I really liked this series and it was very meaningful, I would recommendation it, however coming from a person who's sibling committed suicide this series in a weird way felt like the MF was replacing the daughter in a way, having her be born on the same day, sleep in her room etc I understood the meaning behind it, but still I found it kinda weird.
On ep 3 so far so good and love the funny moments but tbh even if I hated the plot I would watch it! His voice is so dreamy, deep and rough! Damnnn never seen a korean ML with such a voice!!!
I dont wanna watch this drama anymore but can you tell me why the FL thought he had died?
First the ML ran away from home and lied about age and FL forgive him. He got sick cancer, broke up with her and so on but then didnt tell FL he was sick instead said he was going to school abroad (after he returned home). She waited for him to return. His mother shows up and tells her he died of cancer. She was heartbroken. Crying. Everyone was, his friends he met. Years later NOT months but 5 YEARS he randomly shows back up and is like hey im alive. She is crying and he is sat laughing. I couldnt get over that point. So disgusting and ruined the series. Why lie he is dead (his treatment at the time wasnt working) and then show up 5 years later after everyone has grieved and cried over you. Ugh hated it sm and really made me hate ML so much.
How annoying was the ending? -10/10 so so bad and made me so angry! Like who comes back from the dead after 5 years, has the person you love infront of you and is laughing and smiling while they are breaking down and crying! LIKE WTF? WHO WROTE THIS?? I went from loving the ML to being so angry and disgusted! 5 years? she was grieving you, accepting your death, trying to move on and you just show up like hey I'm alive ha ha ha jokes on you!!!! WTAF! How disappointing, the series started so good! I am not a fan of the whole sick plot and how it was randomly thrown in but I still went with it and when the mum told her he died, I cried and felt her grief and sadness too. Watching everyones reaction to his death, was heartbreaking too. ONLY for them to bring him back? WTF! And if I was the MF I would of slapped him and never have wanted to see him again! Personally I think every character we saw grief him deserves to give him a slap (I am not for violence) because WTF who plays with people like that? and the excuse is, I wanted to be fully healthy before I returned? LIKE WHAT? First time ever watching a series in which I wanted the ML to stay dead. Like was the writing smoking pot? drunk? when writing the last ep! UGH!
Ugh feels like this is never coming out! Haven’t even started filming yet! A whole year and basically no actual updates from anyone (Reason why I know it hasn’t been filmed yet due to the actor who plays Cheong San in a interview a few days ago said he has no update and doesn’t know if he will be in season 2 or not and is waiting).
Don't mind me, just sobbing at 4am watching this! So bittersweet and heartbreaking. Such a well written story about the three characters, some places were dragging but overall a sad story which made me cry.
I'm I the only one still hoping and praying that a miracle will happen and YoonHee will turn up alive and well? (I know its impossible now but the show just isn't the same without her)
Season 3 so far as been such a let down. Mostly since killing of YoonHee. Since that episode, each episode has been dragging and more and more boring. Damn i wish they hadn't of killed such a good character, they could of easily of killed of one of the other mums.
I always liked this show but since they killed of Yoonhee, its went really down hill. I was never 100% a fan of her character but now she is gone, I see how much her character was a big part of the show.
I mean lets be real they didn't need to kill her. She could of been in a coma. I think the storyline should of been finding out logan is alive and finding him not a unnecessary death, and then 1 or 2 mentions of her. I don't get fhe logic behind it.
Okay so yoon hee is not dead, the fact jennys mum said they used a dummy is a big sign. So when he was going to put her into the water, she either moved or he felt she had a pulse.
So disappointing, after all the begging for forgiveness, begging for her daughters life, she kills the woman who saved her out of jealousy . No character develpment and even worse they killed Yoon Hee off. I don't get it. They said because her story was finished but I didn't see it finish, she never got to see Ro na find who her father is and the backlash off it, never came face to face with Ha Yoon Cheol again, never told Su Ryeon who her daughter is. How could her story be finished? I don't get it, find it very random to throw her death in. Such a shame. She deserved a better ending, I get penthouse isnt about happy endings but her death was not needed. I do however think now that Logan is alive due to the backlash from his death and i also think the cheque will be stolen before Su Ryeon sees it and logan will tell her that Yoon Hee had the money, so then they'll know whoever has it played a part in her death.
So annoyed though they killed her off. I wish they hadn't. However even though i wish she was alive, dont bring her back, its so unrealistic and stupid. We saw her dead body. They hide her in the wall, put her back in the water. I'm sad and heartbroken she is dead but for her to pop up back alive would be very silly and poor writing.
(I think Rona is either telling Ha Yoon Cheol or Ha Eun Byeol that its their fault her mother is dead.)
Ps i believe Ha Eun Byeol will have the most character develpment, think she heard about the DNA results and seen her mother kill Yoon Hee and will speak up even in secret.
I really hope if Rona is alive that we find out pretty quickly and see her recovery slowly. I really don't want to have to wait until the end of the season or season 3 when she comes back good as new.
