How I hope we'll get to celebrate the show's 10th anniversary with the show still airing new episodes and the same cast. Actually I hope it'll keep going even longer.
This is the show I always watch all new episodes and go rewatch old ones when nothing else interests me or when I need to watch something that will make me laugh and feel good.
The life of the show and the reason I started watching is Heechul, but I genuinely love all of the cast, their chemistry and the concept of the show.
My favorite show ever (along with Psych - an american tv show), among kdramas and variety shows and all the american tv shows I've watched, KB takes the top.
I score based on enjoyment and given the scenery, bromance and most importantly, Song Joongki's character, I did enjoy this.
But other than that, I'm not a fan of romance focused stories, especially not a romance this repetitive. I feel like they keep doing the same flirting-separating-flirting thing over and over. I'd like this story a lot more if they focused on the military aspect and the hospital aspect and left the romance as a back story. The military mission at the start of the series left me exited, the constant relationship drama from then on made me exhausted.
Generally it's a light-hearted and enjoyable watch in the fact it doesn't really need you to think or concentrate and you won't be surprised because of it's predictability. The emotional scenes are decently made, but just don't really land. The comedic elements are nice. The acting is mostly good. The cheesiness is overwhelming.
8/10 for me, but if Song Joongki and the bromance were removed, I wouldn't even watch. And if I did, this would be 6/10, definitely not bad, but not that good either, just a very average show.
This is for fans of romance, relationship drama and cheesy scenes. If you came here for the military/action tags prepare to be patient, those genres are more of a side-story.
20 episode version is a uh decent introduction but I would really suggest you watch the original 50 episodes version…
After much consideration I'll probably watch the 50 ep one, I don't want to miss certain scenes or plot points that I'm afraid might be missing in the shorter version.
I don't think you should watch this if you're fan of the original series. This will probably feel boring and lacking in comparison. I think this misses the thrill and overall feel of the original by far. Especially Reid and Gargia aka Lee Han and Na Na, I loved both of them in the original, but in this I just found them annoying. Lee Han seemed arrogant and rude, while Reid was lovable in all his weirdness and actually gave of that genius feel. Na Na was just bland, the quirkiness of Garcia didn't seem natural at all. Though this is based on just the first episode, I'm not sure where this will go in the rest of the episodes, I'm not sure yet if I'll watch the rest.
BUT if you aren't a huge fan of the original and just like police/crime/investigation dramas, I didn't find the first episode bad at all. If the rest of the episodes follow the same line, this could be an average/decent police drama.
They have appear in a lot of variety and do lots of press conferences I have watched them and they seemed pretty…
These three are definitely charismatic. I know LDW does well in variety, I'm not that familiar with the other two, but seeing them in Amazing Saturday I think they'd make a really entertaining Knowing Bros episode. Well, let's hope...
I already know how this ends and given that and how many people criticize the story, I normally wouldn't watch this (not really a fan of historical dramas). But I'm such a huge fan of Woo Do Hwan, that I have to.
Over-dramatic directing for my taste and I prefer more slow-moving stories, but I'll keep watching because of…
lol never mind, the second episode was already a lot more smooth. The flashbacks at the start were still overly dramatic for me, but rest of the episode was a lot better. Starting to look forward to this (for more than LDW)!
And I liked that the female lead didn't go to the direction I feared, but actually apologized for her actions and acted more rational from then on. A strong but reasonable female lead is rare in kdramas, but the kind I love.
Of course Dong Wook is charming, he's still the thing keeping me interested. His character Yeon is interesting and entertaining, so it's not only Dong Wook's visual that interests me.
This is the show I always watch all new episodes and go rewatch old ones when nothing else interests me or when I need to watch something that will make me laugh and feel good.
The life of the show and the reason I started watching is Heechul, but I genuinely love all of the cast, their chemistry and the concept of the show.
My favorite show ever (along with Psych - an american tv show), among kdramas and variety shows and all the american tv shows I've watched, KB takes the top.
But other than that, I'm not a fan of romance focused stories, especially not a romance this repetitive. I feel like they keep doing the same flirting-separating-flirting thing over and over. I'd like this story a lot more if they focused on the military aspect and the hospital aspect and left the romance as a back story. The military mission at the start of the series left me exited, the constant relationship drama from then on made me exhausted.
Generally it's a light-hearted and enjoyable watch in the fact it doesn't really need you to think or concentrate and you won't be surprised because of it's predictability. The emotional scenes are decently made, but just don't really land. The comedic elements are nice. The acting is mostly good. The cheesiness is overwhelming.
8/10 for me, but if Song Joongki and the bromance were removed, I wouldn't even watch. And if I did, this would be 6/10, definitely not bad, but not that good either, just a very average show.
This is for fans of romance, relationship drama and cheesy scenes. If you came here for the military/action tags prepare to be patient, those genres are more of a side-story.
Especially Reid and Gargia aka Lee Han and Na Na, I loved both of them in the original, but in this I just found them annoying. Lee Han seemed arrogant and rude, while Reid was lovable in all his weirdness and actually gave of that genius feel. Na Na was just bland, the quirkiness of Garcia didn't seem natural at all.
Though this is based on just the first episode, I'm not sure where this will go in the rest of the episodes, I'm not sure yet if I'll watch the rest.
BUT if you aren't a huge fan of the original and just like police/crime/investigation dramas, I didn't find the first episode bad at all. If the rest of the episodes follow the same line, this could be an average/decent police drama.
It's not actually bad imo.
I've a really hard time of focusing on long lasting series and I've watched the two seasons of the animation so I know how the story goes.
I know LDW does well in variety, I'm not that familiar with the other two, but seeing them in Amazing Saturday I think they'd make a really entertaining Knowing Bros episode.
Well, let's hope...
Any other The Good Detective fans around? xD
And I liked that the female lead didn't go to the direction I feared, but actually apologized for her actions and acted more rational from then on. A strong but reasonable female lead is rare in kdramas, but the kind I love.
Of course Dong Wook is charming, he's still the thing keeping me interested. His character Yeon is interesting and entertaining, so it's not only Dong Wook's visual that interests me.
Hopefully this will get over it's awkwardness after a few episodes, like many awkward-at-first shows do.