This review may contain spoilers
From the moment I finished the novel last year to when Pursuit of Jade finished airing, it has been a long wait.. This has been one of my most anticipated dramas of 2026.. Well, did it live up to my expectations?? It’s sort of muddy waters.. Because I loved the drama, even though it wasn’t exactly what I pictured.. I just felt it could have been more.. The Lin’an arc like most people said, was the best part of the drama.. They took their time developing the relationship and the romance, building the characters.. It was all done very well.. But once the story moved out of the town, it all just got messy.. Not because the script was poor, but because of the storytelling.. It wasn’t nearly as gripping as the novel.. Still, it was a pure delight to watch the main leads and their journey on screen..Need to mention this.. Honestly, they did Zhang Ling He’s character pretty dirty once he went back to being the Marquis of Wu’an.. All he really had were some witty BGM moments and slow mo scenes but nothing with real weight or charisma to match the reputation of a ruthless marquis.. Not to mention the lack of screen time.. They should have utilized him more and given him scenes that showed the Marquis in his full glory.. And the war?? The battle scenes were very poorly done.. Not one noteworthy fight.. Add the bad CGI to that.. It was disappointing.. Even so, ZLH still did an outstanding job..
Tian Xi Wei.. She was really, really good as Fan Changyu.. Her character development from a common woman to a General felt rushed, but it wasn’t bad.. I think she got better action scenes than ZLH.. And her attires were really beautiful.. She gave a brilliant performance, the camera really loves her..
The rest of the cast are incredibly phenomenal.. Special shoutout to Deng Kai and Snow Kong.. I really didn’t expect them to be this good.. Especially Deng Kai, he was terrific.. The others were solid too.. They are another big reason why the drama worked so well.. When you have a good story to tell, it helps when the people telling it are all doing it well..
Okay, the romance.. I gotta say, it was something else.. The chemistry and intensity between the main leads were just amazing.. If you have watched it, you would know.. There was that sense of yearning right from the beginning, then the sexual tension building up.. And the intimate scenes in the last phase of the drama?? Intense, really intense.. I am just a bit disappointed that the “I can’t do it anymore” scene didn’t make it to the final cut.. If you have seen the leaks, you will know what I am talking about..
Slightly off topic, but I have seen quite a lot of edits of Sui Yuan Qing, romanticizing his character.. He is the same person who slaughtered an entire town and let his men rape those women, serious psychopathic issues.. And people are making edits for him.. Like, how?? why??
The cinematography was okay.. I mean the overreliance on CGI/AI kind of ruined it.. I don’t know.. The visuals should have been better.. The music was good.. It sort of fit the tone of the drama and elevated a lot of scenes..
Now, the middle phase of longer shows are usually boring.. Because the writers have to tie everything together to set up the final phase and sometimes they rush through it.. Here though, they managed to minimize the damage.. The pace never feels draggy or cramped.. My mind did wander at times but not enough for me to call it boring..
The last phase, storytelling wise, was good.. It was set up for an epic conclusion.. But nothing really happened.. We didn’t get a war or a proper battle, not even one good action sequence.. Everything got resolved so quickly.. Why?? Why couldn’t you give us an epic conclusion?? You had the cast and the story right there..
Overall, despite all its flaws this is a 9 for me.. Because it just worked where it mattered.. I loved the romance and the chemistry.. Also the yearning, the evolving relationships.. Loved the main leads. The Lin’an arc was just bliss to watch.. The drama didn’t fail in any way, it just could have been more.. I had a great time.. I was happy..
P.S. Read the novel.. It’s the best way to enjoy the story..
Was this review helpful to you?
Now that's what you call a wholesome drama
There are so many things that other directors could learn from this show. How to make your story gripping and engaging, how to utilise technology without being overly dependent on CGI, how to do proper editing, how to utilise actors in a way that their characters become believable. I don't remember watching any of Zhang ling He's earlier dramas and believing his characters completely, they always looked very superficial. But this time this director had other plans in mind and he gripped his character so well in a tight leash that it is completely moving the way he wants. No over the top expressions or using just the face card to make him act. You will be in awe, watching all the subtle changes in their expression and body language that even without dialogues sometimes, they are conveying every emotion with such an ease.I am loving our FL here because her character is not all over the place. She is called brute in the drama but she is more than that. She is the exact image of a young girl that you could imagine from that era in impoverished state, without parents and struggling with the harsh realities of life. I am loving how they are not shying away from it just to make her look a perfect female character. Special mention for the child actor. I just adore every scene with her and all the village scenes and their interaction has a 'The story of Miglan' vibe a lot.
Complex political struggle is yet to unfold completely but so far it is interesting, I had no idea this show would give the best villain of all time to me. He would give you creeps. Court politics could make you skip certain scenes a little bit if you are not into that much politics but every character looks believable and have a story to tell, even the villagers and the side characters with extremely small screen time. What I loved the most is the way they used the natural lights to enhance the beauty of the scenes. Even the set design doesn't feel like as if it is a set. Costume and makeup are equally good and for me it is Zhang Ling He's best look so far. Whether it is romantic moments or any slow motion sequence playing with the scenery to amplify the presence of the character everything requires well thought out execution and all thanks again goes to the director and the actors. Whether it is romance sequence, emotional sequence, war sequence or slap sequence...cough*.... everything is top notch. It is THE best show for me of this year in all aspects.
PS: I don't remember which was the last drama where I felt a drama married couple had such a real couple vibes. I can just watch these two spending their lives in small town and doing all their daily work, forever and to all the people who think it is very slow in the beginning, the director is smart enough to take that time because he is building a world where viewers could feel the emotions of the later episodes, which is only possible if one gives proper time to all the characters. Believe me it will hit you hard when the time comes. Trust me this drama knows how to play with the feelings.
PS 2: Despite everything I still felt that this one is the best drama of yr (at least for now). My only complaint would be the way they started to cut the scenes and letting it all fall for viewers' imagination. Including Marquis' battle scenes. Towards the end I could feel how they were rushing badly and chopping the scenes to compress it all into ep. limit. The room that they were giving to breathe this world became too small in the second half. I had no problem with other leads getting a screentime but I felt our main leads needed more screentime as we got attached to their characters more. In second half, the leads were there for such a short time together or their story only became part of post credit scenes. Our over powered FL would have looked more believable if they would have given us some hint that she was a prodigy in martial arts since birth...defeating seasoned soldier in two blows was too much even for her character. More time should have been given to her character for us to believe her well deserved status of a general. But it will still be a nitpick because first half raised too much expectations. It was definitely 10/10 if not for the second half. I will still recommend this show to everyone who is into Wuxia dramas. It has definitely raised the standards for others.
Was this review helpful to you?
Amazing start, shaky middle, dismal climax, good ending—
Here lies another victim of censorship and the 40-episode rule. You watch the show and see how everything is going well in terms of the production, storytelling, and writing; and then it reaches the middle and it falters. And it's all because of the weird cuts you know well that something should have been there. It's such a shame. But Zeng Qingjie has outdone himself, though—I think this is better than Blossom. For Zou Yue, I still think Coroner's Diary is her best work (especially in terms of the romance, but I guess that's more of a personal preference).STORY:
Like I said, it started REALLY good. I even wrote a lengthy comment before about how the exposition in Lin'an County really set the stage for the events that will happen in the middle part of the show. The Lin'an Arc was so good, I just wanted to stay there. And even when the show ended, I wanted to go back. It's just so PEAK to me. But then, we reached the middle part and despite the several aura farming scenes and Fan Changyu's AMAZING fighting scenes—don't get me wrong, they're cool and I loved every second of them—I feel like the show really fell short when it came to telling the story of the battles they faced. I feel like they focused too much on the "Yan Zheng hiding his identity" plot instead of enriching the story about their life in that military camp, because from what I understood, they were in that camp FOR MONTHS and yet the only thing I clearly remember was the plotline about Xie Zheng hiding his identity (which, they could've written better, by the way). And towards the end of their Military Camp Arc, it was also so obvious that there were LOTS of cuts and I'm guessing it has something to do with censorship (maybe it was too violent?) Because one moment, this is happening. Then the next, another thing is happening. And then all of a sudden, an important general is dead? Didn't even show us how it happened. But it did. And we just have to accept it. And now, Fan Changyu is bedridden and OH she also discovers a BIG secret about her identity. It was all too abrupt. It was obvious that they were rushing things to have space for the Capital Arc.
