Kai Ting Xian Chang
25 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
Not groundbreaking, but still a hidden gem that is definitely my best watch so far this year~
This show only having 26 episodes is unconstitutional! It's realistic and grounded, but with very good writing and direction. People often mistake "ethereal aesthetics" as the pinnacle of good dramas, but good direction shines even more in dramas like these. Before I start with my review of the story, it's important to note that this is a slice of life show that you watch with your family on TV over dinner or while you're lounging in the living room in the evening. It's intended to be a legal education that is digestible for normal people. It's not some grand legal drama emphasizing the "glory" of the legal profession and the judiciary. It's very down to earth, and if you don't like that and expect dramatics, you probably wouldn't enjoy this one. Another downside I can see about this show that might turn people off is the weird dubbing at some scenes. But it's not even a problem of the actors. It's more of the production team changing the lines post-production to pass censorship. If you can get past some scenes where they do that, then you're good to go.STORY:
I'm going to preface this by saying that they definitely did their research in writing the show. But then, I read that this was supervised by the Supreme Court, so it's bound to be accurate to a certain extent.
First of all, what I love about this show is that some of the cases don't end definitively or in a way that is intended to satisfy the audience. Instead, some cases are resolved in a way that is true to human nature. It's very much true to life and close to reality. Because some family matters just don't get resolved in the "perfect happy ending" that we wish them to be resolved. Like Shen Xiezhi, we go on this journey to slowly acknowledge that even when the law dictates this, even when the moral norms of society expect that—the wishes of the parties themselves are the most important, and to truly resolve the grievances in their hearts, the resolution of their cases must be tailored for them and their situation, and not mere textbook answers we find in codals and society.
On this note, I also love how they don't just focus on one case at a time, because the reality is that judges and lawyers have to deal with several cases a day. And this show simulates that pretty well without disrupting the flow of the story, since we are still able to see the linear timeline of the main characters' personal lives.
Another thing I love about this show is that the world doesn't bend to accommodate Shen Xiezhi and Qin Rui's love. Instead, they are the ones who have to bend to accommodate to how the world goes. That's reality. That's life. And it makes me appreciate their relationship even more, knowing that they've made a lot of efforts and thinking to make it work—all the while not sacrificing what is inherent in them as individuals. Their careers really matter to them, and they respect each other's careers and choices, too. Shen Xiezhi and Qin Rui are two people with different dreams and aspirations—one wants to be a judge in the High Court, the other wants to work in a big law firm and earn a lot for herself and her Grandma—and they both know from the start that being together might hinder their career options in the future (because of the recusal rule preventing a judge and a lawyer from working within the same jurisdiction). And you know what? This is what makes the angst so good, delicious, and just *chef's kiss*~ This is what makes the wait to see how they will resolve all of this all the more thrilling. Here are two people who love each other; and they love each other too much, to the point that even if it hurts their heart—even if they miss each other all the time, they are still genuinely happy for the other for pursuing their dreams. There is no resentment in the choices that they made—just understanding (that it is what it is), longing (to be with the person even if it is impossible at the moment), and a sense of pride (that the other is reaching greater heights that they have long dreamed of achieving). I can't emphasize this enough, but they are truly just such a mature pair and a very healthy couple. And even when they started off at the wrong foot, with endless "meet uglies", their best traits still shone for the other to recognize and admire.
I also love how we saw different types of marriages in this show. We saw Judge Shu Jing and her husband's marriage, as well as Judge Yu Le and her husband's marriage. I particularly like the side story about Judge Shu Jing and her husband because I think aside from Shen Xiezhi and Qin Rui's relationship, they are another good contrast to Jiang Feng and Lou Yue. While Jiang Feng and Lou Yue think that it will be a sacrifice to take a step back in their careers for the sake of their marriage and may be a cause for emotional blackmail in the future, Judge Shu Jing's husband has made peace with his decision regarding his career change and doesn't necessarily see it as a sacrifice, because he's more than willing to live a much simpler life for his family. As for Judge Yu Le and her husband, they're kind of a "perfect" pair. I say this lovingly: She's such a pampered princess off work, but it's okay because her husband is more than willing to indulge her. There's also Judge Ying Danian and his wife, who are quite a lovely and chill pair, even at the face of challenges (like his wife being sick). They're braving it together and he's a constant support for her, and it's just lovely to see.
