This review may contain spoilers
A great drama with a few problems.
I have a lot to say about this one.
To be clear, generally, I think it's a good drama that really is worth the watch. The story is compelling, the characters are interesting, the chemistry is good, and the pacing wasn't bad either.
The story starts with Gu Qing Zhi, the eldest daughter of the Gu clan, as she kills herself. She then somehow merges souls or overtakes the body (idk; they never made it clear what even happened) of Shen Xi He, the Commandery Princess. The previously gentle, kind, and delicate Princess transforms into a ruthless, fierce, and strong woman overnight, and literally no one, NO ONE, questions it. They're like, 'oh ok whatever'.
The Crown Prince is portrayed as this frail, sick, and weak poisoned prince with a short lifespan. But surprise surprise, he is actually really strong and agile, completely mastering martial arts, and really smart, the big brains behind everything. He saves the Princess from drowning, falls in love with her, and becomes the most devoted, dramatic, delulu fictional man I have ever seen.
The Princess has to choose a husband between all the princes, 3 of whom are completely in love with her—for some reason. This part was really dragged out; my girl refused to CHOOSE, like come on, you have like 3 fine shyts pursuing you, one of whom is literally just the EMBODIMENT of green flag. However, when she does eventually choose the Crown Prince, it gets significantly better.
I really did like both characters a lot. Xi He is a headstrong woman who doesn't fear anyone. The Crown Prince is a downbad diva, but also really smart. Both are calculating and always 10 steps ahead of their opposition (perfect for my delicate heart), so it's never a matter of IF they can outsmart them, but more so a question of what masterplan they have to knock everyone out.
The 2nd couple has got to be one of the best parts of the show. It's a shame they got so little screen time. I was squealing every time they showed up on screen.
The villains of the show were all really well done, I just wished that the 2nd ML wasnt part of them, I really hoped they would finally make him let go of his obsession, but NO, this is a cdrama and no one can healthily deal with regection (I am joking, the other guy who was in love with her did let go, which I loved)
My biggest issue with this drama was the ending, which felt very incomplete and riddled with unanswered questions. The Crown Prince dies, and I cried, truly. They then spent literally the next 4 episodes developing what happened after and that whole plot, which I really liked; it was flushed out well and was interesting. The real problem is when, like 5 years later, PLOT TWIST, the Prince ISN'T dead and was like stowed away somewhere (idk) and somehow magically recovered from the poison which was uncurable the WHOLE show; he suddenly didn't care WHO poisoned him (also a big part of the show), is really old with grey hair for some reason, and what? Xi He knew the whole time????
There was so much left unanswered: How did he fake his death? Where did he go? How did he cure himself? Is he the emperor now? Why is the physician also suddenly really old? What were the people's reactions when the dead Crown Prince suddenly comes back to life??
Although I was heartbroken when he died, I had come to accept it. It worked for the story. It made sense; it tied up most of the loose threads. But to cater to the happy ending, they destroyed a perfectly good ending, instead introducing something completely useless, so instead of inducing any lingering feeling after watching the drama, all I felt was confusion. I'm not mad he's back; I just think the story didn't need it, at least at that point, or in that specific way.
I understand that the novel probably answers these questions, but I wasn't here for a novel adaptation; I was here for a drama, so I expect an ending that makes sense, and I expect the drama to deliver it, not a book I do not want to read.
TL; DR
A good drama, with a compelling story and great characters. It only had some logic and ending problems; otherwise, it was a satisfying watch.
To be clear, generally, I think it's a good drama that really is worth the watch. The story is compelling, the characters are interesting, the chemistry is good, and the pacing wasn't bad either.
The story starts with Gu Qing Zhi, the eldest daughter of the Gu clan, as she kills herself. She then somehow merges souls or overtakes the body (idk; they never made it clear what even happened) of Shen Xi He, the Commandery Princess. The previously gentle, kind, and delicate Princess transforms into a ruthless, fierce, and strong woman overnight, and literally no one, NO ONE, questions it. They're like, 'oh ok whatever'.
The Crown Prince is portrayed as this frail, sick, and weak poisoned prince with a short lifespan. But surprise surprise, he is actually really strong and agile, completely mastering martial arts, and really smart, the big brains behind everything. He saves the Princess from drowning, falls in love with her, and becomes the most devoted, dramatic, delulu fictional man I have ever seen.
The Princess has to choose a husband between all the princes, 3 of whom are completely in love with her—for some reason. This part was really dragged out; my girl refused to CHOOSE, like come on, you have like 3 fine shyts pursuing you, one of whom is literally just the EMBODIMENT of green flag. However, when she does eventually choose the Crown Prince, it gets significantly better.
I really did like both characters a lot. Xi He is a headstrong woman who doesn't fear anyone. The Crown Prince is a downbad diva, but also really smart. Both are calculating and always 10 steps ahead of their opposition (perfect for my delicate heart), so it's never a matter of IF they can outsmart them, but more so a question of what masterplan they have to knock everyone out.
The 2nd couple has got to be one of the best parts of the show. It's a shame they got so little screen time. I was squealing every time they showed up on screen.
The villains of the show were all really well done, I just wished that the 2nd ML wasnt part of them, I really hoped they would finally make him let go of his obsession, but NO, this is a cdrama and no one can healthily deal with regection (I am joking, the other guy who was in love with her did let go, which I loved)
My biggest issue with this drama was the ending, which felt very incomplete and riddled with unanswered questions. The Crown Prince dies, and I cried, truly. They then spent literally the next 4 episodes developing what happened after and that whole plot, which I really liked; it was flushed out well and was interesting. The real problem is when, like 5 years later, PLOT TWIST, the Prince ISN'T dead and was like stowed away somewhere (idk) and somehow magically recovered from the poison which was uncurable the WHOLE show; he suddenly didn't care WHO poisoned him (also a big part of the show), is really old with grey hair for some reason, and what? Xi He knew the whole time????
There was so much left unanswered: How did he fake his death? Where did he go? How did he cure himself? Is he the emperor now? Why is the physician also suddenly really old? What were the people's reactions when the dead Crown Prince suddenly comes back to life??
Although I was heartbroken when he died, I had come to accept it. It worked for the story. It made sense; it tied up most of the loose threads. But to cater to the happy ending, they destroyed a perfectly good ending, instead introducing something completely useless, so instead of inducing any lingering feeling after watching the drama, all I felt was confusion. I'm not mad he's back; I just think the story didn't need it, at least at that point, or in that specific way.
I understand that the novel probably answers these questions, but I wasn't here for a novel adaptation; I was here for a drama, so I expect an ending that makes sense, and I expect the drama to deliver it, not a book I do not want to read.
TL; DR
A good drama, with a compelling story and great characters. It only had some logic and ending problems; otherwise, it was a satisfying watch.
Was this review helpful to you?