I say this with no offense meant but maybe they wouldn't have the need to rush important plot points if they took away some of Qi Min and Yu Qianqian's screentimes. It was so unnecessary. I don't understand what they're trying to build up about their relationship and even in the end, it just didn't MOVE me. It's also so frustrating because we get full scenes of Qi Min and Yu Qianqian UNSOLICITED, but for the main couple, we have to beg for scraps of their scenes that they obviously filmed (based from the behind the scenes and leaked clips) but didn't make the final cut. I saw some people blaming Zou Yue for this, but she only writes the script. She doesn't decide what ends up in the final cut and what doesn't. It's the director. And obviously, these scenes were filmed so I really want to know what's going on with Zeng Qingjie when he decided to explore their relationship and dynamic for nothing.
Now, for the final arc—it was all over the place. The climax was dismal. And resolving the conflict of the show with dreams and chance discoveries? It's pure lazy writing and I will die on this hill. I remembered how chaotic the writing was in the last arc of Coroner's Diary, too and I'm faulting Zou Yue for this one. But I loved the reveal about Wei Yan, though. Truly a compelling villain (if we can even call him that; he's more of an anti-hero for me). I wish they explored Xie Zheng's dynamic with Wei Yan more. It was just so interesting to see how he's Wei Yan's pride and joy, but he's also the one person who can beat him in his own game and I think it unsettles him. I also wish they explored Xie Zheng's emotional turmoil more. I think he is complete as a character in terms of merits. He became a Marquis at a young age and it's well-deserved because he is both a good strategist and a good fighter—and it's pretty much established. But I feel like there's something that falls short in terms of his emotional struggles—especially his feelings about his parents, his uncle, his cousin, and basically his life before Changyu and how they related to her. It feels like they just dumped some scenes here and there about his interactions with them as a child and called it a day. There's no depth in it aside from what they want to evoke from the audience during that exact scene, which they try to get away with through editing.
As for how they showed Fan Changyu—from her humble beginnings as a butcher from Lin'an to her rise to power as a Great General—NO NOTES. I loved seeing every chapter of Fan Changyu's life. It's like seeing my little baby grow.
Last thing: I wish we got more of the alternate universe. I would really pay to see more of Xie Zheng and Fan Changyu being childhood sweethearts. (Instead, it feels like they set up everything for that specific scene at the end. But, whatever. Good to know that Qi Min and Yu Qianqian won't involve themselves with each other in their other life. They're physically repulsed by it. I'm repulsed by the idea of them, too.)
ACTING/CAST:
Like I have always said, my only criteria to say that an actor is good is when I'm able to enjoy the show while watching him or her. If the actor delivers what he has to deliver and make me feel for their character, then they're good in my books. For this show, everyone has done a good job in doing that. I felt for every character, whether good or bad, whether I love them or I hate them.
Special mention to Tian Xiwei because she really brought Fan Changyu to life. She has always been one of my favorite actresses, and I have trust in her acting skills, but seeing her as Fan Changyu was still a pleasant surprise, even as a long time fan of hers. She has improved so much over the years and I'm just so happy to see her getting the recognition she deserves through this project.
As for Zhang Linghe, I'm not particularly a fan of him, but I tend to end up watching his shows because for some reason, he always ends up in good shows. And from what I've seen, it's clear that he has also improved a lot. He was convincing in both personas as the ruthless Marquis Wu'an and the gentle matrilocal husband Yan Zheng. It was such a joy to see his pretty face on screen, I'm not going to lie. This is the best he's ever looked on camera, and mind you, he has always looked good.
I would also like to applaud the actors for Yu Bao'er and Fan Changning because they really held their own in their scenes, especially the actor for Yu Bao'er. These kids are definitely going places!
Special Mention 1: To the actor who played the Emperor. He's so convincing as a useless emperor, I couldn't help but roll my eyes whenever his scenes come up. But at the same time, I also couldn't help but feel sad for him in the end. He's a victim in all of this and things would have been better for him if he remained a prince. It's clear he had no ambition, but he was suddenly thrust into power and given more than enough food than he could chew. The actor did so well in portraying the helplessness of it all.
Special Mention 2: To the actor who played Wei Yan, Yan Yikuan. NO NOTES. Truly amazing performance as Wei Yan. It's also so convincing that he's Xie Zheng's uncle. They really look like they share the same genes, even Xie Zheng's mom. I think this is one of Zeng Qingjie's strengths—picking the perfect actors to play as family members and finding the perfect actors to play as the younger versions of other actors.
MUSIC:
The OSTs of this show are all ICONIC and the way you can associate certain scenes or know what kind of scenes will be shown from the OSTs alone show how effective they are in bringing up the whole atmosphere of the show. I especially love "Pure As I Am" by Yisa Yu because I really love the tender moments between Xie Zheng and Fan Changyu. They're just so sweet and heartwrenching in a good way.
REWATCH VALUE:
I will DEFINITELY rewatch this for the Lin'an Arc. Their domestic life was just so cozy and like I said, I really wish we could just stay there. It's such a memorable arc for me and I want to return there again and again. What I feel about Lin'an is like those trends on TikTok where they caption it with: "Not my place, but I know my way around." Because even with the petty fights with the neighbors, even with people looking down on them despite the big destiny they hold, Lin'an is still home.
OVERALL:
I initially said above that it's such a shame that such a good show faltered midway. But then, I can't deny that this is still an amazing work. So, congratulations to the casts and crew because this is really a memorable show in a sense that it was a very enjoyable watch and I've never felt so excited about watching a historical show since Coroner's Diary.
Was this review helpful to you?
A Masterpiece That Redefines Historical Drama Perfection
When it comes to historical dramas that seamlessly weave mystery, romance, and war into one unforgettable experience, China continues to set the gold standard and Pursuit of Jade stands tall as one of its finest achievements.From the very first frame, the production commands attention. Every costume, every set, every carefully constructed detail breathes life into its world with stunning authenticity. The snowy landscapes are nothing short of cinematic poetry, transforming scenes into visual masterpieces. Paired with fluid, hard hitting martial arts choreography, the drama doesn’t just look beautiful, it feels alive.
But what truly elevates Pursuit of Jade into something extraordinary is its unforgettable female lead. FanChangYu breaks every expectation. A butcher’s daughter who turns her blade into a weapon of survival and strength, she is fierce, grounded, and unapologetically powerful. She is not written to be admired from afar, she pulls you in and demands to be remembered.
The supporting cast adds heart and soul in all the right places. The little sister is an absolute scene stealer, bringing warmth, innocence, and perfectly timed humor that softens the intensity without ever taking away from the stakes.
Then there’s the chemistry. Zhang Linghe and Xi Tian deliver performances that feel raw and genuine. Their connection is electric, balancing tenderness with tension, while their fight sequences carry both emotional weight and physical intensity.
Every interaction adds another layer to an already rich story.
Now having completed this series, I can confidently say this drama never falters. It grips you from beginning to end, delivering action, emotion, romance, and visual brilliance with unwavering consistency.
