Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Kaseifu no mita is a really cool family drama. I really don’t like family dramas a whole lot but this one was pretty good. A creepy, robotic, Nanny McFee character is the housekeeper who of course teaches the family valuable lessons, and unifies the family all while learning one herself. The main reason I don’t like most family dramas is because they are really unrealistic. However this one really touches on a dark side of life. Not all smiles and happy times, this drama delves into teenage sex, infidelity, suicide, longing, angst, anger and tragedy. Looking at how a family fell apart and was unconsciously mended back together through individual choices made me want to see each episode. I wanted to know whose turn was it to get “fixed”, and how/where was it gonna happen.
Nanako Matsushima was awesome!! She was not only totally believable but she was the character, and it was played to perfection. Other outstanding actors were Shiori Kutsuna who really did bring out the troubled teenager she was playing.
What I didn’t like was the ridiculous concept that the housekeeper never getting into trouble doing what she did. If they were going to be realistic and dark they should have gone all the way. I found the youngest kid annoying (I think that’s what they were aiming for) and a lot of her parts I fast forwarded through. I really wanted one of the kids to become a yankee but ***** no spoilers here****. The grumpy grandfather never became loveable to me and for some reason I found the longing of the aunt (urara played by Aibu saki) annoying and unnecessary. Each time the kids asked Mita (housekeeper) what to do, she answered the exact same thing, that drove me crazy because they kept looking like she would say something different.
The story was great but I felt like the revelations at the end were rushed and unnatural, almost as if the writers didn’t realize it was time for the drama to end. I would have liked the drama to focus a bit more on the housekeeper throughout and not just at the last 15 minutes. Dot get me wrong the ending was still nice and sweet , but it could have been better. The story itself seemed as if midway they needed new material. Like they ran out of problems within the family to tackle so they moved to the unnecessary neighbors. Still it looked like they have this one primed for a second season and I would watch that one too. However in the next family maybe they could make the family less annoying, because in some episodes 4 whiny, selfish, nosy brats and a spinelessa, cry-baby father were too much to take. Although it doesn't suck you in, and make you a part of the family, this one is an interesting watch.
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
The thing I like best is the acting & music & the storyline.It shows that sometime life could be harsh but you could find happiness back.Even the tempo of drama is slow in first but it gets better once you start watching it & it took less than two days to complete this drama.
The thing I don't like is that you get curious to know whats next & you get addicted, just kiddin'. It is freakishly good drama.
It's a must watch.
P.S: Sometime I was like,"Gosh!!I freakishly want that housekeeper!!"
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
The difference between them that i understand now after reading some reviews is that the Korean virsion is more Digestible and the western viewers can relate to while if you into Japanese dramas and Japanese culture you can relate to this maybe more then the K virsion.
What i feel about the Japanese tv is "Still waters run deep" , it's slow and revealing piece by piece with some kind of deep emotions that hard to understand , and maybe the view on the woman is different
The korean version is more memorable as times go by now after a couple of years i can see the empact on me.
worth a watching
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
It may be the difference of culture, but I found this drama just a bizarre and strange show, which tries to justify the problems of a dysfunctional family.If it was just explaining why each was like that, that's fine. But the way the family treats Mita ... didn't give it to me. I was going to leave, but I jumped for the last episode just to know how it would end.
It was one of the worst dramas I've ever seen.
The performances were medium, but the plot, which could be well developed, was run in a freak way.
SPOILER
The scene in which the boy punches her several times, and then, after a round of each one bursts out her sorrows, and the night ending as a happy family ... Where NOBODY apologized to her, and continued to treat She as a servant while she still had her mouth bleeding from the teenager's punches ... was the worst part of the drama. That made me jump to the end.
END OF SPOILER.
Would re-watch: Oh Hell NOOO!
Was this review helpful to you?
