As I said before, Im Ba Reun (Kim Myung Soo) was a male lead that did his job letting the real protagonist shows up. The story didn't about him, but about Park Cha Oh Reum (Go Ah Ra) and her boldness to change everything around her, and this was shown a lot here. The most impressive thing to me was the fact that nobody of the characters was perfect. Ba Reun starts as a rigid and insensitive judge that had to learn to make a balance in his point of view, and the same happens with Oh Reum, that was pure emotion and had to learn to see the processes with more impartiality. It was amazing to see all characters learn and grow with each other.
A low point for me was the romance, unfortunately. For me, see their relationship growing up was amazing and I loved the fact that Oh Reum didn't fall for Ba Reun immediately because this made the process be more real. But I really missed more of their relationship being showed in the drama. Ba Reun was so cute and they were so cute together... I just wanted to see more. My empty was filled with Jung Bo Wang (Ryu Deok Hwan) and Lee Do Yeon (Lee Elijah), the cutest second couple that I had seen these days! I had to contend with their relationship and be frustrated with ReunReum couple.
Besides the important issues approach in this drama, I have to say that the script wasn't one of the bests in my opinion. Many times I got confused with the episodes and the drastic changes of posture in some characters from nowhere. The edition also didn't bring my attention. The idea of put the thoughts being narrated was interesting in the beginning, but, with the following episodes, I started to get tired with so many narratives and conversations just happening in the mind of the characters. The OST, in another way, was pretty beautiful, even just one song being played in the most part of the time (I think this is an issue in dramas with heavy themes).
To finish, I'll put this one as a "pretty good one" (★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★). Some things in the production and script could be better, but the message and the way how the story shows the weakness and strongness to be a human and to follow real justice made this drama worth it.
Honorable mention to the explanation of the meaning of the expression "apple of my eye". I never heard an explanation like that and made me think a lot! I loved it!
I just finished "Tale of the nine-tailed" and I'm recovering now. I'll write about it later! Wait for it!
See you soon!
XOXO, Mari.
Was this review helpful to you?
A drama that depicts issues in society!
The male lead and female lead do have amazing chemistry because they are polar opposites in their personalities. The FL is head-strong, impulsive, passionate while the ML is reserved, introverted, and prudent. Their romance story is portrayed well, but it could be a lot better. The drama mostly revolves around social and other issues in society, and romance comes secondary to that! As the plot progresses there is comedy added through supporting characters.The secondary couple in this show OUTSHINE the main couple, and there is basically no comparison between the 2 couples. The secondary couple is the best! Lee Elijah did a phenomenal job and her chemistry with her partner is outstanding! They deserve more screen time, but due to the drama's primary focus of social issues, etc it's not possible to give the 2nd couple as much screen time as one would like!
Overall the drama is amazing with great OST, acting, & plot! The ending is really nice and touching! Enjoyed watching it! The plot progresses well and there aren't many parts where you feel like you're watching filler episodes to kill screen time!
Was this review helpful to you?
But I really love dramas about the judicial system even when they’re portraying impossible situations like in « Your Honor ».
But Go Ara’s character and the way she interpreted it... i just couldn’t.
Obviously in a lot of dramas, because it is not reality, you can see how humans feelings and « sense of justice » are important even when facing the law.
And I get it, it’s a drama, not a documentary on the judicial system.
but Miss Hammurabi is going too far, Go ara’s character is constantly crying and whining, thinking about the victim’s Feelings instead of being objective.
How can she be a judge ?
And Go ara’s acting didn’t make it better.
In conclusion, If you wanna watch a legal drama, I do not recommend this one.
Was this review helpful to you?
--------------------------------------------------------------
More than entertainment, this show offers food for thought through a social critique of not only South Korean culture, but of society as a whole. It presents problems by putting the status quo on trial, allowing us to witness the protagonists fight tooth and nail to change the way we think of "justice".
Though this is an inspirational show, the overdramatization of some of the cases results in a rose-tinted version of an otherwise realistic scenario. By presenting cases in black and white, with very few shades of grey, the writers also discouraged any surprises. The show could've benefitted from some variety in regards to the cases, showing that trend they set wasn't absolute.
Other than that, however, it was an enjoyable ride.
MAIN CHARACTERS: Provocative
--------------------------------------------------------------
One of the thing that's worth highlighting is the interactions between the two leads. This is a story of Idealism (Judge Park) meeting Cynicism (Judge Im) and striking a balance between their views. The saying "opposite attracts" is perfectly portrayed and it allowed for a lot of positive character growth.