Pursuit of Jade is not just a great drama. It is a rare 10 out of 10 that earns every second of your time and leaves a lasting impression long after the final scene fades.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Take me back to 6 March 2026, 6 p.m., when this beautiful dream beneath the rain pavilion began
What I would give to hear the words “我杀猪养你啊🔪🐷” for the first time again. 逐玉 made my March so delightful, and I want to thank its incredible cast for keeping me hooked from start to finish🥹To preface, I tend to separate my enjoyment of a drama from my analysis of it. I gave Zhu Yu an overall 10/10 purely for my own list and reference (despite not giving any individual category a 10), because for me, it was a 10/10 experience🥲. Realistically, I would rate it around an 8.5 from a more critical standpoint, as I did have some issues with it. If you’d like to hear more, please read on💖
💗Stylistic Choices💗
As someone who is a sucker for cultural symbolism and loves looking for tiny details that add to the story, director Zeng Qing Jie hits all the right notes for me😭There are many things I LOVED about Zhu Yu, but here are some of my favourites:
💗Shadow Puppet Show
True to his signature style, ZQJ opens the first episode with a puppet show, just like his other hit, Blossom (2024). I appreciated that he uses the Qin Qiang Opera style, which not only enriches the cultural texture of the drama, but also deepens our immersion in its world. If you pay attention to the post-credits scene of the 1st episode, there is a poem recited during the shadow puppet show. It foreshadows and outlines the story, and is originally written by ZQJ and the production team. I did a very rough translation (poems are hard😢):
隆冬朔野玉尘飞,与君初遇雪地危。
天降姻缘两情许,杀猪为汝誓不摧。
暗潮翻涌金戈震,生死契阔心相随。
戎装换却庖刀影,巾帼辉戈向云麾。
“In midwinter, jade-white snow swirls across the wilderness; our first meeting was a chance encounter amid that perilous snowfield.
Heaven brought us together, and our hearts chose one another; I slaughtered pigs for you, and my vow shall not break.
As hidden currents surge and the clash of arms resounds, through life and death, our hearts remain bound.
I laid down my butcher’s knife and took up armour; now, as a woman of valour, I raise my spear toward the clouds.”
A super poetic and classy opening to Zhu Yu, imho🤩
💗Visual Storytelling
But of course, we cannot mention Zhu Yu without talking about its cinematography!!! The colour grading, the clever use of lighting with candlelight and shadows✨, the super satisfying framing and composition, and the brilliant use of unique shots (e.g. POV angles), everything is so thoughtfully done.
Visual symbolism is used so effectively, examples include the Yin-Yang motif, recurring imagery like the hair ribbon💙, as well as visual parallels and callback shots that mirror earlier scenes… I can go on and on about the visuals, everything about it is just so well done 😭✨
❣️Story❣️
This is the part where I wished it could’ve been better, and I knocked off 2 points for pacing and the butchering of plot points (lenient, I know, but I couldn't help it :") ). The story itself isn’t particularly anything new, it’s fairly straightforward and everything unfolds quite logically, though I did watch and rewatch it without subtitles and had read the novel many times beforehand, so that likely helped. But there were changes here and there that made me go ??? at times, especially in the middle arc, and I will blame that on the screenwriter🙄
When it comes to the story’s pacing, I will readily agree that Zhu Yu pales in terms of plot progression compared to other good dramas that I’ve watched before. There definitely are parts that were too rushed, some unnecessary filler, and some important parts were cut out. It started off super strong and promising, but as it progressed, its flaws slowly emerged and became too apparent to ignore completely (blaming the screenwriter and anyone who made editing decisions, ugh!!).
Now, the first 19 episodes were an absolute chef’s kiss. I really loved the slower pace, which helped build the rapport between Chang Yu, Yan Zheng, and their relationships with the villagers. It made me not just feel for them, but feel like I was actually part of the homely village of Xi Gu Alley. Which is probably why I ugly cried when the massacre happened, and even now, I can’t bring myself to fully watch that episode, even though I’ve watched the others countless times😭
The 2nd arc felt excruciating at times, and combined with the painful airing schedule🥲, the relief brought about by the revelation of the secret was liberating, to say the least. Compared to the masterful build-up in the first arc to the massacre (a hard one to match, definitely), this build-up felt less complete and was repetitive, and there were instances where the editing was weird and changes made from the novel felt off.
The final palace politics arc is very fast-paced, too fast for the amount of content it wanted to mash together in less than 10 episodes. It didn’t help that audiences have already long forgotten about the palace politics, with how little of it was shown in earlier episodes. Hence, the sudden bombarding of so much information may cause significant confusion for many. But also, this is where I loved the interactions between our main leads, as after such a long journey, they are finally on equal ground, and are able to support each other truly and fully❣️
❤️Characters and Acting❤️
Casting for Zhu Yu was spot-on, the best I’ve seen from C-dramas in recent years. Every character felt well-rounded and vivid, even minor ones, and I daresay that there wasn't one character which I felt was totally useless to the overall story (though some were really annoying!)
But if I went into detail for everyone it will be a very very long essay🤣, so I will just focus on our two leads.
❤️Chang Yu
There have been many C-Dramas with a "female general" tag released in recent years, and most of them have not met the mark for me. But Fan Chang Yu, the woman that you are!!😭 Our FL starts off as a simple, straightforward, kind but somewhat ditzy girl, forced to become head of the household due to the tragic death of her parents. The story begins when, out of kindness, she saves a man she doesn’t know and gradually falls in love with him.
As we follow her on her journey, we come to understand her better: she's extremely protective of her loved ones, she's a badass that can hold her own in fights, she's very understanding and forgiving, and she has the bravery to match her sense of justice, which allowed her to attain the growth that she achieved by the end.
Undeniably, Tian Xi Wei absolutely shines in her role as Chang Yu. I am a Tian Xi Wei stan, and I feel that Xiao Tian really made the most of her role in this drama, and successfully brought Chang Yu to life😭 She's so beautiful here and the styling suits her SO WELL. But not just that, she is able to pull audiences in and we are able to immerse in the emotions Chang Yu feels in each scene. Whether it’s her crying scenes, fight scenes, cold expressions, or her soft and adorable moments, she nails every single one and switches between them so effortlessly!
My favourite scene of hers has to be her grieving for the lost villagers in ep.19, it really did feel like Chang Yu was going to fall apart into pieces at any second, especially that line “And my Ning Niang😭”, it made me bawl😭 Her previous roles never really gave her this much room to shine, so I'm really happy that Zhu Yu has let people see her real capabilities as an actress🤩
❤️Xie Zheng
As for our ML, he is a proud and accomplished Marquis cum commandant of the Xie Army, who narrowly escapes death and is saved by our FL. He marries into the Fan family under the pseudonym Yan Zheng, both out of gratitude and out of necessity to hide his identity to regain strength and eventually return to his position.
While our FL’s growth was more external, I really appreciated that the focus of Xie Zheng’s growth was internal. From the start, he was already at the top of the food chain in the political and military scene, but he didn’t have a true family, he didn't have people who would go to great lengths to protect him, it had always been him protecting others. So what he needed wasn’t more fight scenes, it was a chance to show vulnerability and his flaws in front of someone, which he is able to do with Chang Yu🥰
Zhang Ling He’s performance here is a breakthrough for him. As an actor that possesses striking features, people may tend to focus on his visuals, and overlook his ability to portray miniscule emotions very well in this drama. Many times, I felt my emotions rising and falling in sync with his.
My favourite scene of his has to be when he showcased fear for the first time when he saved Chang Yu in ep.19. I felt that ZLH really captured Xie Zheng’s panic, fear and regret, evident in little details, like how he didn’t even notice the blind granny come in and was shocked to see her, and how he used such a desperate and clumsy method of warming her face with his hands, a huge contrast to his usual confident self.
❤️ZhengYu
Truly, they are one of the most complementary drama couples I’ve seen in a long time. This couple was promoted as a “power duo”, and it is really hard to accomplish that, with most dramas falling back to the typical trope of the FL relying more on the ML. But for ZhengYu, I never felt that either one of them was overpowering or overly reliant on the other.
Throughout the course of the story, both of the main leads achieved growth, just in different ways. Chang Yu needed guidance and a sense of security, and Xie Zheng was able to provide just that. Xie Zheng lacked a sense of belonging and love, which Chang Yu brought into his life. Like the Yin-Yang Symbol in THAT scene😌, they are interdependent and complementary opposites, and neither side can exist without the other🥺
💞Music💞
💞OSTs
The OST line-up for Zhu Yu is unbelievable, and the songs did not disappoint. I find myself singing the songs without looking up the lyrics, they just remain rent-free in my brain😂. But what I really loved and what gave me goosebumps was the Suo Na BGM that sounds during battles, in the intro, and towards the end of some episodes. A fantastic use of the loudest traditional instrument in China’s history of music🤩
💞The intro sequence
Believe it or not, I never once skipped the intro of Zhu Yu on my first watch of each episode. It is rare that this happens for me, because I usually just skip the intro songs. ZQJ makes it a point to place the intro song at different points in many episodes, some after 10+ minutes, which made it a jumpscare because I was tricked into thinking that I already finished the episode😂 The opening sequence is sectioned into 3 parts that mirror the progression of the story, and the visuals combined with the music reflect just that. Starting with the tranquillity of life in a small town (LOVED the subtle Guzheng here), it transitions to a tense atmosphere as war breaks out (Suo Na was so good!). The last section is goosebump-inducing, ending with a powerful, commanding feeling (such a crisp, bright sound from the Di Zi) that gives a sense of victory, and after that, a sense of peace and prosperity.
