1
Started out well, ended up dark, depressing and emotionally vacuous
By the time this ended, I disliked almost everything about the drama.
Starting out incredibly well, it turned into just a vacuous cesspool of depravity, evil and narcissism, with nothing good coming from any of it.
Feng Shao Feng's performance as the iconic Di Ren Jie, and who was initially portrayed interestingly, turns into a truly arrogant, lecture-y and constantly-berating-others caricature, while Li Yu's always-shouting-at-high-volume Duan Shi Si is annoying as hell, and the other bland two might as well not even have been there, as mostly useless as they turn out to be.
There is also no chemistry between any of the leads who, IMO, did not seem like a team at any point during the entire story.
The cases themselves are dark, depressing, nasty and without much redemption.
For me, for dramas like this to work, there has to be some goodness comes out of the evil occasionally, or it ends up being just a debauched slash-fest with no substance, which this turned out to be.
Like one of the main characters said at the end about all the people in town just going about their business as if they had no part in the mess - De Ren Jie lecturing them was pointless. Just as pointless as this drama.
And it's why Strange Tales of Tang Dynasty, with its humor and its cases sometimes working out for the best, works and this one doesn't.
From the drama deliberately being titled 'Season 1', I'm presuming there will be a Season 2. I doubt I will be watching it. Not unless the plot is markedly different, as I'm not interested in something this dark with no conceivable goodness or redemption to it.
Not if it's the same self-indulgent, emotionally empty, and ultimately bland and draggy mess.
Eventually gave it a 7 out of 10 as the cinematography and set design is gorgeous, the opening animation is beautifully created, and I loved the ending theme (even if it is, apparently, AI-generated? Disappointing as well, if true.)
Starting out incredibly well, it turned into just a vacuous cesspool of depravity, evil and narcissism, with nothing good coming from any of it.
Feng Shao Feng's performance as the iconic Di Ren Jie, and who was initially portrayed interestingly, turns into a truly arrogant, lecture-y and constantly-berating-others caricature, while Li Yu's always-shouting-at-high-volume Duan Shi Si is annoying as hell, and the other bland two might as well not even have been there, as mostly useless as they turn out to be.
There is also no chemistry between any of the leads who, IMO, did not seem like a team at any point during the entire story.
The cases themselves are dark, depressing, nasty and without much redemption.
For me, for dramas like this to work, there has to be some goodness comes out of the evil occasionally, or it ends up being just a debauched slash-fest with no substance, which this turned out to be.
Like one of the main characters said at the end about all the people in town just going about their business as if they had no part in the mess - De Ren Jie lecturing them was pointless. Just as pointless as this drama.
And it's why Strange Tales of Tang Dynasty, with its humor and its cases sometimes working out for the best, works and this one doesn't.
From the drama deliberately being titled 'Season 1', I'm presuming there will be a Season 2. I doubt I will be watching it. Not unless the plot is markedly different, as I'm not interested in something this dark with no conceivable goodness or redemption to it.
Not if it's the same self-indulgent, emotionally empty, and ultimately bland and draggy mess.
Eventually gave it a 7 out of 10 as the cinematography and set design is gorgeous, the opening animation is beautifully created, and I loved the ending theme (even if it is, apparently, AI-generated? Disappointing as well, if true.)
Was this review helpful to you?
