Details

  • Last Online: 8 days ago
  • Gender: Female
  • Location:
  • Contribution Points: 0 LV0
  • Roles:
  • Join Date: August 9, 2021
Completed
Bad Buddy
5 people found this review helpful
Dec 20, 2021
12 of 12 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 10
Story 10
Acting/Cast 10
Music 9.0
Rewatch Value 10

Best BL of 2021

I began watching this series before it was completed and had to wait patiently for new episodes. Never have I been so anxious to know what happens to fictional people. I have never seen a story that captivates the unpredictability of emotions so perfectly. The complication of having family drama and the pressure of keeping everyone will be happy at what may seem to be the cost of your own happiness.

The story centres around Pat and Pran and builds so much that I honestly was wondering where they can go, but they found a way to not only keep it fresh but captivating. They are separated both at school and at home, due to faculty wars and family wars, which had me wondering if this series is really a BL because their was no one for them to be in the same space unless they are fighting. Then in the heights of emotions and battles, emotions get out of hand and then that balcony scene happened. I was literally holding my breath. The actors really showed of their skills in this scene, the will they wont they dynamics came to a head. the tension, the intensity, the emotion and the uncertainty had me at the edge of my seat. I was so worried about what was going to happen that I had removed the subtitles and tried to judge what was going on from their actions. This had me broken from the moment Pran walked off and left Pat standing there. I literally could not process it and I had to re-watch the scene with the subtitles only for every word to pull at my heart to have it finally ripped out when he walked off.

When it finally began to look like they got everything figured out, the curtain drops and its back to square one. I felt for Wai the most because he actually was genuinely hurt by his best friend keeping secrets. The writing on this show truely captured the essence of having to keep things a secret for everyone to be happy. While also showing that love has no limits and doesn't require much for you to have all you need. That moment when they returned home because they realise it isn't all about their happiness, made it worth so much more for me because too many times people forget your actions affect others.

This show truly was a rollercoaster of emotions with highs and lows, the best part about it is that, no matter which emotion they had someone right there with them. It was an amazing experience going through this part of their lives with them.

PS: If you have made it to the where the Pat's dad refused Pat's friend gift. Congrats to their parents for possibly turning into adults.

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
United Win
5 people found this review helpful
Mar 20, 2022
12 of 12 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 9.0
Story 9.0
Acting/Cast 8.0
Music 7.0
Rewatch Value 10

Friendship goals

This was a light-hearted and funny series, that managed to throw in some serious subject matter. Following primarily the relationships between the various boys of the school track and field team. Giving me a true sense of great writing, because they honestly were perfect friends. Always there for each other, always helped each other... without looking for anything at all in return. This series gave me family and friends, which is totally what I love to see, but they had real natural drama, not the kind that requires a fight and tears, but the kind that has you feeling for the characters because it hits close to home. The actors brought their A game to their roles, making their characters pain, happiness and confusion seem real. The lack of rediculous drama also made them feel like the children down the street, with real problems and the actors brought the personalities to life with ease.

Thankfully it had no cliché drama to speak of, but did touch on some serious issues of poverty and how it affects the children that care enough to know what their parents are going through to provide for them, especially for a single parent household. Bullying was also added to the mix and they did it masterfully, letting it play out naturally giving the audience a sense of placement within the story, making judgements based on what little we know. Teaching real lessons that it's not good to judge a book by its cover.

The ending unfortunately felt really underdeveloped and abrupt. The last couple episodes introduced so many new elements into the best friends lives, but the series ended before we could know what truly happened. However, as disappointing as this was, it was still an amazing series that touched all the right feels.

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
Kimi ni wa Todokanai.
3 people found this review helpful
Dec 21, 2023
8 of 8 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 9.0
Story 8.0
Acting/Cast 10
Music 8.0
Rewatch Value 10

Sweet romance

This was a very short series, but it packed so much heart into it. I was able to believe every word and they did this without any of the tropes being over done or even present. The little details of each interaction sold the story.

