1
2
Waiting for Xiao Fan to grow his wings is like watching the second hand on a clock.Everyone around him seems to be changing—even his pathetic brother is finally showing signs of growth—yet Xiao Fan remains frustratingly passive, still allowing everyone around him to walk all over him. Ten episodes in, I keep asking myself: Will the change finally come, or are we going to fall off a cliff with only two episodes left?His character development has been painfully slow. Xiao Fan is almost like a sponge, absorbing lessons from everyone around him, but rarely acting on them himself. And this is where my struggle with the series lies.Watching Xiao Fan is beginning to feel like watching The Truman Show. He moves through his life almost oblivious to the world around him, unaware that the people closest to him are manipulating him, using him, and taking advantage of his innocence. Then, slowly, the walls begin to crack. The life he thought was real starts revealing itself as nothing more than a carefully constructed shell.And I ache for Xiao Fan to finally break out.I want to see him grow those wings, break the bondage Bei Lu Qin has placed on him, and finally free himself from the parasitic family that has fed off his weakness for far too long. Even Lu Qing’s former lover is taking advantage of him. It seems that everyone sees Xiao Fan as something they can use, while Xiao Fan still struggles to see his own worth.But perhaps that is ultimately what his journey is really about not simply escaping Bei Lu Qin or his family, but learning to love and value himself.With only two episodes left, I’m hoping we finally get that transformation. I want Xiao Fan to spread his wings, not because someone finally gives him permission to fly, but because he realizes that he was never meant to remain in bondage.Then again, there is another possibility.Perhaps Xiao Fan will finally fly only to discover that freedom comes with its own dangers.Let’s just hope he doesn’t become Icarus, flying too close to the sun only to come crashing back down.Two episodes left.Grow those wings, Xiao Fan. Please.
Was this review helpful to you?
A Winter Sun Wakes the Wind in Spring Hills' Dream Episode 11
1 people found this review helpful
Previously episodes we were gearing for a painful separating and yet the writers were able to find a way to stitch them together that was subtle, a little pin-prick of a pain…but the most beautiful part is how the episode ended…over three minutes of continuous shot video of the couple supposedly in a dream state longing for each other and using words spoken in the past instead of the horrible flashbacks used by most C-drama. Or was it a dream? And that’s how you make a memorable BL. Hands down. back to square one is the appropriate title…
Was this review helpful to you?
Don't Be Too Emotional Episode 1
1 people found this review helpful
If the first episode is this fascinating full of intrigue and mystery, I can only imagine the rest of the series and I hope the writer can sustain the suspense, it’s killing me in a good way.
Was this review helpful to you?
Agent Kim Reactivated Episode 3
1 people found this review helpful
Damn if this episode doesn’t get you to see what this show will become. Careful when you let the dog out it can bite hard and it did. And it’s just episode 3. Oh my…
Was this review helpful to you?
A Winter Sun Wakes the Wind in Spring Hills' Dream Episode 7
1 people found this review helpful
This pair deserves the award for the best BL kiss I’ve ever seen. It was so intense that I could almost feel the electricity filling the room. Absence truly does make the heart grow fonder, and the reunion carried all the longing that had been quietly building.What stood out even more, however, was the recurring metaphor of coffee and tea. Coffee on one hand, tea on the other—two contrasting drinks reflecting two contrasting souls. One is bold, intense, and invigorating; the other gentle, calming, and contemplative. This subtle but elegant comparison of their opposing personalities feels like the emotional center of the series, reminding us that love often flourishes not despite our differences, but because of them.
Was this review helpful to you?
Three episodes in, and I think I’ve figured out what’s bothering me: the show keeps telling me there’s romance, but I’m not feeling it.Having the female officer openly shipping James and Ken and gossiping about them with coworkers felt more like high school behavior than something happening inside a police unit. At least they finally break that ridiculous red tape dividing their tiny office. And apparently a very drunk James can now casually bear-hug Ken in front of everyone without anyone batting an eye.The editing remains choppy, with scenes jumping from one moment to another without enough connective tissue. The lantern lit bridge scene is a perfect example. James is supposedly very drunk, yet suddenly he can carry on a perfectly coherent conversation with Ken. Cue the romantic music, beautiful red lanterns…and somehow I felt absolutely nothing romantic.Maybe that’s my real struggle with this relationship. James comes across as overbearing and overly eager to get close to Ken, while Ken seems far more interested in blood and finding a way to finally die. James keeps pushing his mouth to Ken even in the seemingly empty police station until he gets his hug and his kiss. Where exactly is the chemistry between these two? I’m looking for it, but so far the romance feels strangely one-sided.Ironically, I’m getting more chemistry from Dr. Ji and Chita. Even their fever-reducing scene had more tenderness and sensuality than the carefully staged “romantic” bridge scene between our leads.Three episodes in, NOUR still has not context but the show has all the ingredients for romance: the lanterns, the music, the lingering looks but chemistry isn’t something you can create with an English-lyric OST. I was hoping for a more romantic Thai OST instead.
