Completed
blackstar_aria
25 people found this review helpful
Nov 4, 2011
20 of 13 episodes seen
Completed 1
Overall 5.0
Story 4.0
Acting/Cast 5.0
Music 8.0
Rewatch Value 5.0
Trust me there is a better drama that you could be watching.In chatting with some other drama fans they told me to not watch Hayate, but I couldn't listen to them. I said to myself "the anime was cool so let's try the live action!". I thought the first 2 episodes were good, so I just had to see the rest for myself. What an epic waste of my time and production money!

First what I did like; they used pretty handsome people in the cast, there were also some really cool special effects incorporated in the story. However, I hated that they had Park shin Hye with a voice over, I could never get used to it! I don't know if she was lost in translation because her acting was awful here. I kept thinking Maria should have been the female lead.

I don't know if the episodes were just long or boring. I found myself skipping episodes, and just watching the very beginning and the very end.

I didn't read the manga so maybe the story line in the drama is closest to the original, but I liked the anime way better. I think the drama had trouble staying true to the story that it was based on while trying to update it so it would be realistic and a hit. Maybe some things should never go live action.

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
wonjana
13 people found this review helpful
Feb 4, 2012
20 of 13 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 8.0
Story 7.0
Acting/Cast 8.0
Music 10
Rewatch Value 7.0
I actually watched this because of Park Shin Hye and also because it's from an anime manga/show. This was so epic, a little bit of unbelievable and it was funny. I loved the funny scenes and yeah, the story itself was fine. A bit confusing, and surprising scenes like about the royal jade and Xiao Zhi's grandfather. I love the music, I dont know why, I just love it. The acting was fine, but I've got to say PSH wasn't that good here. I hate the dubbing of her voice, it could have been better if she really spoke taiwan without dubbing. She doesn't even look like Nagi from the original anime. But besides that, I still think this drama is good. The story, the thrills, the epic(ness). The only downfall is the looks of the cast and the dubbing.

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
Kala
2 people found this review helpful
Nov 6, 2016
20 of 13 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 10
Story 9.0
Acting/Cast 10
Music 10
Rewatch Value 8.5
DO NOT LISTEN TO THE BAD REVIEWS HATING ON THE LIP SYNCHING. It's not that bad, I actually think Park Shin Hye did a great job acting as the female lead. I was so hesitant on watching this drama because of the negative reviews but i'm so glad that I gave it a try... I wish I would have sooner. I laughed and cried so much. I've watched over 40 dramas and this is one of my new favorites. (: Please watch at least 3 episodes. Also all of the actors and actresses did an amazing job. I wanted to watch this drama so bad because it had my two favorite female actresses in the. My Korean one and my Taiwanese one! Tia Li and Shin Hye! ((: I CANT EXPRESS MY LOVE FOR THIS ENOUGH. I will definitely rewatch this drama i the future! DM me on insta if you have any questions! @annyeongkala

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
Shiqi58
0 people found this review helpful
Oct 20, 2021
13 of 13 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 7.5
Story 8.0
Acting/Cast 5.0
Music 8.0
Rewatch Value 5.0

Its okay

The story itself is very interesting, however the script could use some improvements. There is an awful amount of a character talking to themselves out loud, and other then Park Shin Hye, and George Hu, the acting for this drama is okay, not as good as some of the other dramas i watched. Also the editing is just not real enough, there is some clear green screen scenes where I can still see some green trim, and some video effects are not used at a reasonable time. Its understandable that Park Shin Hye can not speak Chinese, but using someone elses voice and replacing Park's voice just isn't real enough. I would watch it again because it's Chinese and I can understand it, but I wouldn't if this is Kdrama

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
MissBuyNLarge
0 people found this review helpful
Jun 7, 2013
20 of 13 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 8.0
Story 8.0
Acting/Cast 9.0
Music 8.0
Rewatch Value 6.0
I must say, going into this I wasn't quite sure what I was getting myself into. I like George Hu and I've seen enough of Park Shin Hye to know she's a good actress, so I thought I'd watch this.
Personally, the acting was spot on. George Hu and everybody else did a really good job. From what I've seen of Park Shin Hye, I always seem to watch the dramas where she plays a VERY naive innocent kind of girl, which is not a problem because she's good at it.
The only thing that REALLY bugged me about this drama was the voice-over they had to do for Park Shin Hye. Because of that, I probably won't watch it again (at least not any time soon), but this was an enjoyable venture for me. The story was cute, the characters were well-adapted (I've never seen anything of the manga or anime, so I really have nothing to compare this to, but oh, well), and the script had just the right balance of touching, goofy, serious, and downright facepalm moments. I'd definitely recommend it if you like silly and somewhat ridiculous plot lines with a few touching moments on the side.

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
MG Mayre
0 people found this review helpful
Sep 13, 2023
13 of 13 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 5.0
Story 6.0
Acting/Cast 7.5
Music 3.5
Rewatch Value 3.5
Hayate The Combat Butler (Taiwan) (2011) - I came to watch this because of Park Shin Hye basically. Of course I didn’t like the dubbed part, but I love the story of this and also the flow of the story. This is just a 13 episode drama which I like because mahuman rajud sya. I didn’t have previous knowledge, so I didn’t read the manga version and haven’t seen the anime version as well so I did think that it helped me be able to like the drama. Having no expectations with just the plot as a guide, it helped me love the drama. I like the chemistry between the main leads, and also the family part of the story which gina highlight kasagara sa Taiwanese drama is well portrayed.

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Hayate the Combat Butler (2011) poster

Details

Statistics

  • Score: 6.6 (scored by 1,245 users)
  • Ranked: #9898
  • Popularity: #3371
  • Watchers: 3,961

Top Contributors

15 edits
15 edits
9 edits
3 edits

Popular Lists

Related lists from users
Live Action Shoujo Manga
236 titles 337 loves 6
Live Action Dramas/Movies
241 titles 33 loves
Dramas
359 titles 22 loves

Recently Watched By