Your wildest theories on AoS (part 2) - THANK YOU ALL

Interesting, it's time for my boy finally master Hwansu level. 

 Kathryn_51:

1.  I'm not convinced it  is Woo-tak.  Woo-tak said to Jin Mu: "Thanks to that girl, a good-for-nothing man like me was able to marry the daughter of the Jin family."  The implication is that JBY was either born or on the way before he married Mama Jin.

2.  Shaman Choi supposedly died when she occupied the Queen's body.

3.  With regard to the divine power of Bu-yeon's body, the answer will be:  mumbo-jumbo. or, abracadabra. or, hocus-pocus.  In other words, whatever new rule the Hong Sisters come up with, if they even both to do so.  The "story" required Naksu to run wild and therefor she did.  No other explanation necessary.  

1. No it was Jin Mu's lies. And mama Jin reprimanded papa Jin while he was in Sejukwon about it. Bu-Yeon really was his daughter.

2. Yea, supposedly. The queen's body sure is dead though, otherwise the queen'd have soul shifted back into it.

3. This is the biggest problem they'll have to solve convincingly in part 2 besides convincing the distraught audience that it was a good call to do this plot twist.

 Kathryn_51:

We will need to agree to disagree on this one.  If Woo-tak is biological father to both Bu-yeon and Cho-yeon, then why doesn't Cho-yeon manifest the same amazing divine powers?  Bu-yeon's father may be a descendant of the original Choi family, but I'm still betting it wasn't Woo-tak.  He clearly cared about her but he stated from the beginning that he wasn't her biological father - because (my theory)  Mama Jin was already pregnant.  Jin Mu suggested the biological father was Jang Kang to feed his insecurity.

Mama Jin said that once she fell for Woo-tak, she never loved anyone else.  Hinting that there had been someone before.

Isn't it obvious already? It's because Bu-Yeon was born with the help of the ice stone. Who knows what's up with her? Also, not every family member has to be a superb specimen, it rarely happens irl as well.

And no, it was mentioned that Jin Mu played on papa Jin's insecurities. He lies like he breathes.

And if you couldn't gather what mama Jin was saying to papa Jin and indeed how big of a punishment for him these news were along with his reaction I don't know what to say anymore. But keep denying it if you want.

1. yes. Bcz it's unclear why bu yeon didn't resist the bells. I think it's bcz she's also a result of ice stone. Practically she's alive thanks to alchemy of souls.

2. Either he's possessed by naksu/ He was stabbed with naksu's sword. Maybe there's some connection as he literally came back from dead/ he doesn't have another sword as jang gang's sword is in songrim and he has no ownership to it as he lost his rightful ownership to gwangju position.

3.This is not my theory. I saw it in a video. Jin Cho Yeon and a maid from jinyowon/Jin ho gyeong. I was thinking it would be bu yeon's and jin seol ran's souls (as they said bu yeon may be seol ran's reincarnation/ her powers transfered to her ) /naksu and bu yeon's souls (bcz they both has an immense energy) or just simply the heavens. Naksu got her power back when she was inside the lake. Only this time she didn't really want to live as she just stabbed jang uk to death. So the lake had to do it in order to save naksu / bu yeon./ According to Bu yeon ice stone gives much more than you ask for. Right before Jang Uk died he holds mu deok's hand to symbolize what he said to her about their hand lock being the one and only ring for him. It showed his love for her even though she's the one who stabbed him.  So maybe when he was reincarnated the ice stone's power brings her back. We see the both of them coming back to life in the same time as the ice stone's and king star's powers are shown. 

4.Jin ho gyeong has naksu's ashes and uses the ice stone with Jang Uk's help or by some other way / Jin mu didn't burn her body. He just used some magic trick to show as naksu's body was burning and hid it somewhere maybe in the lake./ Jang Uk's desire for mu deok to not to run wild and pertified. He didn't want her to run wild but to be safe. Bcz the ice stone gives much more than it asked for, maybe naksu's body was able to bring back. Bcz the only way that naksu won't run wild and have her powers is going to her own body. 

 shhkarma:

1. Yes

2. After being alive, the first thing Uk would do is look for Mu Doek so he probably finds the sword during his search and uses it. He is able to use it because he has ice stone powers lol

3. I am guessing either the medic granddaughter and her friend OR someone sent by Jin Mu bc he was the only one who knew for sure where she would be.

