My village is still recovering the aftereffects of this season
I might sound more emotional than usual. I’ve fully accepted that this will be a sappy review filled with praise, so buckle up.This season was… too good. I adore Yumi and all her cells. Every single one of them has such distinct personalities, and the writing team truly did wonders here. I found myself cheering on literal 2D animated cells like they were main characters. That alone says everything.
I was initially very scared of the 8 episode run. I was convinced it wouldn’t be enough and that I’d be left unsatisfied, but it didn’t feel that way at all. The story feels complete in my heart. Would I have taken one more episode? Absolutely. But that’s just my greed cell wanting more Yumi and Sun Rok content.
This season made me laugh so much, just like the previous ones, but what really stayed with me is how much I’ve grown attached to Yumi as a person. Watching her across the seasons, seeing her change as she got older… I genuinely feel like I grew up with her. I felt so close to her, her feelings, her struggles, the way she processes things. Not because we’ve lived the same life, because we definitely haven't, but because she felt so real to me. Her emotions and her reactions made so much sense to me and her honesty and vulnerability is what made me connect to her so deeply, and for this, kudos to the writers.
The writing of this show is so honest, witty, and personal that it genuinely felt like reading Yumi’s diary. And I love that. It’s such an original way to tell a story that is, at its core, very ordinary, but that’s exactly what makes it special. Yumi isn’t perfect. She has flaws, fears, insecurities, and she makes mistakes. She’s lived, she’s learned, and she’s grown and that emotional journey is what makes this show hit so hard for me. I loved how grounded in reality a lot of the moments were.
Now for this season specifically; Kim Go Eun was, as always, phenomenal. She is Yumi. I genuinely can’t imagine anyone else playing her. Her look this season was also adorable, I personally loved the pixie cut, she pulled it off so well. What I loved most this season was seeing a more mature version of Yumi. She’s grown, she’s a bit more guarded, but that hopeful, bubbly core of hers never disappeared. It was just… quieter at times. But still there.
And her cells? Icons. The Naughty cell continued to be the showstopper and the cause of so much of my laughter. The hunger cell...I’m convinced if I ever peeked into my own cell village, my hunger cell would look exactly like that.
I also really appreciated seeing the contrast between Season 1 Yumi and Season 3 Yumi, while still recognizing that at her core, she’s the same person. That consistency in her character was so comforting.
Kim Jae Won as Shin Sun Rok was also genuinely perfect casting. He embodied that role so naturally, and considering he’s still relatively a rookie, acting opposite someone like Kim Go Eun couldn’t have been easy, but he held his own. Their chemistry felt effortless and real. I adored him.
Shin Sun Rok as a character? By far my favorite of Yumi’s boyfriends. Straightforward, proactive, emotionally present… just a genuinely loving partner. His naughty cell was also… yeah. An experience. You go, Yumi. And him being a cute reindeer? I was smiling at my screen so much my face actually started to hurt. If I get smile lines in the future, you're picking up the tab sir.
Also, if you watch this show for anything, let it be for the version of Sun Rok we get in the later half. I fell for him right alongside Yumi. I get it girlie. I fully get it.
I won’t spoil anything, but the way he handled things in the final episode, his attitude, his care, the way he approached Yumi… A MILLION GOLD STARS. Truly.
I also really appreciated that we didn't get into any unnecessary side plots/characters because the 8 episode run is already quite short so I definitely love that the showrunners kept the focus mainly on Yumi and Sun Rok.
Sun Rok’s cell village was also soooo good, there was so much personality and so much humor there. Whoever did the voice acting deserves a GOLD STAR, especially his reason cell. The tone, the delivery… I fully lost it every time his brain just short circuited and the animation was also so good, I couldn't stop laughing. But beyond the humor, it also added depth. His village made him feel just as layered and real as Yumi, which is something this show consistently does amazingly well.
For the story itself, I thought season 3 was very well paced, the change in relationship dynamics felt very natural, and I don't think I ever felt frustrated watching this season at all. I am someone who has a bad habit of fastforwarding some parts of shows, but this season was amazing. They didn't waste even a second. If anything, I wanted more. Honestly, I could’ve watched them do absolutely nothing for 10 more episodes and still been completely invested because I just love these characters so so much.
I think my review will forever remain biased, because I feel so much for this show and for Yumi, but I think that was also only possible because of the superb work everyone has done all throughout the seasons. While I can say that it's possible to watch this as a standalone, it would be such a shame for anyone to miss out on the adventure of seeing how Yumi became the person she is in season 3.
Her story was beautiful and made me both sad cry and happy cry many times, in the best way possible. This show will always have a very special place in my heart and I'll definitely be rewatching it from time to time.
Was this review helpful to you?
Absolutely FANTASTIC
Dream Within a Dream is one of those rare dramas that fully committed to its tone, and actually pulled it off. It had a story-within-a-story setup (which is a very difficult concept to pull off without confusing the audience) it blended comedy with well paced drama and plot, and somehow managed to make that balance work all the way through. Gorgeous work, pure quality.First of all, the comedy absolutely slaps. I don’t think I’ve laughed this much watching a cdrama before. What I really appreciated is that the show doesn’t abandon its humor as the plot gets more intense, it keeps that comedic aspect right up until the very end, which makes the whole experience feel cohesive rather than tonally confused. I have to emphasize this because I've watched a lot of dramas where it starts off as something fun and charming but ends with a totally different identity. This drama? Wonderful from start to finish.
Liu Yuning was a standout here. This is genuinely the best I’ve seen him, he looked great, but more importantly, his comedic timing was ON POINT. I really hope he leans into this kind of “hopelessly in love but slightly ridiculous” character again in the future because he clearly has a knack for it.
