After looking at my BL list, it seems that this is my rating scale;
10- Masterpiece, Highly Recommend, Comfort Drama, Most likely cried
9.5-8- Great Story, Small Plot Holes, Unanswered Questions, Unbalanced Character Development, Still has Rewatch Value
7-6 - Average story, Enjoyed the MLs, Needed to be "Flush out" more, Good OSTs, Will Rewatch for the NCs
5.5-5- Average to Boring Plot, Skippable Scenes, Cringy/Unnecessary Dialogue, Has Toxic Characters, Some Cute Interactions, Good Cinematography, Ok NCs and OSTs
4.5-3- Bad to Borning Plot, Toxic Characters / Relationships, Most likely enjoyed side couple, Appreciated Cinematography, Favorite Actors was Casted can't Trash it. Don't Recommend
2-1 - I'm offended; belongs in the Trash. What were the writers thinking? Actors need a new agent! Do not recommend; there are better ways to spend your time.