An Experimental Drama with Murky Plot Structure
This was enjoyable, but the subplots could have been explained better. I was impressed by the cast and the cinematography was beautiful. It frequently used dream-like sequences to evoke captivating allure and tone, but there were plot holes and the ending wasn't clear. I skimmed through the novel but was confused by how the storyline deviated from the onscreen performance. So as much as this drama is artistic and somewhat experimental, understanding it was challenging.Was this review helpful to you?
A Romance-Heavy Drama Felt Limited in Depth
This drama was okay and I say that disappointingly because I could have loved it. The performers delivered a great performance, the choreography was engaging, the steam was steamy, and the storyline was unique. It has a nice twist with unexpected hidden identities, and the underlying conspiracies give the drama political intrigue. However, there were several opportunities to expand on these subplots and it never happened. This made the overall story a romantic trope that lacked dimension.Was this review helpful to you?
An Eerie Supernatural Mystery with Mixed Execution
I enjoyed this, but it wasn't consistent. It started strong and then fizzled for me as the series progressed. It is divided into 5 cases, so there are different subplots each time, making the storyline unique and engaging and they revolve around a larger narrative that comes together near the end. The cinematography and sound effects are eerie and great for fall watches. But certain plots weren't as strong or cohesive for me compared to others. I enjoyed "Mysterious Tales of Chang'an" more, but this is a nice option for supernatural and mystery watches and I could see myself watching the more stronger episodes again.Was this review helpful to you?
A Love-Hate Kind of Drama for Me, Engaging Fantasy with Slow Sequences
I initially tried watching this once before but quickly dropped it for its low appeal in the first episode. Much later, I gave it another try—and that time, I stuck with it. It was a strange watch for me, because there was so much I didn’t like, yet also a lot I genuinely engaged with. Some themes fell flat and disrupted my viewing flow—especially the romance scenes, which lacked chemistry or believability. They took up too much screen time and made the story drag for me. But then the show would segue into really compelling sequences that recaptured my attention. There were also stretches where too much time passed without any strong subplots to push the narrative forward, leaving me underwhelmed in the middle. I found myself moving through the drama slowly and somewhat out of obligation. That said, I did enjoy the overall story and theme. The content felt rich, the underlying framework was engaging, and the comedic moments hit all the right notes. I loved almost all the subplots—they were layered with enough poignancy that it was easy to fall in love with the characters and be drawn into their storylines. I don’t regret watching this—I just don’t think it was particularly well-rounded.Was this review helpful to you?
Not Till the End of The Moon, But It Hits Similar Notes
This was an okay watch and I liked it, but it isn't the best production and I wouldn't recommend it to everyone (there is a lot to forgive). It is low budget and you can tell from the execution, the script, scene transitions, and the set. The version I watched had terrible English dubbing, so I couldn't watch it with audio and the subtitles were so simple that it was like reading at a beginner's level. With that said, it has several elements of Till the End of the Moon and for those who know me, this is my favorite Chinese drama and I have to watch everything related to it. So although this was an okay feature for me, I enjoyed all of these elements, including wardrobe.Was this review helpful to you?
Great Comic Book Premise, Execution Didn’t Work for Me
I really liked Ma Sihan in Eternal Lovesickness, so I went into this hoping to enjoy it just as much. Unfortunately, it wasn’t my cup of tea. If it hadn’t been such a short watch, I likely would have dropped it around the halfway point.It started off light and familiar, but I quickly struggled to stay engaged. The pacing felt slow, and I found the overall execution a bit uninspiring. The story and side elements didn’t capture my interest, and I often wished things would move along more quickly. I also had a hard time connecting with the characters and the narrative, and the subtitles unfortunately made the experience more difficult at times.
That said, this hasn’t put me off Ma Sihan—I still look forward to seeing more of his work in the future.
Was this review helpful to you?
A Familiar Time Travel Plot That Didn’t Fully Land
This reminded me of Different Princess and The Queen of Attack, though I didn’t enjoy it as much. The early themes were amusing and engaging, but the narrative began to fizzle in the later episodes—especially after reaching its apex and introducing conflicts. The conflicts felt contrived and could have been more effective if handled in a unique way without relying on familiar tropes. That said, the performers are skilled and delivered strong performances. This might still be worth watching for fans of Yan Zixian.Was this review helpful to you?
A Miss for Me, Despite Loving Guan Yue
For those who don’t know me here, I absolutely love Guan Yue. It started with The Reincarnated Lovers and was cemented with Devil Falls in Love with Fairy. Ever since then, I’ve made it a point to watch his costume dramas. That said, I didn’t really connect with this drama. Through no fault of the performers, the storyline just didn’t draw me in, and I found it hard to stay engaged. And it was a struggle to finish. Usually, even if I’m not a fan of the overall production, I can at least appreciate the storyline — but in this case, the arcs just didn’t resonate with me. It wasn’t quite my cup of tea.Was this review helpful to you?
