Her articles are only getting more and more inappropriate, outrageous, gossipy, click baiting, and containing less and less of the actual truth. Today's didn't even have anything to do with dramas. All it did was speculate on a misfortunate woman's death and possibly slander an uninvolved idol.

Honestly, a boycott of this site would be more appropriate if there is one more single article from Lily Alice.

Edit: typo

71votes

I was shocked at the content of today's article. Has it been removed? My first reaction is to not renew my annual subscription coming up. Also is there anywhere on this site to register complaints? Or does one message an admin? The email contact to use is just a black hole.

Like, did admin approve of that article to begin with???

I reported it, but it's still up. As she is the Editor, the report might just go to her? So I came here next and posted this a few hours later. You can try reporting it too, it's in the upper right corner of the field in the article. Otherwise, I'm unsure what to do.

Yeah I reported it, but who knows what happens bts. I'm so disappointed with the MDL site.

I can get this kind of sick news in lots of other places if I want it. I just wanna come here to read about dramas and chat with other members about the dramas we watch and keep track of my lists.

The "news" article is no longer accessible. Possibly because of the backlash it received?

I don't think this will change anything long term about how the "news" is more a Koreaboo gossip corner, though.

ThiSong:
The "news" article is no longer accessible. Possibly because of the backlash it received?

That's a relief. I'm gonna guess there was a higher than usual number of reports and maybe DMs to admin. ?

But yeah I agree it prob doesn't change anything unless this is a catalyst for change in article guidelines by admin...here's hoping! 😆

Fully support. Not sure how other people feel but I really hate the whole "news" section in general. MDL was much better when the focus was always on users expressing their ideas and opinions through editorials and recaps.

I definitely support and agree.

News should only be about castings, not scandals and controversies.

Editorials and recaps back.

MDL should write for itself a mission statement and make clear rules for what kind of content needs to be avoided. There are thousands of user contributed articles that don't see the light of day. We should be discussing dramas and maintain respect towards actors.

Lily Malice loves the Koreaboo method: take a random negative comment and make an article blowing it up into a "controversy" it. I've been vocal on this issue for so long that Lily Malice already knows what the reception for this kind of article will be.

MDL could be good site for drama discussion and analysis if not left in the hands of gossip hungry tabloid writers who live deep in that mudpit. There are already enough malicious gossip sites for those who love any whiff of a "scandal" or "controversy".

Just anyone, no matter what age and level of maturity, can start writing to MDL. Nobody reviews. The consequences are what we've already seen. Kids invited to post death wishes for actors, kids invited to throw mud, kids invited to misbehave and be disgusting. There needs to be an adult in the room saying: we should not be deriving joy from bad things happening to actors. "Celebrity News" does not really belong to MDL, positive or negative. There will be those those who defend publishing these "articles" with slanted framing and sensationalism, but these people 1) could use other sites if they're interested, 2) are most likely the writers themselves.

YouTube makes concent creators responsible for also the user comments posted under the videos. At first I thought it was just a mechanism for censorship. But now after observing for a longer time how publishing a "celebrity" articles almost always invited comments that are de facto defamatory and hurtful for the actors, I do think MDL and Lily Malice are directly responsible for attracting defamatory comments.

All of these articles invite people to act as a public court. The insults are usually harsh, allowed by anonymity.

The mentioned article is still up, to correct earlier comments: https://news.mydramalist.com/article/kim-soo-hyun-to-make-first-tv-appearance-after-a-year-long-hiatus

Some other problematic articles:

https://news.mydramalist.com/article/our-sticky-love-star-ha-young-s-agency-issues-statement-on-family-history-controversy

https://news.mydramalist.com/article/doh-kyung-soo-s-agency-to-pursue-legal-action-against-malicious-posts (false framaing of the case from Lily Malice)

https://news.mydramalist.com/article/moon-lovers-scarlet-heart-ryeo-actor-ji-soo-shares-life-update-from-the-philippines - people repeat condemnations and accusations without any knowledge of the case with Kim Ji Soo.

https://news.mydramalist.com/article/cha-eun-woo-appeals-tax-assessment-agency-confirms-legal-proceedings-underway

https://news.mydramalist.com/article/jung-jun-won-opens-up-about-career-struggles-amid-attitude-controversy

MDL should avoid causing harm to actors.

Mu Hyul:
All of these articles invite people to act as a public court. The insults are usually harsh, allowed by anonymity.

Nothing good comes from this for sure. It brings out the negative side of human nature. It's not helpful to anyone and brings down the integrity of this site.

Mu Hyul:

News should only be about castings, not scandals and controversies.

Editorials and recaps back.

Add me to that. The gossip articles are way off topic, and it really doesn't contribute to the goal of what dramas are out, what is upcoming, and casting choices and changes.

Mu Hyul:
MDL could be good site for drama discussion and analysis

MDL used to be such a site when I discovered it 6 years ago: no news articles, no Lily Alice google translating from Koreaboo, just all kinds of editorials (with one exception - no BL related content). Now they have become a business which depends on clicks and all the "articles" they publish are just clickbait! The users' complaints are just brushed off if it is not in MDL's interest to deal with them.

Don't waste your time: short of a massive unsubscribe movement, nothing you say or the number of votes you manage to collect (see the demand for gaga listing as service provider vote falling on deaf ears!) will make them react.

Yellen:

MDL used to be such a site when I discovered it 6 years ago: no news articles, no Lily Alice google translating from Koreaboo, just all kinds of editorials (with one exception - no BL related content). Now they have become a business which depends on clicks and all the "articles" they publish are just clickbait! The users' complaints are just brushed off if it is not in MDL's interest to deal with them.

Don't waste your time: short of a massive unsubscribe movement, nothing you say or the number of votes you manage to collect (see the demand for gaga listing as service provider vote falling on deaf ears!) will make them react.

At least raising others' attention to it and calling for community action is better than having a shitty attitude yet doing nothing. The more people vote on this, the more attention it gets. Also the more people are aware. Hopefully more people will feel okay calling this awful behavior in the future too, and will also unsubscribe (as I have). Doing nothing will never create reactions, and maybe this silly little vote post won't either. But it's better than doing nothing and wondering why things are bad. If you can create actionable changes or, please do so.