This review may contain spoilers
Worth your time, but not very memorable
This show will leave you with mixed feelings. It's both brilliant and disappointing, poignant and underwhelming. There are moments charged with emotional intensity sandwiched between scenes of unreal cheesiness. Sometimes the show trips up over its own habitual need to make the characters look cool. Other times, it sells a human story of how grief and vengeance can share an unhealthy relationship with each other.I should start, perhaps, with the things that I enjoyed. The highlight was always going to be Park Seo Joon because how could it be anyone else? I watched him in Fight for My Way and he is even better here. His character is a sympathetic one, struggling to hold onto his principles because that is the only way he can honour his late father. Their relationship seemed interested but would have been better had it been fleshed out over an episode or two. Understandably, a lot needed to happen so this could not be done.
Kim Da-Mi as Jo Si-Yeo grew incredibly on me. Her character was the heart of the show in that as the story did, so did she as a person, learning to see the way as Park Saeroyi did. The show wrote her character - for the most part - really well and the scenes with her never disappointed.
I also appreciated how the show tackled tropes both in the social sense and how a kdrama show is meant to be. It delved into what it was to be transgender, as to whether ethnicity constituted nationality, rather too simply sometimes but quite well. The humanity of the protagonists shone through here. I also liked that the first love isn't the one he ends up with - although I'll get onto the problems of this later.
The music also complemented the show's tone quite well and bears similarities to Start-Up. But now, let's get onto the problems of which three existed:
1) the show moves too fast. A single episode can sometimes cover years. It leaves characters seeming static. Or sometimes a problem is encountered and then resolved too efficiently. Other things are not actually shown but swept alongside too quickly. How did they first fare as a new pub with customers was sped along. The business plan to go global wasn't shown but just told through an accelerated process. His time in prison. Throughout the show, there was this nagging sense of things rushing at a ludicrous pace while the characters themselves didn't change much.
The next problem is the love triangle. I liked Soo-ah's character at first. As an orphan, her need for survival as an independent woman was understandable. But we never saw her backstory so it was a case of telling rather than showing, which this show suffered from. The whole thing about her joining Jagga Co never added up to me and it culminated in her becoming increasingly hard to sympathise with. Had she joined to protect Park Saeroyi, it would have sufficed as an explanation, considering her own affection for both him and his father. But it was done by her need to survive. Which seemed strange because she could have done that anywhere else.
The show's rapid progress through time actually worked worse for her too. While others around her changed to some extent, she never did. She remained the quiet, silently suffering secretary of a boss she hated, a deeply immoral man who she wouldn't break away from. And so you come to realise that the love triangle wasn't really a triangle because there was no way she could have ever deserved Park Saeroyi. She never did anything for him, but instead for years waited, made him suffer, continued to wait, continued to serve a man who covered up the murder of someone who looked after her, and became increasingly difficult to sympathise with. Her conversation with Yi-Seo towards the end of the show highlighted this: whereas Yi-Seo was doing everything for Saeroyi, she did nothing. She might have been there with him from the beginning but she wasn't there for him. This was the underlying difference between both the women and why the love triangle, though done with nuance, became clear as to who would deserve him.
The final problem, which I'll keep brief is the conflict of the last couple of episodes. It was an unnecessary way to tie up everything because it didn't fit in with what the show had been doing. It was ridiculous and damaged my view of the show.
Was this review helpful to you?
The OST was one of my favorites, maybe even one of my top 5. My favorite song is Sweet Night by V and Begining by Gaho.
Park Seo Joon is one of my favorite actors and I loved how he played Sae Ro Yi. Sae Ro Yi is one of my favorite character in the show he very true to himself which and his values. He has a positive effect on people around him and which shows that he will never be alone again.
The DamBag gang in general is one of my favorite friendship groups. I would do anything to be a part of this group. They have shown how loyal they are toward each other and basically created this family. I love the leadership that Sea Ro Yi has in this group, he showed what it means to be a leader and it left the group with positive impacts from him.
YI Seo was my girl !! I freaking love her! She is such a strong woman and didn't take crap from anyone.
Was this review helpful to you?
