1) The reason I watched this: I watched all versions of Hana Kimi, thus I wanted to discover the Korean incarnation. 2) Storyline/Plot: *I already knew the general story which means that I didn’t try to discover it (predictable). I will basically compare storylines and plot changes. Positive Points: *Unlike other versions, this one focused on the romantic side; there were too many fluffy moments that would make the drama more enjoyable. Moreover, this Korean adaptation gave the romantic elements its right to be intensively present. *This version had the best visual cinematography; yes I had to admit that since other versions didn’t focus on this aspect. I am glad that this one took it into consideration and actually pulled it off in a good way. Negative Points: *The huge negative point that I found in this version was the absence of friendship and relationships inside dorms, it was the main element in other versions that’s why I felt betrayal when I didn’t find it here. Yes, the version should stand out but cutting such an important element made the drama lose its taste. *Another important negative point: The lack of humor; It was an important element too, maybe it wasn’t present in all other versions but here, it felt absent or maybe “left behind”. That was annoying; the lack of funny scenes was simply bothersome because it created many boring moments. *I hated the fact that script writers wanted to cover up for everything by showing the cute romance the whole time, it felt like cheating the audience and creating fan-service scenes by using Choi Min Ho’s body and Lee Hyun Woo’s face. *Dragging: The drama fell into dragging especially near the end; that wasn’t nice to watch. Story: 4/10. 2) Acting/Cast: *This drama’s cast is mostly singers so you can’t expect to have strong acted scenes plus the storyline didn’t allow actors to show their skills since it focused on the cute side. However, that doesn’t deny that Choi Min Ho, Sully and Lee Hyun Woo did a respectable job in this. *As for characters, Tae Joon’s Sano was a decent portrayal out of all versions I’ve seen. Goo Jae Hee was average: no love, no hate. Eun Gyeol character was the worst Nakatsu portrayal mostly because it lacked humor and took the triangle side way too seriously, yes, there were some cute imagination moments but they didn’t last for long. That being said, I have to refer that Hyun Woo was the best actor in this drama, it wasn’t his fault that the storyline made his character more serious than it’s supposed to be. *Side characters were uninteresting most of the time which was the storyline’s fault for cutting and changing many important characters. *Appreciated character: Min Hyun Jae because he had a different character from what I remember plus his presence was always good to watch. *Relationships: --->Romance: On terms of chemistry, I can’t say that it was the greatest ever but there were many cute and fluffy moments all over the place. --->Friendship: None! I haven’t felt any friendship between characters except some moments with Eun Gyeol and his roommate. Other than that, it was annoyingly absent. --->The triangle: It was taken way too seriously than other versions so it felt bothersome to watch. Cast: 6/10. Acting: 7/10. 4) The ending: Finally! I kept waiting for the drama to end ever since the 10th episode. It was a normal ending, no special feelings. The ending: 6/10. 5) My impression (How did it affect me): *I was really excited at the beginning but after three or four episodes, I just lost interest somehow. *This was a disappointing remake for me, I expected a lot from the K-version but I end up watching something pretty and shallow. *Is this drama memorable: No, I can’t possibly remember this drama because it dragged a lot which made it pretty boring but I may remember the vivid colors and the cuteness overload. My impression: 3/10. 6) Overall: *If you’re looking for a cute school drama then you may like this. *If you watched other Hana Kimi versions and want to see more romance then you would like this. *If you want something pretty to look at then watch this. *To the Beautiful You was a cute drama that dragged a lot and delivered nothing when it comes to friendship and school relationships. As a remake it was a disappointment. Overall: 5/10.
Was this review helpful to you?