On the topic of Judge Yu Le off work, I really love her off work outfits. She's so fashionable. Also Hu Aixi.
Special Mention: Jiang Feng and Liu Lian. Jiang Feng is such a funny friend. He's just a silly comedic relief for me. Whenever he goes to Shen Xiezhi's apartment unannounced and unsolicited, I just know they're going to piss each other off. As for Liu Lian, she's such a great friend. I really love her friendship with Qin Rui. They have stuck with each other for better and for worse and I love how in the moments where Qin Rui feels down, she's there to pull her up and remind her that she's there, better days are coming, and everything will be alright.
Special Mention 2: Chen Xianghui. I really love his ending. It was such a pleasant surprise for me when I saw it. And you know what? HE DESERVES IT! He's so dedicated to his job and constantly shadows Shen Xiezhi to learn from him. He can be a little self-deprecating because he has failed the Bar Exam multiple times, but that never stopped him from doing his best. It's just so commendable.
(You can check the comments if you want to read some of my insights on Shen Xiezhi and Qin Rui's characters and relationship.)
ACTING/CAST:
I'm going to be honest, Gong Jun didn't really stand out to me as an actor BEFORE. I watched his shows early in his career and after that, I stopped tuning in for his shows altogether. I am quite fond of him in variety shows, though. He seems like an overall lovely guy in real life. But this show changed my perspective of him as an actor again. He's actually good if given the chance to work with good directors and writers. He really brought Shen Xiezhi to life and his acting is so natural and convincing. He can be funny with his judging looks in the courtroom (he's a judge, and he judges LOL), but he can also deliver the perfect emotions of a discerning outsider watching emotionally-driven confrontations in court. Sure, he is moved, but he also maintains the level of professionalism required for his job. I really hope he gets a chance to work in similar shows because I feel like these types of shows suit him more? (Anyway, this truly put Gong Jun back in the map for me. I might even revisit some of the shows he has done after I stopped tuning in for his shows back then. And tune in for his future ones, too.)
As for Ren Min—THE ACTRESS SHE IS. I have always liked her. She's such an effective actress that I can always count on being immersed whenever I'm watching her. There's so much depth and nuance in her acting, that I could empathize with Qin Rui and feel for her. I saw that she actually wrote a character analysis for Qin Rui before they started filming and this dedication to the craft is truly awe-inspiring. She's definitely going places and I'm so excited to see her future works.
Gong Jun and Ren Min have amazing chemistry, especially when they're bickering. I really ate up their dynamic in this show and kinda went crazy when the obvious dislike their characters had for each other became charged with something else that they're both too scared to name. I hope they work together again. I think they would work well in an investigation drama. Or maybe those infinite flow stories (I think it's the new trend in C-Dramaland right now).
I have constantly said before that an actor is good is when I'm able to enjoy the show while watching him or her. If the actor delivers what he has to deliver and make me feel for their character, then they're good in my books. For this show, everyone has done a great job in doing that. From the main characters, to the supporting characters, and most especially to the main characters in each of the cases. The acting in this show is very grounded, and I think that's what makes it more effective for me. I am truly convinced that these are real life people facing these real life problems and I'm really just wishing the best resolution for their cases all throughout the show.
MUSIC:
The OSTs in this show are quite unassuming. I didn't even realize that I've had it memorized (and that I even remembered it) until I started humming along when the songs play in some scenes. There's nothing really much to say about the music, but the sound effects and BGM are all well-placed throughout the show and they have never felt out of place.
REWATCH VALUE:
Would you believe it if I said it has so much rewatch value, I end up rewatching while I'm still watching the episode itself? I always catch myself rewinding the scenes (especially Shen Xiezhi and Qin Rui's scenes) and as if that's not enough, I even go to XHS to watch edits. The rewatch value is just so high for me, I can't even explain it. It takes me hours to finish a 45-minute episode, it's quite insane.