Was this review helpful to you?
A Winter Sun Wakes the Wind in Spring Hills' Dream Episode 16
1 people found this review helpful
The final episode, appropriately titled “Beholding,” may be the most beautiful expression of Changyang’s love. His joie de vivre, passion and emotional intensity make us wish that everyone could experience a partner who looks at them the way he does. For Changyang, there is only one person in his eyes. Gender becomes irrelevant. What he sees is the person, the soul he has chosen to behold.And perhaps that is exactly what Zelia is trying to say.The series feels like a commentary on China’s risk-averse attitude toward same-sex relationships. “The social divide between us” does not weaken their love; it seems to intensify it. If absence makes the heart grow fonder, then societal pressure makes their bond stronger. The more the world tells them what they cannot be, the more determined they become to simply be.I was particularly intrigued by Zelia’s use of Venezuela’s brutal Hunter School as the antithesis to the social constraints surrounding homosexuality in China. Was this simply part of the story, or was Zelia deliberately creating a symbol of rebellion against rigid systems of control? The Hunter School represents one extreme of a society that attempts to reshape people through force. China’s social environment represents another kind of pressure, less physical, perhaps, but capable of controlling lives through conformity, shame and public judgment.Then Zelia finally makes her own Hitchcockian cameo, appearing as Director Li. I translated the text message she sent and reads as follows:“Mulan disguised herself as a man to join the army in place of her father. When a woman dresses as a man, it's called "leiwu satao" (a type of martial arts performance); when a man dresses as a woman, it's labeled "effeminate culture." Is this a case of cultural hatred towards women, or a societal lack of confidence in its own culture? Ultimately, it's only when humanity entered a patriarchal society that we fell into a social acceptance of male worship.What does it matter if you're male or female? We're all just a shell containing a soul. Some retain their spirit, some lose their soul; some are clear-headed and blind, some can't distinguish right from wrong. When will humanity be able to let go of gender?”And what she says after their film is criticized for being gay-centric may be the most direct statement of the series’ philosophy. Mulan can disguise herself as a man and be celebrated as a heroic cultural icon, yet when a man displays femininity, society is quick to condemn him. Zelia asks whether this is cultural hatred toward women or simply a society insecure about its own definitions of masculinity.Her conclusion is even more provocative.What does it matter whether we are male or female? We are all merely shells containing a soul. Some retain their spirit. Some lose it. Some remain clear-headed while others become blinded by convention. Some can distinguish right from wrong, while others simply follow what society tells them. And ultimately, she asks: When will humanity finally be able to let go of gender?That, to me, is the real theme of this series. Love does not see gender first. Society does.Zelia’s reference to Chinese netizens as moths dying in a flame could not have been more pointed. The frightening power of strangers to elevate, destroy or even ruin someone’s life through online judgment is a sobering commentary on modern society. Reputation becomes public property, and people who have never met you can decide who you are.Shi Yu Hao’s redemption caught me completely off guard. But beneath that redemption, I also sensed something darker, the price people sometimes pay when they become trapped by the expectations of others. In a country where the entertainment industry has seen a disturbing number of young actors do not live beyond 45, the storyline carries an uncomfortable resonance about the cost of losing one’s way, one’s identity and ultimately one’s will to live.Very few series know how to end on a high note. A Winter’s Sun Wakes the Wind in Spring Hill does.It ends with a rising sun.Not a declaration that everything has changed. Not a fantasy that society has suddenly become accepting. But a suggestion that change is possible. That love can survive the systems designed to contain it. That perhaps one day, China may look at same-sex love not as something that needs to be hidden, explained or condemned, but simply as love.And that is why the final image stays with me. It reminds me of that lone man standing in front of the tanks in Tiananmen Square. One person standing against something vastly more powerful. He did not stop the tanks. But he made the world stop and look.Perhaps that is what Changyang does. He simply stands there, loving the person he loves.And asks us to behold.
