Details

  • Last Online: 20 minutes ago
  • Gender: Male
  • Location: Erehwon
  • Contribution Points: 0 LV0
  • Roles:
  • Join Date: September 7, 2024
The On1y One taiwanese drama review
Ongoing 7/12
The On1y One
2 people found this review helpful
by br85
7 days ago
7 of 12 episodes seen
Ongoing 4
Overall 7.0
Story 5.0
Acting/Cast 7.0
Music 1.0
Rewatch Value 7.0
This review may contain spoilers

By the numbers?

A conversation between me and a friend, who calls himself Zhuang Zhou:

Part I. After 7 Episodes

ME: There’s a new Taiwanese BL in town!
ZZ: Oh? Is it about stepbrothers?


ME: Ummm…
ZZ: Let’s run through the checklist. Are the leads unusually attractive?


ME: Yes.
ZZ: Is one of them poor, the other one rich?


ME: Yes.
ZZ: Is one of them a taciturn grouch, and the other a happy-go-lucky pout?
ME: Wait…
ZZ: A dead mother, or an absent father?


ME: Both!
ZZ: Does it go from (step) sibling conflict to (step) sibling rivalry to (step) sibling love to (step) sibling banging?


ME: I don’t know about the banging, but the rest of the arc is covered.
ZZ: Is there an outing by the beach, by the river, or in an arcade?


ME: Two out of three ain’t bad.
ZZ: Being pushed against a wall? "Spin the bottle"? "Teach-you-a-lesson" kiss?
ME: Uh-huh.
ZZ: An older, supportive side gay couple?
ME: Yes. But helpfully, they have no individuality so far.
ZZ: Cameos from other TBLs?


ME: Aplenty.
ZZ: Loud, intrusive background music? I mean, so relentless and unceasing, that it sometimes makes it hard to hear what they’re saying?


ME: Yes! Why do TBLs do this?
ZZ: Is there a timejump and a trip abroad?


ME: We aren’t there yet, but it is based on a novel, and the young people who have read it hint at both in the comments.
ZZ: Don't tell me they're going to pull another Addicted or Stay With Me on us.
ME: That's the fear.
ZZ: So tell me why I should watch it.
ME: Well, it is not without charm. The characters are in school, and they are actually shown schooling! You know, books, teachers, homework, and all that stuff which other BLs pretend don’t exist? Plus, in this world, the teenagers do have boners, which, of course, most teenage boys do all the time. (Remember what filth we entertained in our heads?) So, it is not chaste. And the leads do have great chemistry.
ZZ: Tell me why I shouldn’t.
ME: The fans might murder me for this. But the episodes are far too long for what they contain. They could have done each episode in 30 minutes or less (which the Japanese seem able to do effortlessly). I'm not sure what all those lingering shots of nothing accomplished. Don't get me wrong, I love seeing the boys together. At the same time, this is not exactly Andrei Rublev. So if you do watch it, you might want to skip or speed through parts of it.
ZZ: It does sound like it is full of the tropiest tropes that ever troped.
ME: Doesn’t matter if done well, though, does it? I myself am a bit divided about the show, but on the whole, I'm rather enjoying it than not.
ZZ: Maybe I’ll give it a go. I’ll call you after it’s done.
ME: Shhhhh…. Don’t let people know we call each other! What will the teenagers on MDL think?
ZZ: Right.
Was this review helpful to you?