OVERALL:
I thoroughly LOVE this show. I love this show so much, I have written a lot of thinkpieces about Shen Xiezhi and Qin Rui. I just cannot find it in me to shut up about them. At the same time, this show has also generated a lot of discussion (especially on Chinese social media) and it's quite interesting to read some of other people's takes, too. Not only is the show fun in itself, but the experience of watching it is fun, too. Call me a nerd, but I really love it when good discussions are made regarding the plot and the characters, interpreting their backgrounds and motivations and how these affect how they move along in the story.
Like I said above, it's not groundbreaking. But nevertheless, it is still a hidden gem that everyone should have the luck to come across with. It's definitely my favorite watch this year so far and I really hope everyone can give it a try~
Cet avis était-il utile?
Quand nous étions jeunes
0 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
Depressing
I found this drama to be a major disappointment. While many coming-of-age stories find beauty in growth, this one was unnecessarily depressing. The finale was particularly frustrating; seeing the core group of friends disconnect and move on in different directions felt like a betrayal of the audience's emotional investment. Instead of a satisfying conclusion, it offered a cold dose of reality that made the hours spent watching it feel like a total waste. If you are looking for a show that celebrates friendship, I would suggest skipping this one."🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🤭🥲🤭🤭🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🤭🥲🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭Cet avis était-il utile?
Bloodhounds Season 2
0 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
bloodhounds 2 review.
I still prefer Season 1, but Season 2 is a strong and smart continuation of the story. It’s darker, more intense, and the emotional moments, especially in episodes 6 and 7, hit so hard. The wait was absolutely worth it. The main duo is incredible their chemistry, teamwork, and dynamic energy are on another level. Overall, Season 2 delivers excitement, suspense, and emotional depth, making it a must watch continuation of the series.The acting is phenomenal every emotion feels real.
totally recommended.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Kai Ting Xian Chang
14 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
Narrative
I finished it and Loved it, very touching stories of life,the 2 Main Actors chemistry great, I just missed a Kiss between them I think 26 episodes was to short, we want to see more stories and how the judges mediate between the plaintiffs it was very informative about the family laws and how the law will protect both sides, specially on divorce cases where are too many people involved. The natrative about the Male Lead Actor (Gong Jun) and the Female Lead Actress (Ren Min) was great i just loved it 👏👏👏👏👏👏❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️Cet avis était-il utile?
Please Feel At Ease Mr. Ling
0 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
Sweet
I really loved the male and female leads. The 1st half of the drama was definitely my favorite part. I also enjoyed the two side couples, who were friends of the leads. However, the 'adopted brother' relationship with the female lead felt really creepy to me.✿♥︎♥︎♥︎♥︎❀❀❀❀❀♫♫♫♫♫◐◐◐◐◐◐✜✜✜✜✜✜✜✜✥✥❈✰✱✩✡︎✸𓃵𓃠𓃟𓃭𓃟♥︎♥︎❀𓃭𓅿❀𓆉♫✥𖠑ꪉ✈︎☔︎☔︎☔︎☔︎☽☽☽⁂⁂😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘💙💙💙💙💙💙❤️💙❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️💙💙❤️❤️❤️💙❤️❤️❤️💙💙💙💙❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️💙💙💙💙❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️Cet avis était-il utile?
A Hidden Gem
This drama is a delight to watch. Its two main leads join forces to solve cases set in the Tang Dynasty. The cases are intriguing and unpredictable. Some of the cases allow the audience to see what women faced during that time and how important women's roles are in their society. Some of the cases are very touching. The martial arts/action scenes are done very nicely too. The story focuses mainly on the cases. There is some romance, but it is not the main focus. However, I do enjoy their chemistry together. I do plan to rewatch it again.Cet avis était-il utile?
Kateikyoshi no Kishi Knight desu.