The story is nothing special, as friends fall in love all the time, but the execution of it in this series was well done. The small details that made the other wonder but could never quite figure out why made it seem natural. They are supposed to be best friends and that seemed to be the main driving force behind everything. It was really well paced with the romance building without being outright, the glances the unexplained annoyances when the other spent too much time with someone else. It was all great and the fact that they had great friends was a nice touch. This complimented everything about the story, as the advice from the secondary friends were always spot on. It was a perfect example of how friends should be with each other in real life.

The acting was spot on from both leads and their chemistry was undeniable. They played well off of each other and really conveyed that jealous boyfriend energy well. This also worked well for their best friend dynamic and the supporting cast was also on point.

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
HIStory: Obsessed
3 people found this review helpful
Sep 10, 2021
4 of 4 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 1.5
Story 3.5
Acting/Cast 5.0
Music 5.5
Rewatch Value 1.5

A rapist wet dream

This was something else. I don't understand how this qualifies as a romance when there was nothing romantic about it. Don't be fooled, his obsession took the form of sexual assault, which moved to manipulation. Blokes like this are trash in real life, learn to take no as the answer, not as an invitation. Furthermore, don't be playing you crying because you taking advantage of someone and claim it is because you love them so much. That is just crazy.

Story - I think they could have developed it into a proper storyline that seemed to have a build up to obsession, but since it jumped right into obsession... It was not pleasant to try and follow, because it felt as if something was missing the entire time. The ending was just so messed up... That is not love that is just sadness. This is not a story anyone should live in real life.

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
Close Friend
2 people found this review helpful
Dec 2, 2023
6 of 6 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 3.0
Story 3.0
Acting/Cast 5.0
Music 7.5
Rewatch Value 1.0

An honest failure

This was truly a nice attempt at being a good multiverse of stories, but it failed on so many of them. The stories were just lacking substance and some of the actors just didn't have enough to go on. A few met the mark, but I am an A+ student... So I will leave it there.

Episode 1: Having such great acting talent and not going anywhere was sad. This was mostly because of the rushed sto... well what should have been there story, but it went by so quickly that it seemed like a rumour. It was arguably the best in the short stories that this show offered. I felt a little cheated out of what could have been a great story, a little longer and we could have seen a real start, challenge and resolution.

Episode 2: This was just uncomfortable, like up to now I have know idea if the main lead was having a fever dream or not. It was way too confusing, the acting wasn't stella neither, but at least they are handsome. I think the plot didn't give them much to work with so they just did the best they can.

Episode 3: Was this episode really necessary? It felt like a waste, hurried and pointless in terms of character and direction. I mean what really was the story here.

Episode 4: Was a slight gem within these stories, simple and realistic. It didn't feel rushed and had a nice buildup that made me believe it wasn't to fake. The actors chemistry wasn't amazing, but it was alright, the story was cute enough to be enjoyed.

Episode 5: Definitely the sweetest out of all the stories. The pacing, the story telling, everything was great. The cinematography could have been better, but that's minor. Worth making it through the others to see.

Episode 6: Steupssss. Lost me again with this episode, the story was sad and not in a good way. I can't even say more because it really doesn't have much substance to speak of why I didn't like it at all. I like fantasy games but this was just not it. Get a life bro, you to handsome to be wasting it in your room.

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
Crash Landing on You
2 people found this review helpful
May 12, 2023
16 of 16 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 9.5
Story 10
Acting/Cast 9.0
Music 8.0
Rewatch Value 10

Amazingly well done

I saw this show as a suggestion within my Netflix's account, wondered why it was there, but I decided to give it a try. Never in my wildest dreams would I guessed how much a grip this show would eventually have on me. I often found myself wondering what will happen next, and that isn't an often occurrence when I watch shows. From beginning to almost the end this series crash landed on my emotions and took me for an amazing ride.

The story...
Was well written to the point of me not being able to guess what was coming next quite a lot, that masterful mystery, kept me watching episode after episode. While it may not have been totally original, it was original enough to make me feel like no aspect of it was repeated in another show. The comedy the action, the suspense, the uncertainty of it all had everyone on the edge of their seats. Wanting and waiting for what is going to happen next. The pacing was also well done, building from a moment of will they wont they, are they falling for each other, or are they just crazy. It was so much fun watching their dance of the sugar plum. The action, the back stories and everything in-between built a series that everyone should watch. The leads dedication to each other's happiness and well being will keep you watching, along with their interactions with the other members of the 5th company. That moment when they were trying to surprise her for her birthday, even I wanted them to still be there. Even the mole is loved in this show.