And I have to mention Fugui, FUGUI!!! His comedic timing was incredible. If you’ve seen The Prisoner of Beauty, his character there had a similar energy but a much more tragic trajectory, so seeing him here alive, well, and consistently hilarious was deeply satisfying. The actor did a fantastic job.
The script itself is strong, though it can get a bit overwhelming at times. I actually had to take breaks between episodes because there’s so much going on, but interestingly, every time I came back to it, I was completely hooked again. That says a lot about how engaging it is overall. I think if I watched it as it was airing it would have been the perfect experience for me.
That said, it’s not without flaws. The romantic chemistry felt a bit uneven, while Liu Yuning fully sold it, I didn’t quite feel the same level of emotional investment from Li Yitong. It created a slight imbalance that made parts of their relationship less compelling than they could have been. However, I still think they looked great together and both gave such strong performances as their characters that I could overlook this in the long run.
Also, the second male lead? I genuinely could not stand him. Just relentless, frustratingly one-dimensional, and so single-minded that it became more irritating than interesting. While I do think that this might have been because he IS in theory a tropey tv show character, I still disliked it. Mainly, because the whole point of the show is Li Yitong's character realizing that the "characters" around are real and multi faceted. And don’t even get me started on the in-universe scriptwriter's questionable choices all around.
On the production side, though, this drama really shines. The editing is sharp, the color grading is beautiful, the costumes and sets were genuinely impressive, and the supporting cast added a lot of depth. There’s a strong sense of overall synergy that made the world feel fully realized.
The ending was also surprisingly well done, I’m honestly still a bit shocked they managed to get that past censorship rules around this kind of plot. And true to form, the show kept delivering on the humor until the very last moment. Even the post-credits and extras were hilarious.
Overall, this was a genuinely delightful watch. It’s chaotic, funny, occasionally overwhelming, but ultimately very well put together. Definitely one of the most fun dramas I’ve seen in a while and probably will keep this title for a bit.
Was this review helpful to you?
Looks Gorgeous But Lacks Soul
This is one of those dramas where I kept sitting there thinking “this should be hitting harder than this.” Because it IS visually stunning. The cast ,on paper, should work perfectly. A modern monarchy setting is also right up my alley. AND YET somehow there’s this weird emptiness to the show that I just can't quite understand.That being said, it’s still pretty decent and I am enjoying it overall but it's mainly due to it's airing schedule, the glamour of the royal settings and the very very pretty leads. I just wish I felt more excitement for it.
On a positive note though, I’m obsessed with the Queen Mother, Gong Seung Yeon. She's the definition of a scene stealer for me. Her acting is incredible and she feels like one of the only characters in the show that truly feels fully alive and multifaceted. The actress brings so much weight and nuance to even the smallest moments that I genuinely believe her station and her background. Incredible. Same goes for her father honestly. He’s one of those actors where the second he appears on screen you already know you’re about to get a solid performance and always have this sense of impending doom, bc boy does he play evil characters well
Actually, the supporting cast in general is carrying this show on their backs a little bit. They’re all such familiar faces and everyone is doing a genuinely wonderful job. Aid Hyeon’s actor Yoo Soo Bin continues to be one of my all time favorites because he NEVER misses for me. Secretary Do was also insanely charismatic. And I-an’s residence staff were true icons. Especially Butler Kim. He was such fun person that I'm actually a bit dissapointed that we haven't seen much of him past the halfway mark of the drama.
Mr. Prime Minister...Noh Sang Hyun, now HE is definitely on my nice list, because he's done a very good job here. I can feel his charisma and he carries himself so well. Incredible casting. The Queen Mother and him are the saving grace of this drama for me tbh.
My only issue with his character is probably the love triangle. It just felt very bland and unnecessary.
Now for the leads themselves;
I’ve seen people absolutely tearing Byeon Woo-seok apart online because of his acting here and honestly… I don’t FULLY agree. However, I do think that there are scenes where he could’ve done better, because I do feel a sort of emotional disconnect with I-an as a character. But I also think people are ignoring the type of character he’s playing. His cold demeanour can actually serve a purpose. Now I don't know if this was an intentional choice or pure serendipity, but I personally couldn't care less. It worked for me.
I-an is literally a grand prince raised under constant scrutiny since birth. A man who has probably never had the luxury of expressing himself freely for a moment. So of course he’s restrained. Of course his default expression is going to be more muted. This is someone raised in an environment where every facial expression could be judged, analyzed, weaponized. So while I do think there are moments that lacked impact, I can also understand why the performance is more controlled. I also think that his crying scenes were pretty well done. All that said, there is room for improvemet but this was definitely not BWS's best work.
My REAL enemy in this drama is his wardrobe. Why are they dressing this man like a royal bathrobe salesman?? Those horrific robe like lapels haunt me. It’s always the SAME suit in slightly different variations and I genuinely don’t understand why the styling team refused to have fun with the royal concept. They could have done SO much. I don't even want to talk about the banquet look because why are we suddenly in....western.... military....attire...why...
Now for IU. I'm afraid she has the same frozen face as BWS during most scenes, HOWEVER, I’ve always liked her acting style that leans slightly comedic and this role feels very comfortable for her. I also thought her delivery during emotional scenes were pretty solid. The comedic moments especially remind me a lot of Jang Man Wol from Hotel del Luna, which I personally love because that’s still one of my favorite performances from her. Again, it could have been better but it's not bad enough to make me mad, i just don't really feel any strong emotions.
