it is a very illogical writing or scenario.

He is a suspect. He said he will not leave his house. He also said to his own servants that he will give this much money to the one who kills Su Muzhe. However, none of them agreed. Now, how do you explain why he armed them, kidnapped Su Muzhe and buried her alive? Is it that simple? If it is that simple, why did he come to her house several times. He would have had her killed. If that was the purpose, he would have killed her immediately.
Look, I wrote a long and reasoned explanation. However, the writer or scriptwriter has simplified these. He has written as if these events never happened. He has distanced himself from reality. He has lost his credibility.
What is more important is that those who kept him under house arrest never watched him, they did not put a guard at his door. They released him. A man who is tied up, has lost his money, and has fallen into a miserable situation, is bringing down a rising value. In other words, Su Muzhe should have had a lot of bodyguards. According to the subject and legend created by this writer. Just as these actions were proportional to Master Zheng's existence, Su Muzhe has now surpassed him. He became the owner of 3-4 shops but still wanders around in deserted places with only one person. Is that possible? You know, credibility. It didn't work. I don't agree.

At least this could have happened. He would have gone with a lot of guards. Everyone would have known. For example, Zheng would have gotten rid of those waiting for him, someone would have helped him, like the person you mentioned, for example, they would have trapped him, killed his men, etc. it would have been closer to reality. Someone wanders around in deserted places, the enemy would have put him in a coffin and buried him without hesitation. Oh, how nice.

He does all kinds of shit while under house arrest. Here, while someone is under house arrest and has fallen so low, and even his servants do not listen to his orders as shown a couple of episodes ago, I am now saying that this Zhang person, along with his many servants who look like assassins, buried a woman alive.
First, shouldn't the people assigned by Zhang Ji Ran be watching this suspect? Don't you check on a person you have imprisoned in your house?
Second: How does a suspect or a person who is considered a criminal maintain this power when there is no one around him and he has no money.
Third: Why does a person who has achieved everything travel through impassable forests and mountains with a bodyguard, why does he go looking for someone when he can hire many men and find them, why doesn't he inform anyone, in other words, when there is a suspicious situation, he doesn't inform these people whose names I mentioned.
Many more. I am not saying that it is written badly about just one thing. I am showing them all one by one. I think it is not convincing. Then, from now on, Shi Ciu should drown them all, throw them into the fire, and become the sole owner of all the shops, for example. Find a hundred assassins. Root them out. How? Isn't that very convincing? It's the same thing. I'm not joking. Add a little bit of reality. You can't write such scenarios or whatever with gibberish. It's too simple. It didn't work in my opinion.

Unfortunately, there were huge mistakes made in this episode as well. The scriptwriter and director, or the person who wrote it, ruined this beautiful series. Whoever thought of these things is completely wrong. I had previously mentioned that they fell into the desert after the ship for this series and some mistakes there. Now there are huge mistakes in this episode as well. The first mistake; Master Zhang is under house arrest. He was sent home by the judge's decision that he cannot go anywhere. However, it has been shown several times that Master Zhang is traveling. He does whatever he wants. Second: Again, Master Zhang tells his servants that he will give a reward to whoever kills Su Muzhe. None of his servants accept. They say they won't kill. Third: The same Master Zhang kidnaps Su Muzhe with these servants and buries her alive. In other words, he not only does not leave his house, he also commits murder. Or let's say he attempts to murder. The men who say they will not kill kill a woman. It is not clear yet, but they are participating in the same crime. Fourth; Didn't Zhang Jin Ran, who made this decision, take the weapons, swords, and cutting tools from this person? Since the decision was made not to go out. Isn't a guard or a team checking this? Aren't they waiting in front of his house? How is this man being controlled? Does the story progress correctly like this? Or don't you think there is an illogicality, a mistake? What kind of fiction is this? I mean, I did it, it happened. I want it that way. No one should see it. No one should hear it. So what? Fifth; the person working for Su Muzhe disappears without telling anyone. Isn't there any suspicion? We are already trying to do business despite the opposing groups, wouldn't there be a thought that someone could ambush us. They could kidnap our man? Of course, they searched and looked, but couldn't find him. Wouldn't this thought come to mind after that? Wouldn't any precautions be taken? The woman is traveling on roads where birds won't perch, where caravans won't pass, with one person by her side. Does it make sense? Or shouldn't Zhang Ji Ran inform Yan Zi Jing and go with a protection team? Or shouldn't they form a team and search? Did it have to be such a simple plot? It was far from convincing, far from reason, far from science. It was a plot far from everything. I didn't find it convincing or worthy of the series. My ratings kept dropping. It's a shame for the series. A man who lost everything makes someone who gained everything kneel. He gathers people, forms an assassination squad. Buries them alive. Give it up.

