A Female-Driven Twist on Tang Dynasty Mysteries
I loved this drama — it’s a real gem with a compelling detective narrative. It reminds me of Strange Tales of Tang Dynasty, but with a more prominent and intelligent female lead. Like in Miss Truth, she plays a key role in leading investigations and solving cases. The story is structured around four distinct cases, each solved collaboratively by a team of well-developed characters: the crown prince, Li Xinghe; Chu Qi, an investigator from the Court of Judicial Review; and Zhang Xiaomeng, a skilled coroner. Each character brings their unique expertise to the table, making the mystery-solving all the more engaging.Case 1. Posthumous Marriage.
Case 2. Serial Killer.
Case 3. Envoy Murder.
Case 4. Fox Spirit Murder.
Was this review helpful to you?
A Visually Breathtaking Costume Fantasy
A few films have really set the standard for me when it comes to Chinese costume dramas, and this is one of them. It checks all the boxes for what I personally enjoy in the genre:✅ Strong fantasy elements
✅ Dark, atmospheric aesthetic
✅ Morally complex characters
✅ Xianxia-inspired worldbuilding
✅ Strong adaptation source material
✅ Beautiful cinematography
This is a visually stunning adaptation of a Jiu Lu Fei Xiang novel, presented in a way that also works well as its own standalone interpretation. The storytelling is emotionally engaging, with romance that feels natural rather than overdone. The pacing is tight, with no unnecessary subplots or prolonged misunderstandings, and lighter comedic moments help balance the more serious tones.
The cast is well-selected, with strong performances from both leads and supporting actors that bring depth and energy to the story. Overall, it’s a highly polished fantasy production that I would recommend to anyone who enjoys xianxia or atmospheric costume dramas.
Was this review helpful to you?
A Character-Driven Political Drama Worth Completing
The storyline is intriguing, and I found myself genuinely invested in the politics and character dynamics. However, without watching both seasons, the story feels incomplete.That said, the comedic interactions between characters are enjoyable, and I liked all of the roles—though some stood out more than others. My biggest critique lies in Part 1, where a few character arcs felt rushed while others dragged. Still, I enjoyed the first part, adored the second, and ended up loving the series as a whole.
What I appreciated most is the psychological depth given to each character. We see lost and forced love, humiliation, regret, and abandonment shaping their lives. These emotional layers influence their decisions, affect their children, and echo into future choices. The actors did a wonderful job bringing all of this to the screen.
Was this review helpful to you?
A Haunting Portrait of Life in the Imperial Harem
While there are multiple interpretations of Hongli and his harem, this one is presented from the perspective of Ulanara Ruyi and it is one of my top-shelf favorites. Although it spans 87 episodes, the storyline makes every moment worthwhile The narrative is intelligent, the plots are well-developed, and they seamlessly overlap and transition to keep you engaged.From start to finish, you’re fully immersed—both through the depth of the content and the emotional connection to the characters, making you an interactive viewer. It’s easy to become invested and deeply affected by the narrative, which unfolds through the lives and deaths of each consort and concubine, spanning several generations of children, love, hatred, rivalry, deception, hardship, and disappointment.
I highly recommend this, even for those who may not typically enjoy palace dramas. The storytelling is dynamic and dramatic, appealing to viewers drawn to narratives about women who longed for better futures yet were forced to live under rigid societal constraints—sometimes sacrificing their integrity and the lives they might have had, had they not been bound by familial duty or imperial law.
Was this review helpful to you?
A Cohesive and Satisfying Tang Dynasty Mystery. One of the Best Folklore-Inspired Detective Dramas.
I absolutely loved this. It has 27 episodes, divided among 5 subcases and 1 main case that they all connect to. There are several similar dramas that follow this investigative style—detectives solving cases shrouded in haunted folklore. Guan Yue even starred in another one called Tang Dynasty Unusual News Report. While I enjoyed that drama too, it fell apart in the second half when the focus shifted to the overarching case. The transition wasn’t seamless, and the episodes felt disjointed. In contrast, The Crime Unit of Tang Dynasty stayed cohesive and consistently strong through to the end. Like its counterpart, it taps into spooky elements, but what made this one stand out for me were the stories themselves. They felt elevated because they centered on touching situations and explored the layers of human behavior and its impact.Was this review helpful to you?
