peng-peng:
There is no " could it be this " or " could it be that". If TH wanted it to be all those, she would have showed it in the text. She did not so all the " couldn't it be.." are not valid.
We have detailed narrative of XY thoughts to show us the reader what she is thinking. Why the need to even think " could it be this.. " when Xiao Yao herself has been telling us since chapter 1 her thoughts. TH has made sure of this. Why even question XY's internal thoughts, her wants, her desire . XY is a character who knows what she wants and is not compromising.
Your two cents are always worth more! :D
Absolutly agree. As I said this wraped chapter 13 left me...exhausted...too much of vicious mass ongoing stuff :D! For those curious, go and read here: https://mydramalist.com/discussions/lost-you-forever/122337-tong-hua-s-xiaojing-drama-novel-exploration-x1f49c?p=2959463&page=14
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@
Symbolika1:
Your two cents are always worth more! :D
Absolutly agree. As I said this wraped chapter 13 left me...exhausted...too much of vicious mass ongoing stuff :D! For those curious, go and read here: https://mydramalist.com/discussions/lost-you-forever/122337-tong-hua-s-xiaojing-drama-novel-exploration-x1f49c?p=2959463&page=14
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@
The vicious mass drained you. Bless you have some well deserved rest.
Happy Chinese New year to you as well.
@ah_luck
quick answer for now. (have whole day work on sat..)
Symbolika1 and peng peng had already answered though. We could not see her emotions shown as "romantic".
As about this ,her consciousness in this particular one...
the I reason why I said before that she's unconsciousness is because the word "her eyes were gradually seeing black"
Well if you like...you can take it as "gradually seeing black" is not "unconsiousness"or not completely ....but to me "seeing black" means not able to consiously aware anymore...nevertheless I do not find the scene romantic as to say "he came into her heart", especially looking at how she's feeling, the words used there.
Anyway....we will still have a lot to go through ...we will see how the character of XL and others will be revealed in upcoming chapters.
@Peng - Thank you for going through all (again) in your post
You've highlighted the importance of understanding the characters' perspectives and motivations in this scene. It's evident that WXLs focus is on the natural beauty of the underwater world and the creatures within it.
The emphasis on the exploration of the sea flora and fauna, as well as the avoidance of detailing the act of air sharing, underscores the non-romantic nature of the scene. Additionally, your point about Xiang Liu's conscious sharing of air and his lack of romantic thoughts or physical reactions further from WXL supports the interpretation that the scene, while can potentially appearing romantic on the surface, is not viewed as such by the character.
It's important to consider the characters' perspectives and the author's intent in crafting the scene. By analyzing the characters' motivations and reactions, we gain a deeper understanding of the non-romantic nature of the underwater experience, despite potential romantic overtones.
Your insights into the characters' perspectives and the non-romantic nature of the scene provide a valuable lens through which to analyze the dynamics of reader interpretation and authorial intent. This analysis enriches our understanding of how readers may perceive romantic elements in scenes that the author intended to be non-romantic.
here are some points that highlight the absence of romantic elements:
Focus on Exploration: The passage primarily emphasizes the characters' exploration of the underwater world. There's a focus on the wonders of the ocean, the variety of sea creatures, and the vibrant colors of the marine environment. The emphasis is on the experience of discovery rather than any romantic interactions.
Xiang Liu's Attitude: Xiang Liu's behavior towards Xiao Liu is more like that of a guide or companion. He doesn't rush Xiao Liu along and seems to be patient and accommodating, allowing Xiao Liu to take in the wonders of the underwater world at his own pace.
Interaction with Sea Creatures: The interaction with the sea creatures, such as the sea conch, the jellyfish, the ocean grass, and the predatory flowers, highlights the characters' curiosity and the unique nature of the underwater environment. These interactions are focused on the novelty and sometimes the danger of the sea life, rather than on any romantic sentiment.
Absence of Romantic Gestures: There are no romantic gestures or expressions of affection between the characters in this passage. The focus is on the characters' reactions to the underwater world, their interactions with the environment and the sea creatures, and their evasion of the Gao Xing soldiers.
It's clear that the focus is on the characters' experiences and reactions to the underwater world, and the absence of romantic gestures is evident in the passage. The misinterpretation of air passing as kissing by some readers highlights the potential for varying interpretations of a scene, but the absence of romantic gestures within the passage itself is evident.
Overall, the passage emphasizes the characters' exploration of the underwater world and their interactions with the marine environment, without any explicit romantic elements or gestures between the characters.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
@Peng - Thank you for sharing your thoughts and providing such a detailed analysis!
<3 Kisses and hugs !
THIS IS A KISS....:D , and SHE IS EAGER - SHE SAY YES !
This is WXL being naughty and hot in chapter 8-(excerpt):
There are so many interesting XiaoJing physical, loving interaction, this is just an exemple; there are more and earlier in the book. ...But saving those for now, as when we'll have covered novel and drama in our TH thread, I 'll be happy to write them all and share them. Untill than, sharing just this one :)The provided excerpt from the interaction between Xiao Liu and Shi Qi in chapter 8 presents a distinctly different tone and dynamic compared to the underwater scene from the previous passage. Here's a comparison of the two:
In contrast, the underwater scene emphasizes exploration and wonder, with no romantic gestures or interactions between the characters.