BEST KDRAMA EVER
I had no idea what to expect before coming into this kdrama, but I was blown away. By far the most entertaining show I have watched this year. I loved the revenge plot, romance subplot, tremendous acting, ost, etc. Surpassed all my expectations, such a different and refreshing show. Just amazing, deserves this high review from me. I especially liked the main two actors, Park Seo Joon and Kim Dami. Park seo joon is usually the rom com king, but I really liked his performance in Itaewon class, he had lots of emotion in his acting. Now Kim Dami was equally amazing. I had never heard of her before this show, but I am excited to watch her future works based on her performance in this work.Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
The ratings were high and first few episodes were awesome. I had great expectations after i started but highly disappointed afterwards.Story:
The story was very good during the first half which is where most of the positive points come from. The friendships, trust, protecting people, learning from each other, growth - things were perfect in the beginning. The characters, cast, momentum - everything was going great but it went completely downhill from there. The show had a lot of potential but lost its way in the middle. My favorite character used to be Geun Soo. His character had so much potential to grow and contribute. I didn't understand why writers forced him to turn bad. His character wasn't like that. He was originally sweet, caring, compassionate and forgiving. Unfortunately, in the middle, writers took the track in a totally different direction. I didn't like how Saroyi and Yeo So totally ignored his feelings when taking revenge or even in the end towards the finale. Yeo So became very annoying. I loved her character but there weren't real learnings for her. She did good things just for her boss and never was shown actually learning her lessons. Remained inconsiderate till the end especially to Geun Soo. Geun Soo deserved much more. Didn't like the 7 year and 4 year leaps too. The growth of the company was much easier than expected. Expected more challenges there. Ending was horrible. Saroyi and Yeun So had no chemistry. I would have preferred Saroyi with none of the woman. Janggak Co was number 1. Could the chef really beat them so easily in the competition! Many things like that put me off.
Acting/Cast:
Cast did a good job in terms of acting. Yeun So gave a powerful performance as well.
Music:
Music was good.
Rewatch value:
I don't think I would rewatch it because by the end of it, I got really frustrated and wanted it to just end. First few episodes are wonderful.
12 episodes should have been good enough.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
First part is good but is rushed the second part
We watched the series to prove that he does not need to kneel down to those disgusting people. If he would do that just for a girl he magically love why can't he do it for his father which means EVERYTHING TO HIM. For the story? Well that makes the story shit. The pub was supposed to be used to achieve his goals and in that goal he has Oh Soo Ah in it (did not happen because of sudden changed of heart which is kind of a bad decision because he loved and treated Yi Seo as a little sister), To Destroy the Jangga Co. (somehow managed to achieve by destroying its core but decided to buy it), To destroy and make Chairman Jang and His Son apologize. (Make an old sick man on a cancer kneel before him which makes the whole awaited moment became the most pitiful moment, which is hard to swallow even if you know what that old sick man did at the momment). We also watched and I certainly enjoyed how the pub goes bigger and bigger by a single step but suddenly the time skip, also turns out that they stopped clashing with the Jangga Co. which makes no sense at all. Starting something and suddenly stop for a break and let the little pub grow bigger without us interfering. THAT IS THE WHOLE STORY ABOUT being bullied by the powerful just because they hated your guts, but then after sometime well actually no let's let them do their thing even he put my beloved planned successor in bars and after being humiliated by being 2nd on a tv series that hurts our pride because we are and we SHOULD be always at the peak, let us not be bothered. I mean WTH its the perfect time to take your move because he actually did something for you to get on your nerves then decides to do nothing. Now there is Soo Ah where was the first love the one who waited 15 years, the who knows it all and been there all the time but don't have feelings but actually do for Sae Ro Yi enjoying their rivalry but did not like both of them to win (LOL) being in the enemies side while being a dog of the enemies boss but was actually a helping hand. She is one of the reason why Sae Ro Yi wants to destroy the Jangga Co. because of what they did to both of them which is forgotten by the time. Did not get chosen, but here is the thing she also waited for the 15 years did not dated anyone, and is safe to say did not have a single relationship, INSTANTLY falling to a chef from the palace (LOL).The pub arc was good the only reason why I finished the last two episode because the building the pub from the very beginning while trusting your co workers to achieve things step by step was the best. I was thinking on how he can manage to defeat the No. 1 in the industry (which came out that its not a good way). First I was shocked that Seung Kwon beat the ass out of Sae Ro Yi when he is such a fighter (shows in the school days and should gain more punch when he's done all those job) but turns out to be an elite fighter him self that fills out the hole, and all the club moments were the best you can see them as a true co workers and it is God damn satisfying. Hyun Yi was the best! she resembles the looks of Jeongyeon of TWICE and acts boyish and I actually thought that she was a girl acting as a he but I AM DEFINITELY WRONG! I am a new fan of hers actually immediately search her to see if she is not a real thing but thankfully she a real SHE, going on her acting is so good and the being bad at first although cliché comes up good and the actually winning the contest is just satisfying. Toni is a needed additional he made the pub story more interesting the only thing is that his father was an idiot for not noticing they are RICH, or is just lying to Toni for no reason at all. Yi Seo on the building the pub is a good character which did care if her feelings is not returned and was clearly rejected the "it's not a business" thing but in the end swallowed and does not make sense at all, moving on she is really good at her role as a psychotic manager who will do anything to make the pub the No. 1 in the industry. Thought Geun Soo have invested in the "IC" and will use that as a card for later issue like how Sae Ro Yi did but turns out that was never an option and him being the instant villain is not that good choice because it was for naught. Geun Soo was suppose to be searching for someone to lean on and forgot all the things they've been through and the I belong to DanBam not in the Jangga Co. just for NOTHING. Soo Ah is also good at her role, being around at the pub while being boycotted is good (for me atleast) and actually being nosy on the pub makes the rivalry enjoyable.
