i decided to watch this after being a kdrama fan for two years. everyone is going crazy over it so i was curious...i was hesitant mostly because of the age gap thing? and i still do feel uncomfortable...i dont understand why they couldn't make the FL at least a college student from the beginning (like in her 1st year maybe?) but anyway, overall it was pretty enjoyable. the cinematography was the best for me you can tell this is the same director of mr sunshine. i also enjoyed the grim reaper and goblin's scenes the most.
i was hesitant to watch this because it's an old drama and most old kdramas are just.....not watchable, and unfortunately this wasn't watchable either. i only endured watching it while skipping scenes every episode. i was curious to watch it until the end since the story in general is interesting (the modern royal korea aspect etc.) but all the characters are so damn annoying. The FL, her friends, her family, the SFL, THE SML OOF, i also disliked the ML in the beginning but he grew on me later on. i truly hope the remake of this drama will be better and i'll be tuning in cause the premise of this story is interesting. it's a 7 for me (and yes i'm being kind with this rating lol)
overall it was good. but it got very slow after ep 12 for me. i had to skip many scenes (especially with the side couples like im sorry i just dont find them interesting lol)
i've seen 4 eps so far and i'm trying so hard to endure this because i'm curious but i don't think i can,,, the characters are all very uninteresting and the pace very slow......can someone spoil me lol . who is the culprit/what happens to the chimera cases etc? 0.0
Even though i can relate to the FL the most i think i liked Chang Hee and Gijeong more from the Yeom siblings (is it because i'm too similar with Mijeong and i feel exposed lol) so idk why people are hating on them but i really enjoyed their scenes!
did i watch this only for kento? yes i did (one of the main reasons why i can't watch jdramas is because the production quality is usually terrible, the acting is usually not that great either...but i'll make an exception for him lol)
Idk why people keep saying this reply series is perfect when Tae Woong's character exists 🤢 like if it wasnt for him it would be so much better. Was there a need for him like wtf?? For me, this is how it goes. Reply 1988, 1994, and lastly 1997. I couldnt feel the friendship feels the way i did with 88 and 94 either. The only thing that i enjoyed in this drama is probably Shiwon And Yoonjaes relationship.
I completely agree. This show just skims over and skips a bunch of key moments.
it makes me want to watch the anime again fr i remember when i was in high-school i watched the anime for the first time and i loved kazehaya so much but i'm not feeling it here as much :d
i've only watched the anime so i was excited to see it getting a live action drama, but i must say that i do prefer the anime over the drama since the anime gives you more details and depth to the characters // it was okay for a binge watch tho!
some of my complaints: sawako here looks too pretty and not scary/awkward at all so it doesn't make sense for everyone to be scared of her lol in the original anime/manga she was kinda creepy and VERY awkward . i also didn't feel very interested in kazehaya and sawako's relationship, where as in the anime i really adored them! the best thing in this drama for me was definitely chizu and ryu! (i loved them in the anime too!)
overall the drama was pretty enjoyable, but what didn't make sense to me was Sua's character and her behavior towards the end. How did she go from being obssessed and wanting to kill Hae-e to suddenly becoming besties in uni after the timeskip lmao??? if i remember correctly they didn't show us any scenes with her seeking professional help for her hallucinations or obsession? (i think only her mother calling a doctor?)
1 
(one of the main reasons why i can't watch jdramas is because the production quality is usually terrible, the acting is usually not that great either...but i'll make an exception for him lol)
For me, this is how it goes.
Reply 1988, 1994, and lastly 1997. I couldnt feel the friendship feels the way i did with 88 and 94 either. The only thing that i enjoyed in this drama is probably Shiwon And Yoonjaes relationship.
some of my complaints: sawako here looks too pretty and not scary/awkward at all so it doesn't make sense for everyone to be scared of her lol in the original anime/manga she was kinda creepy and VERY awkward . i also didn't feel very interested in kazehaya and sawako's relationship, where as in the anime i really adored them! the best thing in this drama for me was definitely chizu and ryu! (i loved them in the anime too!)