Physical Interaction: The interaction in chapter 8 involves direct physical contact and a sense of electricity or shock between the characters, indicating a more personal and intimate connection. In contrast, the underwater scene focuses on the characters' experiences and reactions to the underwater world, without any physical or intimate interactions between them.
Emotional Response: Xiao Liu and Shi Qi both exhibit a strong emotional response to the interaction, with Xiao Liu showing shock and embarrassment, and Shi Qi experiencing an electric shock. This emotional response highlights the personal and romantic nature of their interaction.
In contrast, the underwater scene does not involve any emotional response between the characters beyond their reactions to the underwater environment and their evasion of the Gao Xing soldiers.
Overall, the interaction between Xiao Liu and Shi Qi in chapter 8 presents a more intimate, personal, and romantic dynamic, while the underwater scene emphasizes exploration, wonder, and evasion without any romantic elements.
I didnt imagined this. I read this.
Have a good week end! *waves off*
Ps/ I know we agreed with you @Peng and @Winny, to post a comparative, wich you wrote soo effectivly...It's not only a good idea as we said, but it will also allow readers, and drama viewers to size more effectivly the differencies!. (tones, settings, context etc).
@ah_luck
Sorry for my last post I think I did not really answer you last time. I am really sorry. I am very uncomfortable about what Xiang Liu did in Chapter 13.
I will recall your post.
In case you are still visiting our thread. So I will answer you, probably not answer you because you probably have your preference to see things already. But I will still say what I personally think about that scene.
Let me share that part from the chaper.
XL passed oxygen into WXL. But I am focusing more on her feelings towards the guy which was not told here. It was all about surrounding the ocean. She was thrilled by it. As well as she thrilled by "Xiang Liu" . I got this from the scene on their way to Five Gods Mountains.
It's still vague assumption but it does give me vibes that she was fascinated by Xiang Liu. it sorts of said that Xiao Yao liked thrill dives in Chapter 13. (But her female self did not accept Xiang Liu ...so i did not call her attachment to XL as romantic. That's how I feel in chapter 13. ). Her happiness in getting into exploring Ocean and their relationship development, still uncertain about her romantic feelings.
Getting to save XL in gorilla mirror to me is not equal to her being in love. Because so far I don't find Tong Hua writing indicate as XL is the man Xiang Liu want as a man at all. Since all those feminine attraction feel were written for Jing. No matter whether other think XL bites and giving air as kisses, if Xiao Yao does not take it as kisses. Then no. Sorry but I just could not feel XY longing for XL in such a way.
About Gorilla mirror... umm...its precious to her because it kept her on track to who she was.
For me personally, all three male leads are vital in Xiao Yao life one way or another. So I do not consider any of their relationships as "cheap" in overall feel.
Xiang Liu and Wen Xiao Liu relationship started out with him opening up her wounds and dealing with her fear. With her nature she did not hate him but overall fascinated by him instead. But I do feel the connection with Gorilla mirror to Xiang Liu..because the mirror is rare and showing about the past but not future. Xiang Liu to me sounds more like XY escapism and dealing with her dark side which was caused by her past trauma . i may be repeating this my take so far is her fascinating towards XL in the ocean moment that she took memory of him . The object used is to keep memory from the past....if there is more feelings from Xy towards XL... hope i find more in later chapter. She chose to look at it when she made poison...she made poison because her anger was provoked by Ah Nian.
As for Cang Xuan, he was her brother, and family. Out of all 3 relationship ...yep I can still say he's number one bond for Xiao Yao so far even though theres no romance feelings as such from her. But then with the nature of the story love should not be only considered when it is romantic.
As for Jing, or Shi Qi is the one who provoke a feminine feel from WXL. Their love story started out as "first love" between young couple ...that has to face challenges both external and internal from both sides.
This is a detailed reread for me and I am still at chapter 13. I guess that there are many things I yet will get to explore more.
Romans_Revenge:
Any new pictures from s2? And when a girl tells you, you’re not the type to appear in a woman’s dream should NEVER be a compliment. That’s the most scariest thing any man would never want to hear.
Also xl NEVER had his way with XY nor got into her heart,dunno where that thought is coming from. She has been attracted, very possessive of Jing since day 1. You think she’d waste her time getting jealous of Jing’s maids, skipping the 227 stars as she counted or even looked at her side when panzi was getting married & shi qi had to avoid ah nian? Or her telling him that when she looks at him, she wants to pull him down & keep him for herself? Whiles xl she fears him. XY isn’t stupid to flee with an enemy, she’d be on people’s hit list cos not only people want to kill xl,they also want to off XY knowing who her biological father is? Not even ZX would’ve been able to protect her, plus she’s not stupid.
Yes I am looking forward to new leak pics...which are not yet up.
Xiao Yao is jealous of women around Jing. Feminine jealousy. And I am repeating whatever the reason, the book never give me the vibe that XY was in love with XL. All those matters should prevent her from falling in love with him. Because love is not just something we can choose with head all the time. She is just not for him in such a way.