I’m also enjoying Heeju as a character so far. I like her emotional progression and I WAS super seated her to absolutely turn the palace upside down and yet................nothing. We've spent so much unnecessary time on plotlines that had so little impact. The first half of the show is honestly a much better drama and Heejo as a character feels much more alive there. She could have been such a force.
I’m also really curious about her relationship with her father because I can already see the setup for the inevitable “he secretly cared all along” reveal. But I’m sorry… I genuinely do not care. You cannot emotionally terrorize your child for years and expect me to clap because you loved her secretly deep down inside. How you treat someone to their face matters. The emotional damage is already done my dude. BYE.
Now that I’m nearing the later episodes, I think my biggest issue is that the drama struggles with impact.
Major moments that should feel monumental just… don’t.
I-an's big move should have had me stressed. The reactions from everyone around him should have carried more weight and yet, a moment that is perhaps one of the most monumental events in the show fell extremely flat. I FELT NOTHING. Even the emotional progression between him and Heeju, especially when they finally take that final step toward each other, felt strangely muted. And I genuinely can’t tell if this is a directing issue, an editing issue, an acting issue or something missing from the script itself, but the emotional payoff just isn’t landing the way it should.
Episode 10’s ending is probably the clearest example of this. That moment should have either been laced with more tension beforehand or it should have totally come out of left field. And yet..all I felt was boredom because it was just SO predictable.
Similarly with episode 11, there were so many moments that needed more of a pause and yet the show just failed to capture it's momentum, which is such a shame. The only positive part was that we got to see a bit more of Heeju taking control; however, because the scenes were all cut so short, even this lacked the desired impact.
Even the overarching theme of "class" that the show attempted to explore fell short. I think the dramas team failed to really explore this to it's actual potential and just kept it surface level, sadly much like the rest of the show.
And that’s honestly my overall issue with the show.
It looks beautiful but somewhere underneath all the gorgeous cinematography and expensive looking sets, it feels like the drama is missing it's soul.
Was this review helpful to you?
A True 10/10
When I tell you this show had me in a chokehold...I’m not exaggerating when I say I couldn’t skip a single scene. Not one. That alone should tell you everything.It was just… perfect. The storyline, the chemistry, the action, the characters, everything clicked. And what I really loved is that it actually balanced fantasy and romance properly. Neither one overshadowed the other, which almost never happens. Usually one ends up eating the other alive, but here? Perfect blend.
The chemistry between Hou Ming Hao and Lu Yuxiao?? INSANE. Like, I could feel it through my screen. Every look, every interaction, there was tension, there was softness, there was everything you want. You know how they say, I opened the book and they fell out? Yeah this is basically that. Perfect casting.
And the female lead, finally!!! A “strong” character who is actually strong. I’m so tired of dramas throwing around titles like “general” or “warrior” just for the character to stand there and look pretty with nothing to back the shows claims. Not here. She was smart, capable, fierce, and actually acted like it the entire time. No false marketing, no last-minute personality loss.
Also can we talk about the visuals for a second? The sets were great, sure but the COSTUMES?? Absolutely insane. Hou Ming Hao’s slutty little red number? Hang it in the Louvre. Immediately. And Lu Yuxiao’s flowy dresses?? So dreamy, so magical, I genuinely felt like I was floating half the time.
And the HAIR. Oh my god the hair. Whoever was in charge deserves a raise and a vacation. Everyone has never looked better, and the amount of creative, intricate hairstyles?? Literal dream material. No wonder everything went viral on Xiaohongshu.
Even the secondary characters?? I cared about them. Like actually cared. Their storylines didn’t feel like filler, they added to the whole thing, which just made the world feel fuller and more alive. I can safely say this has one of my all time favorite second lead couple.
I’m genuinely sad it’s over. This is 100% going on my “rewatch when life feels empty” list. It just delivered on all fronts.
And I’ll say it again because well.. I can. BEST Hou Ming Hao HAS EVER LOOKED. Top tier. No notes.
Was this review helpful to you?
A different kind of kdrama
First of all, the chemistry is too good. Jung Hae In and Son Ye Jin truly had a beautiful dynamic and looked amazing the whole time. The script is also a more mature one that didn't shy away from more serious topics in relationships and families that do exist in todays society, especially in Korea. There were toxic relationships that appeared normal on the surface, family dynamics and the general view of the society regarding older women dating younger men, navigating a borderline abusive partner whom your parents support and like, how to break that kind of dynamic off, creeps in the workplace and in general the issues women in todays society face overall. It felt like a genuine window into the Korean society.It actually reminded me of older Korean movies that wasn't too bothered with presenting an ideal world but rather showed the flaws in society. The dynamic between the leads was also a more realistic one that depicted a proper adult relationship and all that comes with it. I think a lot of recent shows has this purity complex and shy away from even referencing physical intimacy. While I don't think that it's always necessary, I do think that for a story like this it definitely did serve a narrative purpose and also made the characters and the relationship feel much more realistic.
The one thing that was a miss was the overuse of the soundtrack. I just really wanted to mute it after the 20th time it played.
Was this review helpful to you?
On repeat
I've rewatched this an unhealthy amount. The documentary style of the show is so well executed and the color grading and editing really gives it that familiar, nostalgic feeling that makes you feel like you're truly in the story with the actors. The entire cast did a wonderful job and I could truly see the point of view of each character so clearly and that every action they took made an insane amount of sense.It takes true talent to create characters that comes alive on the screen and this show has definately captured that.
Was this review helpful to you?
