lilmeow

I almost quit this show after 6 episodes, but some online advice suggested waiting it out past 10. I do think it gets better after episode 10- a new chapter starts for the FL and all the abrupt and emotionally void developments before that can simply be treated as premise- but unfortunately the show itself is still not that good.

My main issue is probably that the main characters are really one-dimensional and uninteresting. The show is very focused on the FL, but she’s as generic as they get, a “good person” in the most direct and bland way possible: she wants to be an official to serve the people.

In principle this concept (career-building power woman) could be done well, it’s just poorly executed here. Her desire to help the common people is way too emphasized and seems to be her only defining feature. She just cheerfully persists in the face of blatant prejudiced mistreatment. She doesn’t have much other personality, nor does she have any particular abilities or good ideas. I didn’t actually dislike her, I just didn’t particularly like or care about her.

And yet two guys are head over heels in love with her. One is very green flag- just wants to help her achieve her dream- and the other is very red flag- keeps trying to help her but can’t seem to understand basic concepts of morality. Both ML and SML, like the FL, felt to me like one-dimensional stereotypes taken to the extreme. Their romantic entanglements are a weak part of the story because they’re not properly built up, nor is Fan Yun extraordinary enough to merit all this- I simply could not understand why they were both so obsessed with her- yet unfortunately this aspect is also quite central to the plot.

By the way, the ML is a “governor”, but he seemed more like an emperor to me (court, eunuchs, palace, deference, etc), which he also was in the source material. I found everything made more sense and also felt more impactful if I just mentally replaced “governor” with “emperor”.

This show does have a lot of side characters I like- fun and interesting, many helping to contribute to an overall lighthearted tone. For example, the ML’s two lovable ministers. The second romance is also not bad, particularly because Wei Ying is chaos. But many of the side characters seem to get dropped and their stories feel incomplete.

Which brings me to my next complaint. I think the plot, in addition to being overall boring, is just sloppy. There are some pacing issues with many things developing too quickly, and then- setting aside meaningfulness, how about just tying up your storylines? The show isn’t completely incoherent, but some story arcs seemed to move on without proper explanation (like the epidemic), and some characters are given two seconds of development and then dropped. The villain situation is also somewhat confusing and muddled, which isn’t helped by Fan Yun being so cheerful about being mistreated.

I do credit this show for having a fun, lighthearted feel, which I thought is integrated and executed well. It made me actually enjoy a lot of the show despite some of my other problems with it. There are also some genuinely heartfelt moments that made me feel moved or touched.

But I don’t think these are enough to offset the sloppy writing or the boring and lackluster plot. I may have surface-level enjoyed the lighthearted tone, but I had to watch the show at accelerated speed, and I couldn’t stand more than maybe 1 episode a day before I got bored. To be fair, it worked out well for a period of my life when I didn’t have much time to watch and being properly addicted to a show would have been inconvenient.

For the acting, I think it’s actually pretty good. Joseph Zeng does comedic expressions really well. Li Yitong is very pretty but I felt her character is too bland for her to do anything with it. The supporting cast also did quite well, but that can’t save a plot.

I don’t think the production is that good. Some of the scene transitions look really funny and a lot of the fight scenes are weird, too. I saw people defend that it’s a bit of an older production, but come on, it’s not like standards were that different a couple of years ago.

The styling and costumes look good- everyone looks good and the makeup is not too heavy. I also like the music. I think the BGM is fine but I really love the OST, several songs made it onto my permanent playlist. But again, can’t save the plot.

By the way, I am not familiar with the source material, though I understand it’s quite popular. In the beginning I read some reddit posts explaining some of the character backgrounds (since it wasn’t properly developed in this drama) and I was surprised at how much more depth and meaning they had in the original. But I stopped looking into that because it was turning the characters into something different. I would guess the source captures the imagination a lot better than this show does.

ENDING – READ AHEAD ONLY IF YOU WANT TO KNOW, CONTAINS SPOILERS





This show has a happy ending, unless you count a somewhat sad fate for the SML (but he was pretty unhinged by the end). I don’t think it’s wrapped up that well, though. Like the immediate conflicts are resolved and it ends with reunion and kiss, but there is no view of how things would play out after that. Endings like this aren’t unusual but I still never find them satisfying; in this case, the story wasn’t epic enough for me to want a Happily Ever After and I didn’t care enough about the characters to be upset.