This review may contain spoilers
Entertaining but lacking
Overall, a pretty entertaining show with some good visuals and action. Love the premise of the show, just wish it was executed differently. I haven't read the webtoon, so I'm reviewing solely the show itself.First off, I agree with many other people who think that adding the Imagine Dragons song to dramatic scenes was a little unfitting to say the least. Ruined some of the dramatic moments, but still, not that big of a deal for me. My problem was with the way they develop Song Kang's character, Hyun-su.
I was under the impression that Hyun-su was going to be the main character and have a lot of scenes. Unfortunately, with such a large ensemble cast, he was often pushed to the side in order to focus on the other 10 main characters (not to mention the side character's screentime). They gave Hyun-su a very sad and dramatic backstory that looked like it was going to develop as the show progressed, allowing him to overcome his demons and possibly utilize it to help others. Although he does help others intermittently throughout the show, he rarely gets any satisfying scenes where he saves the others and is often the one who is needing saving in the first place. Most of the main cast were given strong characters who are capable and have their moments to showcase their strengths, whereas Hyun-su didn't really get any satisfying moments (except at the very end).
Even at the end of the show (spoiler warning), I was expecting Hyun-su to do something dramatic and possibly sacrifice himself to save the others, showing them that he was a good person even if he was labeled a "monster". This doesn't really happen, and his climactic ending moments are overshadowed with the "sacrifice" of the other main character, Eun-hyeok. Speaking of, I don't understand the need for Eun-hyeok to even sacrifice himself in the first place. He could of gone with the others to safety, but instead he decided to sit in a room and die for no reason? I don't know, maybe I'm missing something (I was often confused by the plot). This just overshadowed Hyun-su's part that could have been so much more impactful.
In general, that is my biggest complaint about this show. I understand the need to showcase all of the characters in this large cast, but I feel like they could have done so much more with Song Kang's character. There was so much potential to develop him into something great, like having him transform at the end and sacrifice himself to save the others as a clear indication of him accepting himself and having grown as a person, but instead he just leaves. Not really a sacrifice, no recognition or satisfying ending, and doesn't even get to prove to the others who judged him that he was truly a good person and could control his inner demons. Even the whole relationship between Hyun-su and Eun-yu could have been more impactful at the very end if they didn't unnecessarily throw in Eun-hyeok's death.
Overall, decent story with some hard to follow plot progression and plotholes, great acting, questionable music choices, good effects and animations, good action, but with the unrecognized potential of the character of Hyun-su.
Was this review helpful to you?
this is the new level monster story
From the rotten fish scene, I knew this one would be interesting.The monsters are scary and yet your eyes fixed on the amazing details that they have done. They are even beautiful to watch in a way.
Korean drama has raised the bar again because this is not just a simple fighting and running away from monsters kind of movie but with lots of human elements which make the story much more meaningful and impactful (like Train to Busan).
There is not a second to be bored and you will finish it in a day.
Was this review helpful to you?
Very Overrated
The story is extremely slow. Nothing actually happens. the length could be restricted to max 3 episodes even with fillers.I think there was a vague concept of how unchecked human desires cause to become monsters (in various senses). But it was not touched upon, at all. There was close to no plot in the show. Everyone was just trying not to get killed. ML's backstory is touched upon a bit, we see the BEGINNING of a character arc towards the end of the show. The whole concept of why ML is special is because he literally has no thoughts, cause his mental health was already very bad, before the pandemic/acopolypse hit. So he doesnt have desires. So he cant turn into a monster. (like go crazy and kill other people)
And reading on the reviews of the following seasons, i gathered that s1 is actually one of the better seasons.
So im gonna stop here.
Theres nothing sweet about this home. It not even homely..
All the side characters (almost all) are killed. Even the ones with interesting backstories and possibilities of role in the story arc.
Was this review helpful to you?
A big win for Netflix !
Don't bother with positive comments from webtoon fans, or the bad critics, this series is really cool.and it worth every second of your life
the ones who disliked it just didn't understand the series, or didn't even complete it, prob just a stupid brains,
I CAN SAY NOW, THAT I'll DIE HAPPY NOW !
just waiting for season 2 now, hopeful it will be amazing as season 1
it just get 1.4 Billion views from the world, do you what it means ?, it's a really 2ufh29ef9e2fo;2efjifwuf9weu just watch it or die !
Was this review helpful to you?
Promising and popular, but can be slow at times
I started Sweet Home after hearing how popular it is and my friends' recommending it. I loved how different each monster was and the CG of how real it looked. The story is also quite unique as it does go into the depth of each of the character's personality and backstory.However, I wish that they answered more of the questions around "why?". I felt like I was confused most of the time in the drama and some episodes can be quite slow. The pacing is quite odd as it starts off with a great concept and then slows down until the last 2 episodes.
