Promising Setup, but Uneven Execution and Limited Resolution
This drama wasn't a win for me. While it has a few standout moments, they were just that—moments.In my view, the drama felt underdeveloped and could’ve benefited from more consistent storytelling. Several plot points were introduced but never fully explored. The female lead started off strong and decisive but gradually became more passive and domesticated. Meanwhile, the male lead spent a significant portion of the story pushing her away, only to later reverse course without meaningful resolution—making that subplot feel drawn out and unnecessary. And while the ending ties up surface narratives, many of the core conflicts and supporting character arcs are left unresolved or simply forgotten by the time the credits roll.
Was this review helpful to you?
A Dark and Emotionally Heavy Story with a Divisive Journey
I found this storyline very difficult to sit through due to its heavy tone. The central relationship is portrayed in a deeply toxic dynamic, and much of the narrative focuses on emotional strain, manipulation, and the destructive consequences of the lead’s single-minded pursuit of revenge. Across its lengthy run, the story leans heavily into themes of suffering, moral collapse, and the impact of unresolved trauma on both the characters and those around them.I also explored the original novel, hoping for a different or more redemptive direction, but found it similarly bleak, so I ultimately stopped before finishing it. The adaptation does include additional material that continues the story into a more modern setting, offering a sense of closure and resolution. However, the journey leading up to that point is emotionally exhausting, which can make the final outcome feel more bittersweet than uplifting.
Was this review helpful to you?
My Top-Tier Pugilist Drama with Outstanding Martial Arts Choreography
I truly loved this drama — it’s top-tier for me.Set in the pugilist world, the story is deeply rooted in martial arts sects and cultivation levels, with an emphasis on layered power dynamics, strategy, and rivalries. I wasn’t expecting to be so drawn in, but I found myself completely mesmerized early on. The fight choreography and footwork are especially impressive, making the martial arts sequences a highlight throughout.
The narrative is packed with intrigue across both main and side plots, with multiple revenge arcs and sharply written characters who often operate with strategy and intent. While the large cast and their shifting significance can sometimes be challenging to keep track of, the complexity also adds depth to the world. The story maintains strong momentum, with a structure that reminded me of Nirvana in Fire meets Dominator of Martial Gods, especially in how it balances schemes, alliances, and unfolding revelations.
What stood out most to me is how well the drama handles its character balance. Although it centers on a male protagonist, many of the most compelling figures are women — both allies and antagonists — who are skilled, decisive, and fully integrated into the martial arts world. Even the villains are engaging, often given motivations that make them feel layered rather than one-dimensional.
Overall, it’s a tightly built martial arts sect drama with strong cultivation-world atmosphere, excellent action choreography, and a consistently engaging narrative. The only caveat is that it’s not romance-heavy, so viewers looking for a strong romantic focus may not find that here — but for fans of sect politics, strategy, and martial arts storytelling, it’s highly rewarding.
Was this review helpful to you?
A Personal Favorite in the Martial Arts & Fantasy Romance Genre
This is one of my all-time favorite watches. I’ve rewatched it many times—sometimes skipping certain parts on revisits just to focus on the main leads, and other times watching it in full as I did the first time.Overall, I really love this drama, from its tone and music to the romance between the two leads. I’m especially drawn to their dynamic and the way their relationship develops as they navigate misunderstandings, shifting loyalties, and personal growth. The story also balances heavier emotional moments with lighter comedic scenes, which helps keep the characters grounded and engaging.
As one of my earlier VR drama experiences, it still stands out compared to newer releases. The narrative approach feels distinctive, particularly in how it explores themes like fate, moral ambiguity, and unconventional romance that doesn’t fit typical expectations. It remains a drama I often recommend and continue to return to.
Was this review helpful to you?
Disjointed Storytelling with Minimal Narrative Drive. A Low Priority Even for Existing Fans.
I liked a few subplots, the soundtrack, and the use of reincarnated characters. However, I didn’t enjoy this drama overall. While most of Samael and Lilith’s productions are a bit disjointed due to their low budgets, they usually still carry meaningful momentum. This one, though, felt haphazard and random, with no real narrative beyond showcasing tension between the leads. It lacked the depth and potential I’ve come to expect from their work, which is unusual for them.If you’re new to watching Samael and Lilith, I wouldn’t use this drama as a benchmark — it’s one of their earlier productions. And if you’re already a fan, I wouldn’t place this high on your watchlist.
Was this review helpful to you?