4. Priestess magic maybe

3. I completely forgot Yun Ok. Yeah maybe that's her. Maybe she got the order from master lee. He always said mu deok doesn't have any malice.

 Kathryn_51:

1.  I'm not convinced it  is Woo-tak.  Woo-tak said to Jin Mu: "Thanks to that girl, a good-for-nothing man like me was able to marry the daughter of the Jin family."  The implication is that JBY was either born or on the way before he married Mama Jin.

2.  Shaman Choi supposedly died when she occupied the Queen's body.

3.  With regard to the divine power of Bu-yeon's body, the answer will be:  mumbo-jumbo. or, abracadabra. or, hocus-pocus.  In other words, whatever new rule the Hong Sisters come up with, if they even both to do so.  The "story" required Naksu to run wild and therefor she did.  No other explanation necessary.  

1. I think Woo tak is her father. Maybe he and jin ho yeong met before and probably jinyowon was against the marriage. he thinks she's not his daughter bcz of jin mu. 

I began this two weeks ago but got distracted but here are my Wild Crazy Predictions for Part 2, I’ve given up on “theorizing” because the writers don’t hesitate to change the (i) ice stone “rules/description/power” and (ii) Jin Bu-yeon’s status (dead/shared soul/WTF???) so these focus on characters.  Oh, and ChoDang. Rules.   

I absolutely reserve the right to change at any time, however, the benefit of the "Discussion" page is that it is easy to show edits.  I'll keep track of my wins/losses.  Enjoy. :-)

1. “A really powerful priestess can control people’s souls and trap them to be helpless.  If the priestess traps their powers, even the most powerful mage is helpless.”  Cho-yeon, Ep. _16, Mark 34_)

WILD Prediction:    After recovering the partially petrified body of Jin Bu-yeon, Mama Jin will attempt to extract/shift the soul of “Naksu” from the body and trap it in an inanimate object. 

• Side note:  after calling Jin Bu-yeon (or perhaps Jin Seo -ran) a “relic” of Jinyowon, this would be the ultimate karma for Naksu. 

2. "They say whoever breaks the yin-and-yang jade will never have a long-lasting relationship.  If you break the yin-and-yang jade, they say the person you love will never love you back.”  Mu-deok to Cho-yeon, Ep. 7, Mark 23.

Prediction?  at beginning of AoS Part 2, Jin Cho-yeon and Park Dan-gu are married but estranged.  (According to a tweet from Arin, Jin Cho-yeon and Park Dang-gu ARE officially married.).   Jin Mu will conspire to marry her off to the Crown Prince.  One way or another, the jade eggs will bring them together and the adorable ChoDang couple will reconcile. By Episode 30, Cho-yeon will be pregnant with twins – one boy and one girl. {My personal note:  my two kids are boy/girl twins - I'm biased!  and VERY blessed.]

3.  In July, many cast members traveled to Daegu (??) to film in a new location.

Prediction (?):  The celebration shown in the Part 2 preview will be at Seoho Fortress honoring a visit of Queen Seo Ha-sun and this is when we will meet Yul’s uncle Seo Yoon Oh.   This will occur early in Part 2.  Hopefully Part 2 doesn’t begin there -  we need some transition.

4.  My Wildest, Craziest Prediction:  When the body of “Naksu” is "revived", her first words will be: “Hello.  My name Mu-deok, I’m from Sari Village and I was sold to Chwisenoru.”

Is she Cho Yeong?  Jin Bu-yeon?  I have no idea.  But my guess is that we won't have answers for several episodes while the entire MDL fandom goes stark raving crazy over  WHEN-will-Jang Uk-and-"Naksu"-meet???

Posted:  September 13, 2022

 ShinHyeSunFan6021023:

I feel like the reunion scene in part 2 will be quite epic, Jang Uk will either recognize Naksu by her technique and use of Tansu, or, it will be a poetic parallel with episode 1 where he recognizes her by her eyes ( preferably with his sword on her neck just like in episode 17 with Jang Gang ). Not too far-fetched or unrealistic of a prediction

i can't wait for this