🙏

I usually prefer costume dramas and historical dramas. I watch them. I also congratulate the people who did this work. They achieved good results. But I also have a list, in my humble opinion.

Some of my favs
Drama: Nirvana In Fire, Empress Ki. Dong Yi
Melodrama: Nirvana In Fire, Empress In The Palace, Moon Lovers:Scarlet Heart Ryeo
Romance: Love Like The Galaxy, Mr. Sunshine, The Princess Man
Fantasy: Ashes Of Love, Immortal Samsara, Goblin
War: The Long Ballad
Action: Vagabond, Healer, Six Flying Dragons
Wuxia: Princess Agents, Jumong, Sword Snow stride
Romantic Comedy: Secret Garden, Mr.Queen, Queen In Hyun's Man
Mystery: Joy Of Life, Mysterious Lotus Casebook, The Double, Sky Castle
Thirller: The Judge From Hell, Luoyang, Tale of The Nine Tailed , Stranger
Political. Empress of China, Legend of Mi Yue, Legend of Hao Lan
Food: Royal Feast, Coffee Prince
Medical: Doctor Jhon, Heo Joon, Good Doctor
Life: My Mister, New Life Begins
Crime: Prison Playbook
Sci-fi: Tunnel, Signal,
Business: What's Rong With Secretary Kim, Destined.
Youth : Reply 1988, Reply 1997.

I agree. A very good observation. Yes, some actors cannot get rid of this image they have played for years. However, I wanted to state that Dilruba should play the roles she could not play and wanted to play, and that I think she would suit these roles better. I hope we see her in those roles as well.

I agree with your views. If he doesn't play those roles, how will we know if he can play them? A correct observation. I hope the producers see this and make offers accordingly. I want to see and watch him in these roles.

It is a very nice explanation but it is not REALISTIC. Unfortunately I cannot agree. She saw something that was kidnapped as a child, and she inherited it from her father and mother. She was between the ages of 3-5, or younger, what could she have seen. What could she have done? She observed her surroundings, she does not know her mother and father. Her mother, who educated her, taught her to read and write. She can teach whatever she can with her housekeeper identity. Because the girl dives every day. She sleeps or is made to work. As you said, she is already under threat.

I already said that she can recognize a pearl and interpret it. I do not say that the pearl diver does not know this. The only thing she knows is pearls. And those are the pearls she sees. The others are not.
Secondly, you can imitate one or two moves with a sight, but you cannot dance. Saying that she knows these, saw them, imitated them does not comply with the facts at all. We watched the same footage. I did not see anything different.
Thirdly; she was selling waste. The other robbers there were also selling waste. This is not a virtue. It may mean entrepreneurship or I have to get out of here somehow. But calling it a virtue is again not compatible with the facts. Not everyone who sells waste understands these things. In my opinion, there is an identity image that is entrepreneurial, cunning, bold, brave, and willing to do anything to get out of here. It is exaggerated.
Look; Some things can come from birth. What are these; Talent. You have a talent for drawing. Your writing is beautiful. Or you can sing, your voice is beautiful.
You definitely need to take lessons to develop these. Otherwise, you cannot go beyond improvisation. Finding education strange and putting it aside is the same as being disconnected from reality. A person definitely needs to receive education in order to develop. Otherwise, they cannot even take a step. I am one of those who believe in this. In other words, you will remain as you are. But I believe that this talent of yours must be developed with training, courses, traveling and seeing, learning from others. That is why I found some things exaggerated. Pure talent can only go so far.
You have also contradicted yourself. You said that it doesn't need to be taught in a classroom, but you graduated from university, started your career and became successful. I think you must have come to the conclusion that you did what you achieved on your own. Look, even DuanWu is not alone here. He has people by his side. Don't be so stubborn. Don't deny education, don't try to convince anyone that every person changes the world with their innate talents. Every person definitely needs to develop, improve themselves, and learn new things. If this doesn't happen, they will become dull. The condition for this is EDUCATION. I don't accept the opposite.

