Ep6... puppy GC has no condition. Woooow! She's soooo moved now. 😳 I notice the drama shamelessly put the kiss scene under the rug. Hey, she kissed him!! What's that? Everybody act like nothing happenned?! It was just to create a funny cliffhanger?
Ep6, lot of confusion about what say the woman in the art gallery, the girl Jae Yi, then reaction of SJ on the bridge. I get nothing from that. It's like Jae Yi was SJ daughter, but the traduction give me "sky". Annoying use of dialog to give informations impossible to make sens.
SJ talk to her friend "Jun Hee". But now I realise I've no idea who is this character. Not in the cast, not in the characters map.
Of course, going alone in the night to meet a supposed murderer, in a isolated place perfect to be killed. Then she calls for help, but she talks anything instead to say the first thing to say when calling for help, where she is... after many time he asks her. Then final BOOM.
Ep6... the financial scheme... I'm easely lost here. Complicated stuff. I'm not sure I get a good traduction moreover. Looking like, if the deal don't work, Han group will have to pay x2, then they say TK will pay x3 instead. I don't get who is the guy she speaks with at the fast food in the street, nor know the motivation of the Han Ko nephew here.
Ep6... the scene with Choi Yoon Sang and Soo Jae. Quite absurd love triangle thing. Two students for one teacher. It takes that as comedy as it's impossible to takes that seriously. Yoon Sang, in short, tell her the same platitudes than GC, except his condition. Crazy nerve! Then, she touch her fronthead, kind of "omg, I don't know where I am anymore in my life"... 😯😓
I have dropped but you make me want to watch again. Gosh!!!
Hey, thanks to you, I tried episode 5. It's better now (the ending is very nice). I still find some writing mistakes but not to the point to push me away.
What’s wrong with these Choi’s? I thought the two elder maggot Choi’s were already a problem to Soo Jae…
I find in Ep5 there is another Choi Son... Maybe it was shown before? Do you remember if there is a scene in episode 1 to 4 showing that? I'm not sure it's a new information or something I forgot.
Ep5. As before, things resolve a bit too much on heavy dialogues. Making we are quickly lost in the many subplots and characters. - Coffee PPL scene, many names we don't remember, just quick flashs could help. - Later the meeting with the guy from Hanso group. Long (5 minutes) dialog, with some difficulties to catch that. But I said already this writer isn't fully bad, and here shes uses two flashbacks in this scene. That help a lot, but there was room for more. Then, we understand President Choi is the smartest vilain in the gang (I needed to rewatch the scene as it's quite subtle the way president Choi convince Han). - Scene in the pool, additionnal dialogs with new random guys. - As I was aware I'd lost the situation (put the drama on hold since then), just I quickly watched a few parts of previous episode to remember who's who, and be attentive to the "previously in" scene (quite well made with additionnal narrative text). But even that's wasn't enough. There is something woobly and unstable in this drama. - Next scenes: many dump and name dropping, it makes this so uneasy. In the list of most painful things in a script: people speaking about other people not in the room. And worst when it's minor characters, guys it's impossible to remember or when there are too much characters in the story. - 34:50, here it's better. Choi father and son. First it's a good dramatic (break a glass!) and just when father say "Hong Seok Pal", we get the flashback. So we remember who he is. And it's a character already easy the remember (the "henchman").
Later, there is a good scene with the law team. I find strange Gong Chan reveal to them the Usb Key (The FL could quickly be aware then). Else it was enough funny.
I continue to list good scenes: - SJ is pissed of by GC. Accuses him to once again "cross the line". Now GC is like a annoying puppy. - Good flashback scene with the Han guy in the park. I was wondering why we got a scene here before, it's the way SJ saw the shoes first time. - 55:00, very good revelation about SJ past. On the way to marry the Choi son, but misscariage (she had no pride at this time! Or she really believed that?). That's enough to make me want to watch a bit more the drama. Until the end of the episode, it's all good.
This drama will be 100% better without gong chan. It doesn't need romance. Kdrama writers are cowards, they add…
It's not unnecessary, and it's quite a good strategy too. Look at the korean rating! This drama checks box. Good airing day, quite makjang (but alas not enough), noona romance that please a lot ajhummas who are the main audience target. But I'm agree the romance is badly made here, until episode 4. I'm taking a look at episode 5.
Problem is a big word. I detected way too many writing problems and lost interest. However, reading through the comments, someone gave some spoilers and the last few episodes seem fun.
This drama uses classic makjang concepts, I guess any good makjang should please you. The most famous is "Penthouse: war in life". Perfect writing, however the drama also plays on self-parody and black humor hidden by irony.