(just got around to finally watch this movie) i saw that too... so does that mean he was also sick since the start?…
No he died, it seemed they all died. Even his friend at the end was secretly ill from the beginming too. Such a sad story. All three were sick and eventually died.
1. CSJ manipulated HYC & he is now as crazy as his daughter2. HEB will try to turn herself in but CSJ will do…
I agree with you in all them expect Seokhoon and Eunbyeol because before this seasons they were asked about Seokhoon and Rona and they said there relationship will be like Romeo and Juliet (forbidden love) and i keep reading that they're also hired another male to play a love rival between Seokhoon and Rona (maybe for season 3)
EP 1 - 12 I would give 9/10 but from 12 onwards, especially 15 and 16 I would give 4/10. It did not need that plot or twist. It was totally not needed. I usually love the last few eps but these were so poorly executed, with lame excuses I have to point out, I did not like the last scene. RaRa crying badly over thinking he was dead (great acting, showed great emotions) And Jun is kinda just laughing it off, like 'hey no big deal' wipe them tears oh, you think 'why did you lie about being dead for 5 years?' 'so I could fully recover' - Jun I mean seriously? couldn't come up with a better reason? I guess I expected more, him to be more sorry, more emotional, especially having pretended to be DEAD for 5 YEARS but the scene was lacking, especially the kiss (BUT the actors did great acting with the scripts they had) I really wish they hadn't spolit it with the last two ep. I mean the ending was happy but it was also meh. It was less than I hope for and less than I expected. Overall I would recommend but you may be disappointed with the last few eps.
How annoying was the ending? -10/10 so so bad and made me so angry! Like who comes back from the dead after 5 years, has the person you love infront of you and is laughing and smiling while they are breaking down and crying! LIKE WTF? WHO WROTE THIS?? I went from loving the ML to being so angry and disgusted! 5 years? she was grieving you, accepting your death, trying to move on and you just show up like hey I'm alive ha ha ha jokes on you!!!! WTAF! How disappointing, the series started so good! I am not a fan of the whole sick plot and how it was randomly thrown in but I still went with it and when the mum told her he died, I cried and felt her grief and sadness too. Watching everyones reaction to his death, was heartbreaking too. ONLY for them to bring him back? WTF! And if I was the MF I would of slapped him and never have wanted to see him again! Personally I think every character we saw grief him deserves to give him a slap (I am not for violence) because WTF who plays with people like that? and the excuse is, I wanted to be fully healthy before I returned? LIKE WHAT? First time ever watching a series in which I wanted the ML to stay dead. Like was the writing smoking pot? drunk? when writing the last ep! UGH!
😭😭😭 been waiting forever for season 2.
I mean lets be real they didn't need to kill her. She could of been in a coma. I think the storyline should of been finding out logan is alive and finding him not a unnecessary death, and then 1 or 2 mentions of her. I don't get fhe logic behind it.
So annoyed though they killed her off. I wish they hadn't. However even though i wish she was alive, dont bring her back, its so unrealistic and stupid. We saw her dead body. They hide her in the wall, put her back in the water. I'm sad and heartbroken she is dead but for her to pop up back alive would be very silly and poor writing.
(I think Rona is either telling Ha Yoon Cheol or Ha Eun Byeol that its their fault her mother is dead.)
Ps i believe Ha Eun Byeol will have the most character develpment, think she heard about the DNA results and seen her mother kill Yoon Hee and will speak up even in secret.
Season 1 he was weak
Season 2, beginning i thought YES some character develpment, he will protect Yoon hee and Rona. He has changed.
*5 seconds later*
He betrays them both again.
If that isnt bad enough, he doesn't even attend the funeral.
Fast forward ep 7 he doesnt comfort Yoon hee once. (ASSHOLE)
BUT then throughout ep 6-7 he has this attitude of poor me. ARE YOU SERIOUS?
YOU BETRAYED
LIED
LIED AGAIN
COVERED UP
Now your like Yoon Hee never forgive?
I cant go back to you?
REALLY??
WHO TF SAID THEY WANTED YOU BACK??
Yoon hee didnt
*10 seconds later*
He wants his ex wife back?
He is such trash and needs to stfu.
I cant wait until he gets his punishment. Highly needed.
(Only men on this show you can trust is Logan and Seok Hoon.)
Also,
Pretty clear now that Rona isnt dead and will be back at the end of S2.
However, why do you think Seokhoon will fall in love for real with crazy girl?
I have to point out, I did not like the last scene.
RaRa crying badly over thinking he was dead (great acting, showed great emotions)
And Jun is kinda just laughing it off, like 'hey no big deal' wipe them tears
oh, you think 'why did you lie about being dead for 5 years?'
'so I could fully recover' - Jun
I mean seriously? couldn't come up with a better reason?
I guess I expected more, him to be more sorry, more emotional, especially having pretended to be DEAD for 5 YEARS but
the scene was lacking, especially the kiss (BUT the actors did great acting with the scripts they had)
I really wish they hadn't spolit it with the last two ep. I mean the ending was happy but it was also meh. It was less than I hope for and less than I expected.
Overall I would recommend but you may be disappointed with the last few eps.