💓In short, if you’re looking for a light, easy watch with solid acting and breathtaking visuals, this drama may be for you.
However, is Zhu Yu the most interesting in terms of plot? Definitely not. Is it the most beautiful-looking drama? Many would argue against that. But what made me rate it a 10, despite my criticism of the story and its progression?
Well, Zhu Yu has this addictive charm that I could not fathom or explain even after completing it. I know this at least for me, because I'm someone who has never put in this much effort in watching a drama before. I’ve anticipated this since the day they announced it. I watch silently and don’t really watch shows the second they drop everyday, let alone rewatch episodes while the drama is still airing. I’ve NEVER written such a long review, unless it was for work/assignments😂. Even now, I cannot believe that I translated over 200+ posts, driven purely by my love for this enchanting piece🥲. (you can find my posts under Discussions!)
ZLH mentioned in an interview that if you watch Zhu Yu, you will experience “happy insomnia”, and he was right😂 I’m thankful to have been able to watch this while it aired, and I'm really grateful to everyone who I’ve had lovely interactions with in the comments hehe❤️
But unfortunately, as much as I’m reluctant to part with Zhu Yu, all good things have to come to an end.
And as Gongsun Yin says, 风雨廊亭 梦已醒。(The dream beneath the rain pavilion has ended)
Thank you for the great memories, Zhu Yu! 😭😭💖💖
P.S. There's still 4 days of normal airing, gotta finish translating🥺 But even so I'll probably be back very soon to rewatch again and again hahahaha
Was this review helpful to you?
Couldn't live up to initial hype with uneven pacing and a crash & burn ending
Subjective Gut Rating: 7.75“Pursuit of Jade” was all the hype when it was first aired. The Feeds couldn’t get enough of Zhang Ling He (of course) and also praised how much they love the female lead, Fan Chang Yu (played by the adorable Tian Xi Wei). Add on a long silver haired toxic Deng Kai, it has all the ingredients to be a successful drama. But then, it somewhat crashed in the end and just could not stick the landing. “Pursuit of Jade” is not a bad drama, but the expectations were just so high that many were disappointed. I don’t always agree with the ‘highs’ but I do with the ‘lows’.
Since the title of the drama is about the pursuit of Jade, Jade I assume is the female lead. The story focuses on her journey much more so than the male lead. I guess this causes some criticisms that the male lead’s character was not fully utilized. His investigation of what happened 17 years ago gave us the initial setting of a plot that is not romance-focused. But as the story goes, his investigation becomes more of a way to help FL instead. Did he still want to find out what happened? For sure! But I think he cares more for FL than his father’s death.
Many love Fan Chang Yu (FL). She’s smart, caring, sweet, and strong both physically and mentally. She can hold her own, push back when needed, even when she’s in love or heartbroken. Yan Zheng (ML) never gets an upper hand when he’s fighting with her. He will eventually give in. She has girl power! She will fight alongside her man in battles, but not behind him. She saves his ass a few times, too. But there are certain decisions she made that I want to shake some sense into her. I was especially mad at her for her actions in the army camp. She is smart enough to know you can’t do whatever you want and not follow the rules. She’s not a careless person, but a very considerate one. Yet, time and time again, she didn’t listen. Of course, Yan Zheng is at fault as well, as he kept his identity a secret for way too long. Additionally, she said she wants to be independent, not relying on others and doesn't like others making decisions for her. Yet she did that several times to Yan Zheng and Li Huai An. She made decisions on their behalf all in the name of protecting them. I don’t think she would have appreciated them doing the same to her. She doesn’t care what others are going to gossip about her and her status, yet she would break up with Yan Zheng for his sake. This girl has a lot of double standards! Having said all that, she’s still a rare independent and strong female character.
Many also love the first 17 episodes when a lot of time is spent in the village. Those times were a great set up and introduction to most characters. It’s the time when romance blooms in a slow but natural way. The villagers are mostly likeable and even the annoying ones aren’t that bad. However, I might be one of the few that feels the happy times lasted a little long. I wanted a little more of the serious plot, e.g. investigation of what happened 17 years ago, the scheming that the silver fox is doing behind-the-scenes, or court politics. Because this didn’t happen much, the last 10 episodes felt rushed. I knew a lot was going to happen, that’s why I wanted the happy village arc to end soon. There’s a lot of business ML needs to attend to instead of hanging out in the village!
As for the actual romance, I do like the scenes of the leads together. They have good (not great) chemistry and they are both very likable. I’m glad to see ML didn’t fall into the lovesick puppy trope and forgets he is a ruthless warrior. I like that he only goes soft for her, but resumes his charisma when he’s needed. Aside from the hidden identity part, they communicate, understand each other and have a very loving and healthy, mature romance. Well, but the kiss scenes are quite disappointing. We all know Zhang Ling He can do better. I think even Tian Xi Wei kissed better in “Moonlit Reunion” with Xu Kai than in this drama. But luckily, our toxic couple comes in and saves the day. The secondary romance between Yu Qian Qian and Qui Min has so much potential. Both are great actors, have good chemistry yet the story felt very one-note. There’s not enough backstory about Qi Min’s obsession with Yu Qian Qian. Is it just because he saved her? All their scenes are the same: he’s obsessed with her, she wants to rebel and leave, rinse and repeat. I wish we got more, especially Yu Qian Qian’s backstory with what she said she came from a faraway land.
Let’s talk about the last 5 episodes and how disappointing they are. I will try to not spoil anything. This is the most childlike, unexciting and anti-climatic palace takeover I’ve seen in a big production. While the takeover is happening, on the other hand, we got some family drama/duel. Where is the sense of urgency here?? Additionally, we got dumped a lot of information/revelation about what really happened 17 years ago. Where is the foreshadowing? There’s so much time in the first half of the drama to plant more seeds, so the revelation doesn’t feel so sudden. The breadcrumbs that were shared through a couple flashbacks were not enough. It was a disappointing end to a great start of the drama.
Well, my review is getting long. So I’m going to wrap it up by saying I would only recommend this drama if you like Zhang Ling He, Tian Xi Wei, Deng Kai, Snow Kong and Yan Yi Juan (ML’s uncle). Their acting is great and they have good chemistry. But if you want a well-written and well-executed drama, I do not recommend it. I would go for “Moonit Reunion” if you like Tan Xi Wei. She’s amazing in that one, too.
Completed: 4/2/2026 Review #680
Was this review helpful to you?
The Lie That Built a Life
If I had to summarize Pursuit of Jade in one sentence, it would be this: a butcher girl picked up a half dead man in the snow and accidentally picked up a marquis, a war, political conspiracies, and the love of her life along the way. The story follows Fan Chang Yu, a butcher’s daughter who becomes the breadwinner after her parents’ death, and Xie Zheng, a fallen noble hiding under a fake identity while seeking revenge and justice. What started as a fake marriage slowly turned into real love, but fate and war had other plans. Chang Yu eventually carried her butcher’s knife onto the battlefield while Xie Zheng reclaimed his title and fought to protect his country and the people he loved. In the end, they reunited through war, politics, and bloodshed, uncovering the truth behind the past while choosing each other again and again.What made this drama special for me from the very beginning was Fan Chang Yu as a character. She is strong but not overpowered, kind but not naive, capable but still very human. She is not book smart, she makes mistakes, she struggles with money, she gets tired, she cries, and that makes her feel real. Watching her butcher pigs in the morning, fight debt collectors in the afternoon, and worry about her sister at night made her one of the most grounded female leads I’ve seen in a costume drama. Tian Xi Wei really carried this role with so much charm. She can look cute, funny, fierce, heartbreaking, and charismatic all at the same time. One moment she is carrying a grown man on her back through the snow, the next moment she is sitting properly because she realized the man she saved is handsome. That duality is exactly why Chang Yu is so lovable.