Was this review helpful to you?
This episode stopped feeling like a BL drama and began feeling like I was reliving my own high school years. My best friend was the school president…the confident one who protected the nerdy me from bullies and taught me how to smoke, drink, and cut classes. He was so protective that whenever he wasn’t around, my world felt empty. Then, during summer vacation before our senior year, that friendship crossed an invisible line and we became lovers. Watching Eun ho and Do-l hyeon brought back the intensity, confusion, and tenderness of that summer.Perhaps that is why Do hyeon’s refusal to put a name to his feelings affected me so deeply. Eun ho is not merely the boy he loves. He is his best friend, his family, his refuge, and the person around whom his entire world has been built. How do you label someone who has already become everything? The quiet classroom moments…Eun ho sleeping on his shoulder, hands finding each other, and a gentle kiss on the head…that really felt even more intimate than a confession. Yi hyeon is also doing exactly what a third wheel should do, forcing Do hyeon’s hidden jealousy and possessiveness into the open. He is not creating feelings that weren’t there…he is exposing feelings that have been buried for years. Even Eun ho’s resistance feels less like rejection and more like fear. He knows that once they cross that boundary, they may never be able to return to the safety of being friends The scene with the fingers was more provocative than an actual NC scene. The love was always there, the question is how does it show itself beyond the constraints of friendship. The drama that ensues when the line is crossed…
Was this review helpful to you?
I Feel You Linger in the Air: Uncut Version Episode 1
0 people found this review helpful
The trope of time travel is nothing new, but creating a convincing love story across time can be a writer’s nightmare. For me, the bar was set by Christopher Reeve and Jane Seymour’s Somewhere in Time…a tragic yet beautiful romance carried by an unforgettable soundtrack and the mystery of an old photograph.I Feel You Linger in the Air enters through a similar doorway: an old house, an old photograph, and an inexplicable feeling connecting the present to the past. What first draws me to a great script is its premise…the “what if” that persuades my pragmatic mind to suspend disbelief. Then come the editing, production, and the director’s ability to draw genuine emotions from the actors. From its opening episode, this series already understands that atmosphere is not merely decoration…it is part of the story.Time-travel romances rarely promise happy endings. Love may transcend time, but two people from different eras are like oil and water…destined to touch, yet unable to remain together. That is what makes writing such a story so difficult. But in the hands of a gifted writer, impossibility becomes beautiful, and pain becomes proof that the love existed at all. Time may carry the person away…but somehow, you still feel them lingering in the air.Thanks to the discussions of @Lynnea and @NLE, I was introduced to this series.
Was this review helpful to you?
As the series end nears, here’s my thoughts of episode 11. The “summer” is not merely a season…it is an emotional time capsule, preserving Chiharu and Wataru as the boys they once were. Their separation allowed that memory to grow into something almost sacred, but absence can make us long for the idea of someone rather than the person they have become. Wataru must now decide whether he truly loves Chiharu in the present or is still chasing the boy who disappeared, while Chiharu remains trapped by guilt and afraid that he no longer deserves that love.The fork in the road represents more than choosing whether to stay together…it is the choice between continuing to live inside that remembered summer or finally stepping into the present. The keychain suggests that love, like anything entrusted to us, can be cherished, misplaced, or lost. And Wataru’s fall makes emotional pain physical…perhaps reminding us that sometimes we must allow ourselves to hurt before we can stand again and move forward.This is a story about love, but not necessarily a traditional love story. It asks a more difficult question…when we finally meet the person we have carried in our hearts for years, can we love who they are now, or were we only in love with the memory of who they once were? The finale may lead them apart or bring them together, but either ending can work if they finally choose with honesty rather than longing or guilt.
Was this review helpful to you?
