La Reine des Larmes (2024)

Beau, intense… mais pas inoubliable pour moi...

J’vais être honnête… j’ai lancé "Queen of Tears" en mode “Ok, je suis prête à vivre LE chef-d'œuvre dont tout le monde parle” 😮‍💨✨ J’étais ultra bouillante, entre le casting de rêve, les teasers à tomber et la hype de malade sur les réseaux. Mon cœur était en mode : battements maximum...😍

Et puis… j’ai regardé. Et il a pas vibré comme je l’espérais 😬🥲

Alors oui, c’est beau. Oui, c’est classe. Oui, c’est ultra bien joué. Mais j’ai attendu une tempête émotionnelle et j’ai eu une pluie tiède 🌧️ Rien de catastrophique, hein. Juste... j’ai pas été foudroyée, et ça m’a laissée un peu à côté... 🤷🏼‍♀️

On suit un couple en crise avec des secrets de famille, des enjeux d’héritage, et une romance censée tout traverser 💔 Ça aurait dû être poignant, ça aurait dû m’achever… mais j’ai jamais réussi à me connecter à fond...

Et pourtant ! Kim Soo Hyun donne tout. Il est touchant, hyper sincère, fragile à souhait 🥹 J'aurai pu fondre s’il n’était pas en mode “j’ai les yeux mouillés dans chaque scène... 😩”. Kim Ji Won, elle est magnétique et glaciale, un vrai mur de marbre 😶‍🌫️ J’aurais aimé la voir craquer un peu plus, ressentir un peu plus ses failles. Leur alchimie est présente par moments, mais j’ai pas eu de papillons 🦋🤷🏼‍♀️

Visuellement par contre rien à dire 👌🏻. La réal est sublime, c’est un drama grand luxe, on sent qu'il y a du budget 💰 Les plans sont propres, avec cette vibe très "ciné mélancolique"… mais ça manque de feu 🔥, de spontanéité, de rugosité. J’avais envie qu’on lâche les chevaux... Mais non, c’était joli. Trop joli, peut-être 🫠

L’OST… Elle est douce, belle, mais rien qui m’a hantée. Aucun moment où je me suis dit mais Wahoo...😩🎶

J’ai mis un 7⭐️, parce que ça reste propre, c’est bien interprété, y’a des moments suspendus. Mais perso, ça m’a pas fait vibrer les tripes 😔 Sûrement trop de hype autour, et je m'attendais à plus...

"Queen of Tears" c’est pas un flop, mais ce n'est pas un coup de foudre non plus. Ceci est mon simple avis personnel 🫣 et n'engage que moi 😊 Goûts, émotions, ressentis... tout ça c’est super subjectif, et je comprends totalement que plein de gens aient adoré 🫶🏻✌🏻

Lire la suite

When you try to be too many things and end up being nothing.

Queen of Tears is a show that is trying to do it all. It wants to be a complex story about a dying marriage. It wants to investigate the fragility of mortality. it wants to look into twisted messy familial relationships. It wants to explore the tragedy of losing your children. It wants to be a thrilling chabeol game of thrones. It wants to be documentary about toxic unrequited love from an obsessive villainous male lead. The end product is a sopping misshapen mess that manages to be none of the above .

It claims to be a journey of a married couple at odds finding their way back to each other (but the male lead spent half the show trying to divorce the female lead or hoping she dies) it attempts to be a meaningful essay on death and sickness (but haein's illness seems to be an afterthought half the time, merely a plot device to remind the people around her that she exists and that shes human and that she deserves to be loved) it takes multiple sloppy shots at trying to play the inheritance games (but the chabeols you're supposed to root for are so stupid and pathetic you feel no sympathy for them when they get taken for all they're worth) The messy familial dynamics fall flat as we watch a mom very unreasonably neglect and villainize her 10-year-old kid over the apparent murder of her other child. It tries to skim over the terrible topic of miscarrying your child into a mere oddly placed 10 minutes.

The show is its own worst enemy. it stages an effective angsty scene between the leads about the difficult choices u need to make when ur ill and then undercuts it in the editing room by immediately following it up with an oddly placed flirtatious and humorous scene. It tries to impress upon us the terror of yoon eunsong's controlling, manipulative ways and immediately follows it up with Haein freely stalking her apparently abusive lying cheating ex-husband with a smile on her face. some shows are capable of maintaining a light tone while speaking about heavy topics and still pay them the respect and significance they are owed [refer: oh no here comes trouble] but queen of tears is not one of them. Rather than a show that uses comedy cleverly as a way of bringing to light its complex subject matter, it comes across as a jarring whiplash of moments thrown together by two different editing teams who were given two very different instructions.

This is a show that tries to tell more than show. They want to tell you that these people love each other but when you think upon it for more than two seconds you start wondering why they fell in love, why they fell out of it, why the miscarriage that got 8 minutes of screentime tore them apart so viciously that the husband began to wish his wife would die and her terminal illness would make her more likely to leave him with some soft cash to fall back on. On the surface level, it's all there, Hyun Woo's self-centeredness, and Haein's inability to communicate her emotions but it's too little too late for the depth of the melodrama they plunge us into.

Despite Kim Jiwon's and Kim Soohyun's stellar performances, you exit the couple's showdowns thinking "damn is it really that deep?" and that's where a romance drama fails for me, it fails if I think the romance is too soppy coz that means that the foundation or crust of the writing is too weak to hold the decadence and the intensity of the acting job.

Queen of Tears ends it's run tonight as a show that tried to do too many things and ended up doing none of it satisfactorily. Rather than introduce terminal illness, scheming villains trying to usurp wealth, and obsessive friends from college they should have delivered on the one thing they promised, a married couple at odds finding their way back to each other. If only they had stripped down the additional dressing and focused on the messy terrible marriage of Hyun Woo and Haein and their respective and combined issues and how they overcame it without the unnecessary roadblocks like amnesia and evil second male leads, maybe it could have been worthy of the acting performances of the leads.

if you want to watch a messy married couple falling back in love its better to watch hits like flower of evil or go back couple coz this one was just disappointing.

Lire la suite