A show that makes you feel warm even in the coldest of winter
I went into this drama with pretty low expectations, if I’m being honest. I just wanted something decent enough to keep me entertained for a few nights and instead I ended up finding one of the warmest little hidden gems I’ve watched in a while. There’s just something about this show that feels comforting.Even when the story deals with grief, loneliness, anxiety, trauma and all the messy complicated feelings that come with human connection, it never feels heavy in an exhausting way. It feels gentle. Like the drama is quietly holding your hand the whole time.
One thing I appreciated immediately was that the writers didn’t drag out the mystery surrounding Chan’s identity for half the show and told us exactly who he is. I was fully prepared for 8 episodes of dramatic staring and near reveals, but surprisingly they handled it pretty quickly, and I think that was the right choice. It kept the emotional momentum moving instead of making the story feel frustrating. While I was confused at the beginning as to what was going on an who everyone was to the other, that was the exact thing the writers were going for. I'm just glad they resolved it very fast and kept the pace moving all the way until the end. Come get your gold stars, the writer team.
And usually I HATE when dramas rely too much on characters randomly running into each other all the time. You know the type. Suddenly everyone in Seoul shares the same three sidewalks. But weirdly enough… it genuinely didn’t bother me here. The grandmother randomly meeting Ha Dam’s boyfriend, everyone slowly intertwining into each other’s lives, all of it somehow worked. I think that’s honestly a testament to the directing and editing because they managed to make an overused plot device feel natural and cozy instead of forced.
Now let’s talk about Chan because I absolutely adored this man.
Genuinely one of the most lovable male leads I’ve watched in a while. His smile is SO infectious and Chae Jong Hyeop embodied this role perfectly. There’s this softness to him that immediately draws you in, but underneath that warmth there’s also so much pain and loneliness quietly sitting there. And I loved that the drama didn’t dump his trauma on us immediately for shock value. It slowly unfolded his backstory at a really good pace without making us wait too long either. The balance was honestly perfect.
And that therapy scene after the accident??? When he said “I don’t think there’s anyone in my life who would say I love you to me” I genuinely wanted to crawl through my screen and give him a hug. SHUT UP YOU ADORABLE LITTLE CAPYBARA OF A MAN. YOU ARE SO LOVEABLE.
His personality was clearly shaped by everything he’d been through and that made him feel so real to me. His brightness didn’t feel fake. It felt intentional. Like someone who consciously chose warmth despite life repeatedly giving him reasons not to. That made him such a layered character for me. His presence on screen also gave me such warmth.
I also weirdly found his passion for animation and storytelling really moving. As someone who’s personally struggling a bit with figuring out my own path in life, there was something genuinely inspiring about watching someone so deeply connected to what they love doing.
Also his styling team deserves a raise because his wardrobe and hair were EXCELLENT. More of that immediately please.
As for Ha Ran, I thought Lee Sung Kyung was such a good casting choice. I’ve always preferred her in quieter, darker, more emotionally restrained roles compared to brighter characters and she really fits the atmosphere of this drama perfectly. Her makeup, hair, styling, the color grading around her scenes… everything complemented her so beautifully. I genuinely think this might be my favorite she’s ever looked in a drama.
I also really liked Haran as a person, and as someone who also struggles with anxiety over my loved ones, I can fully relate to her struggles, even though hers are at an extreme spectrum. I can clearly see where she is coming from, and I loved that she herself could identify what a problem is in her behaviour and was actually quite communicative about it to her family and later on to Chan. I found these to be great elements in creating a layered person that actually feels real. She felt flawed in a very human way.
I also really liked Ha Ran and Chan's dynamic. I thought they complemented each other so well. Although I wish we didn't have this past connection, I can also recognise that without it, we can't really have a 12 episode drama.
They’re both characters carrying around old wounds and there’s something really beautiful about watching two people slowly become a safe place for each other. I especially loved how naturally their relationship progressed. I’m a total sucker for friends to lovers and while this isn’t exactly a traditional version of that trope, the emotional progression felt very similar to friendships that slowly and naturally deepen into love. I loved that neither of them really tried to aggressively hide their feelings once they started developing either. You could SEE it in their behavior long before anything was verbalized. The small moments between them ended up meaning the most to me. I'm simply enjoying them enjoy things together.
I also loved watching Ha Ran slowly realize that while Chan appears very open and cheerful, he actually reveals very little about himself emotionally. There’s this quiet distance in him despite how warm he appears, and watching her gently notice that made me even more invested in their relationship.
The side characters were also genuinely lovely. The coffee shop owner was such a comforting presence, Ha Ran’s grandmother was an absolute icon, her sisters were great, and even Genius the dog managed to become one of my favorite parts of the show because LOOK AT HIM. ADORABLE.
Everyone fit the tone of the drama so well and the family dynamics especially added a lot of warmth to the overall atmosphere.
I also really enjoyed that so many of the characters worked in artistic fields because stories centered around art, animation, writing and creative spaces will always immediately pull me in.
NOW. I do have one complaint.
Chan’s animation project “Won” genuinely looked AI generated at times and I’m sorry but it kept taking me out. If I were Kim Nana I would not have hired their team lols. HOWEVER, his other sketches and drawings later on actually looked much more human and expressive, so eventually I let the “Won” animation crimes against art go.
The ending itself was also very lovely. They wrapped things up in the best way possible while still keeping just enough mystery alive until the very end for us, the viewers. I had my suspicions about what truly happened, but this is dramaland and writers sometimes suddenly lose all common sense during finales and sabotage their own work for fun. Happy to report that thankfully wasn’t the case here.
Overall, I just thought this was such a lovely drama about surviving the cold periods of life and slowly finding warmth again through other people.
And somehow, despite taking place during winter, this show made me feel incredibly warm the entire time.
Definitely one of those quiet little hidden gems that deserves so much more love.