After falling off the fence in Episode 2 and remaining somewhere on the ground through Episode 3, I think NOUR may finally be handing me a ladder…although I’m not quite ready to climb all the way back up. I can certainly relate to James itching to get closer to Ken and finally have something resembling romance. But apparently Ken’s idea of a romantic date is a cup of coffee over a cadaver during a forensic examination. Really? It immediately brought me back to my anatomy classes in pre-med school. Surrounded by cadavers and that unmistakable smell of formaldehyde, I can assure you…romance was the last thing on my mind.But perhaps there is something revealing about Ken in that moment. Here is a man who has lived for more than 200 years, has spent much of that existence wanting to die, and seems far more comfortable around death than intimacy. James, meanwhile, is almost the opposite. He is impatient, physical and increasingly determined to break through Ken’s walls. For the first time, I’m beginning to understand what the writers may be trying to do with these two polar opposites.Unfortunately, understanding it and feeling it are still two different things.Meanwhile, Jin and Chita continue quietly becoming the relationship I find more interesting. Their intimacy feels less manufactured and more organic, but there is something underneath all that tenderness that makes me uneasy. Perhaps I’m reading too much into it, but I sense darkness looming…and I have a feeling their relationship may eventually carry much of the emotional weight of this story.Then we arrive at that final scene.James pushes himself onto Ken almost as if he needs to prove the intensity of his desire. Ken initially resists, then notices the blood on James’ lips…and suddenly everything changes. Desire? Hunger? Instinct? Perhaps all three. Conceptually, I understand what the writers are trying to suggest. But once again, the execution left me scratching my head though I feel James knows at this point when he backed off. In broad daylight? At the bend of a road? Beside a temple? Really?This has been my recurring problem with NOUR. The series has interesting ideas, but sometimes seems so determined to create a moment that it forgets to ask whether the circumstances surrounding that moment make sense. Chemistry cannot simply be created by romantic music, beautiful scenery or physical intimacy. The audience needs to understand why these two people are being drawn toward each other.Still, Episode 4 gave me something the previous two episodes struggled to provide…movement. Ken’s emotional walls are beginning to crack, James’ attraction is becoming more consequential, and Jin and Chita are quietly pulling me deeper into their story.So yes, NOUR…you finally brought me a ladder.Unfortunately, after that scene beside the temple, I checked the ladder first to make sure all the steps were there
Was this review helpful to you?
After Episode 9, I’m really struggling with Mr. Kill. I wanted to like this series because the premise had so much potential…an artist whose drawings eerily mirror the work of a serial killer should have made for a dark, intelligent psychological thriller. Instead, the writing keeps asking me to suspend not only disbelief, but sometimes common sense.The acting isn’t helping either. Dew, whom I know can act, isn’t convincing me as this constantly vulnerable and almost helpless character. Tee, as the tired and increasingly frustrated police officer, and Off, as the manipulative newscaster, should bring tension and intensity to the story…but neither performance makes me fully believe the character. Dew fares better, but overall the performances often feel like actors playing their roles rather than people actually living them. Even the supporting characters feel fragmented…much like the storyline itself.Nine episodes in, the mystery should be tightening its grip on me. Instead, I find myself questioning the writing more than questioning who the killer is. A thriller can mislead me, surprise me and even make me believe the unbelievable…but it first has to create a world believable enough for me to get lost in it.GMMTV…please do better. You had a killer premise here. I’m still waiting for the series to actually kill it.
Was this review helpful to you?
Hold on, Harutora-kun Episode 3
0 people found this review helpful
As Sui gradually peels away the protective layers he built after the trauma of being outed, Haruto gently teaches him that it is safe to open his heart again. It was in these poignant and tender moments…as we slowly began to see Sui change…that the series also changed for me. The sweetness felt sincere, while the awkward “going commando” scene was absolutely hilarious. Episode 3 found the perfect balance between healing, romance, and humor…and suddenly, I am much more emotionally invested.
Was this review helpful to you?
For once, a BL that feels intellectually written. A nerd whose gravitational pull is strong enough to attract another star…it reminds me of The Big Bang Theory. Two polar opposites gradually drawn into the same orbit. Yes, it’s slow…as slow as Earth’s journey around the Sun. But as Cheewa says, it is gravity that keeps Earth close to it. Smart, quirky, and unexpectedly tender…this is every geek’s BL dream.
Was this review helpful to you?
Finally…a few embers that might actually ignite some fireworks after six episodes. At least they still have another six episodes to build the romance, deepen the drama, and strengthen their chemistry…oh, wait…what? There are only ten episodes?Oh, GMMTV…you’re trying to imitate the tighter Japanese format, but your scriptwriting formula and choppy editing remain the same. Beyond a collection of cute, easily marketable moments, when do you plan to develop these characters and give us a romance worth investing in…instead of merely preparing the next fan-meeting ship? Domundi does a much better job developing its characters, especially in romantic BLs. And what exactly is going on with hormonal Sun? He behaves as though he’s experiencing his monthly…you know what.
Was this review helpful to you?