0 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
Serviu boas risadas
Vi todos os eps, agora começam os dois especiais. Ai, que BL conforto, com certeza vou lembrar pra sempre dele. Muito fofa a relação que eles criaram, e como o KishiKishi acreditou no Toru e apoiou ele até o final. Se tirarmos a comédia e o exagero dos personagens, esse BL tem uma mensagem bem legal de não julgar as pessoas pela aparência e também sobre como muitas vezes as escolas desistem dos alunos e os subestimam. O Toru era um adolescente sem perspectiva de vida, ele não fazia nada, só tirava zero e possuia um professor que o levava cada vez mais para baixo. Dai vem o Kishikishi, incentivando, elogiando, mostrando maneiras de ele conseguir estudar, mostrou que pode ser divertido. Fiquei me sentindo uma mãe orgulhosa quando ele decidiu ir para a faculdade e virar um professor também.Acho que essa série pode não ser para todo mundo, porque é uma comédia beeem escrachada, chega a ser ridicula mesmo essa parte, mas eu amei. Eu amava o Toru agindo todo marrento, mas ele narrando os pensamentos com uma voz fininha, adorava muito ele ficando todo boiolinha pelo Kishikishi, a maneira que ele abaixava a guarda, as caretas, os alunos do ensino medio aparentar ter 40 anos, a gangue parecnedo mais uma gangue dos patetas. Confesso que me senti até aliviada por não ter beijo nem nada, porque não sabia a idade do Kishikishi, e o Toru tinha 17, então espero que esses eps especiais sejam com ele já na faculdade, reencontrando o Kishikishi. Resumindo, se quiser dar muita gargalhada, algo para ver com o cerebro desligando, apenas acompanhar um maluco que quer ser lider de gangue se apaixonar por um professor perfeitinho e também esquisitão, esse BL é perfeito. Também teve varias cenas que eu estava surtando igual o Toru pelos momentinhos dos dois.
Vi nos comentários do ep sobre não poder ser considerado um BL, porque não teve beijo... minha opinião sempre será: se o personagem é abertamente apaixonado pelo outro, é um BL. Esse é o ponto que eu discuto sobre não curtir bromance, porque eles dão falsos momentos românticos apenas para alimentar os telespectadores. Agora, um BL sem beijo, os personagens tem sentimentos um pelo outro, são gays ou bi/pan, mostra um romance entre dois garotos, mesmo que sem a parte fisica, então não é um bromance. É BL.
OBS: minha nota é totalmente pelo sentimento. Me apeguei muito a esse mundinho e aos personagens. Se for olhar pela parte tecnica, seria um 7. É basico a atuação, o roteiro, a cinematografia, etc.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Le baiser de la sirène
1 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
A Arte da Reviravolta em "O Beijo da Sereia"
Existem produções que se definem pela primeira impressão, e existem obras como "O Beijo da Sereia", um K-drama que exige paciência para entregar uma das experiências mais imersivas e surpreendentes dos últimos tempos. O que começa de forma sutil e despretensiosa floresce, ao longo dos episódios, em uma trama completamente diferente daquela que imaginamos inicialmente.O grande trunfo desta obra são, sem dúvida, os seus plot twists. O roteiro brinca com mudanças radicais e inesperadas, transformando o rumo da história com uma dinâmica sensacional. É um exercício de pura tensão e mistério: detalhes que pareciam inexistentes no início surgem gradualmente, alimentando a curiosidade do espectador e reformulando tudo o que acreditávamos saber.
Um ponto de destaque que merece atenção é a trilha sonora instrumental. Diferente das tradicionais OSTs cantadas, a sonoplastia aqui foi escolhida a dedo para ditar o ritmo da narrativa. O impacto sonoro é fundamental para construir a atmosfera de suspense, tornando a imersão muito mais profunda e impactante.
É verdade que o tom da série pode dividir opiniões. Por ter um início mais lento e cadenciado, alguns espectadores mais apressados podem perder o interesse. No entanto, essa construção gradual é necessária para que o clímax tenha o peso devido.