A Goofy, Outlandish Comedy with an Aimless but Fun Tone
This is an outlandish drama with an offbeat comedy lasting for most of the series. The characters are absurd and goofy, but they work for the storyline, which is sometimes aimless because this airs on the side of absurdism. But I enjoyed the watch. However, I don't know if it's for everyone since this might fall into a niche watch.Was this review helpful to you?
An Underwhelming Palace Watch with Weak Flow and Limited Impact
I wouldn’t recommend this series. It starts with a disjointed style that seems intentional at first, but as the story progresses, it feels more like a lack of cohesion. The performances didn’t resonate with me, and the characters didn’t have much chemistry. Transitions between subplots felt abrupt, and although the main storyline is generally understandable, translation issues made parts of it confusing. The plot also felt familiar rather than original. Finally, the final episodes move quickly and don’t fully resolve the narrative threads.Was this review helpful to you?
A Strongly Executed Revenge Drama with Fresh Emotional Impact
I enjoyed this immensely. It is wonderfully executed and well-performed. There are the usual revenge and hidden identities and agendas that we have seen before in other dramas. However, the impact of this narrative and the way the scenes were executed didn't make it feel like I was rewatching old and borrowed storylines. The performers gave an authentic performance, enhancing and refreshing the narrative. And each character had their own story with nuanced tones that captured my interest and sympathy. I enjoyed the plot and character development for all themes and characters and was surprised by how underrated this is.Was this review helpful to you?
A Well-Executed Time-Loop with Strong Characters That Explores Choice and Consequence
I really enjoyed this. I liked the play on timelines and the way cyclical fate was portrayed—it’s almost like the chicken-and-egg dilemma. Even though time-travel and transmigration themes are fairly overused in Chinese dramas at this point, this one was well executed and still felt fresh and engaging. The narrative had a satisfying build, and I loved the character dynamics and the gradual unfolding of the plot. I was fully invested thanks to its layered relationships, the intensity of the sub-arcs, and the strong characterization across every role. It’s a solid watch.Was this review helpful to you?
Strong Start with Hidden Identities, Revenge, and Court Intrigue—But a Weaker Second Half
I absolutely loved this drama at the start and was certain it was on its way to becoming a top-shelf watch. Unfortunately, it ended up feeling like two different dramas between the first and second halves—and the second half didn’t work for me. As the drama approached the halfway point, the narrative moved away from politics and the central conflict, and instead turned into a strange tug-of-war between romantic interests and petty family dynamics. So, I ended up dropping the show a few episodes before the end. It’s upsetting to think about because it had so much potential. The setup—hidden identities, second chances, and revenge themes—offered a lot to work with, but the execution ended up being weighed down by less impactful story arcs.Was this review helpful to you?
An Epic Journey with Strong Character Depth and Layered Conflict
I randomly stumbled upon this after watching Ni Ni in The Rise of Phoenixes. And it was an absolute win for me. I thought the storyline was epic, the characters had depth and development, and even the villains stood out to me. Many were morally grey, with backstories that made them sympathetic and understood. I also appreciated how intricately they were tied to the protagonists, it made conflicts layered and blurred.What I loved most was the layering and how their stories unfolded. It made the experience emotionally resonant and engaging. The pacing also felt perfect, with well-timed comedic moments that broke up the heavier scenes without ruining the tone. I found the cinematography beautiful, and by the end of the series, it truly felt like I had been on a full journey with the characters.
Was this review helpful to you?
A Solid Sci-Fi Mystery with Mythic Depth
I really enjoyed this one. It started on a slightly confusing note as the story was introduced, but with each episode the drama weaves an increasingly engaging sci-fi narrative, and it only got better as it progressed. That said, I was initially disappointed by the creatures. However, as the story developed, the intrigue and depth of the plot made up for that, because it quickly becomes clear that the story isn’t about the creatures' presentation.Instead, it becomes more focused on its mythology and the broader history behind everything, shifting away from first impressions into something more layered. It was enjoyable to watch the traditions and customs unfold, along with the intricate setups and battles between the two forces as their backstories were revealed.Having said that, I’ve seen negative reviews from viewers who expected more romance. This is a creature feature, though, so any romance will follow a different formula or have a lighter presence than in a true romance drama (and rightly so). Personally, I thought there was a nice balance that helped broaden the plot layers. The buildup felt natural and fitting, and my only real critique is that the beginning includes a few repetitive misunderstandings that didn’t quite land for me.
Overall, I enjoyed this watch. While it isn’t a top-tier favorite, I would definitely watch it again, as the script is smart and includes several sequences filled with mysteries and Easter eggs. I hope they continue the story with a season two.
Was this review helpful to you?