A Folklore-Inspired Mystery with Mixed Execution
I have mixed feelings about this drama. It is structured around a series of investigation cases, each intended to carry a spooky, folklore-inspired atmosphere tied to different regions. However, I didn’t feel this concept was consistently executed throughout the series. A noticeable portion of the later episodes leans more toward conventional investigative storytelling rather than maintaining the eerie or supernatural tone introduced early on.The beginning stood out to me the most, as it leaned heavily into its atmospheric and unsettling elements. The sound design, setting, and overall mood were especially strong and created a compelling sense of mystery. These early episodes were where the drama felt most distinctive and engaging for me.
As the series progressed, the tone shifted and the remaining cases felt more grounded and procedural, which didn’t hold my interest in the same way. I also struggled to connect with the romance subplot. That said, the performances were solid throughout, and the martial arts and action choreography were definite highlights.
Overall, I appreciated what the drama was trying to do, but I personally wished it had leaned more consistently into its darker, folklore-inspired direction.
Was this review helpful to you?
The Assassins Were More Interesting Than the Plot
I hate to say this—I know others really liked this drama, but I didn’t. Although I enjoyed the lead characters when they were part of the supporting cast in Butterflied Lover, their comedy and dialogue fell flat for me here. The overall narrative is interesting, and the subplots had a cute framework, but for me, they failed in execution. I found myself disinterested for most of the series. I was intrigued by the characters' backgrounds and the larger organization surrounding them, but the drama doesn't explore those aspects in as much depth as I had hoped. Instead, it places greater emphasis on the central relationship and interpersonal dynamics.Was this review helpful to you?
A Female-Driven Twist on the Tang Dynasty Mystery Formula
I loved this drama — it’s a real gem with a compelling detective narrative. It reminds me of Strange Tales of Tang Dynasty, but with a more prominent and intelligent female lead. Like in Miss Truth, she plays a key role in leading investigations and solving cases. The story is structured around four distinct cases, each solved collaboratively by a team of well-developed characters: the crown prince, Li Xinghe; Chu Qi, an investigator from the Court of Judicial Review; and Zhang Xiaomeng, a skilled coroner. Each character brings their unique expertise to the table, making the mystery-solving all the more engaging.Case 1. Posthumous Marriage.
Case 2. Serial Killer.
Case 3. Envoy Murder.
Case 4. Fox Spirit Murder.
Was this review helpful to you?
A Visually Breathtaking Costume Fantasy
A few films have really set the standard for me when it comes to Chinese costume dramas, and this is one of them. It checks all the boxes for what I personally enjoy in the genre:✅ Strong fantasy elements
✅ Dark, atmospheric aesthetic
✅ Morally complex characters
✅ Xianxia-inspired worldbuilding
✅ Strong adaptation source material
✅ Beautiful cinematography
This is a visually stunning adaptation of a Jiu Lu Fei Xiang novel, presented in a way that also works well as its own standalone interpretation. The storytelling is emotionally engaging, with romance that feels natural rather than overdone. The pacing is tight, with no unnecessary subplots or prolonged misunderstandings, and lighter comedic moments help balance the more serious tones.
The cast is well-selected, with strong performances from both leads and supporting actors that bring depth and energy to the story. Overall, it’s a highly polished fantasy production that I would recommend to anyone who enjoys xianxia or atmospheric costume dramas.
Was this review helpful to you?
A Character-Driven Political Drama Worth Completing
The storyline is intriguing, and I found myself genuinely invested in the politics and character dynamics. However, without watching both seasons, the story feels incomplete.That said, the comedic interactions between characters are enjoyable, and I liked all of the roles—though some stood out more than others. My biggest critique lies in Part 1, where a few character arcs felt rushed while others dragged. Still, I enjoyed the first part, adored the second, and ended up loving the series as a whole.
What I appreciated most is the psychological depth given to each character. We see lost and forced love, humiliation, regret, and abandonment shaping their lives. These emotional layers influence their decisions, affect their children, and echo into future choices. The actors did a wonderful job bringing all of this to the screen.
Was this review helpful to you?
Palace Intrigue Done Exceptionally Well
I absolutely loved this. I typically struggle with Ren Jialun’s performances, but I have to say this one is a top-shelf favorite of mine. Everything worked—even when it didn't.While the overall narrative wasn’t entirely new, with its focus on palace infighting and conspiracies, the execution was so effective that I was fully absorbed, hanging on every line and plot turn. I loved the rich martial arts and the bold characters whose power and potential weren’t limited by gender. Each character captured my attention and drew me into their storylines in impactful ways that stayed with me throughout the drama. I was truly invested in their lives, and I appreciated the multiple layers in both the plot development and the character growth as they navigated identity and relationship dynamics.
