Details

  • Last Online: 1 day ago
  • Location:
  • Contribution Points: 6 LV1
  • Roles:
  • Join Date: May 15, 2020
Replying to JohnGilbert Dec 30, 2021
Title The Silent Sea Spoiler
Remember it's just a show. Sometimes you just have to go with things. That's what I do anyway.
The thing that you don't seem to understand is that if you cancel the Science part of a Science Fiction drama that takes place in space then you cancel a huge part of the story plot.
What would be f.e the reason for the crew to run to get into the space station if at the end of the day Moon had enough atmosphere in order to transmit the sound of their footsteps or the sound of their spacecraft while it is sliding on the cliff? lol

Same applies to almost everything else in this drama. Vac suites f.e are made heavy in order to allow you walk on no gravity conditions. Each and everyone of them weights 100 pounds. So you can't walk with them in full gravity conditions.

And for sure nobody can scream while s/he vomits. It isn't possible. LOL
0 2
Replying to strevisa Dec 30, 2021
My list of points (1-6) refers to science. I fully realize it was far from complete. Thanks for making it longer.…
I didn't say that you didn't point out some of the factual errors. I'm just pointing out that the whole drama is full of such huge factual errors that it ends up look more like just Fiction and not Science Fiction.

Some MDL members said on the comments that they don't mind if it is just Fiction. But if the writers of this drama cancel completely all kind of physics and scientific facts then the whole story plot has no point. What would be the reason f.e for the crew to run to get into the space station if at the end of the day Moon had enough atmosphere in order to transmit sound waves...! lol
0 2
strevisa Dec 29, 2021
Most of the things you've mentioned are the Fiction part of the otherwise Sci Fi drama.
The director and the writers messed up even in the Science part. We hear for instance the sound of the steps of the austronauts while they are walking on the vacuum of the Moon's surface.
Or we hear the noise that the spacecraft does while it is sliding from the cliff again in complete vacuum.
The whole crew wears the vac suits and walks and moves normally with these suits in full artificial gravity.
And of course none of these people get tired, or hungry, orthirsty etc. they have no normal human function in the whole duration of the 8 episodes. From the moment that they step on the Moon's surface ( with a crash landing) up to the final episode they don't seem to have any normal human needs. They look like they are the mutated super humans and not the girl.
0 4
Replying to JohnGilbert Dec 29, 2021
Title The Silent Sea Spoiler
Remember it's just a show. Sometimes you just have to go with things. That's what I do anyway.
Sci Fi films and drama ought to retain at least a bit of scientific realism. How people and things react in low gravity and the fact that there is no sound in vacuum is basic scientific knowledge and facts.
If the writers and the director ignore or don't mind to depict accurately these things then they shouldn't claim that their drama is a Sci Fi one but just a Fiction one.

In this drama the Science part should be the accurate depiction of a group of people walking on the Moon's surface and the Fiction part is the child with the extra terrestrial mutations that walks without vac suit on the surface of the moon.
4 4
On The Silent Sea Dec 28, 2021
Title The Silent Sea Spoiler
Episode 3. How the fuck is he able to scream while he is vomiting a tank of water??? LOOOOOL. How is this even possible?
P.S WTF am I watching.... ?
3 0
On The Silent Sea Dec 28, 2021
It seems also that Gong yoo is working hard for an international career. His accent in English is great.
1 5
On The Silent Sea Dec 28, 2021
Title The Silent Sea Spoiler
I'm on the second episode and I have already noticed four factual errors. First of all is Gong woo's hair that are immaculate in almost zero gravity just after the crash landing on Moon's surface. He doesn't wear a helmet but his hair are not flying either. as they should have in lower gravity.

Then on the same accident scene we see Dr Song's fall from her seat to the floor. She fall like a sack of potatoes, lol though Moon has the 1/10th of Earth's gravity. She should have fell way slower and not even hit the way she did the floor.

Then it is the sound the spacecraft while it is sliding the Moon's cliff. Lower gravity and no air equals to no sound and slower slide on the cliff no matter what is the weight of the spacecraft.

Same applies to the sound of the steps of the crew that is walking towards the space station. They might hear their breathing inside their suites but they shouldn't and we shouldn't hear their steps on the surface of the Moon because there is no air to transmit the sound and of course the gravity is way lower than that of earth. So even if their suits are heavy enough to prevent them from flying their steps shouldn't make any noise.