A Compelling Mix of Mystery, Survival, and Human Psychology
As primarily a costume viewer, I enjoyed every episode, though I slightly faltered at the last one due to its heavy romantic themes. The series maintained strong storytelling and compelling subplots throughout, which kept me engaged from start to finish. It left me intrigued and eager to see what the creators might do next.You might be interested in this drama if you enjoy mystery, investigative themes, gaming, and survival plots. I cried throughout the series because the scenes are poignant, delving deeply into character psychology, personal growth, and social dynamics. The themes explore human nature, selfishness, and altruism in life-and-death situations. The drama also examines group dynamics, including acts of self-sacrifice based on the roles individuals assume within the group—roles that continually shift depending on personal interactions both within and across groups.
Was this review helpful to you?
Still a Favorite Two Years Later
I already watched this in 2024 when it first released, and it was my top-tier favorite then. After being disappointed by several newer watches and dropping or passing on them, I decided to revisit this one, and I have no regrets. It was a favorite in 2024, and it’s still a favorite two years later. There are so many layers to the story that it barely feels like a rewatch. I’m noticing and feeling things now that I completely missed the first time, so this entire experience has been incredibly welcoming.While GJM isn’t for everyone, he definitely is for me. And although this drama seems to divide audiences, even among people who enjoyed his other dramas or films, I hold this one in just as high regard as the rest of his work. Some people describe it as slow or depressing, but that’s not something I personally connect with. I find the drama very well-paced, consistently engaging, and I’m practically hanging onto every scene. Plus, I find it incredibly funny.
And while the mood can be heavy at times, it genuinely moves me and I connect deeply with it. I see this story as a pendulum swinging between highs and lows, where moments of joy exist alongside hardship. Is this a bright, carefree drama where no one struggles and every day is perfect? No, but that isn’t realistic, nor is it the point of the story. These characters are on a journey to confront and resolve hardships, so naturally they encounter pain and obstacles along the way.
What makes it meaningful for me is the promise that it will all matter in the end, and that they find love, comfort, and support through the friendships and bonds they build with one another. This is only one chapter of their lives; another story will begin once this one ends.
Was this review helpful to you?
One of Li Fei’s Best
This is my second favorite Li Fei drama (with my top pick being Zhao Ge Fu, also known as Song of the Dynasty). It features a rebirth storyline that starts off with a light comedic tone and becomes more poignant as the plot unfolds. The layers are complex, and it’s engaging to watch everything come together. The character development is strong, and the chemistry between the leads feels natural and satisfying. It’s easy to connect with the characters as they face and resolve various conflicts.My only critique is the ending—it didn’t make much sense to me, and I had to chalk it up as a plot hole in order to move on. You might enjoy this drama if you’re into second-chance storylines, palace intrigue, beautiful costumes, and a mix of humor and drama.
Was this review helpful to you?
An Engaging Blend of Mystery, Tension, and Emotion
I believe this drama can appeal to fans of both short- and long-form content. Directed by Zeng Qingjie—whom I know from Provoke, Butterflied Lover, and Blossom—this drama is no exception in terms of quality. It features a strong ensemble cast, and I found the second leads just as compelling as the main ones. This was my first time watching Ke Ying, Kay Song, and Wang Zexuan, and their performances were both strong and captivating. It’s easy to see why they’ve gone on to appear in many more dramas.The story is tense and gripping, with twists and mysteries that are well-paced. While not overly difficult to predict, they are still satisfying in their execution. The villain arcs are deeply human, often blurring the lines of empathy and morality. I especially enjoyed the dynamics between Ke Ying and Cheng Lei, as well as between Ke Ying and Wang Zexuan. Overall, this drama offers a compelling viewing experience that I’d recommend to anyone
Was this review helpful to you?
