China's dating reality tv show - Highly recommended!
I like the Chinese version of Heart Signal much better than the Korean version. On the Korean version of Heart Signal, the commentators talk too much and for too long (most of the show, is the commentaries giving their feedback). It is one of the reasons why, although I've watched two seasons of Heart Signal Korea, I never made it to the last 4 episodes. However, with Heart Signal China, the commentary was very good (not too much, not too little). Additionally, the contestants on the show are kinder to one another, specifically the women. The men also seem more sure of what they want (I believe this is a cultural difference). Lastly, the women on the Chinese version don't do aegyo/sājiāo unless it's a joke. The only con to Chinese variety shows is the shallowness of the famous people. Mostly everything is focused on the importance of physical appearance and name brands. I hope globalization from the west (I am a westerner) didn't encourage Chinese people to be like us. SIGH!Note: There was no acting/cast. To be honest, I probably would never rewatch a reality tv show or dating show.
Was this review helpful to you?
A dating show filled with wonderful and mature people :)
Among all of the dating shows that I've watched heart signal s1, so far was my favorite. The members of the house we're kind to each other. I love seeing them grow and progress as a couple, and above all I love how their friendship grew as time goes by. Most of the dating show that I watched was full of drama and issue when 2 people overlapped when choosing a partner, but this show was different, it was full of wonderful people. I was surprised how their mature side was presented in this show. I have one last ep to go and I think the last episode will bring me tears. I personally think none of them should get hurt, they are wonderful people who truly deserve to get loved. But that's life...we always have to choose in the end.I enjoyed all the background music. I was surprised that the music are as great as love catcher playlist. The vibe is perfect on the scene. I love it.
Was this review helpful to you?
Predictable
I was able to predict who's going to be the couple based on the editing of the show. It's really predictable. Also compared to Korean Heart Signal, the commentaries are less engaging. The Korean heart signal are more on point in analysing the behaviour of the participants. The panelists guesses can't be trusted coz more likely they have errors on prediction. I enjoyed their lapses though.My favorite casts are Xiang Tian Ge, Gou Ru Bin and Li Jun Jie. If I were Li Jun Jie I would pick Ru Bin.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Fans of the South Korean version will appreciate the cultural nuances
9/10 is my rating. This is a 2018 Chinese reality dating show with 10, 85 minute episodes.First I provide a unique synopsis then review
Synopsis
This is the Chinese version of the Korean reality dating show of the same name. With some subtle differences mentioned below and the inherent cultural differences, the show is essentially the same in form and content. The show starts with six singles, three men and three women who enter the chosen house location one at a time the first day. They cohabit the “signal house” (which changes each season) with the women sharing one bedroom and the men sharing two bedrooms. The overall goal of the show is for the singles to go about their daily lives while freely flirting/sending signals with the other occupants of the house. There are few organized activities, the main focus is on them living together and getting to know each other more naturally. At the end of each day they send a signal (an anonymous text) to the opposite sex single of their choosing and the detectives must determine who will send a signal/text to whom.
Signal House rules
>Singles must return to Signal House each night
>Singles cannot reveal their age or occupation until the 2nd day
>Singles cannot directly confess their like or love at any time during their stay
>At the end of the day, singles can send an anonymous text to one other house member
>Singles can go on one official date but each female picks a location without revealing her choice and the males choose the location they prefer.
Detectives
*Note I say they were this profession or that because people change careers so this represents what they were doing at the time. This is true of the singles as well.
*Zhu Yawen Born in 1984. He would have been 33 when the show was filmed. He was an actor.
*Zhang Yugi Also known as Kitty Zhang.Born in 1987. She would have been about 30 when the show was filmed. She was an actress
*Yang Chaoyue Born in 1998. She would have been 19 at the time of filming. She wasan actress and singer. A member of the Rocket Girls, girl music group.
*Jiang Sida. Born in 1993. He would have been 24 at the time the series was filmed. He was a presenter and had a television show.
*Guan Hong. Also known as Darren Chen. Born in 1995. He would have been about 22 when the series was filmed. He was an actor and model.
*Jiang Zhenyu. Born in 1996. She would have been about 21 when the series was filmed. She was an actress, singer and dancer.