Was this review helpful to you?
Pretty decent, nothing superb but very lovely all the same
I'll keep it pretty short for this one.It's a pretty decent drama and the cast worked really well. Personally, there were a lot of laugh out loud moments for me. While it did have some over the top, ridiculous moments, you just have to remind yourself that this isn't a documentary but a tv show made for fun. Therefore due to that aspect, it did feel like a proper manwha adaptation and I really enjoyed seeing the FL come out of her shell.
I also liked the romantic progression between the leads, it captured the awkward and clumsy feelings of love at that age. It was just a good time for me, it didn't tackle any major issues or heavier subjects but focused on the growing pains of teenagers, pressure from parents and the feeling of not really knowing who you are. A solid watch if you're in the mood for what it's serving.
Was this review helpful to you?
A show that could have been great, and yet...
It could have been so good, almost like a Korean version of Life As We Know It (if you haven't watched it I would highly recommend a Hollywood take on a similar plot). Unfortunately, it ended up falling into the same old trap: a love-triangle-heavy storyline that felt bland and predictable. If I'm being honest even the love triangle part was boring, I personally couldn't care less how it ended simply because NONE of the characters were interesting.Let's start with what I did like, which was the small community they built with the neighbors and how Hyeon Jin, Tae Hyeong and U-Ju became a true family. The ups and downs, their efforts and obstacles they faced...That aspect had so much potential, and I would have loved to see a clearer focus on the found-family dynamic. The child actor playing U-ju was absolutely adorable, and honestly the show could have worked much better as a family-centered story with the romance as a secondary element.
Instead, the characters felt underdeveloped, the script was somewhat lackluster, and the whole thing just felt like it was missing a bit of soul. One detail that also kept pulling me out of the story: because I’m fluent in Korean, I noticed that they kept addressing each other as “in-law” even after they supposedly grew closer and agreed to speak more casually. At that point it would have felt much more natural for them to start using each other’s actual names.
For the actual cast; I really like the actress Roh Jeong Eui, and I genuinely mean no harm, but every time she spoke, I found myself focusing more on how tired she appeared than on the actual scene, which pulled me out of the story. Her line delivery was also not her best work.
I’m also a fan of the male lead Bae In Hyuk from his early days, but the two leads just didn’t have any real chemistry together. Their dynamic never quite felt convincing. The second male lead didn’t help much either, his character felt like an overly idealized version of a past love. He was almost unrealistically nice and accommodating, to the point where it felt artificial. Love Park Seo Ham but I understand the backlash over how much screen time he occupied for it to serve no purpose in the end.
This could have been a healing drama with comedic moments, something about two people confronting the fact that they both grew up without a large family and slowly redefining what “family” means. There were interesting contrasts the show could have explored more deeply, like Hyeon Jin having her sister as a parental figure while Tae Hyeong never really had that kind of support, and how that shaped his feelings toward his own brother. They do get into this but it almost felt like an afterthought rather than a main focus.
In the end, the premise had a lot of potential, but the execution never quite lived up to it. I just think the show really missed the mark.
Was this review helpful to you?
I have so many questions for the writer but none they will enjoy
This show was SO all over the place, I was fully skimming the eps for one reason and one reason only; I had already invested time into the show.Was it trying to be a thriller? a mystery? crime? The characters were so undercooked, the dialogue weird, the chemistry non existent, the suspense was also nowhere to be seen. Like this masterplan that they've made is horrible that everyone figures it out within 5 seconds like what are we doing???? what was in the air in that writers room?
I thought the final episode was the only one that was kind of okay, I genuinely think I could have just watched that one episode and wouldn't have missed anything. Which is saying a lot considering the fact that I even skimmed that one.
What a letdown...the premise sounded so good and yet the execution was the worst.
Was this review helpful to you?
Kicking Myself For Putting It Off For So Long
Love Between Fairy and Devil really had everything: stunning visuals, layered characters, angst, yearning, romance, and even morally questionable choices that kept things interesting, a sweet FL that didn't annoy me, who was naive but believable and a ML who was toxic at times but felt real enough that I didn't have to force myself to like him, the plot did it for me.I had put this show off for a long time because like I said, I expected the female lead to be overly sweet (and borderline annoying) and the male lead to lean too far into toxic tropes. To some extent, those elements are kinda there, but the way they’re written, performed, and framed through the dialogue and cinematography made them feel much more grounded and emotionally authentic that it didn't bother me and actually added to the experience. I can't imagine the characters being any other way. Kudos to the writer and the director because I can really tell that a lot of care went into making this show.
The female lead, Little Orchid, was a pleasant surprise, sweet and somewhat naive, but in a way that felt believable rather than frustrating. I was initially scared because I'm very familiar with Yu Shuxin's acting and her portrayal of characters but honestly? This character was made for her and she really brought Little Orchid to life. The FL's decisions always made sense within the context of her character and her past, which made it easy to stay invested in her journey. Even though I'm not a big fan of overly sweet and innocent characters, Little Orchid wasn't actually JUST that, she had a lot of depth and heart which made me connect to her character. Shuxin also brough out something very different for the last quarter of the show that really made the show way more interesting anf I personally thought she pulled it off well. I can't say anymore because it would be a spoiler, please watch it.
I also didn’t think Little Orchid was “stupid,” which was a criticism I often saw. She was kind-hearted, pure, and brave, someone who understood the risks of her actions and chose to take them anyway. I think there’s an important distinction there. She didn't jump into danger without thinking it through and expected others to magically solve her problems, she just grew up with a very low sense of self worth due to her low station within the society and is very sacrificing by nature which formed her actions and her reasonings. While I usually gravitate toward more cunning, strategy-driven female leads, Xiao Lan Hua(Little Orchid) stayed completely true to who she was: a loving, courageous little orchid with a giant heart.