Then we have Xie Zheng, also known as Yan Zheng, the most handsome matrilocal husband in drama history. Zhang Ling He looks insanely good in this drama, probably his best costume drama look so far. But what made his character work is not just the visuals. Xie Zheng is smart, strategic, calm, and ruthless on the battlefield, but in Xigu Lane he becomes someone soft, awkward, and quietly in love. The way he fell for Chang Yu was very gradual and believable. It was not love at first sight. At first he trusted her, then respected her, then admired her, then slowly loved her. One of the most beautiful parts of their relationship is that Chang Yu respected the Marquis Wu’an before she even knew Yan Zheng was him, and Xie Zheng fell for Chang Yu before she knew he was powerful. They loved each other as people, not because of status.
Their relationship progression is honestly one of the best parts of the drama. From fake marriage, to awkward newlyweds, to partners, to lovers, to fighting side by side on the battlefield. Their romantic scenes were full of tension even before they officially became a couple. The silhouette scene, the measuring clothes scene, the cheek kiss, the tangerine candy kiss, the iconic teardrop, the forceful kiss in the snow, the gua sha scene, the bathtub scene, all of them were memorable. Their chemistry was not just romantic but also emotional and strategic. They trust each other with their lives, not just their hearts.
The side characters were also very memorable, and this is actually one of the reasons the drama stood out to me. Qi Min and Qian Qian in particular provided a very interesting parallel to Xie Zheng and Chang Yu. Both Chang Yu and Qian Qian saved the men in their lives, but the relationships that followed went in completely different directions. Chang Yu and Xie Zheng’s relationship grew into mutual respect, trust, and partnership, while Qi Min and Qian Qian’s relationship turned into something much darker and more obsessive. When Qi Min made advances toward Qian Qian, she often had to play along as a way to survive and protect herself, but when Xie Zheng tried to flirt or push Chang Yu, she would literally smack him or push him away. The contrast between these two relationships was very strong, and it made both arcs more interesting. One relationship showed what love built on respect looks like, while the other showed what happens when love turns into control and obsession. It was also impressive how the drama made viewers emotionally invested not just in the main leads, but also in side characters like Qi Min and Qian Qian, whose story was tragic, frustrating, but very memorable.
Another thing I really loved about this drama is Xigu Lane. The Fan sisters, Uncle Zhao, Madam Zhao, the neighbors, the pig butcher squad, all of them made the drama feel warm and alive. A large portion of the early episodes focuses on Chang Yu and Xie Zheng’s life there, and those episodes are honestly some of the most charming and heartwarming parts of the entire drama. Because of that, when the story later shifted into politics, revenge, and war, the change felt quite sudden. I sometimes wished the drama had sprinkled more political developments or court conflicts earlier on so the transition would feel more gradual rather than switching from slice of life to political drama almost all at once.
The cinematography in this drama is honestly one of the best I have seen. The director plays a lot with warm and cold tones, framing, symbolism, and camera angles. Xigu Lane is always warm, golden, and lively, while the palace, battlefield, and revenge arcs are often cold, blue, and distant. Some scenes feel like paintings. The snow scenes, the lantern festival, the massacre and war scenes, the fire scenes, the Yin and Yang composition bathtub scene, so many wallpaper worthy shots.
Interestingly, the drama also did a very good job with Chang Yu’s action scenes. When she finally stepped onto the battlefield, she did not feel like a random civilian holding a weapon. She moved like a soldier and fought like a general. Her fight scenes were sharp, decisive, and powerful, and Tian Xi Wei really managed to give Chang Yu a very commanding and empowering presence in those moments. You could believe that soldiers would follow her into battle. However, this also made the contrast with the rest of the war scenes more noticeable. For a story filled with generals, battles, and military strategy, many of the large scale fights and duels felt surprisingly restrained. Some confrontations that should have felt desperate and intense ended up looking more stylized than dangerous. As the story moved toward its political climax and final confrontation, the scale and urgency never quite matched the amount of buildup. The rebellion, the revenge, and the palace showdown should have felt explosive, but instead some parts felt smaller and less intense than expected. This is probably where the drama felt the weakest, not because the story was bad, but because the execution of the final conflict did not fully match the emotional and narrative weight the drama had been building for so long. Episode 39 in particular felt like it should have been bigger, more chaotic, and more emotionally explosive.
However, episode 40 gave a very good closure. We finally learned the truth about what happened in the past, and it turned out many characters were victims of the late emperor’s tyranny. Wei Yan was not purely evil, Qi Sheng was just a puppet emperor who went mad, Qi Min and Qian Qian finally had closure, Bao Er becoming emperor felt like a new beginning, and the best part was Chang Yu, Xie Zheng, and Chang Ning returning to Xigu Lane and becoming a real family with the Zhao couple. When Chang Yu called Uncle and Madam Zhao mother and father, that scene really hit me emotionally. It felt like everything came full circle. The love knot tree scene near the end perfectly describes Xie Zheng’s love. He wrote his name on many love knots so that no matter where Chang Yu throws hers, it will still land with his. That is basically his character in one scene. He does not control her, he just makes sure that no matter where she goes, he will always be there.
Overall, Pursuit of Jade is a drama that starts warm, becomes intense, then ends warm again. It has romance, comedy, politics, war, action, friendship, family, and very beautiful cinematography. It is not a perfect drama, especially near the climax and war execution, but the characters, relationships, emotions, and visuals make the journey very worth it. More than politics or revenge, this drama is really about finding a home, finding people who choose you, and choosing them back no matter how chaotic the world becomes.
And honestly, who would have thought that a butcher’s knife could shine brighter than a general’s sword.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Power Worn Like Silk, Truth Buried in Blood
Pursuit of Jade is undeniably a good drama— and I personally think it fully deserved the overwhelming hype it received. That said, it ticks one of my favorite boxes: a power couple where both leads are equally strong, ruthless, and commanding in their own ways ⚔️🔥.I have to admit, I wasn’t previously drawn to Zhang Linghe’s visuals, but this drama completely changed my mind 😮💨. The styling? Immaculate ✨. He looked so good that I found myself internally screaming every time he appeared on screen 😩 (don’t mind me). Beyond that, his acting has improved tremendously compared to when I last watched him in The Princess Royal—there’s a noticeable depth and control in his performance now 👏.
As for Tian Xiwei—this being my first time watching her—she absolutely embodies Chang Yu 💯. It’s as if the character was tailored for her. The way she balances softness and cuteness with cold ruthlessness? I loved every second of it 🖤. The OSTs and background music were also exceptional 🎶, elevating each scene perfectly. And the cinematography and editing? Chef’s kiss 🤌✨. I didn’t even mind the repetitive snow scenes—they added to the overall aesthetic ❄️.
However, despite all these strengths, the drama does falter in its plot execution ⚖️. The first half was easily a 10/10, but the second half felt noticeably rushed ⏩. I understand it’s only 40 episodes, but the pacing should have been more balanced throughout. The Lin’an arc, while beautifully done and crucial to Chang Yu’s development, took up far too much screen time—it felt excessive 😬. In my opinion, 10 episodes would have been sufficient.
Instead, more focus should have been placed on the Jinzhou Massacre from 17 years ago—the very foundation of the entire story 🩸. The masterminds behind it, the victims, and the lingering consequences deserved deeper exploration. Because this wasn’t properly fleshed out, the narrative often jumped from one point to another without explaining how or why things unfolded 🤷♀️. Novel readers might understand these gaps, but first-time viewers are left confused.
Another major issue was the late revelation that Wei Yan had staged a coup 17 years ago to force the emperor’s abdication—only mentioned in episode 40 😭. Why introduce something so significant without giving it the proper backstory or buildup?
Similarly, while I absolutely love Chang Yu’s rise to General Huaihua 👑, the drama didn’t do her journey justice. It felt rushed and somewhat unrealistic. Becoming a general in less than a year after defeating just two warlords? It needed more development, more struggle, and more justification 📈. The novel version, from what I’ve heard, handled this much better.