This drama isn’t perfect—there were a few moments that made me raise a brow—but everything else made up for what became minor flaws. This is a 10/10 win for me.
Was this review helpful to you?
Six Episodes of Doubt, Then It Clicked: A Romance That Won Me Over
I had a difficult time getting through the first six episodes. I usually love offbeat and exaggerated satire, but the stylized deliveries and constant misunderstandings just weren’t my cup of tea. I’m not sure if it would have worked better with a different lead, but something about the execution didn’t quite land for me. Still, I had a feeling the underlying storyline would eventually shine through—and I’m glad I stuck with it, because it ended up becoming one of my favorites.It’s not quite top-shelf for me, as those six rough episodes are hard to ignore, and the plot occasionally relied on convenient or hard-to-believe twists that separated the main characters one too many times. Even so, it was a drama I couldn’t pull myself away from, and it made for an easy, comforting watch while I was stuck at home recovering from a terrible cold.
The cinematography was beautiful, and the themes reflected many of the elements I love in Chinese dramas. I found myself connecting with both major and minor characters, and the villains were especially compelling—complex, morally gray, and backed by layered stories that made it difficult to truly despise them, even after witnessing the harm they caused. I also appreciated the character dynamics, the steady plot growth, and the overall narrative arc. While I don’t always enjoy the style of romance often found in popular Chinese dramas, this one suited my tastes perfectly. I absolutely loved the main couple and their relationship.
Overall, this was a win for me.
Was this review helpful to you?
A Cohesive and Satisfying Tang Dynasty Mystery. One of the Best Folklore-Inspired Detective Dramas.
I absolutely loved this. It has 27 episodes, divided among 5 subcases and 1 main case that they all connect to. There are several similar dramas that follow this investigative style—detectives solving cases shrouded in haunted folklore. Guan Yue even starred in another one called Tang Dynasty Unusual News Report. While I enjoyed that drama too, it fell apart in the second half when the focus shifted to the overarching case. The transition wasn’t seamless, and the episodes felt disjointed. In contrast, The Crime Unit of Tang Dynasty stayed cohesive and consistently strong through to the end. Like its counterpart, it taps into spooky elements, but what made this one stand out for me were the stories themselves. They felt elevated because they centered on touching situations and explored the layers of human behavior and its impact.Was this review helpful to you?
A Compelling Mix of Mystery, Survival, and Human Psychology
As primarily a costume viewer, I enjoyed every episode, though I slightly faltered at the last one due to its heavy romantic themes. The series maintained strong storytelling and compelling subplots throughout, which kept me engaged from start to finish. It left me intrigued and eager to see what the creators might do next.You might be interested in this drama if you enjoy mystery, investigative themes, gaming, and survival plots. I cried throughout the series because the scenes are poignant, delving deeply into character psychology, personal growth, and social dynamics. The themes explore human nature, selfishness, and altruism in life-and-death situations. The drama also examines group dynamics, including acts of self-sacrifice based on the roles individuals assume within the group—roles that continually shift depending on personal interactions both within and across groups.
Was this review helpful to you?
Still a Favorite Two Years Later
I already watched this in 2024 when it first released, and it was my top-tier favorite then. After being disappointed by several newer watches and dropping or passing on them, I decided to revisit this one, and I have no regrets. It was a favorite in 2024, and it’s still a favorite two years later. There are so many layers to the story that it barely feels like a rewatch. I’m noticing and feeling things now that I completely missed the first time, so this entire experience has been incredibly welcoming.While GJM isn’t for everyone, he definitely is for me. And although this drama seems to divide audiences, even among people who enjoyed his other dramas or films, I hold this one in just as high regard as the rest of his work. Some people describe it as slow or depressing, but that’s not something I personally connect with. I find the drama very well-paced, consistently engaging, and I’m practically hanging onto every scene. Plus, I find it incredibly funny.
And while the mood can be heavy at times, it genuinely moves me and I connect deeply with it. I see this story as a pendulum swinging between highs and lows, where moments of joy exist alongside hardship. Is this a bright, carefree drama where no one struggles and every day is perfect? No, but that isn’t realistic, nor is it the point of the story. These characters are on a journey to confront and resolve hardships, so naturally they encounter pain and obstacles along the way.
What makes it meaningful for me is the promise that it will all matter in the end, and that they find love, comfort, and support through the friendships and bonds they build with one another. This is only one chapter of their lives; another story will begin once this one ends.
Was this review helpful to you?