For the male lead, Dongfang Qingcang, I especially loved his character development. Even though his name is GENUINELY a mouthful, watching his arc unfold was one of the strongest parts of the show. His actions all throughout the show through various changes he experienced really resonated with his character and rarely felt out of place. I also think Wang Hedi did a really great job with this character and I almost couldn't tell he was dubbed. The dubber and the character worked so well together.
The show also LOOKED really good overall. Visually, the CGI was impressive, the sets were beautifully designed, and the costumes added so much to the overall atmosphere. With cdramas, the sets and CGI can really make or break a good concept (iykyk) and for a fantastical show you really need that good production quality. I think Love Between Fairy and Devil really brought that.
Overall, this was a beautiful and emotionally engaging watch. Wang Hedi and Yu Shuxin both delivered strong performances and brought a lot of emotional depth to their roles.
My only real complaint is how rushed the ending felt which is why I dropped half a point. I wished we had one more episode or even 30 more minutes to wrap it up. Everything before that, though? Genuinely fantastic. If you're on the fence about watching it, just press play and thank me later.
Was this review helpful to you?
Incredibly strong start with an insanely underwhelming ending
It was so good, sooo good.....until episode 10.I loved Kim Dami's character and her styling was INCREDIBLE. I actually started this show because of how absolutely amazing she looked and the darker vibe. Honestly, up until the very end, the show fully delivered on everything ı wanted and more. It was so good, with interesting events and well thought out scenarios.
So sad it crashed and burned at the end. It wasn't exactly a horrible ending, it was just SO underwhelming. Somehow, the show lost all the stakes and the tension towards the end :(
Was this review helpful to you?
Something was missing...but damn Zhou Yi Ran was superb
This was one of those dramas where I kept wanting to love it more than I actually did. Zhou Yi Ran is an actor that I'm very excited about because he feels like a true performer, and this is my first impression of Sabrina but she looked so nice from the promos that I really wanted to give this drama a fair shot.However… Like I didn’t hate it. I actually think it’s decent. But by the end I was left sitting there feeling like something important was missing and I still can’t fully pinpoint what it was. The vibes were there, the actors were definitely trying, the emotional beats occasionally HIT… but the overall show felt strangely hollow. I think a huge part of that comes down to the fact that the drama never really figured out what it wanted to be.
The high school portion was genuinely my favorite part by far. The friendship dynamics, the found family aspect, the quieter emotional moments all felt warm and grounded in a way that made me really attached to the characters. There was this comforting slice of life energy to it that worked SO well. Then the university timeline starts and suddenly it feels like I accidentally clicked on a different drama.
The found family aspect gets pushed aside, the tone shifts, and Shen Juan’s storyline takes such a sharp turn into sports that the show almost starts feeling sports focused instead of coming of age. Which would’ve been fine… if it felt cohesive. When you think about it Shen Juan is a physics major, a silver goods craftsman and a genius sharpshooter all by the age of 18? Like my dude was out here collecting skill sets like Pokemon cards. And yes, there was technically some setup for the sharpshooting thing earlier on, but not enough for how heavily it later shaped his character arc. There were just too many ideas competing for attention.
That being said, Zhou Yi Ran absolutely carried a huge chunk of this show emotionally. He’s genuinely such a compelling actor to watch, especially in quieter emotional scenes. I think his performance made me connect to Shen Juan far more than I normally would have on paper.
Same goes for Sabrina Zhuang. I thought both leads did a really good job individually. Which is why it’s even more frustrating that the romance itself felt so underdeveloped.
Because here’s the thing, I did feel the chemistry early on. The tension was there in the way they looked at each other, the pauses, the emotional undercurrents… but there was almost zero payoff. They genuinely felt more like best friends or an old married couple who occasionally hold hands than two people who had just fallen in love. Their romantic scenes, if you could even call it that, had the flavour of a cardboard box.
And I cannot stress this enough: the lack of romance really hurt the show.
I’m not someone who needs constant fluff or forced romantic scenes every five minutes. In fact, I usually prefer when romance is woven naturally into the story instead of being used to distract from weak writing. But this drama desperately needed something. A little more intimacy, more vulnerability, more moments that actually established them as a romantic couple rather than occasionally holding hands and calling each other boyfriend-girlfriend. Like, if you removed exactly two kisses from this show, almost nothing about their relationship dynamic would change. That’s a problem.
I also found myself less invested in the side character storylines as the episodes went on. None of them were terrible, but they lacked impact, and the pacing started dragging because of it.
What did work for me was the family dynamics. The show actually did a pretty good job making the world feel grounded and emotionally believable. There’s a realism to the writing that I appreciated, especially in the quieter domestic moments. But overall, I really think the writers didn’t fully know what kind of drama they wanted to make. Was it a coming-of-age story? A romance? A sports drama? A healing youth drama? It keeps touching all of these things without ever fully committing to one. They actually could have written a story that dove into all of these but this show wasn't it, which is frustrating because there’s clearly a good drama somewhere in here.
I don't know, it was just very meh.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
I guess some dramas DO deserve a second chance
Fated Hearts was… a bit of a rollercoaster for me, and not always the smooth kind. So buckle up for my long ass rant for an overall pretty okay drama. Also, sorry for the person I will become when I reach the rant part of this review.Was it very enjoyable? Yes. Did it have flaws? MANY. Would I still recommend it for a good time? Absolutely. I find the drama world is filled with so many bs shows and it's becoming increasingly difficult for a drama to keep me engaged enough to want to finish it, so for that reason, this drama deserves its flowers.