Now, about the ending—I loved the alternate ending 🥹❤️. Seriously, give me more of that energy!!! But at the same time, is it too much to ask for Wei Yan and Xie Zheng to reconcile before his death? 💔 It felt like a missed emotional opportunity. Especially considering that the Jinzhou Massacre wasn’t truly Wei Yan’s fault—it was the Late Emperor’s scheme. That burden should never have been his alone, and the truth deserved to be acknowledged to the whole world.
All things considered, I’m still giving this drama a solid 10/10 ⭐—because at the end of the day, I’m an absolute sucker for strong chemistry between the leads 🤭💕. And these two? They had me giggling non-stop until my jaw hurt 😆.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Pursuit of Jade — Review
(edited)After completing all 40 episodes of Pursuit of Jade, I can confidently say that this drama has become one of my favorite C-dramas. While I understand that opinions about this series may vary and others may rate it lower, my experience watching it from beginning to end was genuinely meaningful and memorable. I would also definitely recommend others to watch it and give it a chance, especially if you enjoy character driven historical dramas.
What stayed with me the most is how the drama remained deeply character focused throughout its entire run. Even as the story expanded into themes of war, revenge, and political conflict, it never lost sight of its emotional core. The narrative is not driven by spectacle alone, but by the personal journeys of its characters particularly Fan Chang Yu and Xie Zheng.
Fan Chang Yu’s character is one of the strongest aspects of the drama for me. Her growth feels natural and well earned, shaped by her background and the circumstances she faces. She starts as someone grounded in survival, carrying the practicality of her life as a butcher’s daughter, and gradually evolves into someone who takes control of her own fate in a much larger world. What I appreciate most is that her strength is not exaggerated. She remains consistent to who she is, even as her responsibilities grow heavier.
Her presence in the later parts of the story, especially as the stakes rise, left a strong impression on me. There is something powerful about how she carries her past with her, rather than leaving it behind. It makes her journey feel continuous and authentic, and it reinforces the idea that her identity is not defined by status, but by her resilience and choices.
Xie Zheng, on the other hand, offers a more restrained but equally compelling arc. His character is shaped by loss, responsibility, and a long standing desire to uncover the truth. What I found engaging about him is the way his emotional layers are revealed over time. He is not immediately expressive, but his actions consistently show his depth especially in the way he protects, trusts, and eventually stands alongside Fan Chang Yu.
Their relationship is, without a doubt, the heart of the drama. What begins as a marriage of convenience slowly develops into something sincere and deeply rooted in mutual understanding. I appreciated that their bond did not rely on exaggerated romantic moments. Instead, it was built through shared struggles, quiet support, and the gradual development of trust.
There are subtle scenes throughout the drama that highlight this progression moments where they choose to rely on each other, even when circumstances make it difficult. These moments made their relationship feel real to me. By the time the story reaches its later stages, their partnership feels solid and equal, which made their journey even more satisfying to watch.
As the story moves toward its final arc, the scale of the narrative becomes larger, but it still feels connected to the characters’ personal stakes. The unfolding of hidden truths and past events adds emotional weight rather than just serving as plot twists. I found these revelations impactful because they tie directly into the characters’ motivations and the paths they have taken.
Without going into major spoilers, the ending felt fitting for the kind of story the drama was trying to tell. It focuses more on emotional resolution than shock value, which I personally appreciated. It gave me a sense of closure while still allowing me to reflect on everything the characters had gone through.
In terms of pacing, I found the drama consistent overall. There are slower moments, but they did not feel unnecessary to me. Instead, they allowed the story to breathe and gave more depth to the characters and their relationships. These quieter scenes are part of what made the emotional moments more effective later on.
Visually, the drama maintains a strong atmosphere from start to finish. The cinematography and setting complement the tone of the story, especially during more intense or emotional scenes. While it may not be perfect in every technical aspect, it never distracted me from the overall experience.
What ultimately makes Pursuit of Jade stand out to me is its sincerity. It tells a story about two people navigating a complicated world while slowly becoming each other’s support system. Their journey is not just about love, but also about growth, trust, and standing firm in the face of uncertainty.
Even though I know that not everyone may feel the same way about this drama, it has earned a special place for me. It is the kind of story that stays with you, not because it is flawless, but because of how it made you feel while watching it. Because of that, I genuinely encourage others to watch it and experience the story for themselves.
Overall, I would still rate Pursuit of Jade a 10/10. This is now one of my favorite C-dramas, and completing it only strengthened the impression it left on me. This review reflects my personal experience after finishing the series, and I can say that it was a journey I truly enjoyed from beginning to end.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
First Arc Was the Strongest & Then……..Yeah and Then
Regardless of my health, I got a lot of encouragement from all of you or many of you to put my comment as a review so here it is. It’s completely different than any review I have ever written because this is just a comment so I hope it’s still is up to some sort of standards of my original reviews for you guys.Well, I finally finished it. I couldn’t even really watch that otherworldly alternative universe because it didn’t make sense. They brought everyone back, but why didn’t they bring back the parents of the leads because wouldn’t that make sense if QM is the actual emperor or is he just the CP and his dad is the emperor? Or did they? And we never even found out whose dream or alternate universe was played out because nothing was written on the screen other than if the events 17 years ago never happened (if this was only to show that just because it didn’t happen 17 years ago, doesn’t mean it couldn’t happen 17 years later then it still was unnecessary to be shown other generations would’ve suffered something). In any case I give it after a careful thought an 8/10 because though it started off super strong, I think with great character development in that little village. The military arc was a complete mess and they turned someone who had no military experience, couldn’t read, couldn’t write, had no tact for military anything into goddess of war overnight and she was able to kill all the important generals while the man who's the Marquis, it’s his niche; it really was watered down and his fight scenes came to be about five minutes each.
I have spoken at great length in the comments about this before, so I don’t feel like reinventing the wheel and basically repeating what I had written. I think those people that agreed with me will agree with me here as well and if they feel like commenting, please do, we can continue having conversation in regards to it. The other thing that people mentioned was the fact that his power was on the battlefield was more talked about than actually shown, which was also unfair. I understand that ZLH he was excited for this role because it was the first time he had ever played a general and got to fight a little bit or rather it was filmed like a lot, but was cut. I was very dissatisfied with the FL in that second arc; she could’ve stayed at that Stone quarry and used her brute force, and she would’ve eventually run into her husband, but the fact that she essentially treated him like crap, like he was less than was unnecessary. She made a lot of errors that cost lives and walked away without consequences and that was just unrealistic writing to me.
In the last arc, it seemed that people just forgot what the show was really about and that was understanding the truth of what happened 17 years ago and getting that vindication and vengeance. The fight between uncle and nephew I think was all right. I can’t say it was great. The real standout character here was DK. I’m very very proud of him for the role that he pulled off as the absolute complex lunatic. However, I feel very bad for him because now he can’t even go to pee at an airport without fans sticking phones in his face, and the guy is so shy in real life completely opposite of the character y’all saw that the overnight success is driving him a little batty.
In any case this show could’ve been so much stronger. I feel had it been written stronger and from the novel readers perspective, I think that had they written the leads as a unit and really developed the FL into at least a foot soldier forget all those titles that were heaped upon her because of people that sang her praises in court and her brute strength. The other thing that I really didn’t like was the fact that she used physical abuse a lot; she slapped him, hit him, and punched him when they were having arguments and that’s just not how it rolls. I don’t care what gender because she was like a light version of Amber Heard. It made me wonder in some cases whether she loved him at all because that’s not how you show love. I understood because of her rough upbringing, she was not going to be this googly eyed whatever but there are different ways of showing love and sadly I think it missed the mark. So that’s my take on the show. As you guys know I have taken a hiatus from writing reviews because of my health so this is the most that I can do and say. I really truly wish and I am disappointed that ZLH did not get a chance to showcase his fighting or his characters fighting rather giving that he’s the general of all generals and instead they gave her all of these scenes and all military law and code and everything was forgotten just so she could shine and it was just ridiculous. He had more fighting skill and showcasing it in the first arc when he was injured to the point of death, then he had in his niche arc and I think that the problem there is completely because of poor writing and directing. I know a lot of people loved it. I’m happy for that, but for me personally as a writer, as an editor of scripts, I feel that it was very incorrectly written.
