Tae

it is okay that your prediction can be wrong coz its are theory to cover the plot holes the writer or director never bothered to show in the drama so we might be thinking right or wrong , so no need to be disappointed

the thing about chore is that it couldn't have taken long is because as you can see the HTJ's wife is so violent so if 1 month or 2 months get passed in her house she would have had punished someone by then because of a lowly mistake that doesnt need a punishment but because she was angry so gc's might have had seen something and be cautious rather than that much reckless the reason of he making a move of HTJ is because she was unaware of the violent environment in the house that could be possible if she has been here for small amount of time

manchus could be okay with it but cp's staying out of his palace and roaming for months could be an act of suspiciousness as there is always some sort of royal order or discussion between cp and manchu's leader its not like they will come and cp's people will say that cp's is out of town to roam for 2 months xD

and about your prediction about gc's father you never mentioned that to me lol so I dont know the science behind it

anyway I am impressed that you are such a thoughtful person in this time who teaches their children about history unless they are curious about it themselves when they get older, but I thought that your thinking that thinking is what makes it worth it which is why I asked maybe you are specialized in the history period of time or was it just a hobby that you get to learn such things and now sharing it to the world

I can agree with the travel dates but I cant with the culture thing
you said that it took 2 to half month for a gilchae to say those lines to HTJ which makes no sense at all , remember gilchae was in a mess condition when she was first introduced to HTJ right after she was bring to shinyang and she literally asked the korean girl that night to help her out and do you think she would have had jumped to that irrational conclusion after spending two months in the house where she can literally sense that she was is not a trusted girl and by talking to other people like the girl who got her fingers cut , do you think she would have had remained calm for two months and never saw the girl who can speak the same language as her and has her fingers cut but never asked her how or what happened for two months and then suddenly that girl explained to her why that happened after her interaction with HTJ , that interaction definitely happened with 1 week of her arrival at htj house,
you use familiarity with working in HTJ house needs time but what familiarity she even needs lol she is literally there to clean you dont need to learn mathematical formulas or law of physics start clean all you need a mop or cloth and just use your hands to clean it where everyone else is doing , the guidance and familiarity can be ordered like you go over there and clean it .
2ndly slave camp couldnt be that far, remember how cp once went there with janghyun and eunuch do you think cp can literally disappear from his hostage palace to roam freely in the market for weeks and no royal order or visitor have had visited during that time , considering his life could be in danger if people get to know that cp is out in the town anyone can kill and claim it a market mob fight and that nobody knew who he was. market suppose to be near the janghyun house, cp house and also gilchae house and that should also be within a day travel or more like a 4 5 hours travel for a two way turn because cp's needed to be home within a day and janghyun always come to visit cp whenever he asks him to so he must living closer to him as eunuch came to deliver cp's messages and jj sending a message to translator who should also be living within cp's range to connect whenever asked to , not to mention they all met each other by foot not on a horse or something
I cant argue with the places you mentioned and the time it takes to be there coz it is a rational evidence and you definitely have proof of knowledge for which I am impressed , you definitely dug deeper. is it only because of a drama or are you someone who is in this field of work??

but still even if considering your theory of time to be true for a sec that its already been 3 months plus for gc to be living there
how come janghyun met her there for the first time when she was on escape from the bandits because
gc's entering the htj home and cp been ordered to grow his own food happened the same time
considering janghyun time situation
1 month for the 2way trip for cp to buy people from black market
lets say 1 week for the farmer to get familiar with the soil and claiming a cow 3 weeks for janghyun to get the cow which makes a total of 2 months by now
but jj sent the message after two and half month and was on a run with gc from the prison after 3 months while janghyun saw gc while buying back a cow with him so he must be coming after 3 plus month but he should have had already be delivered the cow by now then so there is a gap mind filling that too ??

the travel time and distance makes a lot of sense from the hanyang to shenyang we can definitely calculate that but the time passed in the shenyang while the people (ryang eum, janghyun, gilchae) has gone through seems impossible
for example
if we take the context that by the time gilchae entered shenyang , ryangeum went back to gwm's house and confirmed the abduction .
now , it means gilchae is there and has safely survived the 3 people cutting heel penalty which means time to go the real owner home .
this step could have had happened within that day.(1 day)
now she went to that owner house , and he already selected her as a chosen one in the ear of her servant , lets assume another day has been passed ( 2 days)
after that gilchae asked the korean servant there to help her and she deceived her(gc) by telling her to say those words to his lord which literally meant I want to serve you personally (lets assume she said that within 2 days of her arrival in the person house coz she was in rush to get saved as she was abducted and she never was a captive so still to get familiar with the situation she spent atmost 2 days within there to say those words , but still lets assume 2 days have been passed (4 days atmost)
now after that saying the owner gets happy and the wife of the owner got triggered and she tried to torture her within that day but was stopped by the servant , now lets assume for the sake of agreement that 2 3 days have been also been passed after that incident the reason why it cant be more than that is because no wife would let a mere servant survive full body intact in her house and no lust full men will hold himself that long after a blunt confession.
being generous i give 3 days ( 7 days atmost have been passed after gilchae went to simyang and ryang eum must have been went to simyang own his own from hanyang)
then the incident of her bath and self hurting happened and she was sent to that selling market assuming how she was beautiful and was ordered by highly official to sell her off and how the market seller was desperate to make big money I dont think it is possible that she could have had survived 1 week there . lets cut it to half 3 days max , by that she already escaped away with others using the fake small pox propaganda
hence ( a total of only 10 days have passed only , since she arrived shimyang )
lets move to janghyun side now , janghyun went to see the captive getting punished on the day1 too after that he faced the crown prince farming situation where he decided to buy farmers next day who get captured again as escapers (day2 has been passed)
now within 2 3 days they get to face the rocky soil situation as soiling the surface of the ground can be discovered within 2 3 of farming hence he was ordered to buy a cow/bull from nearby place (day 5 has been passed)
now assume that he went somewhere closer to buy the cow which was of 1 day travel hence he went out on day 5 arrived at day6 spent the night and came back on day7)
which cant be possible and the reason why is that he met gilchae while she was on run in the field which obviously means this has happened after day 10
assuming the fact jonjong asked the servant to look for janghyun and tell her about gilchae who came on their day4 where gilchae was supposed to get boiled down or get her fingers cut by the wife so either the fact janghyun went out for buying the cow on day4 or the messenger never shared the message .
coz janghyun get to know about gilchae from ryangeum who definetely can never arrive shimyang that early either he take unicorn to travel by air or sea horse to travel by water
no matter how far he came during that time a normal distance time can only be cut to half by water or shortcuts so 2 months travel can only be cut to half by smart ass ryangeum means its only 1 months and how come gilchae survived the 20 days of run while being the area of escapes and how far janghyun could go to buy a cow which is a desperate need of farmers
the time is just killing me xD