Overall
It was a ok KDrama, if they just don't rushed it and expanded the grow the little pub little by little and get another season for better story it will be one of the best but the time skip really messed up.
Actors/Actresses is the best and did what they are supposed to do.
Music is great it can really hype the situation up.
But I don't really think I would rewatch it if not for the pub arc.
It was a roller coaster ride if it not ended like that would be much more fun.
Was this review helpful to you?
I'll start with saying that I'm no Kdrama expert. If anything, I'm a total newbie. That is to say that, I've no means nor any intention to compare the show or the actors to anything else. Now coming to the point, I did think of Itaewon Class as rather interesting in the start. But it went on to become unstable from interesting and then nonsense from unstable. While the first 4 episodes of the show builds upon the premise to give you hope, the final 4 epsiodes just ruins pretty much all of your expectations. I know it's called drama for a reason, but you expect it to satisfy the least of your expectations. On the contrary Itaewon Class managed to do practically everything I dislike towards the end. I actually do think that it's quite incredible in itself, not gonna lie. A story that could've become a lot with better handling and a romance that doesn't make much sense is self explanatory for everything the show did.
All that said, I actually do expect most people to like this, as I know my tastes are quite weird in itself and that the very thing that drives me to dislike this is what people usually love to see. But if I meet someone with my tastes and have to recommend it based on a scale of 1-10, I'll give it a 0, not because the show is particularly bad, but because I don't want someone else to feel the disappointment I felt. Just know that it's not everyone's cup of tea and watch without any expectations in particular, and that'll help you either really like it or at the very least not be disappointed.
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
12 episodes in, the unlikeable characters have become increasingly irritating to watch, especially Yi Seo. Park Seo Joon is the only one holding this drama and even then his character this time is naive and so idealistic it's eye-roll worthy. I find myself rooting for evil Jangga boss and his sons instead, that's how irritating the protagonists are. Too bad, I really want to like this drama because anything with PSJ is usually good.
Not sure if I will even finish watching, at 12 episodes with just 4 more to go I'd probably power through just to conclude and be glad that it ends, unlike other dramas which has left me sad that it ends.
Sadly, this is nowhere near as enjoyable as Crash Landing on You.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Had everything but 'class' ...
Ah .. where to begin.I went into this without even reading a synopsis, dove on into the murky water.
And what murky water it was.
First episode was .. interesting.
I feel the 1st person visual experience of the dad's accident was not needed; made me cry (my own dad died in a car accident).
The villainous son had such an odd look to him - almost like a modern joker in Korean form.
I can't put my finger on it, but his look was just off throughout.
I kind of felt bad for him b/c he was clearly mentally sick due to years of abuse.
Which brings me to the bad dad, the owner of Jaanga (or however you spell it).
He said he started the company so his family would never starve YET he starved his family of the most important thing - love.
He was horrendous to everyone around him, especially his sons.
And do people really get away with slapping others in front of a whole board meeting?
Such odd concepts of abuse scattered about that seem almost over kill (for lack of a better word).
He was a vile creature and the actor portraying him did a great job pulling off the sliminess of the character.
The ML was nothing too special - his feelings were kind of all over the place in the end.
And what was with the romance angle?
His first love choice was just weird; selfish, self centered, and grossly contradicted his core persona.
Then the FL was obnoxious, had horrible hair (distracting throughout), was creepy stalker-ish with ML, completely unprofessional, and her overall role was just ridiculous.
How is a teenager (with no societal status other than social media followers) leading corporate big wigs around, calling the shots?
And then the "woke" concepts they tried to fit in this ... *smh*
There were several that could've been left out.
The story was all over the place already and the side issues were flung in there with no rhyme or reason.
There was no chemistry, no romance, very little solid story to go off of, and outlandish business scenarios.
The music was not that great .. intro song grated my nerves.
Eh .. it was a weekend watch that ended up not being very enjoyable.
Just more garbage churned out by Netflix.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
I started watching this drama for my great love for food, cooking and Park Seo Joon and I just finished it. I wanted to write a review for a long time but I waited to finish this. IT IS PERFECT. The story is really nice and refreshing, with the right amount of drama and cuteness. Everything makes sense and you won't skip even one thing. The caracters are amazing, with great development, everyone even the side characters has a backstory. They use great with all the seriousness and in the right directions themes like powerful yet sensitive women (Ms. Kang, Grandma, Soo Ah, Yi Seo etc), a black character and a trans character in the main cast. I never saw something like this in any other drama. And the cast was perfect for everyone, with special credit to Park Seo Joon and the "Jang family" Yoo Jae Myung, Ahn Bo Hyun, Kim Dong Hee. Also, really good soundtracks with a lot of emotions.And as an architect, I really couldn't forget the really nice scenery and plans. A lot of Itaewon and you feel like you are there even if you never went.
Overall it is a really nice drama which ends with a comforting feeling. No character is good and bad, make mistakes and underastands the meaning and the concequences of them. Besides, that's how life works.
(I'm sorry for any mistakes. English is not my first language)
Was this review helpful to you?