Park Cha Oh Reum (female lead, played by Go Ah Ra): Her character is the embodiment of idealism. Though she overcame a brutal experience, she came out the other side fighting. She's passionate, justice-driven, solution-oriented, courageous and generous. But she's also bias, judgemental, emotionally-driven and reckless. She's someone who isn't afraid of her emotions and isn't easily swayed by others' opinions... but she also has a hard time accepting advice from whoever disagrees with her views. Despite her popular opinions, Judge Park risks her career and takes a stand. In so doing, she inspires those around her to join her cause, showing that change can only be accomplished when one has the imagination to think it possible and the courage to make it so.
Im Ba Reun (male lead played by L): He's the embodiment of cynicism. He follows the rules, acts by precedent, rarely questions the evidence and keeps his emotions on a tight leash. Being an introvert, Judge Im struggles to voice his thoughts and can't help dismissing Judge's Park extroversion as craziness at first. The change in his character is gradual, subtle but constant. We know about it because we get to hear his honest thoughts; those words that he leaves unspoken due to the anxiety caused by his social awkwardness. Yet despite accepting the status quo, Judge Im shows he's willing to listen to other peoples' views, even if --or especially if they contradicted his own. That adaptability and open-mindedness push him to step out of his comfort zone and embrace change. Out of the entire cast, Judge Im is probably the most relatable.
PORTRAYAL OF THEIR TEAMWORK: A match made in heaven
--------------------------------------------------------------
The balance the leads managed to strike despite (or maybe because) of their extreme views made the show come alive. While Judge Im was prone to think rather than act; Judge Park was prone to act without thought. Her recklessness would oftentimes force him into action. But at the same time, his caution would oftentimes force some restraint on her.
So, in a way, Judge Park was like fire. Though necessary for survival, fire without a construct to keep it in check or guide it can become destructive. That's where Judge Im steps in. He's the pyramid of wood for Judge Park's fire, capable of making her fire last longer and shine brighter. The beauty of their teamwork resides in their interdependency. No part can function to its full potential without the other.
PORTRAYAL OF ROMANCE: Like a candle
--------------------------------------------------------------
The romance between Oh Reum and Im Ba was treated as a constant sub-plot, but it never detracted from the real story. The romance isn't portrayed as a raging fire, which is the norm for many K-dramas. Instead, we get a love that burns tenuously, like a candle. The flame is small, fragile but beautiful. It lights the whole room, provides comfort and eventually guides our characters towards one another.
Here are some of the highlights:
1) The romance is in the yearning and admiration, which creates tension that never turns hostile or detracts from the narrative.
2) These two really have each others' back and I appreciated that they found their footing as friends first.
3) No unnecessary love triangle or misunderstandings, it was pretty straightforward.
4) It was gradual, so it made it much sweeter when they got there.
ANTAGONIST: Status quo
--------------------------------------------------------------
Although there were antagonistic characters, the status quo was portrayed as the real (and more frightful) opponent. By presenting controversial subjects, the writers question whether we should let precedent dictate the solutions or if we should start thinking outside the box.
OVERALL: Recommended
--------------------------------------------------------------
This is definitely worth watching for its powerful social critique and its unique female lead. This is a show that will make you emotionally invested, will have you thinking for days and, overall, ends on a satisfying note.
Some of the trials may hit too close to home for some, so keep that in mind if you are very sensitive, as there are no trigger-warnings. Another thing of note is that the pacing of this show slow. There's no overuse of drama to create conflict and no over-the-top romantic moments to spice things up. Even the comedy is sparse, with a serious note taking over most of the show.
But if you're looking for a thought-provoking narrative, complex characters, and interesting human interactions, you've come to the right place.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
This drama is honestly infuriating. I can guess where the creators were trying to take it, unfortunately it just falls short. The best way I can think of to describe this drama is 'agenda driven'. The message the show is trying to convey is too heavy-handed, and it doesn't feel natural.First of all, what I noticed right from the start is that the show deals too much with cases concerning sexual assault and harassment. It gets very, very repetitive and the motiff of harrassment is also brought up outside of the courtoom. Not only does it seem like every other case they deal with concerns sexual misconduct, the very first scene of the first episode is the main heroine confronting a groper on the subway. One of the earlier episodes has a scene where a female court employee is harrassed by a group of men late at night. The main protagonist, portrayed by Go Ara, has also been the victim of sexual harassment in the past, not just once, but twice. The fact that sexual misconduct seems to be a heavy focus of the show really gets tiring, especially considering the fact that the show takes a very biased approach. They seem to portray this problematic matter in a very one-sided manner, that seems extremely condescending not only to the victims, because they are allways shown as weak, frail and unable to stand up for themselves, but also for us as viewers. Go Ara's characters takes these cases very personally, and is eventually able to draw the male protagoninsts onto her side, and none of them seem to take a level-headed approach. The show seems hell-bent on portraying all men as sexual predators, and every woman as a poor victim, oppresed both by society and the men around her.