Singles
Females
*Xiang Tiange Student. Born in about 1993. 25 years when the show was filmed. Salesperson in the securities industry. Sales options. Has a masters from Columbia where she studied applied statistics. Works for one of the best security companies in China.
*Hu Jimming Born in 1994. She would have been about 24 when it filmed. Also known under the English name Diana. A kindergarten online English Teacher.
*Li Junjie Born in 1994. She would have been about 24 when the show was filmed. Drama major at a performance arts college. Served in the military for two years,
*Wang Jinwen. Dance teacher.
Males
*Zhou You Founder and CEO of an interior design company (Renew Design Company/UpdateStudio). Je was born in about 1986 and was 32 when the show was filmed. He majored in architecture and minored in design management Pratt Institute.
*Jiang Mingliang Also known as Oscar. He was 23 when the show was filmed. He was a model.
*Liu Zexuan. Born in 1989. 29 at the time of filming. Race car Driver. CEO of racing team.
*Guo Rubin. Founder of 17hiAPP
Korean Heart Signal Versus Chinese Heart Signal
In the Korean version they call those that comment and try to guess outcomes based on signals the celebrity panel or romance experts. In the Chinese version they call them detectives.
The “gem” the detectives get for right answers look like the plastic hearts you might get out of a coin machine. The detectives even make a joke about it and one pretends to eat it. In the Korean version the gems are much more elaborate and look more expensive. Since it is a reward for predicting right, the nicer gems would be a better reward.
There is a lot of flirty behavior going on with the detectives in the Chinese version. There are sexual innuendos and jokes about other detectives. In the Korean version there is little to no flirty behavior among the celebrity panel.
Among the detectives there is a clear leader that says when they watch, what and how they vote, and just generally steers the activity. In the Korean show they take turns leading the celebrity panel group.
When the singles first enter the house they arrive one at a time and the Koreans are visibly nervous and they talk to each other relatively nervously and very guardedly. I was surprised how quickly the Chinese singles started talking to each other.
The Chinese singles essentially have two names, an American like name and their Chinese name. Because my native language is English it makes it a little easier for me to keep track of who is who. But it can also make it more challenging as they intermix the two names for each single. Koreans do sometimes have multiple names, especially if they are an idol, but often totally adopt the nickname.
Astrology is big in the Chinese Heart signal version, they talk about astrological signs a lot. Koreans focus more on Myers Briggs personality type and blood type but even that is not a huge focus.
In the Chinese version they are more likely to stick with whomever they get associated with. Switching and dating around seems less accepted.
Review
If you are a fan of Korean Heart Signal you should watch the Chinese version as tge cultural differences create some interesting nuances.
I watched this after the Korean Heart Signal 4 which I found to be one of the most frustrating seasons of heart signal. It made the Chinese version all the more refreshing as they didn't as radically and dramatically change.
If you are a fan of Korean Heart signal you will definitely get more of what you love.
Spoilers
I loved that Jimming and Zhou You pretty consistently picked each other and were a final couple. That was a frustrating rarity in Korean Heart Signal.
I was so frustrated with Junjie’s fixation with Oscar. She was such a perfect fit with Guo Rubin and he was so sweet to her. Oscar made it clear he was more interested in Tiange. I wish she would have given up on Oscar when he was avoiding her. She called him on it. So she noticed it.
I think the show manipulated the selection date too much so the relatively new woman, Jinwen, would get a date. She was supposed to be a catfish and I thought if she could not captivate someone that was on her. Forgive me but I think some females use their tears to manipulate. She cried and made the other females feel so bad for yer that she ultimately got Jungie to bless her selecting Guo Rubin. He so obviously was not interested her in that way. They did not have a great date because Rubin was so disappointed it was not Jungie. So Jungie goes with Oscar and that derails the fragile relationship that was developing with Rubin. Then Jinwen more or less blames Jingie for her bad date with Rubin saying if they knew they wanted to go together they should have made it clear.
I think the situation would be incredibly hard to navigate emotionally without getting hurt and without hurting others. It’s such a unique situation for somebody to be in a place where there’s so many perfect choices that you have two people you know you could have a good relationship with and they’re great for different reasons. What a hard choice to make. You would have regrets either way. No matter what you do you know someone’s gonna be hurt and it makes it even harder when you like all the people in the house and feel like they’re at least friends.
Was this review helpful to you?