A Visually Rewarding Watch that Matched its Narrative
I greatly enjoyed this. I found it mesmerizing—with themes that were both haunting and intriguing, and visually beautiful to watch onscreen. The color palette was appealing and, combined with the soundtrack, created an incredibly artistic experience. I thought the narrative itself was solid; the script was well-written, and the subtle nuances added a touch of uniqueness that kept the story from feeling redundant or tiresome. I also appreciated the absence of clear answers for why things happened. It felt realistic—presenting a difficult situation where choices lead to unintended consequences, some of which require atonement in different ways.Was this review helpful to you?
Heavy Themes and Emotional, But Worth It
I loved this drama, but it might not be for everyone. It deals with heavy material and includes sensitive scenes involving heinous crimes. Personally, I didn’t find it overly graphic or difficult to watch, but if true crime isn’t your thing—or if you’re not used to content that explores morally gray or disturbing territory—it could be triggering.That said, this series was more than just a true crime drama. It was deeply psychological and poignant, delving into the backstories of both victims and perpetrators, and offering a nuanced sense of humanity to everyone involved. The crimes were tragic, and the criminals themselves were portrayed as complex, even tragic figures. I often had to remind myself that these individuals committed horrific acts against innocent women. The story follows a string of homicides carried out by four people and their eventual capture—a process that spanned nearly a decade. It’s the kind of drama that fully immerses you in their journey, taking you on a complete emotional arc from beginning to end. By the conclusion, it provides a real sense of closure to the trauma and pain experienced throughout.
Was this review helpful to you?
Wo Zai Dong Bei Zuo Bai Shi Di Na Xie Nian
0 people found this review helpful
Emotionally Rich Mysteries
I absolutely loved this and consider it a top-shelf watch. There are a few dramas that follow this type of thematic structure, and I’ve loved every one of them. Typically, storylines like this unfold through a series of cases or arcs that build toward a larger plot. What always resonates most with me are the short stories we get in each episode. I find them human, endearing, personal—sometimes even philosophical—and always meaningful.Because the episodes are short, the impact feels just right. There’s no extra filler to dilute the emotion, the message, or the central idea of each story. The tight pacing keeps each episode focused, allowing every moral or thematic moment to land exactly as intended.
Was this review helpful to you?
Eerie and Visually Stunning, Delivers on Every Level
This is a top-shelf watch for me. It has everything I love in a drama: a unique storyline, an eerie atmosphere, mystery and intrigue, fantastical plots, beautiful aesthetics, and a vibrant, distinct color palette. I thought these elements were dynamic and worked so well together to create a meaningful and impactful story. These are the kinds of roles I enjoy seeing Zhao Yiqin in, and I wish he did more of them.Was this review helpful to you?
An Underrated Fantasy Worth the Epic Journey
From what’s been recommended to new viewers over the years, I’m genuinely surprised this one rarely gets mentioned. Although the first 4–6 episodes were a bit difficult for me due to misunderstandings between the leads, this is such a solid staple for fantasy watchers. It has everything: dragons, gods, phoenixes, an evil deity, and cultivators. There are heroes, deep betrayals, redemption arcs, and several meaningful sacrifices along the way.I had so much fun watching this. The settings were beautiful, and the action scenes were thrilling and powerful. The story unfolds as an epic journey, with strong character and plot development that gives the narrative real growth and helps connect the audience to both the story and its characters. This was a drama that was hard to put down because it was so engaging, with themes that really landed for me. I do think the last few episodes could have been edited down a bit, as the narrative felt slightly stretched. That said, I loved how everything wrapped up, and overall, I truly loved this drama.
Was this review helpful to you?
Top-shelf and Captivating
I loved this. It currently sits as a top shelf watch. I loved the characters, the content (it revolves around a demon god), the wardrobe, the settings, the color palette, and the storyline. I thought the performers depicted their roles well, there weren't annoying tropes, or dragged out ideas. I also thought the side plots were smart ways of keeping the narrative fresh and adding depth to the original material. And the who-done-it reveal at the end was unexpected, making this a unique retelling of a well known story.Although this has an enemies-to-lovers spin, it avoids the excessive violence often associated with the genre. And some scenes have so much poetry, I was engaged and heartbroken together. There have been a few online debates about the ending, but I was content with the final scene and I recommend this.
Was this review helpful to you?