Still, the acting was really solid and so was that soundtrack, especially when a monster approached. I might check out the webtoon too.
Was this review helpful to you?
Good Enough
Korean Drama 'Sweet Home' has awful CGI, but it makes up with the on-point atmosphere. The settings, the costumes, the music, the performances, everything is and feels perfect, as the group of residence is trying to survive. However, this season felt more like the introduction, as we start to get to know each character and bond with them, without, nevertheless, getting too deep into the mystery of what is happening and why and how to move forward. Still, this season sets strong foundations for those to come.In addition, everything is well constructed, with enough screen time for each character and each storyline. The pace is also perfect for the action element of the story. Finally, the performances were all quite emotional.
So, overall, 7 out of 10.
Was this review helpful to you?
Is it a good show? Maybe. But something is off.
First of all, english isn't my mother language, but i hope everyone at least know what I mean. I think nowadays, almost all tv shows which have good ratings, just part of hype, in fact not all of them is really good. After watching 2 ep, this show is pure action, and i quickly noticed something is off, which is, the logical action of the character based on situation. Enter Lee eun-hyuk. This guy shares a room with his sister. One night, he told her he was going to work. At ground level, he found some occupants grouping together & they seem can't get out. Then a monster attack. Tell me, in your logic, what should the guy do? First he tries to help others to fend off the monster & close the door. Pretty logical. Then he groups up with other. He forbids anyone opening the door to leave. Ok. He goes to security room and watches the monitors. He sits there with others & planning what to do. Errr...wait, did you say he has a sister?Yep, that's exactly why i told you something is off with this tv show. The character doesn't act logically enough. Does he forget he has a sister up there? And when her sister finally goes downfloor, he just hands her a shirt for cover. No talk. Nothing.
Was this review helpful to you?
Eletrizante
Esse drama realmente conquistou meu coração, prendeu minha atenção todo o tempo desde sua abertura inicial até a musica do fechamento. Não desgrudei do sofá momento nenhum, foi realmente fácil de assisti, tudo desenrolar flui muito bem num ritmo bom que não te deixava ficar entediado.Com uma produção e direção boa e um roteiro bem interessante esse show te prende na história facilmente, os efeitos visuais também me agradaram muito, parecia que estava dentro de um vídeo game meu coração saltava ainda mais nas cenas de ação , cara realmente eletrizante, foi fácil imergir na trama. Tenho também que enaltecer a ost , pois contribuiu muito eu adorei essa trilha sonora.
Tudo é tão bem colocado nesses 10 episódios e mesmo que você não entenda a principio depois é explicado nos próximos episódios, digo isso pois teve alguns personagens com quais eu não gostava de primeira e não entendia suas ações mais logo o drama trata de mostrar a verdadeira historia por trás de determinada ação. Foi nesse ponto que me senti mais atraída pelas historias e seus personagens, pois eles eram complexos e interessantes no seu geral, gostei bem dos personagens, as atuações foram muito boas .
O Protagonista masculino deu um banho de atuação também, seu desenvolvimento ao longo dos episódios foi interessante de assistir , com seu passado pesado e com a nova situação na qual ele encontrava fez ele evoluir em diferentes modos. Gostei muito pois ele é aquele protagonista fora dos padrões. Só não dou nota 10 pois ainda quero mais respostas, estou no aguardo da segunda temporada.
Em fim recomendo, leia essa resenha e vá assistir logo.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Très chère Violence, je vous dis BONJOUR !
Avant de commencer cette critique, il faut savoir que j'aime beaucoup le genre trash/gore ainsi que l'horreur (Comprenez que j'en ai donc vu pas mal, asiatique comme américain). Par contre, j'ai plus de mal avec la science-fiction (Oui, parce que pour moi "Sweet Home" est clairement une situation "Postapocalyptique" et donc de la S-F), mis à part la dystopie (Et oui, je préfère le fantastique ou la fantasy à la S-F, chacun ses défauts hein !).Concernant le drama, encore une fois, je n'ai jamais lu le Webtoon (comme la plupart du temps, car l'original étant souvent meilleur, je préfère voir le moins bon d'abord x'D). De ce fait, mon opinion ne sera pas influencée par une autre source que le drama.
Rentrons enfin dans le vif du sujet en montrant les éléments forts du drama :
• Un décor "postapocalyptique" assez représentatif de ce qu'on attend du genre ! (C'est à dire de la destruction & des survivants)
• Des survivants des plus sympathiques... (ba oui, il faut savoir qu'être sympas est synonyme de mort imminente... Donc bien sûr, les gens préfèrent être sans cœur et laisser des gens mourir pour les sauver.)