You can make people equally powerful, a great unit like shows like Fated Hearts (I’m not comparing it to anything and I don’t compare shows but that series just shows an equal unit between ML and FL she’s got the prowess with the bow and arrow and he’s got the prowess with the sword and the two of them were invincible, a real power couple from start to finish there was never anything lacking nor taking away from a character to add to another character.) without making one basically Robo Barbie, and the other one her poodle. It was reverse sexism. It was unfortunate. But because of the stellar acting of the actors, all of the leads, support, everyone is why I’m giving this an eight.
Honestly, I don’t even remember the OST’s that much. I also think that that Li tutor should’ve been killed not just exiled if that abdicated emperor was murdered and so were the other conspirators, he should not have gotten away with just confiscation of property and exile because he had a great grandson that begged for his mercy. This man was just as culpable as WY. People see WY as also a victim and at the beginning, he was but his later choices, killing a lot of people so he’s got to face the consequences; and even he had hallucinations of seeing the nephew whom he harmed right before his own death.
I’m glad the leads got a happy ending (the falcon also got a girlfriend lol) and apparently parents of two kids what I don’t understand is why the ML upon returning to the village had to dress in those patched up clothing when that’s not who he was; I hope Mr. and Mrs. Zhao were told that FL‘s husband was the Marquis unless they already knew and now also the Prince Regent. And I guess what I mistook for everyone being alive at the beginning was really just her illusion the real alternate universe is a post credit scene so I got that a little confused. I do wish we could’ve seen the third couple with their marriage. Also wish they had properly exited out the characters that were still alive even with that bizarre as hell post credit scene, which I honestly think we did not need. I think it was almost a slap in the face that the leads last official scene was riding off to a new war with her saying I’m not going back home I wouldn’t have become general so and so if it wasn’t for all the battles I’ve been in and I’m thinking to myself you’ve been in all of three battles most of which were not that successful other than the killing of major generals. The rest was word-of-mouth of your triumph. Now the man next to you is a different story; but sadly we never saw that it was just told in stories or conversations like he was already dead. Weird and unfair as hell. And lastly, the cinematography was beautiful.
Would I recommend it? Honestly, the high score is for wonderful acting, beautiful cinematography, costumes, some sets. But this show had a lot wrong with attributed to screenwriter and director making even fiction unrealistic in the last two arcs and the potential for amazing was great. So give the show a go, but don't set your expectations high just because of the high ratings and now over 300 reviews most of which saw zero negatives and/or are certain actor fans. Though I watched for ZLH, as you all know, I watch with an open mind. Had it not been for the things I mentioned, my rating would have been a whole half a point if not a point lower.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
❤️ My internal clock woke me up at 4:00 a.m. to watch this for a week.
StoryThe story was surprisingly accurate. When I did a comparison between plot lines in the novel versus the drama I was surprised to see that the drama stayed very loyal to the book. And I say surprised, because it felt, especially towards ep 26-30, that the drama was falling behind. That said, it’s because it was missing a lot of context that was left in the novel.
I completely understand the choice to cut out some of plot lines and missions (ex: the bear, interrogating/breaking out prisoners, the multiple battles in the capital…) for time. But where they cut, they also included a lot of scenes for other characters. For instance, QM and YQQ barely had any of their own pov in the novel, while the drama devoted almost 1/3 of its time to them (and I do appreciate the toxic love story). But the screenwriter decided to incorporate the side stories into the main story, thereby taking away time from the main story.
So we missed a lot of plots surrounding our main characters in exchange for other characters. But for what they kept, they stayed really faithful. Almost word for word.
The story stayed very faithful the characters in a lot of ways, but also deviated from them somewhat. For instance, for XZ/YZ, we barely get any context about his mother’s suicide and how it affected him beyond nightmares and hints about self loathing. In the book, it’s deeply tied to his reluctance to fall in love, how he doesn’t want to end up like his mother falling in love with someone that when they die it kills them. He blames himself more than anyone, and when he finds out that his mother killed herself to save him from his uncle, it completely floors him. It was a huge moment in the book where he went to confront WY at his parent’s graves. Or when they realize that her father was WX and he actually leaves her and throws himself into the war to try to get her out of his head, injuring himself repeatedly, then going to his family and asking to be whipped 108 times because he committed a grave sin by falling in love with her and deciding he cannot let her go. I mean, the angst!! Dial it up by x20 in the novel.
And I can excuse those changes for needing to cut time. I think the change I disliked the most was ep 26/27 when after he’s drugged, he doesn’t kill the opposing side General like he does in the book. That was one change I was genuinely confused why they would do that. It just prolonged that plot point for that guy to come back for 2 seconds and be killed in a 1 second. That was, I think, the only change that actually annoyed me. Because in the book, after he wakes up, he goes to fight in the battle before seeking out CY, having confidence that she could take care of herself and that if she couldn’t his people would take care of her, even though he was worried.
Generally the show did an amazing job. If I didn’t read the novel, I would think this still an amazing watch for its plot. Still 10/10.
And I do love some the changes they made in the show. XZ/YZ is infinitely nicer and less of a dick to people. And while some people may complain that he’s not showing the power of being the feared marquis, I appreciated the change. We still see the depth of his power because he can mobilize people to do what he wants and his reputation is as feared general and he has so much arrogance from his achievements that he doesn’t even kneel for the emperor. I like that we see him be nice to Changning and to Bao’er, especially in the village.
I like that the mains relationship had a lot more consent in it. I think the mains relationship was so beautifully written and perfectly performed (I’ll get to that later).
Despite the fact that it cut into the main story line, I love that they included the side stories and added the complexity to the other characters (WY, QM, SY…)
My general review for the story as a whole was that it’s a good story. Having read the novel, of course I’m disappointed that parts I consider pivotal weren’t included, but I’m not that mad about it because of how the drama came together as a whole.
I definitely think my understanding of the drama is probably affected by the translation. I saw online someone say that the translations lost a lot of the formality and context. So hopefully I can either learn mandarin or someone can do an in depth translation with guides on the jokes or important verbiage that are lost on those who don’t speak the language.
I think overall, too much time in the village, that could have been cut down and devoted to more background in their families and backstory. I don’t know if it helped that I read the novel so I knew what was happening, or if it hurt because I knew what should have been happening.
Acting/Cast
When I say that the best part of this drama was the actors, I am not lying. The actors understood the f*cking assignment, and I applaud them heartily.
Our leads ZLH and TXW had peak chemistry. I have watched their other works before and I do not know if I’ve ever been this obsessed with them. They’ve never looked better, they’ve never acted better.
I swear to god TXW eyes did more acting in this drama than some veteran actors in their entire careers. And ZLH’s microexpressions and his jaw. HIS JAW!! Did so much acting!
Now, yes they are both very pretty people and do benefit from the pretty privilege where you can ignore bad acting. But I genuinely think they did act very well in this series. This is a director who knew what he wanted and got it from his cast.
I also watched the behind the scenes footage and was surprised by how much say the actor’s had in what they wanted to do considering how intentional this director is with his choices in the drama.
Besides our leads, our side characters were also outstanding. DK and SK’s chemistry was on fire. While toxic obsession stories are not my cup of tea I give them all the props for their chemistry and flawless acting. They played incredibly nuanced characters. LQ and YZL also gave an amazing performance of their pure love story. And LMR is a new young break out actor I hope to see more of.
Special mention to the young actors playing CN and YB. They did amazing.
Music / Cinematography
I have nothing but love for this director and his way of capturing the story and the characters. He is so deliberate about his choices, the coloring, the focus, the details are just so layered and intentional.
The music and composition was beautiful.
Rewatch Value
10/10
Would rewatch, would reread, have been rewatching, and rereading.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
One of the Greatest story of extremely Strong General Couple in my book!