Essa construção é sustentada por um elenco formidável. A química entre os protagonistas é evidente, mas o verdadeiro brilho reside no antagonista e na figura do "meio vilão" que opera nas sombras — escolhas de elenco que se provaram certeiras para a complexidade da trama.
No geral, "O Beijo da Sereia" entrega uma história sucinta e bem amarrada, sem deixar pontas soltas ou buracos no roteiro. É uma obra que não se apressa em contar seus segredos, mas recompensa quem fica até o fim.
Se você é o tipo de fã que ama ser desafiado por reviravoltas constantes e histórias construídas sobre camadas de mistério, este K-drama é a escolha certa para a sua próxima maratona.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
I really loved it
En-drama really surprised me in the best way. The school setting feels simple at first, but the story quickly becomes emotional and full of tension. The idea of seven friends all sharing the same secret crush is so messy in the best way—it creates drama, awkward moments, and a lot of feelings. What I love most is how natural their chemistry feels, like real friends with hidden emotions. It’s not just about romance, but also about friendship and growing up. Short, but really addictive.Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
I still don't understand the title
This kdrama showed me a lot of the things I missed about the industry: real people - real skin, pores, skin texture, beard stubble, beautiful and healthy, sun kissed golden skin; people throwing liquids at the FL; a hopelessly in love ML; a healthy dose of nonsense; the nonsense ring tones and a ridiculous keyboard tapping sounds; people looking sad and depressed, saying nothing for long periods of time, looking longingly at their surroundings.It was fun and depressing, with a little sprinkle of nonsense and hope. Even if it was annoying at times, it was nice to see real people and a story that takes its time. The state of recent kdramas has me longing for simpler times and I guess that's why I watched this one.
Even if the beauty standards aren't as strict as today, they're still equating glasses and curly hair with ugliness, but I guess that's still universal, unfortunately. In this drama we see superficial "improvement" or more topical and stylistic ones, instead of the permanent ones we're seeing in today's kdramas. Most of today's kdramas seem like an advertising to the plastic surgery and cosmetics industry. It feels like they're telling us to apply new paint to an imperfect house because what matters is what we see on the outside. Anyway, this kdrama was refreshing because it was an escape of what the kdrama world is largely becoming.
It has been puzzling me for a while how there are so many dramas that deal with cancer. It's a very specific trope to KDramas, which is probably something that is very present in Korean society. Tropes and stereotypes exist for a reason. They might be reductive but are usually indicative of at least a trend. I found out not long ago that there is a correlation between the presence of military bases and the increase in cancer diagnosis. Correlation might not be causation but the probability of causation is very high.
I'll leave a few articles here that might bring light on this:
https://gijn.org/stories/investigating-toxic-military-bases-and-their-links-to-cancer/
https://www.reuters.com/world/us/unpublished-study-finds-elevated-cancer-rates-us-military-base-2023-11-10/
https://www.civilianexposure.org/military-bases-are-full-of-cancer-causing-compounds/
Besides being the highest polluter in the planet, the US military is poisoning the people around the world. They have 800+ military bases all over the globe and these are the ones they have in South Korea, they're a lot for such a small country: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_Army_installations_in_South_Korea
It doesn't matter that many of them are closed, the contamination remains in the soil. The uncountable amount of cancer patients we see in KDramas could be linked to that, since, in some way or another, kdramas reflect Korean reality. Maybe that would be something interesting to talk about in a kdrama but with such levels of pro-US propaganda I doubt anyone will ever do that.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
Came for the actress, stayed for… actually no, I left.
This isn’t a bad drama, and I can see exactly what it’s trying to do. The commentary on toxic fan culture, boundary‑crossing “supporters,” and the way the entertainment industry flips its loyalty the second an idol stops being profitable — all of that is valid, necessary, and honestly refreshing to see addressed so directly. Celebrities are humans, not emotional vending machines, and the show makes that point clearly.But the execution doesn’t always land. The scenes meant to highlight how dangerous obsessive fandom can be feel oddly muted, and the company’s reaction — treating criminal behavior like a PR hiccup — ends up more frustrating than impactful. The message is strong; the delivery wobbles.