Je retiens particulièrement le passage où "Sang-Wook" (Lee Jin-Wook) tabasse à mort un homme (bon, d'accord c'est un meurtrier mais quand même !) et finis par le jeter dehors pour qu'il soit dévoré par les monstres... Quatre personnes voient ce spectacle mais personne ne bouge !
Cela m'a rappelé un "syndrome" que j'avais vu en cours alors que j'étais adolescence : "Le syndrome de Kitty Genovese" aussi appelé "l'effet du témoin". Il s'agit de l'effet de plusieurs personnes qui voient un drame mais se dédouanent de toutes responsabilités car ils espèrent que quelqu'un interviendra... Ce drama montre bien cet effet perfide.
• De la violence à gogo !
• Une tentative de viol... (Bon sérieux ? C'est obligatoire de prendre les femmes pour des objets ?)
• Effets spéciaux plus que... inégaux ! (J'ai malgré tout aimé la transformation de Hyun-Su) Et ne parlons pas de cette hémoglobine à tout va ! (Bien sûr, nous sommes dans du trash... Mais du trash non convaincant avec du sang qui coulent en cascade, ne m'inspire pas des masses :D)
Je dois dire que ce drama m'a laissé un gout amer par moment... J'ai souvent trouvé qu'on nous montrait le pire de l'être humain. Les situations étaient peu reluisantes et horribles humainement parlant... (Oui, car visuellement je n'ai pas vraiment été dérangée bien que cela soit des scènes glauques à répétition)
Et le casting dans tout ça me direz-vous ? Netflix a peut-être un peu trop misé sur la notoriété de son casting... (Car il est rare que je connaisse autant d'acteurs dans une production...) Néanmoins, j'ai trouvé qu'ils se débrouillaient malgré tout pour se démarquer. J'ai d'ailleurs été convaincue par Hyun-Su (Song Kang), le désespoir qui l'habitait ne pouvait être manqué.
Pour finir, c'est un drama que j'ai apprécié visionner. Cependant, l'effet américanisé est beaucoup trop fort, je suis loin d'être habituée à ce genre de production par des pays asiatique qui misent souvent plus sur le psychologique que sur le trash des situations !
Ha oui, j'oubliais... C'est quoi cette fin sans queue ni tête ?! Est-ce un indice pour dire qu'il y aura une suite ? Nous verrons bien =D !
Was this review helpful to you?
«Sweet Home» m’a surprise. Je ne m’attendais pas à vraiment aimer, et encore moins à dévorer les épisodes comme je l’ai fait, sachant que le genre ‘horreur’ n’est pas celui que je préfère, bien au contraire. L’histoire est originale, se passant en huis clos dans un bâtiment d’appartements et avec plusieurs des résidents comme personnages centraux, intéressante, pleine de suspense et d’actions, tout en réussissant également à être touchante par moments. Le début a été un peu lent, établissant la base, présentant les personnages un peu, etc. Mais le rythme s’accélère très rapidement ensuite, quand la réalité de la ‘monsterisation’ commence. Le tout, comme je disais, a donné un drama qui m’a surprise, et que j’ai fini par regarder en très peu de temps, vu ma curiosité de savoir ce qui allait arriver, comment tout allait se finir ! Je ne m’attendais pas à ça, mais je suis ravie d’avoir découvert « Sweet Home » !
⁘⁛⁘⁛⁘⁛⁘⁛⁘⁛⁘⁛⁘⁛⁘⁛⁘⁛⁘
Avis Complet sur mon Blog :
https://lamagiedeshistoires.wordpress.com/2024/08/20/sweet-home-%e2%81%9e-saison-1-avis/
Was this review helpful to you?
¿Cuál fue la necesidad?
Debo aclarar desde ahora que soy lectora del Webtoon, así que mi opinión se basa en comparar ambas versiones.Como fan de "Sweet Home" en Webtoon, esta versión me dejo muy desilusionada. La escencia del Webtoon está pero le cambiaron muchas cosas que hasta cierto punto parece ser otra historia y por desgracia, no le hace justicia a la original.
En el k-drama hay un punto en el que se puso algo aburrido para mí, lo que hace que mi interes disminuyera. La relación entre personajes... bueno, pudo ser mejor porque no sentí por completo la química entre ellos. Los efectos y los monstruos son los que me decepcionaron más, entiendo que son criaturas complejas y que no sería facíl recrearlos pero pudo ser mejor. Incluso, faltaron montruos porque son mucho más los que van apareciendo.
No tengo ni idea cómo van a manejar la segunda temporada, tenía esperanza que en esta segunda pudieran hacer referencia a "Shutgun boy" (precuela) ya que en esta se explica cómo surge todo este "virus" pero por como terminó, lo dudo mucho.
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
