Notawe

You may not be thanking me after you watch Why Love Why. I gave it a 5/10 just because the leads had insane chemistry.

I have no idea, so you could be right. I am just a long for the ride at this point and going with the flow. I do hope the directors/writers give us a clear ending and not some open ending bullshit that we are suppose to interpret ourselves. I am not a fan of open endings.

I like it too and I watched through episode 5 and I am still confused. I agree with you, this is more horror/fantasy, but not sure about the 2 universes. Maybe those are the two time-lines that shoot off from the reality he actually lives in and in the end he has a choice to make, like in the movie Sliding Doors. I have no idea. I am just grasping at straws here.

Crying? Laughing and stupefied was more like it at the powers that be think what Mos/bank are doing is sexy......but if you liked it, more power to you!

Well, just when I think I cannot get more confused, here I am, more confused. I'm hoping the next 3 episodes will make sense of all this. It is an interesting show, but if anyone thinks they have this figured out. I bet you are wrong in the end because so far (in my opinion) there are no clear answers or clear directions on what is actually happening.

SamYo had more chemistry in this one episode than Sun/Salin in the entire series. Also what was up with that scene with the paint, yuck!!!! All I could think about was how unhygienic to have paint in their orifices. Also, were they barebacking without lube or was paint used as the lube? GROSS!!!!! What a stupid scene. What next, a food sex scene like the one in Why Love Why where they used the cake. EWWW! Hey, then lets add one more fainting scene because we can never get enough of Book/Salin fainting scenes. This show is so bad and not in a good way.

SamYo had more chemistry in this one episode than Sun/Salin in the entire series. Also what was up with that scene with the paint, yuck!!!! All I could think about was how unhygienic to have paint in their orifices. Also, were they barebacking without lube or was paint used as the lube? GROSS!!!!! What a stupid scene. What next, a food sex scene like the one in Why Love Why where they used the cake. EWWW! Hey, then lets add one more fainting scene because we can never get enough of Book/Salin fainting scenes. This show is so bad and not in a good way.

Plot holes and all. I loved this series!!! It is a fantasy and does not need to make sense 100% of the time for me. It was super entertaining and for me, that is all that matters!

You completely stumped me on how you justify an 8 rating when you say it really is a 7.2. When rounding numbers if the last number is 5 and under then it should be rounded down and not up. But, to each their own. Have a great day.

This show stunk and the rating of 8.1 is only because of die hard Fourth and Gemini fans padding the ratings. If, and that is a big IF this show had been made 10 years ago back in an era of BL infancy, it might justify the rating, but now that it is 2024 this was a terrible BL. Mudmee and Half were the only thing decent about this show, but who watches a BL for a straight couple? There was absolutely no chemistry between the leads and the acting was terrible from Fourth's overacting to Gemini's non acting (unless staring and speaking in a monotone voice is acting). Please put these guys in long pants and not in a school setting and maybe I will watch their next series with them in it, but for now, I am skeptical to watch another series with Gemini and Fourth as stars. Super disappointed all around.

Sorry, but you lost me at your 8/10 rating. There is no justification for rating this series that high. It stunk worse than a freshly run over skunk.

Please, no singing. I had someone play the guitar and sing to me once and it was super awkward/embarrassing. I endured one song and asked them to stop. I can get behind a group of people singing while someone plays the guitar, but being serenaded is extremely awkward. I started off liking this show, but already 6 episodes in and we have only gotten drunken confessions and one sober confession from a support character that we know will not be the end game and he knows he is stepping on toes, but insinuating himself anyway. Gads, this show is becoming very frustrating and boring.

I am unsure about the character of Maya or why she is needed in this series. I find the best BL's with a girl side characters are the ones where the girl is supportive and not manipulative/jealous. It just gets old watching a female character portrayed as weak/manipulative and makes the story line drag. I do like this show for the most part, especially for the relationship between Taichi and Kohei. It would be nice if a light bulb can go off inside Maya's head and she can become a supportive character and not the typical annoying female in a BL series. I like that maybe Taichi is finding a purpose and goal in life. Oh and on a side note, if someone reached over (like Maya did) to grab food from my plate without asking, I would be furious!!! How rude!!!

I am glad you like the series and hopefully the next episode will be better. Like I said, I am too far into it to turn back now.

In the first episode Taishin said after Takara asked him if he likes mountains (because he noticed that Taishin knew a lot about the plants) and I quote "I loved hanging out on the mountain near my house, that's why I love mountains.." This implies to me that he did hike around where he grew up and that is where he learned about the plants. So again, the comment about him learning to hike from the club made no sense to me. Just my take on it.

I am too far into this show to turn back now, but the lost wallet scene was such a waste of time. Taishin is beyond ridiculously naive. So far I find no reason for someone like Takara to be into him. Also, didn't Taishin grow up around a mountain, so him saying he learned to hike from being in the club makes no sense. I was under the impression that he already hiked a lot around where he grew up. 3 episodes to go and hopefully the fast forward button will not used as much on the next episode.

It was confusing in parts due to all the characters and how they were related. The leads lacked a bit of chemistry and the editing made the story choppy and hard to follow at times. I am also unsure why the 7 red blooms were needed, did they put them in the bath water, did I miss something? Overall the series was okay.

Each episode gets better and better and each character is being fully developed so we can understand their perspectives. Well done!

I find Bank's character Salin so insipid that it is hard to watch him in any scene. He is annoying and his acting induces cringes in just about every scene he is in with Mos/Sun. I am embarrassed for them both in this series. Thank goodness for the fast forward button on the remote. This show is awful, but I am in it too far to turn back now. I never thought I would ever say bring on the lesbians in a BL series.

I am hoping at some point all the fragmented pieces fall into place. Right now I am confused. I am enjoying the show even if it feels choppy and super segmented. I am along for the full ride and hopefully it will all make perfect or even semi perfect sense in the long run.