The mystery element doesn’t help. When I can identify the killer before the story even settles, the suspense loses its footing. Predictability isn’t fatal, but it does make the viewing experience feel flatter than it should.
I’m not angry at the drama — just quietly stepping away before mild disappointment turns into irritation. I’ll give it a respectable score for the actress and the intention behind the commentary, but this isn’t something I need to push through.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Eccellenza nel cast e alta qualità tecnica e atmosfera
Pursuit of Jade è un gioiello nel panorama dei drama cinesi, distinguendosi per una qualità produttiva superiore, una narrazione curata e una chimica tra i protagonisti che evolve in modo naturale e coinvolgente.La recitazione è fantastica, estesa anche al cast secondario, elevando il livello drammatico dell'opera. La relazione tra i protagonisti si sviluppa con un ritmo sapiente, passando da una cura reciproca a un sentimento profondo, supportato da un'ottima chimica visiva e interpretativa. La protagonista femminile offre una prova attoriale ottima, riuscendo a bilanciare perfettamente la forza interiore con un'adorabile delicatezza. La sua interpretazione è sfaccettata, rendendo il personaggio non solo funzionale alla trama, ma profondamente umano, empatico e piacevole da seguire in ogni evoluzione emotiva.
La fotografia è curata nei minimi dettagli come dei quadri d’autore, i combattimenti sono ben realizzati e i costumi dettagliati , tutto a creare un'atmosfera immersiva. La narrazione è solida e intrigante. La serie è in grado di incollare allo schermo grazie alla sua atmosfera coinvolgente. È un drama che incanta, consigliatissimo per chi cerca storie profonde e recitazione eccellente.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Absolutely atrocious!!
If I could give this series zero stars I would have given it zero stars! It says it's a series featuring four distinct stories; yet there's only two that had any, well anything! And I only seen three stories as the last story was 4 of those episodes and that's where it stops; episode 8. I probably would have been interested in the last one called "Blood Fighters" but that one never showed up so couldn't watch it and then this claims to be a BL anthology series, but I just saw one that way. This was very poorly written, very poorly executed, no real plots or stories, the acting was bad, felt incomplete and all in all; it was just really stupid to me.I have no idea what "Make A Picture Production" was doing when they produced this, but it should have never been produced. It should have been named "This Should Never Have Been Produced As a Project For BL Fans" because it's so bad and I wonder why it wasn't completed. Now, I usually don't tell people not to watch something, but I'm telling you, DON'T WASTE YOUR TIME! You'll regret it as I did and I'll never get that wasted time back.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Love Beyond the Grave
36 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
Cette critique peut contenir des spoilers
a STUNNING... SOULLESS drama...
Initial observations 🗯️🗯️I don't know what but something in this drama is just not clicking for me.
I tried to watch it and reserve judgment but as I keep watching this feeling is just not going anywhere.
This drama is beautiful, there is no doubt about it. It's pretty clear they invested at lot of money and the only word I can think of is "STUNNING". Sets, makeup, costumes everything is gorgeous but something is missing. It feels hollow, devoided of any emotion.
I like the ml and FL. They are fantastic actors and the whole cast is on point. But to me it feels like watching a super model, visually stunning but without feeling any attraction to it.
PREMISE OF THE SHOW🗯️🗯️
The Queen of the spirit wordl is taking a break in the mortal realm. Out of luck she encounters a mortal general who possesses the key to her desires: he is able to exchange his human senses with the queen to let her experience the human way of living. Thanks to this pact they destiny intertwined.
RANT🗯️🗯️
I am going to list everything that made me go "meh".
∆ This spirit queen doesn't possess the "human senses"... Which is not true.
Sight? She can see.. she is just colorblind
Earing? She can hear perfectly fine, she is just deaf to music. (But plays music on battlefields for the dying)
At the beginning her reason to experience the human life looked silly. After a while we discover that she actually had a human mother which I guess can be linked to her desire to experience life like her. I don't know because I didn't make it that far.
