Details

  • Last Online: 4 hours ago
  • Location:
  • Contribution Points: 6 LV1
  • Roles:
  • Join Date: December 17, 2020
Shiro Feb 22, 2025
Review Study Group
I thought about giving this a 7.5 but I went with 8 in the end because I loved it up to episode 6 but it definitely got draggy and repetitive after that and also too preachy. I'd still recommend this to people because it was really fun at the start and the less good second half wasn't enough to sink it for me.
1 1
On When the Stars Gossip Feb 22, 2025
Title When the Stars Gossip Spoiler
I knew Eve was getting pregnant from ep 1 (her name! the apple in the post credits sequence!) but they dragged it out until ep 15 with the most threadbare and ridiculous plot. Also! IRL female astronauts have to take pregnancy tests before going into space so more bad science
21 3
Replying to SUNSET Feb 22, 2025
Is this the biggest flop in kdrama history?
I'm pretty sure it's lost more money than any other drama. Most expensive drama ever and low ratings mean no chances to claw back the budget.
11 0
Replying to emmagucci Feb 21, 2025
I really like all the cast's acting (especially Hyo Jin, Jung Se, Lee El, Kim Joo Heon, Jung Suk and Park Jin…
LMH is the center of the drama. His acting is fine, it's the writing that's garbage
5 2
Replying to BWMDL Feb 21, 2025
What's going on? BAD writing and directing. The acting is good, but the actors can't save a bad show. I would…
The sfx are good too. This is a great example of how important writing is to a drama. Bad writing will sink absolutely everything else.
5 0
Replying to sera Feb 21, 2025
If y'all had to describe this drama in one word, how would y'all do it ?
* Incoherent
* Propaganda
22 0
Replying to BWMDL Feb 21, 2025
Hahahah. Do you mean you'll miss it as in "I'm not going to watch it?" Or do you mean you'll miss it AFTER watching…
I'm enjoying the conversations, I dropped after episode 5 but the articles and online chatter have been fascinating. I think I'm also invested because I was so offended by the pro-natalist messaging that I'm enjoying seeing this go down in flames
7 0
Replying to moon Feb 19, 2025
I can't believe this was more expensive than Queen of Tears, TVN needs to recheck its investments.
The one thing that works for me in this drama are the space scenes, you can see the money and it was well spent
9 0
Replying to Holly Feb 19, 2025
I was thinking that even if the kdrama is a flop, the actors have nothing to lose. They're so well known, especially…
Unfortunately, they do have a problem because a lot of their value comes from the viewers they attract to a project. If LMH and GHJ's star power wasn't enough to bring people to this project, it means fewer projects for them to choose from and lower salaries for their next projects. There's also a lot of fear that LMH's upcoming film adaptation of the Omniscient Reader's Viewpoint manhwa is going to be another flop given the poor reaction to the trailer - fewer than 679K views on the official YouTube channel after four days: https://youtu.be/YRIW33DftIM?si=YdRJNiyf3YCQsKWM
15 2
On When the Stars Gossip Feb 18, 2025
One of the wildest things about this drama is pretty much every character is morally bankrupt with no redemption arc. The entire space crew, *including the FL*, stood there and watched Kang Su take the fall for the morulas when they were all guilty of the same thing. Ryong also said nothing. The only character who maybe kinda sorta has a redemption arc is Kang Su because he didn't rat out anyone else when he went down and he sincerely loves and respects Go Eun. It's stunning how there's no one to root for.
20 4
Replying to BWMDL Feb 18, 2025
I just discovered "Toni Watches" and she's recapping WTSG and it's hilarious. More fun than the actual show. I…
She's one of my moots on Bluesky! But she ended up dropping because she couldn't take it anymore 🥲
4 1
Replying to MiHnn Feb 17, 2025
I know it's early, but this drama feels like the biggest disappointment of 2025.
Not just 2025, this drama is so bad that it has dragged down the entire industry with it. It's literally going to change what we see in the next few years. Production companies are going to make more mid-budget romances with actors who aren't big names and they're going to have fewer episodes. Whatever they can do to keep down costs.
13 2
Replying to Getitdone Feb 16, 2025
It must be some kind of record right? When did TVN last has something of big flop?
Melting Me Softly had similar ratings but wasn't as expensive as WTSG
3 0
Replying to BWMDL Feb 16, 2025
1. Is Gong wearing CROCKS? Well, that's a fashion crime deserving 2 years in prison.2. What took him so long?…
Gong Ryong totally deserves whatever he gets.

After all the pro-natalist messaging it would be bizarre if no one was pregnant or successful at birthing by the end of the show. Not the mice, not the SIL, not Eve. Seriously so weird.
17 1
Replying to Juggler Feb 16, 2025
Title When the Stars Gossip Spoiler
Why happened?
💯💯💯 agree with you. The pro-natalist agenda is as subtle as a brick to the forehead. I say pro-natalist because these people are only "pro-life" when it comes to morulas, they aren't pro-women's lives.
2 1
Replying to Juggler Feb 16, 2025
Title When the Stars Gossip Spoiler
Why happened?
In Ep. 13 tere is a weird conversation that Eve's bio mom has with Eve, when she goes to see if Eve was abandoned in a taxi (because we know the mom abandoned her baby in a taxi on Christmas Eve), and Eve tells her no, but then does a DNA test (using the mug mom was drinking from when they talked). But the weird bit is the mom saying something like she was resentful she got pregnant, she never felt like the baby's mom, she worked in a bar and her life was being ruined by her breast's leaking. Why would the writer make the bio mom say such terrible things?
4 3
Replying to HJHofT17 Feb 16, 2025
They haven't sent it/taken it to the gov office so it's not registered yet. That's why he told her for her to…
ah thanks for the clarification!
1 0
Replying to BWMDL Feb 16, 2025
Title When the Stars Gossip Spoiler
1. WTF Mom? That's not the way you announce yourself to your abandoned child. Way to make the child feel like…
Kang Su's being treated like the villain. Meanwhile he didn't narc on any of those hypocrites when he could've taken them all down with him. Plus they had the nerve to be in the room when he was punished which was super weird, who lets coworkers into the room when someone is fired? But Oh Jung Se rises, always
6 1
Replying to kdramaddixxion Feb 16, 2025
Title When the Stars Gossip Spoiler
They're not related at all. Her mom raised him along with the other two ladies when his mom died at childbirth.
It's still super weird tho. What's going on in the writer's head? They don't need to be that close even if blood isn't involved
4 1