The characters...
Captain Ri's character was soooo refreshing, to see someone from his background, be so gentle and caring for basically a totally stranger that crash landed on him. While his every move may not have been calculated, it was all for the same goal. Has character was so well built, from his leadership qualities to his family values to his duty. Nothing could have been better with this man. Just take a look as his faithful squad members, that never missed a beat to make sure that he was taken cared of and safe. When you got people that would risk their lives for you, that is when you know that you have been good in life. His chemistry with yoon se and the 5th company members were perfect. You could swear they were all family that grew up and sipped tea together since they were children. He did an excellent job with his role.

Yoon Se was masterfully built to be a strong and independent woman, that still knew how to be a polite and sometimes petty woman. This made her sooo loveable, that you couldn't help but want the best for her. Given what she endured growing up, she's not broken just bent, but still her family were written to be complete rubbish. You'll see.

5th Company members were all the best ride or die friends you could ever ask for and you could tell it wasn't strictly about them being in the military together. Their personal relationships were some of the best bromances ever written. That moment, when Capt. ri shoed up with those shoes to give to guem. I bet you will cry. These blokes were a joy to watch, their chemistry and physical comedy were amazing.


Wow these people had me. THat's just it, they had me for the entire series, they just had me. They did what they want and they just had me. Thank you for this series. I always say blood ain't nothing but blood, family is what you need to check for.

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
Bro and Me
2 people found this review helpful
Sep 10, 2021
8 of 8 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 2.0
Story 1.0
Acting/Cast 5.0
Music 2.5
Rewatch Value 1.0

Was this real?

I honestly believe that this series was intended to be a joke. No way they were serious when they were making this series. Maybe they wanted to slap a few of us BL watchers in the face and say "take dat"

Story - The story, if it can be called that, did not live up to anything because it was practically none existent. The series began and it ended, whatever happened in-between those things was a failure. They tried, I think, but maybe it could have been a slapstick comedy, but in this series it was painful to watch. The characters had no substance and most of it felt like a child getting into their parents alcohol and having a fever dream. Nothing made sense....

Acting- The acting may have been good, but with the story that was presented, I couldn't tell. Everything seemed overdone or underwhelming. However, it may have just been what they had to work with.

Music - It had music... That's about all I can say. We could hear it but it had nothing to work with.

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Dropped 35/37
Best Choice Ever
2 people found this review helpful
Jun 24, 2024
35 of 37 episodes seen
Dropped 0
Overall 5.0
Story 4.5
Acting/Cast 9.0
Music 6.0
Rewatch Value 1.0
This review may contain spoilers

Ohhh Mother!!!!

There isn't really much to speak about in this series, though it was soooo long. so lets get into it:

Dang, this is such a ridiculously long series that was about a greedy mother. Literally the entire series is about this greedy woman trying to pretend she wants her children to have a better life than her's. It took 20 episodes to solidify she was just a gold digger that didn't get to strike gold for herself so she was doing everything to ensure that her daughter did. Once she found out her daughter BF was rich rich, she couldn't wait to get them married, swear her daughter was a prized cow that she wanted to sell off to the highest bidder. She was truly disgusting to watch, worst yet, episode 16 was the heights of disrespects to her daughter, like how do you even do that to another human being and then have the gull, de audacity, de ko-ho-Nays to plan a whole wedding and not tell the bride.. the bride, the second most important person in a wedding. This lady made all asian mothers look horrible. I've been to China and they love tradition but they not about this level. I felt so sorry for the groom, he really was just a bystander in this horrific accident that his sister and that crazy woman that happen to be the mother of the girl, planned. It just got worst and worst, and finally at the latter half of the series, you get fooled into thinking the mother finally found a clue under her gold digging pickaxe, but no she goes off and makes everything about herself again, making her entire family blow a blood vessel simply out of worry all under the guise that she doesn't want them to worry. Like how stupid is that, you run away so they don't have to worry, because they wont worry about why you just vanish.

