Details

  • Last Online: 29 seconds ago
  • Gender: Female
  • Location: hell
  • Contribution Points: 306 LV3
  • Birthday: March 30
  • Roles: VIP
  • Join Date: February 7, 2013
  • Awards Received: Finger Heart Award298 Flower Award690 Coin Gift Award141 Golden Tomato Award13 Reply Goblin Award18 Dumpster Fire Award20 Lore Scrolls Award12 Spoiler-Free Captain Award3 Cleansing Tomato Award10 Drama Bestie Award34 Emotional Support Commenter6 Comment of Comfort Award16 Hidden Gem Recommender1 Conspiracy Theorist2 Gaslight, Gatekeep, Girlboss25 Clap Clap Clap Award41 Drama Therapist Award2 Award Hoarder Enabler12 Wholesome Troll8 Emotional Support Viewer2 Sassy Tomato5 Free Range Tomato6 Tomato of Chaos2 Thread Historian6 Boba Brainstormer10 Notification Ninja1 Lore Librarian3 Mic Drop Darling4 Emotional Bandage8 Reply Hugger23 Soulmate Screamer20 Big Brain Award38
Heart Signal Season 5 korean drama review
Completed
Heart Signal Season 5
2 people found this review helpful
by Kate
3 days ago
15 of 15 episodes seen
Completed
Overall 8.5
Story 8.0
Acting/Cast 9.0
Music 7.5
Rewatch Value 8.0

Hear me out...

Whenever you gonna love, hate or have ambiguous feelings about this season is all dependent on whenever you like Youkyung - she was the main character and the editing was focusing on her a lot. Since she was my favorite, I loved the season a lot.

Does this season deliver a lot on love lines? Not really. There is exactly one ship with solid progression and if you are not into these two people, nothing will do much for you since most pairings felt like Titanic to crush from the start. That said, what this show for sure delivered for me are friendships and fun interactions. This felt far more like a slice of life than romance genre.

The friendship between the girls was amazing to watch and if you add Queen Jun Hyeon it gets even better. I love that no matter how complicated the romantic relationships were, it never felt like it negatively affects the friendships themselves. Bromance between Jun Hyeon and Seowon? Amazing. Seowon and Youkyung as besties? Perfection.

Obviously there are major flaws too. I don't even want to talk about PPLs, these were a joke. Usually I don't mind these, I view them as literal adds, but when they used pairing interactions to sell products it makes you doubt how real their interactions were in the first place and how much of it was scripted.

What's more, Jeong Gyu Ri issue. Do I care what's the truth? Not really. Sure she is participating in a variety show, but in my eyes she is still a normal private person, I don't care about what happens outside of the show. But I hated how the production team dealt with it. Staying silent, then saying they are checking out the truth, then silence, and then just writing her off completely. Especially since she did in fact bring some spice into the show - that legendary truth game!

Then the forced editing. If by the end you start showing clips from earlier moments that you cut out of the show to confuse the viewers into believing there was more hesitation and conflict than there really was - that's not clever, that's dumb. There is a limit to how much you can manipulate the footage before it becomes a full clownery. I get it, you want people to keep guessing, but you need to have some limits.

Still, I liked this season a lot and I hope we will get a special episode or two with the cast watching some clips from the episodes and interacting with each other more.
Was this review helpful to you?