Completed
AKAshon
2 people found this review helpful
Jul 31, 2020
Completed 0
Overall 6.0
Story 6.0
Acting/Cast 5.0
Music 5.0
Rewatch Value 5.5
This review may contain spoilers

Cute and Charming...

What the eff was that ending? Did Toey really have to die? No, he didn't! Excluding the horrible ending, I really enjoyed this short film, which I first heard about from a BL Instagram account. It was cute and charming. All four leads were attractive. The two ML's were hot. I enjoyed the twist that was revealed in the last act. I would've liked more gay moments between the two ML's though. I would love to see the two ML's (Scott Pannachai and Book Siqaphat paired together in a full-length BL series. That would be awesome!

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
ppkrist
0 people found this review helpful
Jun 4, 2023
Completed 0
Overall 9.5
Story 9.5
Acting/Cast 9.5
Music 9.0
Rewatch Value 8.0

Film pendek yang bagus

Seperti judulnya "heart, not a reason" yang berarti : hati, bukan alasan, sangat menjelaskan latar belakang cerita pendek ini. Series ini tersedia di platform YouTube dengan subtitle bahasa Inggris sehingga bisa diterjemahkan secara mudah dengan Live CC Youtube ke banyak bahasa, benar-benar menggambarkan maksud bahwa "hati, itu seperti tanpa alasan" ; kita bisa mencintai siapapun, bahkan terkadang jika ditanya "apa alasannya" kita akan selalu bertanya-tanya mengenai jawaban yang pasti dan itu berakhir dengan "tanpa alasan". Film pendek ini sangat menggambarkan keadaan itu, walaupun filmnya punya durasi yang pendek, namun film ini bisa menyajikan scene-scene yang pas dan scematik sehingga membuat ceritanya menjadi jelas, singkat, padat, namun berkesan. Walaupun pendek namun detailnya cukup bagus, pengemasannya juga epic menurutku, dengan durasi yang pendek, film ini bisa menghadirkan cerita yang bagus.

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
ariel alba
0 people found this review helpful
6 days ago
Completed 0
Overall 9.5
Story 9.5
Acting/Cast 10
Music 10
Rewatch Value 9.5
This review may contain spoilers

Two young heterosexuals, a kiss that has the power to change lives and a rooftop

When we try to answer the question "what is the reason to love?", we will always be surprised to realize that there really is no reason at all. Through images, music, words and silences, 'Heart... Not a Reason', the 2020 Thai short film, describes this situation, while immersing us in the passionate and secret love relationship between two young heterosexuals, who fall in love after kissing as part of a card game in which they participate.
Toey and Puth, which is the name of our narrative heroes, are two strangers who meet for the first time after their respective girlfriends, May and Ploy, meet again after some time, and decide to introduce their current partners and go on dates double.
During the course of the evening, between plates of food and drinks of alcohol, the four young people agree to participate in a card game, in which the losers must comply with the punishment imposed by the winner.
With the chemical universe behind a kiss, Toey, played by Scott Pannachai Keatkaew, an actor we know for his role as Pent in the LGBT+ themed romantic series 'What the Duck' and 'What the Duck Season 2: Final Call ', and Puth, played by Book Sikaphat, an actor and singer known for appearing in the drama 'Risk Lust Love', also experienced a very deep exchange of sensations and emotions that gave way to love. In other words: knowing each other allowed them to know themselves.
The character played by Scott conveys the image of a person with a confused heart and no confidence. In truth, Toey searches for true love, and what he has searched for so long he finally finds in Puth. He likes how Puth cares about him, pays attention to him, with specific actions such as preparing dinner for him or surprising him on his birthday with a cake. And all this causes Toey to fall in love with him even more.
For his part, Puth is one of the people who gives himself over to love completely. He can't help but fall in love with Toey. While your brain asks you to get away from him, your heart takes you once again to meet him. Puth doesn't want to hurt Ploy, and that's why he hesitates whether or not to continue his secret relationship with Toey, but he can't resist the feeling that has arisen in the center of his chest. It will be very difficult for you to end the relationship with the person you love. While your mouth says one thing, your feelings say the opposite.
However, Puth's girlfriend has also fallen in love with her friend's boyfriend.
Both actors well convey anxiety, restlessness, nervousness, euphoria... all those common and frequent symptoms in people who feel in love. While I see the characters looking at their cell phones, confident that the message is from the other, or how, shyly, they avoid each other's gaze when they meet in public at the shopping center or at the door of one of their houses, I seem to see fluttering the famous butterflies in the stomach, feeling the sweat soak their hands or listening to the beating of their hearts.
The rooftop scene is memorable, as both characters are able to express their feelings and show the incredible chemistry between the two.
The viewer will be able to see how the power of an unexpected and involuntary kiss provokes in the two young people not only that desire to kiss that has a scientific name: filemamania.
The story will surprise us by discovering that nothing is what it seems: while one thinks that they have just started a flirtation, that they feel nervous being close to each other, suddenly we will understand that between the two there is already a deep loving relationship and both they have reached the point where they debate whether it would be right to continue the romance or break up.
The good production, beautiful images, delicate editing, structured script, and a credible well-told story would only be missing a tender and melancholic song. And we have that too, because the short film, in addition to provoking reflection on how no one should be blamed when you fall in love, since no one can control your feelings and your heart, seeks to convey the real story that happened and allowed Book Sikaphat to compose the song "Hua Jai", from the Sikpat Book, which tells the story of two friends who fall in love and how the feeling that arises between them causes the change of their friendly relationship into a romantic one.

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Heart... Not a Reason (2020) poster

Details

Statistics

  • Score: 6.5 (scored by 149 users)
  • Ranked: #73330
  • Popularity: #12456
  • Watchers: 459

Top Contributors

21 edits
7 edits
1 edit
1 edit

Popular Lists

Related lists from users
Thai BL Master List
677 titles 1457 loves 11
gay/bl (Thailand)
552 titles 447 loves 2

Recently Watched By