Now, that I feel like I got enough of that off my chest (sooo much more I wanted to say), lets get onto the romance of the show. That is basically it, because there is nothing to speak about it. The total romance equates to about 1hr and 47 min of screen time, It was totally sad. I mean they were cute and their chemistry was somewhat cute, but it was like a sub-thought in the midst of a family drama soap opera.

I was truly disappointed with the entire series, because it had a romance listed... I can't even pretend this is a cautionary tale to other children, because everyone seems to just love to enable the mother and cuddle her for the rubbish behaviour she is exhibiting. Soo many opportunities the father and brother had to let her know that she is off the deep end of crazy but they made excuses...

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
Debut
2 people found this review helpful
Jan 27, 2022
23 of 23 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 3.0
Story 3.0
Acting/Cast 9.0
Music 10
Rewatch Value 1.0
This review may contain spoilers

Madness

A show about music and the music industry filled with good-looking persons and great music. The acting was solid and every single member of the cast is talented. No doubt about that, they could all sing (it was recorded and lip synced) and they could all dance like crazy. The music was insanely good, every song had meaning, fit the mood and had a purpose. It wasn't just music for the sake of music. I appreciated the singing more than the rapping but that is just my personal preference. The chemistry between all the actors was perfect Everyone played their part well in the collective. They attempted a bromance with some solid I love you moment where the words weren't said but the actors pulled it off.

However, I swear this show pissed me off more and more as it went on. I hopped for so long that it would get better but it didn't. It literally got crazier as it went on and not in the good way. So much of this made no sense, I mean like legit NO SENSE.

Lets get into the bad aspects.
Firstly, lets get into the K=pop world that they created. While it is a known fact that the K-pop factory only values talent that comes connected to a pretty face. It should never be normalised to call someone "Fatty" nor "Skinny" it was literally atrocious, they aren't that bad from my research. People also aren't so desperate to make it in the industry that they turn out to be scum. Miaoli is literally the scum of the earth, No human being should be so despicable, and the worst part about her is that she kept saying that she is doing it to help Yuchi Ke. The worst people are the ones that always say they are helping you but know they are only using you to get what they want, you and Evil are the same person.

Secondly, lets get into the logic of things. An entire person seemed to have disappear and no one is looking for him? Whether he was Bai Ling or Lu Xiang doesn't matter because Bai Ling was dead and they made this clear from the first episode. So where did this extra body come from and why did it not have a name attached to it? The accident also made no sense, because there were two bodies lying on the road, with NO EXPLANATION. People also seem to be easy to kidnap with no one reporting it nor anyone even looking for them... Even when taken from in front a hospital.
Why was this girl pole dancing so much within the series, it didn't even seem to be part of the story development nor to her character development. It was just random, like the fight club they had during training. Pointless and confusing with no contribution to the plot.

Lastly, the final episode had no explanation or completion of anyone's story except for the company's mission to put out ACE. The guys just seem to all debut, but it appeared that the two bodies didn't have to share a soul anymore or maybe they did, I really have no clue because it was so poorly done. There was a disgraced artist who became a director at the company but no backstory as to how nor why. Their were four persons that shared two souls (2x1) and no explanation at all not even a hint.

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
Dear Doctor, I'm Coming for Soul
1 people found this review helpful
8 days ago
12 of 12 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 6.0
Story 7.0
Acting/Cast 7.0
Music 5.0
Rewatch Value 4.0

Could have been great

This could have been such a great series, but for the most part it was very good. That doesn't mean it wasn't great it just could have been better.

Let me get the good things out there
The story was very interesting as it is two sides of the same coin and watching there relationship was great to see. One trying to save lives and one dealing with the lives that were lost. The chemistry between the two main leads was sufficient and those boys cute, so that was a good start. Prakan and Tua did a good job with what they were given. Nuch and Kheeta were great additions to the cast of friends, supportive and caring.

