liliyang123

“However, we would honestly love to lose our memory just to rewatch this show.” Lmaoo sneaky!

Deciding to binge watch this was a mistake. I've been crying non-stop for 9 episodes yet I'm not planning to stop.

Everything was so well done in this show. I loved the leads. I cherished how they took one step at a time together towards healing old wounds. I enjoyed how realistic Moon Soo's relationship with her parents were. Overall, It was a joy watching this!

I wrote this when I was shocked by things that were happening in episode 4 and I didn’t really take all the things you mentioned into account.Now I’ve watched up to episode 7 and though I don’t think I’ll go any further, I understand the sentimentality of it now(being from a different era and people having watched it with a different mindset and enjoyed it)
Oska is definitely my favorite character btw(:

Of course it’s just my personal opinion.

Yeah I guess the same goes to similar kdramas when everything seems to be stretched out and multiplied too much to the point that nothing is really happening

Why do people love this series so much? I've only watched 4 episodes so far and I'm very annoyed and disgusted by the ml's behavior and how the fl just takes it. I mean I get that it's a bit older and it's a rich guy+ poor girl kind of romance but come on, how am I supposed to root for them?

I really enjoyed this show. The lead actors were amazing and the story was intriguing. That's not to say this drama was perfect; There were many plot holes left and things that had to be avoided to keep the story going forward .The writing got kind of messy in the last couple of episodes-especially the final one-(which even though was weird and out of place, kind of worked because of Moon Chae won and Lee Joon gi's wonderful acting!)
Overall it's a fun and at times emotional ride besides all it's flaws.

On a random note, the casting for their younger versions was so impressive. I mean they actually look like their older selves. ( lmao I know it's not a big deal but it really caught my eye)

Exactly my thoughts. I mean it was a really good series but the unnecessary memory loss in the last episode and how the ML kept making dangerous decisions even though his wife trusted him and would've helped him if he didn't hide everything from her in the last couple of episodes was really annoying. I still enjoyed the series and would watch similar dramas but I think 16 episodes was too long for the story and that's why similar things happened over and over.

I miss watching this gem. Such a beautiful show.

Such a wonderful series. Only critique would be that it was a bit too short and episodes felt a bit cramped together. Still, such an emotional ride!

It was just too long. I watched this 3 months ago and I can't for the life of me remember anything happening other than scenes which included Grim reaper and kim shin's sister. The main couple was too boring and had little to no chemistry. I'm usually okay with age difference but when the ML starts to become a father figure for the FL it really ruins it for me personally.

I've only been watching so many kdramas this couple of months and LOST is definitely one of my favorites. It felt so real and the dialogues were top notch. I wanted to give a hug to everyone because it really seemed that everyone was lonely and grieving over a dream they've given up on a long time ago. Like many others I started watching only because of Ryu Jun-yeol but everyone in this drama shared my heart by the end. I keep coming back because of the lost souls and how well they were portrayed!

I feel like this drama would've worked better as a short series or a movie. It started with a great plot and a lot of suspicion of where the story could go but not even halfway through the show, they eliminated almost all the obstacles and started changing rules to explain why the story needed to go on the way it was . It was still enjoyable and it showed some beautiful art and somewhat accurate artistic characters but it was definitely wasted potential.

It was a very sweet drama with likable characters and a cute couple. The problem in this drama was that after episode 1, everything started to get generic. I really liked the first ep because of how different and refreshing the characters seemed and the pacing but then everything went on to become a little too familiar. Overall it was a very fun time but the backstory of the ML and them meeting as children was a little boring and not needed in my opinion.

I didn't finish the drama because I couldn't take how the FL just got over the fact that he lied to her all those times ;maybe the problem was resolved in later episodes but I couldn't keep on because I was also a bit bored.

I don't know why but everytime I try to watch a LMH drama I just get so angry. His characters are so selfish and annoying(I don't remember faith since I was a kid when I watched it) . Also the FL in this one wasn't very likable. I mean she was played well and I understand that most flaws of the character were due to low self-esteem but she just came across as a real pushover.

I simply couldn't stand this drama. Even if I got used to the laws of the world they live in(like teachers/grown ups are never around when crazy things are happening) I just couldn't care about any of the characters. Everyone acted so childish that I don't even think children would act so stupid. Every single character was toxic for the people around them(except maybe jan-di's friend and yi-jeong) specially the FL's parents(they drove me insane!!) and she was made out of hard rock since she would suck everything up so easily. I'm usually okay with cheesy and stupid dramas when they are a fun time but this was so hard to watch due to the immense amount of bullying/sexual assaults happening every few minutes. I can see myself watching this when I was 11 and not really being too alarmed by it and even like it since so much happens so fast, so I get why the drama is so loved. But I wouldn't recommend it to anyone.

I simply couldn't stand this drama. Even if I got used to the laws of the world they live in(like teachers/grown ups are never around when crazy things are happening) I just couldn't care about any of the characters. Everyone acted so childish that I don't even think children would act so stupid. Every single character was toxic for the people around them(except maybe jan-di's friend and yi-jeong) specially Fl parents(they drove me insane) and she was made out of hard rock since she would suck everything up so easily. I'm usually okay with cheesy and stupid dramas when they are a fun time but this was so hard to watch due to the immense amount of bullying/sexual assaults happening every few minutes. I can see myself watching this when I was 11 and not really being too alarmed by it and even like it since so much happens so fast, so I get why the drama is so loved. But I wouldn't recommend it to anyone.