Go Ara's character is very nosy, can't seem to mind her own business and is extremely emotionally invested in the wellbeing of every single one of her female co-workers. She seems to think that they all need her help, speaks of them as "weak" and "underprivileged" and this behaviour, while it may seem like the right thing to do at first, is extremely condescending. Im Ba Reun is completely unable to confront her on any of her foolish ideas, and just goes along with them, even though he should know better. He never scolds her for being too emotionally invested, and for this extreme hero complex of hers.
In conclusion, this show clearly has an agenda, and it's making it almost unwatchable for me. However, when it takes a break from that and takes a more light-hearted approach, when it deals with cases of different nature (not concerning sexual misconduct) then it becomes very enjoyable. I'm just not sure whether the good parts weigh out the bad parts. I most certainly do not recommend it. If you're looking for a great court drama, I suggest Remember with Yoo Seung Ho. That one is much, much better.
Was this review helpful to you?
Hilarious legal drama
LIKEThe humour which lightened up the entire drama - recently saw clips of Miss Hammurabi and burst into laughter. Sung Dong Il and Go Ara were in Reply 1994 and Hwarang and they were always bickering. Totally forgot they were here... brought back memories..
DISLIKE
Nothing much really
MUSIC - personal fav
Ususu - Haru
REWATCH VALUE
Adding to my list probably will re-watch someday when I have the time
Was this review helpful to you?
I also found this drama to be pretty boring with nothing really peaking my interest.
I wouldn't say that this drama is bad or that it's overrated, I just did not find the drama to be enjoyable enough to hold my attention and even though I only watched the first 2 episodes, that's definitely enough time to determine if there's anything promising to encourage me to continue watching. And unfortunately, Miss Hammurabi did not have that special something for me.
Was this review helpful to you?
O que dizer sobre essa maravilha de Kdrama?
Nem sei porque demorei tanto tempo para ver esse Kdrama, mesmo depois de ler vários comentários positivos sobre ele e receber algumas indicações, outros dramas sempre passavam na frente. E, a vibe certa pra assistir um drama jurídico demorou tanto a chegar que pensei que ele tinha virado só mais um drama no meio de uma multidão de dramas da minha lista que talvez eu assistiria algum dia.Não importa quanto tempo levou quando finalmente comecei assistir me apaixonei pela história. Desde o primeiro episódio me senti tão animada ao ponto de querer maratonar o drama todo sem nem olhar para o lado.
Sim. eu já estava assistindo vários outros dramas naquele momento, mas quando comecei: Miss Hamurabi, ignorei os outros e foquei só nele. Só por ai você já pode imaginar que esse drama ganhou muitos créditos comigo.
Mais do que achar os casos jurídicos interessantes, amei ver como os casos inspiravam o crescimento dos personagens. Temos aqui uma juíza recém nomeada, muito enérgica, empolgada e emotiva que lida com cada um dos casos não como uma mera aplicadora das leis, mas que leva em conta o contexto geral para trazer justiça aos envolvidos.
É bem interessante ver o contraste existente entre ela e o juiz Im Ba Reun. Enquanto ela embarca de cabeça em cada caso a fim de tomar uma decisão justa e sempre procura modificar as coisas que acredita estarem erradas no arcaico sistema judiciário. O juiz da direita que trabalha no mesmo gabinete, é o seu exato oposto, suas visões de mundo não coincidem, seus posicionamentos se chocam em diversos momentos. A impressão que temos dele é que ele não acredita mais no sistema e prefere agir metodicamente replicando exatamente os dispositivos legais com total imparcialidade, do que levar em conta as particularidades de cada caso.
Gostei muito de ver como o caráter e a humanidade dela conseguem plantar uma sementinha de esperança e mudança em cada uma das pessoas a sua volta. Podemos dizer que ela é o tipo de pessoa que não apenas passa despercebida em algum lugar, mas que provoca mudanças onde quer que esteja.
Não se iluda com a esperança do aparecimento de um romance nesse drama porque esse não é o foco da história.
O mistério sobre o que a secretaria Lee Do Yeon fazia a noite me deixou curiosa por um bom tempo e acabei me surpreendendo com sua história de vida. Sequer suspeitei de algo do tipo. Gostei bastante dessa personagem e do juiz Jung Bo Wang também. Os dois tinham um bom entrosamento.
ATUAÇÕES E OST
As atuações foram convincentes. Esta foi a primeira vez que assisti um drama com a Go Ah Ra e com o L e embora tenha sentido falta de mais expressividade da parte dela, no final das contas acabei relevando isso já que ela pelo menos entregou o que o papel exigia. Sobre ele, nem preciso dizer que me apaixonei por esse ser.