Else, as much more believable Noona romance and law (+a bit of sci-fi): I hear your voice. Very good screenwriter. A must watch and a perfect episode one. Lot of good feeling. About law: Law school, copied a bit by "with her", but better and more focused.
And tons of other better dramas. "Why Her" isn't fully bad, but way below average.
Very RPG like. Korea produced many video-game in the high-fantasy genre.
Culture is meant to be appropriate, except for retards who want to live in a cave for the next millennia. That's how humanity got out of the caves by the way!
They both get a shower scene, lol (not together, huh? 😆).
I notice the drama shamelessly put the kiss scene under the rug. Hey, she kissed him!! What's that? Everybody act like nothing happenned?! It was just to create a funny cliffhanger?
Ep6, lot of confusion about what say the woman in the art gallery, the girl Jae Yi, then reaction of SJ on the bridge. I get nothing from that. It's like Jae Yi was SJ daughter, but the traduction give me "sky". Annoying use of dialog to give informations impossible to make sens.
SJ talk to her friend "Jun Hee". But now I realise I've no idea who is this character. Not in the cast, not in the characters map.
Of course, going alone in the night to meet a supposed murderer, in a isolated place perfect to be killed. Then she calls for help, but she talks anything instead to say the first thing to say when calling for help, where she is... after many time he asks her. Then final BOOM.
Ep6... the scene with Choi Yoon Sang and Soo Jae. Quite absurd love triangle thing. Two students for one teacher. It takes that as comedy as it's impossible to takes that seriously.
Yoon Sang, in short, tell her the same platitudes than GC, except his condition. Crazy nerve!
Then, she touch her fronthead, kind of "omg, I don't know where I am anymore in my life"... 😯😓
The kind of... he say her the truth, but she's too drunk and won't remember. Yeah cliché. Still works.
Then, the full combo, once at her home, cover scene while she sleep, then he leaves...
I wonder if it could help the romance... For this, It needs more SJ piggy back GC and cover him... 😄
I don't know episode 6 yet.
- Coffee PPL scene, many names we don't remember, just quick flashs could help.
- Later the meeting with the guy from Hanso group. Long (5 minutes) dialog, with some difficulties to catch that. But I said already this writer isn't fully bad, and here shes uses two flashbacks in this scene. That help a lot, but there was room for more. Then, we understand President Choi is the smartest vilain in the gang (I needed to rewatch the scene as it's quite subtle the way president Choi convince Han).
- Scene in the pool, additionnal dialogs with new random guys.
- As I was aware I'd lost the situation (put the drama on hold since then), just I quickly watched a few parts of previous episode to remember who's who, and be attentive to the "previously in" scene (quite well made with additionnal narrative text). But even that's wasn't enough. There is something woobly and unstable in this drama.
- Next scenes: many dump and name dropping, it makes this so uneasy. In the list of most painful things in a script: people speaking about other people not in the room. And worst when it's minor characters, guys it's impossible to remember or when there are too much characters in the story.
- 34:50, here it's better. Choi father and son. First it's a good dramatic (break a glass!) and just when father say "Hong Seok Pal", we get the flashback. So we remember who he is. And it's a character already easy the remember (the "henchman").
Later, there is a good scene with the law team. I find strange Gong Chan reveal to them the Usb Key (The FL could quickly be aware then). Else it was enough funny.
Another good situation: SJ put the Han guy car on surveillance. All this unfold in a nice way, easy to understand. There was two guys. So the guy on the roof was also a false lead before. She know it's Han, thanks to the shoes (quite lucky on that). The agressor shoes aren't the same. This is more exciting than the cliché situation from episode 2.
I continue to list good scenes:
- SJ is pissed of by GC. Accuses him to once again "cross the line". Now GC is like a annoying puppy.
- Good flashback scene with the Han guy in the park. I was wondering why we got a scene here before, it's the way SJ saw the shoes first time.
- 55:00, very good revelation about SJ past. On the way to marry the Choi son, but misscariage (she had no pride at this time! Or she really believed that?). That's enough to make me want to watch a bit more the drama. Until the end of the episode, it's all good.
But I'm agree the romance is badly made here, until episode 4. I'm taking a look at episode 5.
This drama uses classic makjang concepts, I guess any good makjang should please you. The most famous is "Penthouse: war in life". Perfect writing, however the drama also plays on self-parody and black humor hidden by irony.
Else, as much more believable Noona romance and law (+a bit of sci-fi): I hear your voice.
Very good screenwriter. A must watch and a perfect episode one. Lot of good feeling.
About law: Law school, copied a bit by "with her", but better and more focused.
And tons of other better dramas. "Why Her" isn't fully bad, but way below average.