This review may contain spoilers
Great cast but I wish I could get my time back!
I was so mad about this series that I put down my oath of never writing a review and signed up for MDL just so I could give this review. ***Occasional spoiler alert***First things first: I watch historical c-dramas for their stories and (some of the) dialogue as I love exploring and learning more about China's history and past (yes, I know it's not all accurate but as I'm an author, I enjoy being inspired by other scriptwriters).
(*Please note that I skipped MANY scenes because there was a lot that didn't need to be kept in plus I got BORED).
1). Cast: EXCELLENT cast! I LOVVVVEEEE Dai Lu Wa & Riley Wang (hello, DIMPLESSSS) and thought they did the best despite the writing. There are many playful moments that I adored between Shisan & Gao Ran, Fan Yun & Qi Zheng, plus the brotherhood between Qi Zheng, Wei Ying, and Yan Jiang - all of it was great). Fan of Deng Wei but I couldn't STAND his character, Zheng Shi/Lou Qiyan here - UGH).
2). Characters: Now, I tend to like watching characters grow over the course of the series because that's what they're supposed to do but I couldn't believe how confusing and ridiculous some of these characters were (especially the main leads)!
2a). Qi Zheng: He probably had one of the better character arcs throughout the series. Starting off as a baffoonish governor who only lives a lavish life, he's truly hiding someone who cares for his people. First of all, why would you need to show it like this? He cares for the people - that's his JOB as governor. He SHOULD care for his people. I know that the 3 Elders are there to guide (aka hinder) him so they can see their dream of the Nine Cities play out, but come on. That's just silly. Either way, he goes from being super immature to a somewhat understanding person, but that isn't really until epi 35/36.
2b). Fan Yun: As the first female lead, one would think she should have the biggest character growth in the series. Only..... *crickets crickets* there was none. I wanted to smack her character so many fkn times throughout! How are you SO DUMB?? Even near the end of the series, you still couldn't see how Zheng Shi is hella manipulative and insane?! And for all the *strong female character* BS, all it shows is that whatever she wants, she gets. Which isn't always a GOOD thing. PLSSSSSS. And she can't tell when someone likes her? She doesn't understand how she keeps walking into traps, even by episode 30?! HUH? The way they wrote her is super embarrassing, even though it's meant to showcase a strong woman who won't bend to other people's will. But how can you have someone like this who can't even seem to read the room be a "gate commander" or official? That just shows how immature she is. And even when Shisan shows her 1 defensive move, she never uses it. I at least thought she'd would've used it on ZS in the end! But noooooo, she just whines and harrumphs about the unfairness of a man grabbing her. UGH.
2c). Zheng Shi: YO. YOOOOOOO. Y'all managed to get Deng Wei to be in your series and you wasted his talent on acting like some manipulative punkass b*tch who can't take no for an answer? STOP. Please. Just stop. It's 2026 (or it was 2023 when this was filmed, EVEN THEN it should have better writing than these lame tropes). You should be able to create better characters who can show growth instead of demanding attention through manipulation and tricks. That's just hella petty. And for him to keep telling FY how he hopes to drink the sweet dew tea (which signifies the love between 2 people) she brews for him, which was also the antidote to the poison he got from an arrow. (<--- also, this is such a device to use, this is hella lazy writing) In the end, he finally gives up because he realizes FY prefers QZ over him? AFTER HE KNOCKS HER OUT AND KIDNAPS HER?? And tells her that one moment of dislike in her life can pass quickly but one moment of happiness can be revisited over and over? They made him this super insane person who is too stubborn to save themselves from the poison and insists on FY to help him out, when he knew she didn't feel the same way as him? OMG, I wanted to smack him too so many times because at times he seemed decent, respectful, and never wanted to go against FY (his own words) but in the end, he couldn't even keep that facade up. ZERO character growth for him too! How disappointing! I get there needs to be tension between the 2 male leads but seriously? This was unimaginative.
All of the other characters I had zero issue with - it was just these 3 that had some of the worst writing/developments. I was SUPER disappointed, especially after seeing Li Yi Tong in A Dream Within a Dream. I do have to say that there are times when LYT seems to rely too heavily on her looks and being confused - I hope she can grow out of that.
3). Plot: WHAT DID I JUST WATCH?! The plot made ZERO sense to me (and I allow a lot of room for interpretation when it comes to c-dramas, especially historical ones and their ability to stretch the imagination - FINE) but this one? I have no idea what the writers were smoking because I think I want some of it.
3a). Right off the bat - FY is to be married to the governor, QZ. Okay, I can go along with this but for the governor, they paired him with someone from a fallen noble family?? Like that could EVER happen? I get why FY's fam did it for the money but come ON. Plus, the whole money aspect didn't come up (other than QZ feeling disgruntled by the fact that he's only worth 500 taels of gold).
3b). The fake divorce for FY to become an official - was that even necessary? I'm trying to understand this. And if they were trying to get it to this plot point, why wouldn't they just have her start off with petitioning to take the exam, discover that there are no rules (in terms of gender) when it comes to serving in court and building up her merits from there? And while in court, QZ could fall in love with her and the 3 Elders could come in and create a marriage between the two?
3c). Zheng family clan leader election - perhaps I missed the point of this, and I understand that the Zheng family are powerful in Jing City and can control a military but if anything, this should have been threaded throughout the series, not just plopped at the end.
3d). The love triangle - I couldn't stand how FY wouldn't just say something to either QZ or ZS. If you're such a STRONG WOMAN, you should be able to speak your mind more easily. Don't put forth this idea that FY is this incredible person who cares for the people, speaks up IN COURT, goes against the rules and is a timid person around the 2 men who like her? HOW? At least be consistent if you're going to write a strong female character. You can't have her go against the rules, speak out against the Elders and yet suddenly can't seem to say simple things to QZ or ZS! And also, how are you going to write a character who is betrayed by ZS in the end and yet she still trusts him? HUH? FY cannot be THIS DUMB.
3e). The 3 Elders - Look, I get that ancient China was all about being Confucian and filial and all that but the idea that 3 Elders who were there at the beginning of the Nine Cities would prevent the Governor from actually doing his job was ridiculous. There's no FKN way 3 old people could have that much power. Like it didn't make any sense! And when Elder Zheng started going off like a crazy person, why wasn't he removed from court for speaking out of turn? AIYAHHHHH
I know I missed a lot of the other plot points but these were the top ones that my brain couldn't deal with. It makes me so sad when there are great actors involved in a series and yet they had to produce something like this? I just finished the series today and my brain nearly exploded at how stunted so many of the characters were. Like how did this get greenlit?!
But seriously, ALL THE LOVE to Dai Lu Wa & Riley Wang cuz they were THE CUTEST TOGETHER!!! I hope they star as main roles for other series because their dynamic was OFF THE CHARTS!!
Was this review helpful to you?