Don't start telling me that is fiction. It is science fiction and it shouldn't have such stupid mistakes.

Edit to add: Another factual error is the fact that they keep on wearing their vac suites inside the station in full artificial gravity. These suites are supposed to be made for zero or lower gravity and they are heavy as hell. So they shouldn't be able to walk with these suites on in full gravity like they are their casual clothing.
They should have take them off the moment they reactivated the life support and gravity functions of the moon station.
4 6
Replying to gatalito Dec 28, 2021
Talking about democracy but then petition to silence the opposite opinion is not democratic. The drama might offend…
There is no distinction between a far right regime that tries to silence all kind of opposition from a leftist regime that does the exact same thing.
For me at least, both these ideologies express the same kind of authoritarianism and they don't indicate any kind of Democracy.
2 0
Replying to Roxanne Dec 26, 2021
You may think all Korean people naturally cherish the history of democritization and pro-democracy movement but…
Talking about democracy but then petition to silence the opposite opinion is not democratic. The drama might offend ( and I say might because we don't know yet where the plot is going to go ) everyone that was harmed by that dictatorship but in a Democracy all voices have the right to be heard even if they offend us.
That is the difference between a Democratic regime and a Dictatorship.
6 0
Replying to humangarbage Dec 26, 2021
Some of the comments here are actually disgusting. This isn't a work of fiction. this is a story based on true…
Talking about democracy but then petition to silence the opposite opinion is not democratic. The drama might offend ( and I say might because we don't know yet where the plot is going to go ) everyone that was harmed by that dictatorship but in a Democracy all voices have the right to be heard even if they offend us.
That is the difference between a Democratic regime and a Dictatorship.
8 11
Replying to jooxm Dec 24, 2021
I'm confused. Is this supposed to be a big number or a small one? Because I've definitely seen dramas where the…
Quite a big number by the time that the series is called the Rebel Princess!
She should have saved someone or at least herself.! lol
Not to mention that she is not a Princess at all. She is the wife of a Prince but not a Princess herself . She is the niece of the Emperor's wife and the daughter of the Emperor's brother in law.
1 8
Replying to semnir Dec 23, 2021
I've only seen the Japanese remake and it's pretty good. I wanted to watch this one first but as I played the…
Hi I wasn't talking about torrents but about streaming platforms.
Torrent files are in higher resolutions of course, but the problem with them is that you have to have someone to seed the file for you. Most of the older movies' torrents are dead.
0 0
Replying to Its Liane Dec 19, 2021
Title Crime Puzzle
I’m trying to watch this, on episode 2. I think the plot is very interesting. But the writing for some reason…
I totally agree with your comment. I liked My Name too though it didn't have the most original plot. But it was well written. I find this one very boring. I have watched up to episode 3 and it doesn't get any better.
0 0
Replying to gatalito Dec 19, 2021
Title Crime Puzzle
After watching the third episode I wouldn't say that I find it particularly violent but rather boring. Keep in…
The writers will have to persuade me with a very intriguing plot to keep up watching it until I get to the more gore and bloody episodes. Thrillers are not the same thing with splatter and if the writers rely on such scenes to justify the boring plot then I will definitely drop it.
1 0
Replying to PonderinGal220 Dec 19, 2021
Title Crime Puzzle
After having waited for quite a while for this particular drama, I must say that I am very disappointed and for…
After watching the third episode I wouldn't say that I find it particularly violent but rather boring. Keep in mind though that I 'm big fan of thrillers and I have watched countless of them so my criteria are somewhat different from those of those who are not fans of the genre.
1 6
DreamingKoreanBallad Dec 16, 2021
He is one of the most underrated K-actors. I can't even think a good reason why they he haven't cast him in a lead role yet. The guy is stealing the show wherever he appears even by standing in the background without moving or saying a word! It is not his looks that make him have such an impact. It is all about screen presence.
I first noticed him in Last and then I checked some of his other roles just in case....His acting is from another planet whatever role he is given to play. Give him a damn male lead role fgs!
7 0
Replying to ryu Dec 15, 2021
he's 51? 😭😭
Why??? What's wrong with 51?
1 0
Replying to juavelin Dec 15, 2021
give this man more mafia roles please I'll watch them all
You've missed the point.
Give this man more shirts to rip off...
1 3
Replying to zitszack Dec 15, 2021
Always see him in dramas and movies but only notice how hot and how good he is in my name
Shame on you....lol
0 0