Judge Kim - PhD UHT DSc

[Smile Code]
e3 the story pace seems too quick for us. already living together
e4-e8 there seems to be nothing going on except slice of life.

Similar to Flower of Evil, A Beautiful Mind, Cheese In The Trap

Zoomer edits is not really our cup of tea. There are scholars mentioning about this 'promoting toxic fan culture'.

It is true from the concept but we only watched 3 episodes, therefore we cannot confirm if that's a fact. And yes, the edits in EP 3 made us lose interest in this show.

Due to lack watch-hours,
The Council shall not review this for placement.

The Council find this comment section to be uncivilized, stop your scrolling immediately. Imminent spoilers ahead

If you want a grim ending this is not it. This is a well structured, hard to predict drama with average ending, the flashbacks are not annoying either unlike other dramas.

EP 01-08: 8/10
EP 09-16: Momentum increases. 8.5/10
- E11: Cop issue -.1
- E13: it is a good opportunity to bring back Dad of the Year. Directors did but not much +.5
We can't tell if the killer want to be like REDACTED, having a Dad of the Year. Killer seems cooked as expected.
Dad of the Year blunder -.5 point

We find this show to be worth watching its every single minute, especially father-daughter scenes.
The Council shall place this under S1AA. 8.4/10

Great opening to mid eps, followed with average ending eps.

EP 01-09: 8/10
We felt pity for 2nd FL, 2nd lead syndrome kicks in. +.1
EP 08: Another childhood meta -.1
EP 10: Momentum decreases
The way that conflict ended is just pathetic -.1

If you're looking to fill a void after searching forever, this will be a good choice.
The Council shall place this under S1A. 8/10

This show basically tells you that most doctors are cosmetic, toning down others to make one rise is fine but making them lose common sense is just not ideal. -.2

We don't feel much chemistry going on between main leads, 2nd couple seems more interesting. -.3
- a few judges object this because ML was not even trying.
- some also agree because they are still the same UNTIL EP 32. FL was acting like a caretaker instead, even ML mentioned that.
For 2019, below average sub-plots -.5

The Council agrees with public rating of 8.5,
We shall place this under S1A, 7.5/10

Good drama, that's all. Good. If you have nothing else to watch this will fill that emptiness.

EP 01-18: 7.5/10
- 2nd ML being predictable. Directors, next time don't show any signs at all. -.1
- 2nd Couple gets more screen time here -.1
- E6: Boxes waiting for disaster -.1
EP 19-24: average ending 6.5/10
- Director copy pasta -.1
- OST +.5

Being a 2022 drama, it is very average.
The Council shall place this under Section One below average. 7/10

Good momentum from early to end. The conflict got toned down a lot though, it is expected from romcom.

Directors are cooking especially their choice of casts.
EP 07: FL already knew about 2nd FL, why she did hide? -.1 point
End eps: Wound displacement -.1 point

The Council agrees with public rating of this show (8.3),
We shall place this under Section One above average. 8.1/10

People seem to forgot that this is an old drama, this is why some opinion is like an onion.

EP 1-10: 8/10 +1 point
How can the impostor still there for half of the show?
Geesang want to be heard yet used riddles to communicate. Classic woman.
Things go down after EP11, and more after EP13, AND MORE after EP15.

EP 11-22: -1 point
Now another impostor showed up for half the show.
EP 15 Push & Pull, no comms script. -.5 point
2nd ML got played like a ball.
EP 21 rat 2nd ML finally realized how cooked his family is, not as cooked as him.

Due to absurd second half, we agreed with the public rating, and since its an old drama,
The Council shall place this under Section Two above average. 6.3/10

Well structured drama, but momentum is not that strong for a short series.

People that keep saying she has smooth sailing, we're clearly not watching the same drama.
Similar to Coroner's Diary

We agreed with the ratings,
The Council shall place this under Section Two above average. 7.5/10

Well executed slow burn drama but we won't look forward for S2.

ML lack of empathy and social skills is just a sub-genre in this drama.
EP 12 58:30 Why do Directors blur the drawings?
Since Chief Secretary could end the plot any time he wanted, that made the story weak.
He did showed subtle signs when he mentioned about selling cardboards won't even buy you a coffee these days, and more at the ending.
Similar to A Beautiful Mind

The Council shall place this under Section One at average. 8/10

Good opening, average ending.

If you want a grim ending, end it on the half of EP 23.
- We prefer this ending, with a rating of 7.5/10, S1 BA.

Momentum is like a ruler, you see an increasing number yet it's flat and straight.
The Council shall place this under Section Two above average. 7/10

Your average zombie movie, don't expect the same quality as Kingdom or Train to Busan.

How can ML use phone when there's no electricity. -.1 point
Happy ending slightly forced. -.1 point

We agree with the rating of this show,
Therefore The Council shall place this under Section One below average. 7.7/10

This franchise has potential, can do a time-skip in the future zombies like Train to Busan. Using the same zombie origin

If you're here for the concept it won't disappoint you, but directors cannot choose a side, leading to confusing script with forced happy ending. -.5 points

Some of the flashbacks seem unnecessary. FL can read Hangul -.2 points.
EP11: Directors start to blunder from now on.
Similar to The Story of Park's Marriage Contract.

Due to directors cannot commit to their script,
The Council shall place this under Section One at average. 7.8/10

Average opening & ending.

EP 01-02: Two episodes just to introduce the way to time travel.
EP 03-15: Content begins. 8/10
EP 16: back again, so everything is pointless with recycled flashback. Weak momentum afterwards.

This script is not our cup of tea, directors tried to follow Reset (2022) concept but failed horribly.
We shall place this under Section One below average. 7/10

Strong opening, with cheap below average ending.

Too many names to keep up.
The plot armour for 3rd FL is astronomically rare.
Splitting up at end episodes, classic horror movie cliché. 5/10
Similar to Behind Your Touch.

We cannot believe that someone actually gave this show a score of 10/10,
The Council shall place this under Section Two above average. 7/10

Great opening, with average ending. The conflicts seems a bit draggy.

EP 15 & 17: Directors are cooking hard.
EP 20 to 24: Stalemate
Forced happy ending, directors cannot stand tall with their script- disappointing.
Similar to My Fair Lady (2009)

The Council agrees with the review score for this drama, it could go higher if not for the flawed script.
We shall place this under Section One above average. 8.4/10

The Council find it funny that these chopped characters said FL is ugly, who let this director cook? Great opening with below average ending.

EP 01-19: 8/10
EP 20-22: 6/10
Similar to When the Phone Rings

Due to directors sleeping at end episodes,
We shall place this under Section Two above average. 7/10

Great opening and mid eps, with below average ending.

EP 01-10: Average momentum, 8/10
EP 11-12: ???? 7/10
The way chairman conflict ended is disappointing.
Forced conflict with FL in mid episodes, and forced happy ending.

Due to directors sleeping at end episodes,
The Council shall place this under Section One at average. 8/10