I have to preface this by saying that I started this drama MONTHS ago and dropped it after the first 2 episodes until last week.
Now as I mentioned, going in, the first couple of episodes had me doubting my choice and the good reviews. The battle scenes especially felt underwhelming, and the whole thing looked like it wanted to be epic but kept getting stuck in beauty commercial mode. The colors, the shots, it just didn’t do the story justice. This frustrated me to no end because even within the first 2 episodes I SAW THE POTENTIAL. Add in some very questionable editing choices that completely kill the momentum of scenes, and I was already side eyeing by episode 2. It genuinely felt like a drama stuck a few years in the past in terms of execution. This desperately needed the director of Blossom. Now THAT was art.
That said, I’m really glad I gave it another shot because it did get significantly better. The fight scenes improved, the story picked up, and I found myself way more invested than I expected.
Li Qin as Fu Yixiao was a major win for me. I wasn't familiar with her acting so I didn't know what to expect going in, however if I were to choose within a sea of female generals we have seen these past few years, she is by far the most believable. She felt strong both physically and emotionally and THANK GOD the amnesia didn’t wipe her personality like some other dramas (looking at you "Are You the One"). She stayed consistent, capable, and believable and her decisions always aligned with who she was. Her stunt work was also genuinely convincing, you could tell she took those martial arts classes seriously.
Chen Zheyuan also surprised me in a good way. I was skeptical about the casting, but he delivered. Although I could never truly buy him as the cruel "Killer God" they tried to pass him off as. When he embraced his softer side was when his character truly came alive for me. His fight scenes were also pretty solid, even though I always found him a bit skinny to play a battle strong general, the period clothes helped him out a lot and I could gaslight myself long enough to get through the fight scenes.
The chemistry between the leads was also pretty solid. Their dynamic felt balanced, like actual partners rather than one carrying the other (I found the balance similar to Blossom), and the enemies-to-lovers progression was paced well, even if it started off a bit toxic (as it should). Their romantic scenes were also well done, I actually wish we got more, not intricate ones but small light moments here and there towards the end. I actually would have been even happier with the romantic scenes if it weren't for that BIG ASS LIGHT that appeared each time. Was this the directors attempt to strategically blind the censorship committee so they couldn’t see the scenes? Because if the committee can’t see it, guess what, NEITHER CAN I. I was fighting for my life trying to see what was happening.
Also… Chen Zheyuan, respectfully my dude, why are your eyes WIDE open when going in for a kiss? Please.
Now, production choices. The music...why is it so LOUD. Trying to hear the dialogue required actual labor. Also… why the aggressive face smoothing? Everyone is out here blending into the background. The cast is already attractive, we didn’t need this.
Also, the story split into two locations after the halfway point, namely Susha and Jinxiu, and at times it genuinely felt like I was watching two completely different dramas.
The Jinxiu storyline was so lucky to have Chen He Yi’s face because he carried. I know his acting got some lukewarm feedback but I personally couldn't care less because....pretty boy. Call me shallow, I've made my peace with it. The character he plays, Xia Jingshi though? Dogshit. What he did at the end to Xiyang… truly despicable. He bid his time for the throne and acted strategically but my god he has NO heart, at all. This was telling from the start, but it was incredible to see there was no saving grace for him, even for a moment. He was going off of just bad vibes and horrible decisions. My dude literally said "I SHALL NOT BE REDEEMED!" Well, consider your wish granted pretty boy.
Xiyang, on the other hand, was one of the more interesting arcs for me. I found her smart, strategic, and adaptable. Her growth felt earned to me, and I appreciated how she made the most out of her situation. She actively matured and grew a lot in Jinxiu and her motivations, while driven by petty emotion, still made sense to me considering her background and upbringing. Watching her manipulate the Jinxiu emperor was also SO nice. Women in male dominated fields. Honestly, Xia Jingshi was pretty shortsighted for not seeing her value. I'll talk more on my thoughts on her ending in a little bit, so hold off on the pitchforks, I do have some criticism for her.
However, I still don't think her character really deserved the amount of hate she got online. I thought Xiyang was pretty smart and made the best out of the situation she was in, especially as someone who grew up sheltered and not really involved in palace drama, she held herself very well. I began indifferent towards her but after her resolve in regards to Xia Jingshi, she became a very interesting person and I loved her scenes. Obviously, her hatred for Xia Jingshi was unreasonable in some places because yes, he did say time and time again he did not reciprocate her feelings and never will, but I understood her frustration and her reaction felt true to her character and upbringing. She was a beloved princess who was naive enough to believe that her sincerity would make her a small path to Xia Jingshi’s heart. I can't fault her for trying, while holding onto her feelings from years ago built on a fleeting moment of a random act of kindness from Xia Jingshi. Was this stupid? Yes. But does it also kinda make sense for her character? Yeah, kinda. Also when she was pleading with Feng Suige to marry Xia Jingshi and said “I can change him”……Xiyang, I'm going to hold your hand when I say this, no you can’t babe.
The bigger issue lies in the writing for me so... welcome to my descent into madness.
Character development was all over the place so the character shifts felt very abrupt. Murong Yao’s dad? Random personality switch with zero groundwork, not to mention for this character it would have been sooo easy... Also, Suige's little brother Changyang? Went from sheltered teen to master strategist in what felt like one episode. I was genuinely like “did I miss something?” The issue isn’t the arcs themselves but the lack of buildup. Sprinkle in some early hints, some internal conflict, anything! These weren’t bad ideas, they were just poorly set up.
