InaBalerina

I just think it lacks logic (not in the fantasy scenes, but in the scenes where they try to make it look natural and day to day like). I believe there should be a balance if you are going for that type of series. I would have liked it more if they would go all the way with it, fantastic and ridiculous with all of it, it is a type and it would look more like an anime, which would be kinda cool. But when you try to mix it with the REAL stuff it has to have a bit more logic and adaptation to context. It is just an opinion, it’s how i feel about it and i shared it here, where people discuss these things… i was not just being mean with it for no reason. Sorry if I gave that impression.

On a serious note, due to the field i work in i am not allowed to colour my hair :))) (nor would i if i could but i get your clown reference, very “original”)

Calm down, you defend it like you wrote it :))) i said how i feel about it after 2 eps, i said i will keep watching, must i post on this forum only if I agree with everyone else?
Be more tolerant and let people have opinions, just saying

Yeah, i realized it after i wrote it, that i would not wanna compare them but since i got to it, i ended up doing it, pardon me

Actually the acting is ok :)))) it’s just the script i found kind of weak, but hey as pointed above i did not direct any dramas so I should not have an opinion 🤣 but you’ll get to use that popcorn when twilight fans come asking for my head

Agree on the my demon thing with the date thing… but i considered it even so better written than this one her. If i were to decide which is better i would choose My demon
If i were to choose between my demon and other fantasies well, my demon is waaaaay behind :))))

I said the reactions seem more natural there and that in THAT context it is better written. It has nothing to do with it beeing fantasy. It’s funny how proud you seem to be by pointing out what you think is a flaw in my message. You are not point a flaw in what I said, u are actually saying something like “it’s ok to be idiotic, it’s fantasy. What did you expect it to be real?” No… i expect it to be good. I take their context and imagine what pattern it can follow. I don’t oversee a stupid dialog by saying “oh it is fantasy” … this is exactly why Interview with a Vampire is a good movie and Twilight is not.

Actually my opinion is that of a viewer (who saw quite a lot of series) and not producing a drama does not mean i should not have an opinion about what i am seeing. That is like telling a prosecutor he should not have ideas about murder since he never killed anyone.

Yes, the type of drama does have enough room to fool around, i said so above, it is fantasy, no one believes time travel is real, but in those circumstances it should make you buy it, make tou feel like if you were in that reality, you would act/react the same…

Sheesh aren’t people so eager to be offended these days?

It’s my opinion that a good fantasy does not mean you can throw whatever out there.

Relax, enjoy, bo need to take me “seriously”..

My demon, in it's context, looks credible. The reactions and interactions are far more relatable and normal (if we may say so). This one here lacks so much logic it annoys me yet I am curious.. the other one is better in my opinion (not in terms of acting, though it is a bit more convincing) but in terms of dialog I guess..
I would not compare them, but after seen 2 eps of each, I 'd choose My demon.

so you find a girl in a pool and obviously seems insane, ok, you are desperate so you come up with a plot to use her.. does that mean you give no CPR or whatnot she was literraly possibly dead on the floor while they were talking..ok.. moving on, looked dumb but ok..

Your assistant annoying the life out of me knows about all of it and then goes on babblin about how he might have had a steamy night in those conditions? ok... moving on...

You fake a marriage then get all desperate that your family whom you wanted to lie to, finds out... ok...moving on...

You see a girl all messy, hungry, dirty...obviously troubled, and your text is: did you even wash your face? Yeah, I did, in the lake. ok... moving on...

There are more from where these come from and I am sure there will be more. I will still give it a few more chances since I like the leads (seen her in a few dramas and she is good, donno about him, think I saw him once in a drama as second lead) and some scenes were funny (like when she hit her head after seeing the city at the window; threw the sauce on him or whatever that was, and when she couldn't open the door..) + it does manage to get me curious on who is everyone and what is going on...

In any case, i just wanna put it out there that it DOES HAVE SOMETHING but i am still uncertain.

it's kind of bad when it comes to the writing. Seems a bit forced and lacks logic (yeah yeah, it's fantasy but I still think it should be well done and should be believable in those conditions).

Examples:

omg that slap... AHAHHAHAHHAHHA

How slow is this one?

I think they were orphans and adopted separately. .. either way, that second one might have been naturally smart so maybe there was no experiment with her.. heck knows. I am all for open endings but...this one is a bit TOO open. :))

it looked like he shot him in the chest near the heart :))) police officer of the day.
Hey dear wife, I won;t let this guy kill himself in front of you do you don't feel guilty, so I will kill him in front of you. Ta daaaaa :)))

As usual I don't mind spoilers so seeing that it was all out, I checked the ending scene. I still gotta get there and see how it develops towards that ( i love doing this) BUT....
PLEASE.... someone please tell me why did he shoot him ?

I mean dude put a gun to his head, why kill him? You either stop him by shooting arm or you act like an idiot more or less along the lines: don;t you dare die on me or I will kill you!... same logic. Pointing a gun to someone and killing them when they are threatening do do so themselves it is beyond my comprehension man....

-unless he wanted to take his place and be the boss and made sure he wouldn't chicken out and miss. In which case MAN that would be a cool twist.

so the kids on the other 4 addresses were naturally smart?

I do not think we will have season 2 even though I did not quite understand the ending.

So he got jail time, but given how ok he was with it, it's probably a reduced sentence and surely a few years since he cannot take care of his kid attending school. Ok, this does not bother me that much, it makes it kind of fair and credible.

But I do not get the Singapore thing. So there are at least 4 other kids where the experiment was done (given the addresses in the end), implying that Ro Hee had at least one twin sister when she was adopted. Clearly this girl is also very smart. Since Ro Hee had 4 addresses and suggests to the doctor to not use the methods because hey look, I can show you 4 other unhappy kids ...I am not the only one.

Even so, I do not get why they wanted to take her to Singapore. She understands why but it is not explained. Did the other kid not do well in the experiment? Is she dying? Does she need to be replaced, why there? Why 2 of them, to show what? Everyone was trying to get her there and now even after seeing the twin, I cant think of any reason why people would go to all that to take her there.

oh that I can accept :))) I mean I like his character and all but If I have to choose...

i think it was her in that prison but let's live the moment :))