I have been hearing about this drama for a long time, I thought it was just another historical drama about generals but when I started watching it boy!! I was utterly blown away and completely proven wrong. I have been absolutely hooked by this unique gem from the beginning, keeping me glued to the screen eagerly waiting for every episode excitedly.What drew me to this drama is the fact that female lead is undeniably strong, yes it's bordering on supernatural strength but I love this feature. It's deliberate and most importantly it works perfectly for this most outstanding and extra ordinary story.
Hats off to all the perfect cast who have brought this magnificent masterpiece to life with their superb acting and smooth chemistry. Not only the main leads are drop dead gorgeous even the villians are heart throbs.
💫ZLH as always have portrayed his complex, layered and emotionally intense character XZ brilliantly well. With each new project his acting has become more natural, refined, and emotionally nuanced. Once again he displayed his mastery of micro-expressions in drama, particularly his ability to convey deep emotion, longing, or menace through his eyes without needing dialogue through out many scenes in this drama. The drama flawlessly showed us XZ's sweet, caring, sensitive, protective, thoughtful, soft, tender and loving family man side in contrast to his decisive, tough, possesive, manipulative, calclating, tactical, cunning, over-powering, commanding presence, patriarchal and strong unmatched awesome warrior side. XZ has very turbulent life yet he masterfully excelled in educational field and cultivated a very admirable and formidable character becoming a legendary marquis who has incorporated the wisdom of contemplating things through 9 times before taking action. He demonstrated both the brains and the brawn and showed his amazing capabilities through out the drama.
💫TXW has also nailed her character exceptionally and impeccably well. She has brought her sun like energy to brighten, employed her intense agility, perseverance and strength to bring out character FCY's warrior and wild persona. She did not fail to incorporate and blend in her sweet, bright and lively but strong and confident energy with the character to make FCY's extremely likeable and unforgettable character come to life seemlessly. She has delivered a whole range of scenes i.e. comedic, intensly emotional, romantic and action ones extremely naturally and with brilliant skills. FCY's character growth is most significantly engaging and captivating part of the story and it is done stunningly well. Her journey of being a child bearing the brunt of mocked parents, to a teenager with no parents and shouldering her household and her ill younger sister, to taking care of and protecting her severly injured husband with unstable identity and a harrassed friend, to protecting her village, to protecting the country along with all her family and friends is a massive and incrediblly admirable feat. FCY is a beauty who has brawns unquestionably yet lacked high intelligence (not being able to study due to socio-economical factors) yet she possessed very admirable rare wisdom, strong principles and insightfulness that leaves most educated people to submit to her stunning decisions and capabilities in the face of most dire circumstances. She is like a wildflower: beautiful, carefree and having capitivating presence that commands undistracted attention to it. The drama perfectly captivates her loving, caring, bold, hardworking, silly, commited, daring, responsible, wise, destressful, vulnerable, yearning, resilient, progressive, selfless and empathetic sides, she is constantly evolving and achieving new goals.
💫Villians have performed significantly well too. They also have captivated the audience with their masterful portrayal of very complex characters. QM/SYH displayed his very vicious, ruthless, obsessive, vindictive, manipulative, cunning, vengeful, selfish, unhinged and malicious sides yet did not fail to express that he was actually pitiful person and there was part of him that wanted unconditional love and care. The character that was hopelessly unreemable had wish for the light for the sake of loved one only. Then, SYQ who is no less villainous then QM bordering on maniac too similarly had a side who loved and admired his brother and wanted to protect his parents and avenge their death. Not forgetting to mention WY, didn't want to be villian but was forced to take wrong path due to all the events 16 years ago invites audiences' loathing yet subtly compels them for understanding at the same time. Then there are other villians who play the usual troupe of committing henious crimes being pathetic, greedy and selfish for the sake of power.
✨️Amongst all the other characters I love the introduction of pig slaughter squad brothers (different from novel). Their presence added a lot of fun, excitement, brotherhood moments and deeper emotional layers to the events. Also, XZ's sub general's humorous and loyal moments and events stood out a lot. Then there are LHA, Tutor Tao, Mr and Mrs Zhao, GSY, Princess, YQQ, YB, and FCN who were all so very sweet, intresting, lively, warm and handful that there was never a dull moment with them around. The director brilliantly and masterfully made the simple Linan town characters like Mr Wang, Mr Li etc stand out and have emotional presence with their lingering short but impactful stories that it pulled on viewers hearts strings to even see them get hurt.
💫The main couple YZ/ XZ and FCY had fire chemistry that went through the roof!💖👌 They blessed the viewers with all kind of dynamics: at times they were domestic, sweet, soft, cute then they had extremely passionate and emotional moments coupled with times where there was blazing tension and attraction between them. The drama perfectly executed the different phases of their love journey: their acquaintance curiosity turned into admiration then it turned into hesitant love then that turned into beautiful heart warming yearning when they were apart which later transformed into selfless, unrelenting, overpowering and unwavering love. Even though their relationship dynamic wasn't enemies to lovers yet they magnificently managed to build steaming tension between them at different instances. The viewers experience wide range of emotions between the main leads while they start from conincedental meeting, move on to mutual contractual fake marriage, then they develope genuine feelings, take their time to accept their own feelings before finding courage to confess their feelings given their inconvenient circumstances. Eventually building a positive relationship where they trust, protect and rely on each other while unraveling the mysteries and solving the challenges surrounding them.
Although the chemistry between our 2nd CP QM and YQQ was very engaging, it was morally grey relationship. Viewers were kept at the edge of their seats, teasing them that this cp might turn out okay. However sadly the only way out for their relationship dynamic was the ending QM accepted for himself. Now to the 3rd cp GSY and the princess, their love story is very cute, humorous and endearing.
💫The cenimatrography, CGI and sound effects are exteremly impressive! The directing of this drama is unquestionably ingenious. Rich attention to details in set designs, luxurious and status related costumes, resonating BGMs and OSTs, immersive atmosphere, mesmirising sceneries, very elaborate and engaging camera angles all blended in gloriously and splendidly well to bring this majestic work to life. This historical drama has high production quality, strong acting and a delicate balance between historical accuracy and compelling storytelling.
💫The drama story itself is grand in every aspect💯, encompassing emotional, and social struggles, high lighting timeless issues like class, women's rights, and social change, making them feel relevant today. It brilliantly kept multiple romantic stories with various dynamics engaging, suspenseful, exciting and captivating while immersing the viewers in the world of warfare and political intrigues. Viewers get to have taste of how the art of war is employed: the wisdom, the reasons, the psychology, the capabilities, the decisions, the restrictions, the decipline, the miltary rules and ranks, the effects of wrong decisions made on the royals, ministers and citizens' lives.
💫ENDING:
I loved the happy dreamy ending for our most beloved General CP that they have hard earned! Most villians got what was coming for them. I would have liked more elaborate ending for the pig slaughter squad, MK and GSY x Princess CP however, I was satistfied that they had peaceful and good endings where they all came to terms with what they wanted and loved to do and which paths to follow. QM x YQQ ending was very interesting, QM finally learned that to love is to be selfless enough to be able to sacrifice even your life just to make sure your loved one is happy and safe. Their ending was sad but unfortunately in this life he reached the point of no return, only by finally doing something good at the end of his life did he earn good karma for his next life. Towards the end there were many hints that most of them will meet in the next life. It was very surprising for me that YQQ is not from this world but could have been from the future world.
Epilogue:
I really liked this part. It was very unique supernatural element of the ending, it gave some more conclusion to the main narrative, revealed the future fates of some characters, wraped up some loose ends, and provided us with some final reflections. It's either a parallel universe or possible future where events of 16 years ago never happened. Where neither XZ, nor CY has lost their parents, they have a good relationship with WY( who hasn't commited any villainous acts). Like our main couple promised they chose each other in the next life too. Then, QM is a good and wise king who everyone respects while YQQ happily runs the resturant yet when they meet, due to their wish to never meet again in the next life, QM can’t stand to be in her presence in this life (wondering if they were enemies in last life). I would have preferred to see them to be a happy couple at least in this life but if this is what they both wished for in the last life then it is acceptable.
💫Overall, I enjoyed this grand work a lot. I highly recommend it anyone who enjoys historical, romantic, war and mystery dramas. It is 10/10 in every aspect for me!!
Was this review helpful to you?
1
1
1
1
1