There he taught reading and writing, he is a diver. He fishes out pearls. All he sees is pearls. There is nothing after that. What can he learn in such a place? He learns to survive, to struggle, to compete, to work. What I mean is creative things, creative ideas, giving advice to people, opening shops, their knowledge about shops, their knowledge about ornaments other than pearls, diamonds, etc. Their relationships with people. Do you think it is right for someone who has never seen or experienced these things to give advice to someone who has lived outside for years and to lead them? These are a bit too much. I even said a few. I may have forgotten some. For example, being a hostess in a competition. What does that have to do with it? Coming from a diamond cave to such a place and performing various variations, dancing, etc. What else. Impossible things have been made to happen. Otherwise, the series is good. I watch it too. But are there many mistakes? Yes.

I follow the series. I really liked the beginning. The subject and story are excellent. But the reflection did not feel the same after certain episodes. It fell apart. The story of rise. It turned to revenge. Then it turned to travel to various provinces. It turned to the deserts saying we are going west. It turned to fighting desert bandits. Then it turned to rising moves in certain cities from scratch again. The story turned a lot. Or there was a lot of backsliding in reflecting it to us. Or that's how I perceived it. If it had stayed true to the story at the beginning. The series would have been more than excellent. Zhao Lu Si, on the other hand, only responded to this progress from slavery and touched on those issues in his interview, he did not mention jumping from topic to topic, is it normal for a slave personality to be so skillful? This is debatable. However, it is indisputable that he knows everything and understands the outside world. Because he has not seen or lived. How can he make judgments? How can he express his opinions, act like an expert? These things did not happen. The interview is nice but the series is not in the same parallel. The answers seem off topic. It is focused on one thing.
I will continue to watch it anyway. Even though the series digresses and our lead character is more crazy than he allows, it makes you watch it. Because its infrastructure is solid. It has a solid introduction. I criticized it because the flow was not the same. The acting is good. The shooting is good, the direction is good. There is a mess in the narration. I don't know if it is like this in the book, but if you put more on a person than he is, his credibility decreases to that extent.

O.K.

I said it didn't continue as it started, and I'm right in my opinion. There was a decline in the series. But I think it will pick up again. I wasn't happy that the story was left out of its essence. I wanted to point this out.

Thank you. I watched it. They returned to normal after two episodes. I'm continuing to watch.

Don't get hung up on concepts. I said that The Story Pearl Girl started to resemble Love In The Desert after a certain episode. It got into the desert bandits thing. I said this to explain that I don't agree with how the pearl diver thing at the beginning turned into the desert. Watch whatever series you like. I watched both. Good series. Watchable series.

I agree with what you said. However, as I said in my comment, I didn't understand anything in three episodes. I am middle-aged. I realized that it didn't appeal to me. No matter how hard I tried, it was pointless. I couldn't stand Esther Lu anymore. Unfortunately, it doesn't work. It doesn't work for me. You may like it. I respect it. She is a good actress. It can. It gave me the image of a children's series. I have endless respect for the viewers. Based on this, I commented on the comparison with The Story Pearl Girl. In my opinion, The Story Pearl Girl is much superior to Esther Lu's series in terms of subject, it is based on a certain story. It follows certain patterns. This series doesn't have that either. It doesn't appeal to me. I really didn't understand anything. It felt like a mixed series. It's mixed. I'm not going to watch it just because Esther Lu is being funny. It didn't work. These are my comments. Those who like it, please excuse me.

I couldn't stand it anymore. Thank you. I've grown tired of the series.