remind me if it gets a release date

my bad , there are some people who know a lot about drama even before its airing like catching up with interviews and listening to their promotional stuff so I was expecting ans from that certain someone.

will there never be , or is it just mystery/crime only ?

ah yes , u r right thank you

lol lets close it by saying its memoir xD

lol full moon 29.5 days.. i mean everthing could've been okay supporting the memoir theory until they show ryangeum in ep 3 preview it would have made a lot of sense if ryang eum went ahead after finding proof of gilchae been kidnapped and parting ways with yeonjun and only yeonjun came back to share with her husband that creates a loop hole , which makes full moon 29.5 days cycle if coming from ml's to fl's home but 1 day cycle if coming from fl's to ml's xD

guys how's it ? should I wait ? is murder mystery been discussed or is character's introduction ?

I cant seem to quite figure out the time difference of them married and distance between gilchae's home to lee janghyun , on one hand it takes alot less days for gilchae to enter shimyang while the old man who came to buy her daughter back from the barbarian said it took him a year and half year to come back from joseon(even considering joseon is far away from gilchae home still it wont be far away from gilchae home to simyang) to simyang and while ryang eum is already in ml's place to discuss about gilchae kidnapping in the preview of third ep and it seems like its only been a 1 2 days passed in the timeline of janghun and gilchaes place considering how ml was out buying cow and will come back to hear it from the ryangrum's so how the time is going not to mention ryangeum even followed gilchae first to confirm her kidnapping went back to address it to his husband and then went to tell it to janghyun, while there utterly a few days have been passed,
and about marriage duration is because the reason gilchae's husband felt insecure and non-trust worthy of her is because its definitely been more than a year of their marriage yet gilchae is still avoiding him which will trigger anybody intentions towards their partner who has ran away once unless their is some sort of trust development again which in this era can be shared through mutual feelings/interest.
the time difference is making my head spin its like they are living in two different universe and go through some sort of portals where one day spent in shimyang equals months in joseon ..
share your thoughts

was that discussed in these latest eps?
and does that means lovespell is basically a feeling enhancer, even if someone under it uncast it- the feelings will remain the same and wont be nullified to what it was before the spell?

so its upto to viewers to believe in the end, believing isnt a fact.

did they explained it or is it open to the viewer's belief ?

so does the love potion had the effect or it was just a myth ?

what a dull killer reveal, he was there from the beginning everyone suspected him but writer tried to inoccentize him by making unnecessary/useless power check on him , he was everywhere yet no one bothered to just say his name, yebun literally butt checked him and also caught him infront of the assembly man office mind you he wasnt wearing glasses for the first time as he was wearing it second time when he entered the room plus how come he was able to kill mayor and grandpa in such a short span of time while creating his alibi and getting infront of the car, when yebun checked him to help him with his alibi. if he had created the alibi in the first place why did he need yebun help to get through it , as if he was expecting yebun to come and reveal her power to him and help him clear his name by seeing his alibi , why couldnt he say that to detective himself ?? seowoo had the most of opportunities, he was living with him and entered house rushely when detective was following him like he literally just entered and the detective is in a mess state by following a killer who just disappeared infront the house lol how much dumber you got to be on the other hand you figured out people with pyschic abilities without people revealing it you like yebun and even shaman's eyes ability , you know that its case of super power all you gotta do is say that to someone ofcourse the detective but no you have your ego more prestigious to you then people dying and yet you are so smart to record your own death and give your password hint in arabic in the eyes of killer, so much mess yet since its a weekly drama we tend to keep forgetting such details, every week we get trapped in whatever the mess the writer presents us with 2 eps for a week and forget what happened in the previous weeks, which is why I believe thriller crime drama eps should be released at once like who tends to remember 2 hours details for a whole 2 months lol most of us have a memory of goldfish we dont remember what we ate last night lol

lmao

guys the COW is killer, she is killing everybody cause when she got struck by a f meteor and disappeared nobody cared to find out about her and everyone was into sightseeing while drinking her milk she felt betrayed
she killed youtuber girl coz she was rude to geumshik who sells HER milk
she killed detective's boy coz he must have stepped on HER milk while running in town
she killed aeran's friend coz she betrayed her friend while selling tea made of HER milk
she killed assemblyman coz he wanted to upgrade the town and by upgrading means more development i.e chemical packed Milk while himself ordering HER milk at night
she killed granda coz he saw her killing assemblyman what can u expect she gotta keep selling HER milk
geumshik isnt killer , he is just threatened by the cow to keep his mouth shut for aeran's sake and keep selling HER milk.

I see thank you

cant keep up with the drag race.