Tenho que dizer que a OST desse drama é maravilhosa e combinou perfeitamente com o drama. Amei a música Someday, Somehow - U-mb5. Me bastou escutar uma vez para sentir uma imensa vontade de correr no youtube pra escutar mais e mais.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Główna bohaterka może cię nieźle wurzać, jeśli nie lubisz tego typu zachowania jak jej xd
Ta recenzja raczej będzie krótka, bo nie mam jakiś wielkich przemyśleń na ten temat. Pomysł na dramę spoko, ale sama główna bohaterka mnie irytowała... miała swoje zasady itd, ale szła po trupach. Rozumiem ją dobrze, bo chciała dla wszystkich sprawiedliwości, ale moim zdaniem troszku przesadzała, bardzo utożsamiała się z poszkodowanymi, bo sama miała ciężkie przeżycia. Nie oznacza to, że bronie sprawców, bo i w Polskim prawie gwałciciel dostaje takie śmieszne kary, że szkoda o tym wspominać!! Niestety społeczeństwo jest bardzo ograniczone i jeden coś powie inni kraczą tak samo, więc nie dziwie się dlaczego wątki w tej dramie były mega przerysowane hahah sama główna postać kobieca zachowywała się mega absurdalnie, tak jak by nic ją nie mogło powstrzymać, co raczej moim zdaniem w prawdziwym życiu po pierwszej takiej akcji nie miała by pracy haha a tutaj nie dość, że wszystko jej uchodziło płazem, to od 11 odcinka zrobiła się bardziej płaczliwa. lepiej jak by pozostała twarda do końca, skoro tak początkowo ją kreowali xDSam romans głównej pary, porażka hahaha a pocałunku nawet nie wspomnę bo to wyglądało okropnie hahahah
za to para drugoplanowa to było coś pięknego i przyjemnie oglądało się ich losy.
Czy polecam tą dramę?
Osobiście mi się podobała i nie, więc ciężko powiedzieć.... jak ktoś nie ma co już oglądać, albo chce się mega wykurzać podczas oglądania ta drama będzie idealna hahah
Was this review helpful to you?
La jeunesse idéaliste peu parfois faire bouger les lignes et avancer les choses !
Ce que j’en pense :Eh bien, beaucoup de bien !! Tout est dans la confrontation d’une jeune idéaliste à la réalité, à la fois de la Justice qui n’est que ce qu’elle est : humaine, donc faillible, et de la hiérarchie administrative, avec deux lourds handicaps : elle est jeune, elle est femme !! Il n’y a aucun travail d’enquête dans le drama, l’affaire arrive bouclée devant les juges et à eux de se dépatouiller avec le dossier et leur propre lecture dudit dossier.
Par le biais des procès et de la vie des juges on va avoir un aperçu de la persistance tenace du sexisme, malgré, soyons juste une bonne tendance à l’amélioration, à la difficulté de sortir de la fameuse morale « suivant que vous soyez puissant ou misérable les jugements de cour vous ferons blancs ou noirs »
Des amitiés se nouent, des amours commencent, des haines s’installent ,des rancunes se tissent, la vie, quoi ! Juste ce qu’il faut de romance pour éclairer tout ça, mais ce n’est clairement pas le but de l’histoire !
La fin, belle et bonne, ne tombe pas dans le bisounours grâce à un départ, et à la tonalité générale plutôt nostalgique des dernières scènes.
Les acteurs sont excellents, justes, sincères, ils nous font croire à leur personnage (un méchant peut-être un poil caricatural ?? Mais si peu ! ) et un grand bravo au juge Han, Sung Dong Il est vraiment génial, Go Ara pleine de sensibilité et L(je déteste ce pseudo ridicule ) est parfait, donnant une belle profondeur à un personnage en demi-teinte qui ne s’impose pas en « jeune premier » classique.
Je ne me souviens pas de chansons sauf une seule que j’aimais bien, donc de ce côté-là c’est tout bon !
Drama à voir pour sa chaleureuse humanité !
Was this review helpful to you?
Desapontada
Adoro dramas judiciais por isso e também por várias criticas positivas vim assistir esse drama porém já no segundo episódio já me vi adiantando e desmotivada e aqui vai o principal motivo do meu desgosto e pela minha desistência desse show nada mais é que a Protagonista feminina sim ela foi a razão de estragar todo a história para mim, eu entendo que a pessoa pode ser boa e querer fazer o bem mais o personagem dela era irritante,forçada , constantemente intrometida sem ser objetiva parecia uma criança afinal diversas ações dela era infantil ela só pensava em como ela se sentia , como tudo tinha que ser feito como ela queria se não fosse assim fazia birra e chorava definitivamente ela não tinha perfil nenhum para o cargo que ocupava.O protagonista masculino fez o seu melhor porém não me convenceu achei sem atitude meio sem vida ele era um personagem apagado.
Esse drama foi muito cansativo não conseguiu me prender, em fim não é para mim.
Was this review helpful to you?