∆ Talking about "mothers".. at the very beginning the drama introduces the queen as the only queen born directly as a spirit. Ok, to me that implies that she just "appeared" in the spirit world. Oh no.. later we find out that she had a human mother and a spirit dad I guess(?).
∆ Moving on to the ml. He is conceiving his identity. When his turn to explain his past comes, he says that he was born as Duan xi but later is kidnapped and another guy took his place. Ok... So... Then why are you still using your original name, everyone knows by that name and call the guy who was put in your place with a different name?
Maybe I am missing something or the subs were off.. but to me that whole thing is a mystery.
Unfortunately this drama is full of these "weird "things".
∆ Let's talk about the FL. To access the mortal world she has to "possess " a mortal body. When we are introduced to her she basically uses a body that looks like her exactly. Occasionally, the mortal body needs to rest but she is free to go around in her spirit form. Later in the drama we find out that she was actually possessing a body that looks nothing like her and she is now setting her free. Emm. What? Then why didn't the body you showed us before change its features everytime your spirit left it? I don't get it.
I am either too dumb or this drama is just confusing as fuck and not too well though out.
∆ Arthur Cheng is a mortal general who never experienced magic (as far as I know) but isn't a bit surprised when the FL reveals she is the queen of the spirit world. He is cool as it gets, even happy. Shouldn't you be at least.. surprised? A bit frightened?
∆the general is trained as a killer. He murdered countless people as part of his training but one day a random man tells him" hey, the weather looks nice today" and he leaves the assassin world because that conversation changed his mind😒
∆ the general is a skilled assassin but he is still a human, right? Wrong. Because he volunteers to infiltrate the enemy camp and fight hundreds of men alone. You can be skilled as much as you want but that was just ridiculous.
∆ plot armor: there is never a real sense of danger in this drama which leads to no stakes. You never worry about the protagonists because they will always win no matter the circumstances. The Queen loses her powers and is about to die? Don't worry, the general is around the corner.
Hundred of men are about to kill the general? Who cares. He can single handedly kill them all.
∆ romance: I think this is the weakest part of the drama. To be honest I never found them believable.
At the beginning dilraba is this cool , ruthless queen willing to torture and murder when necessary but when she meets this general she basically makes empty treats to him all the time without any consequences. I get that she later is willing to protect him but even when a "punishment" is expected she never follows through.
He on the other hand is the one being "threatened" but after 2 second starts talking about love.
That surprised me quite a bit. It felt out of place because they didn't quite built that romantic energy yet. It felt weird.
After that moment he is so enamoured with this woman that it becomes ridiculous.
Especially when they arrive in the spirit underworld he switches from cold general to an annoying puppy. He seems a totally different character and she feels like his mom.
I never felt the "tension" between them. She feels like an aunt and he looks like an energetic baby.
∆ the episodes in the underworld are so far the most boring ones. They basically spend the time measuring "dicks" because the right hand and the general both are in love with the queen.
∆ while we watch the "void" episodes , what we saw that far never gets mentioned. The emperor, the power struggle, the other generals, conflict with the enemy, the little brother (really sweet actor). They never get mentioned or shown.
That's all I gathered from episode 1 to 18.
I think I might be dropping this drama because even though I am fine suspending my "disbelief", when stuff doesn't make sense with an internal logic , I just cannot enjoy it.
Cet avis était-il utile?
Seeds of Scarlet Longing
0 personnes ont trouvé cette critique utile
Enjoyable Short Drama
I enjoyed this short drama and thought it was one of the better ones I've watched. The female lead was presented as very childish but she was "almost 18". With that age, the story was still very sexualized as they were jade waste demons who had to "be" with their chosen man that they give a love worm too on every full moon. There was good chemistry and implied intimacy but infact they didn't even kiss a lot. Just very close proximity and hand holding. Overall, I enjoyed the story and acting. However the Mango TV English sub translation was really bad. If you are looking for an entertaining shirt drama with some good chemistry, check it out. But, be prepared ahead supposed to be young. However, I didn't feel like the actual age of the actors were a problem. Enjoy!Cet avis était-il utile?