The antagonists also suffered from the same fate. I just thought they weren't very well done. I really like morally grey characters and through decent backstory and motivation I can at least see things from their perspective. I don't have to agree with them but it humanizes them, makes them real instead of just characters which keeps me engaged in the plot. In Fated Hearts however, I found each antagonist undercooked and lacking proper motive. Like “When I was 5 years old the soldiers saved the future emperor instead of me and I.FELT. SAD” like… okay???… nothing else?? REALLY? Even Xia Jingshi, who had EVERY reason to plot a hostile takeover of the court, felt off. His past wasn’t laid out well for the audience and we weren't given enough to connect to him and his sufferings. By the end, he just felt like an obsessive villain and his little rampage felt jarring because it didn't really fit with his character, which was such a waste. I would have wanted to feel torn over his ascend to the throne, but instead it felt unearned. His cruelty was unnecessary and badly explained. I understood him keeping his composure all these years after suffering humiliation and having your life threatened consistently, however, I think if we saw some cracks in his composure leading up to the finale instead of this serene but hypocritical person, I could have understood his actions a bit better and him losing control and going full out lunatic mode wouldn't have felt so jarring.
The show overall felt like it was trying to do a lot within 38 episodes, and while parts of it worked, the pacing for key plot points was a bit off. It’s very much a case of strong leads carrying an undercooked script. If I’m being honest, I stayed for Li Qin, Chen Zheyuan, and their relationship dynamic, not the plot. I'm a sucker for strong leads and mature relationships. And when it came to the Jinxiu plotline, it was Chen He Yi’s face and Xia Meng’s presence doing the heavy lifting. Which… is still an achievement I guess, because I didn’t skip their scenes.
Now, the ending…
Why is Changyang not the emperor? Not to mention Suige talking about the throne like it’s a part time job saying “Xiyang can try it for a few years and if she likes it she can keep it" EXCUSE ME? You did all that for Susha to take the matter of leading it so lightly? I understand that he didn’t want to be emperor himself but my dude...
And Xiyang as empress… I like her, but where was the groundwork for that? I’m all for female rulers, give me that ANY day, but you have to build it. I fear the writers wanted it to be a girl power moment but forgot to establish this within the script. While I did applaud Xiyang for holding her own in the Jinxiu court, she is far from being a leader herself. You can't deny that her motivations were still heavily driven by emotion, pride, and petty revenge. I did not see a leader there, mainly because she wasn’t mature enough.
Meanwhile, Changyang, despite being younger, actually felt calm, strategic, and fit for the role by the end. I really wish we got a proper conversation between the siblings about what they wanted, instead of the script forcing a “he didn’t want it anyway” narrative just to justify the outcome. Did they ever show us in any part of the story that Xiyang had an ambition like this? No. Was it even hinted that she would make a good ruler? No. Like… lay the groundwork and I’ll take a female leader ANY DAY. But you have to do the work!!
That said… I did enjoy this. It gave me:
- a genuinely strong female lead (yay)
- believable chemistry
- a solid enemies to lovers plot
- eye candy second male lead
- not super boring plot that kept me watching
Am I happy I gave it another shot? Yes.
Am I still side eyeing the director for those first two episodes and the big light? Also yes.
Random note: Feng Suige’s brother is adorable and the actor lowkey looks like Rowoon.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Sloppy ending and a weird way to reimagine a horrific period in Korean history
...Idk I really wanted to love this the way everyone else did, but I walked away a bit underwhelmed.Let me start with the positives, because there are quite a few. Yoona was genuinely great, I just love watching her on screen and love that she is getting proper roles and is being taken seriously as an actor. She just has that effortless charm that makes everything more enjoyable. And I called a hit fo Lee Chae-min ever since Crash Course in Romance, so I’m very pleased to see him getting more recognition. He was really solid here too. I thought he did a great job shouldering a very solid lead, especially on such short notice due to him esentially replacing the original actor who was supposed to play the role.
I also really loved how they gave the editing a cooking show touch with recipes you could actually recreate. I thought the cooking itself was the main attraction.
The comedy at the beginning was so good. Like actually funny, not just "ig i should laugh" funny. Which is why it’s even more disappointing that they slowly let that element fade as the show went on. By the time the political conflict took center stage, I was already kind of checked out, it just wasn’t that compelling nor well written.
The leads had good chemistry, I’ll give them that. But the romance itself felt… undercooked. Like all the ingredients were there, but no one left it on the stove long enough. And then the ending?? SUCH a cop-out. It really felt like they backed themselves into a corner and just went “eh, good enough” instead of properly explaining things.
(MAJOR SPOILER) The whole situation with him being in Yoona's world fully as himself while everyone else is some version of reincarnated or altered selves?? Yeah… that needed way more thought and explanation. Did he also travel with the page? But the page was destroyed so how did that work? (END SPOILER)
Now another part that I absolutely hated was the casual reference to SA??? Why did the showrunners think to "reimagine" a true hated figure in actual Korean history?? Why are we redeeming and romanticizing someone who was terribly cruel to women? I think they could have just invented a fake character and gave him a similar backstory(and not as laced with SA!!??) for the initial misunderstandings to happen and it would have served the same purpose.
Also, small but persistent annoyance I had was how they kept marketing this as “Western food meets Joseon cuisine,” but let’s be real, it was just French food. French techniques, French presentation, French everything. Which is fine! Just… call it what it is. The “Western” umbrella felt a bit misleading when there was barely any range beyond that.
All that being said… I still had a good time after forcing myself to overlook the actual historical figure. At the end of the day, it’s pretty people on my screen and I can rarely say no to that.
Was this review helpful to you?