Now lets unpack all the bad things
Soo many plot holes and immature doctors, are they in high school uniforms or doctor uniforms???
Prakan made the relationship between the two leads sooooo toxic. Bro you are a doctor, if you cannot handle death, you really should not be a doctor. Also, all the times you tripped off on a soul reaper like if he is killing people was unnecessary, you a whole doctor and you can't understand a simple concept of a killer and an escort? Being depressed is understandable when certain persons in your life die, but throwing away your entire self worth is a bit much, especially since you are educated grow the hell up, stop making people want to slap you so hard that even your mother feels it, just stop it.
Metha was by far the biggest dushbag I ever did have the displeasure to see, and no that ending didn't give him some redeeming grace. He always lurking watching people through a side eye, what the hell. Not to mention he literally taking bush medicine for his father pain. While his father is wrong for transferring his hate or greed for others to him, he is also grown, he should think for himself. Though that uncle is a snake also, he needed a cut tail for being a crappy adult nut Metha need better people around him so he might be less of a rubbish human.
A doctor based series should not have soooooo many inacuracies, do some research or at least ask a question. Who speeds past an ambulance near an accident scene, that was the most ridiculous scene ever.

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
Cooking Crush
1 people found this review helpful
Jul 17, 2024
12 of 12 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 7.0
Story 6.0
Acting/Cast 8.0
Music 5.5
Rewatch Value 7.0

Cute, but that is about it

Doc and Prem were extremely likeable and charming. Off and Gun, did well in their roles and the romance was pretty believable. They had so many cute moments that made me love their relationship. They honestly made each other better. Neo and Aungpao were honestly way more main couple effect though. Their playful banter, their genuine care for each other, the fact that they are both drop dead handsome. Like power couple handsome, it was perfect, even the issues with Fire's mom was a realistic and finding out how Dy's family reacted to him was heartbreaking but necessary. He is a strong bloke and I think everyone benefits from having him in their lives. They touched on some very important topics of family and friends and while not making it a grand spectacle, they still handled it with care. The ending was just what I expected and it was honestly great to see a show stick to a lesson.

As someone that can actually cook, it was really funny to see a cooking drama that was more of a comedy than anything else. It was also nice to see them pretend to be chefs, because in a real kitchen they would burn a lot of things. I love a cooking and more importantly, eating, so this show was just my taste.

I love seeing a lot of the actors that partook in this series, but the series itself didn't have much of a story to me. They like to cook and they want to be like their hero chef. The 3Bs or whatever the group is called, were sad to see. Like you all too grown looking like parents in a college picking on some children, get a life and graduate on time. His father finding a posted that Doc found at Prem house is so far fetched that I almost laughed. Like who would believe that he kept that posted, like be real.

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
Twinkling Watermelon
1 people found this review helpful
Jun 3, 2024
16 of 16 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 9.0
Story 9.0
Acting/Cast 10
Music 8.0
Rewatch Value 9.5

Refreshing

Honestly one of the best series that I have seen where persons that have a different way of life is depicted. The family life that was shown is so accurate to the ones that persons with hearing limitations have to face. As someone that knows sign language but doesn't have to, it was nice to see a story that revolved around it. All the concerns that go with being in their situation was real and I appreciated having them in such an amazingly positive light.

The story was new to me, having the hint of mystery and time travel and a sprinkle of romance...Sorta. The life conversations I couldn't follow because I don't know the signs used, but it was still beautiful to watch. I must say, for a person that supposed to be "super smart" Gyeol was pretty dumb too many times, but it was funny so I excused most of it. His passion and understanding were his driving force to help everyone he met, I mean he did have direct relation to them, but even if Ha Yi Chan was a stranger I would risk it all to help him also. He is honestly so amazing, his thirst for life and living it to the fullest because he wants to help his grandma. I wish he got the world, but he got the next best thing. He was kind and caring while being a fool, there was no reason to not love him. I literally cried when his tape got left in street because of you know what. Worst yet when he was standing on the roof of the hospital after his grandma visited him. I tell you there was no more heartbreaking scene than these moments. Yoon Cheong Ah was such an amazing example of resilience, strength and determination seeing her growth into having friends that she trust was sweet. Her teacher though, lets just say she needed more than a time out and I was sooooooo happy when all her maids got fired.

The ending honestly wasn't amazing but I loved how things turned out, it was slightly underwhelming but I still liked it.

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
The Uncanny Counter
1 people found this review helpful
Apr 19, 2024
16 of 16 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 10
Story 10
Acting/Cast 10
Music 8.0
Rewatch Value 10

Best of its class

Starting watching this due to a YouTube short that highlights the relationships of the best friends. I could have never guessed how amazing this show would be. From the acting to the fight scenes, the annoyance to the heartbreak, it was truly a masterclass in making a great show.

Story wise, it had some clichés, but it was vastly outweighed by the impeccable writing and execution. The twist of superheroes being punctuated by regular family drama and passion gave the the best dynamic ever. I loved seeing how their relationship evolved and how they protected each other at all costs. Mae connection to her other world partner was heartbreaking to find out but it made me want to protect them even more. Having mo tak story be intertwined with their destiny was also an unexpected touch. You all did him dirty though, I mean come on, he now finds out about the ring thing and has to go a funeral. I was constantly guessing and hoping that things wouldn't happen and found myself screaming at the TV, like if that would make a difference. That is the sign of a great show.

Moon was a bit to irrational for an 18 year old, but I'll excuse him because he has been through a lot. He started off as a major liability but redeemed himself. His relationship with his besties is the stuff of fairy-tales, it was so refreshing to see how much they genuinely loved each other. That rooftop scene between the three of them was gold, it's always great to see friends holding each other accountable. Even them taking care of the bully was done right.

The acting and chemistry between everyone, even the main spirit was amazing. His evil smile, his evil giggle... I was here for it. Lee Hong did an amazing job, to the point where I felt sorry for him when they reveal how he got that scare. They honestly made no mistakes in the series can't wait to see season 2.

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
Utsukushii Kare
1 people found this review helpful
Aug 7, 2022
6 of 6 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 9.0
Story 10
Acting/Cast 8.0
Music 8.0
Rewatch Value 7.5

Flaws and All

This was a refreshing change of story for the BL world. No triple takes of basic moments that don't deserve it, No bully that fall in love, no ridiculous high school drama... My only negative is that the final shot could have been anything else. Literally ANYTHING ELSE.

The cast for this series did very well in portraying their characters and their characters were well written. I say this because they were all flawed, which made them human. While this can be considered unhealthy by some, their brokenness is what made their love seem worth it. They had moments of fear where they acted out, moments of insecurities were they withdrew into their shells. They lived, learned and eventually found the courage to let themselves live.

Give it a watch and remember while watching that nobodies perfect. Even if you want to treat them like a king.

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
Navillera
1 people found this review helpful
Mar 3, 2022
12 of 12 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 10
Story 10
Acting/Cast 10
Music 10
Rewatch Value 10

Amazing

This show was by far one of the most touching and inspirational shows I have ever seen. Giving you everything you need in a few hour long sessions. They had sports, and yes dance of any kind is a sport. At least it is for those that are dancer, not for those that can dance. This story is a true testament that it is never too late to follow your dreams, but it will not be easy.

Lee on his own, has his own daemons to deal with but it never seemed to break him, however, his heart does get broken because of Sim. This well paced and well written relation development, touched my heart. Showing all you really need is one person to support you and you can achieve anything. No dream is impossible, and they both had dreams that they were fighting for. Sim's family honestly made me sad, for they (especially the eldest son) were so absorbed in their own image, that they didn't realise that they can only be held accountable for what they do. Also, no two person's happiness are brought by the same thing.

I was happy to see all the characters development that took place during the series. Telling the story of family, friends and strangers that become family, like no other. The last few episodes broke my heart when he got on that plan but the anxiety I felt was at peak when I studied how it may be if they returned but everything is forgotten. Lee and Sim had the best chemistry between them, setting the stage for their teacher student relationship to grow into something more like family.

These men acted their everything off, I believed every moment of their performances, not to mention Lee (Song Kang) is drop dead handsome, but I am so glad that he is an exceptional actor also. Everyone did an amazing job here and I was happy to be taken along for this emotional roller-coaster ride.

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?