Coming of Age Time Travel Romance
One of the best Chinese dramas ever made, also has one of the flimsiest openings of all time. If you can bear through the first part of the very first episode, you will be rewarded handsomely with one of the best viewing experiences in Chinese cinema history.This drama isn't for everyone. It's only for those with a heart, and with high tolerance for romance. We first meet our FL as a 20 something year old woman, but as soon as she goes back in time, her consciousness is transmitted into the body of a sixteen year old. Well, imagine your consciousness time-travel to the Qing dynasty, and was transplanted into the body of a wealthy 16 year old twin living in that era. I think you'd be out of your mind with happiness, at first.
The FL acts like what a modern day teenaged girl would act like, not what a 20 year old would act like, but I felt like this made sense because of the amalgamation of consciousness between our time-traveling FL and our Qing dynasty 16 year old. That's just my personal take on that characterization choice though. If she didn't act so flighty and bubbly and freely express herself, then it would be impossible for the romance to happen, as that was her hook. The Qing dynasty princes had never encountered a 21st century woman, so they were fascinated and charmed by her, which makes sense.
Probably what makes this drama work, besides the excellent original story, is that serious actors were cast as the main leads. It's almost impossible to make anyone look good in the Qing mullet in any case, and mature actors were cast to play younger characters, which I have no problems with. The handsomest charcter and actor by far in this drama doesn't fall in love with the FL, despite being the character most resembling her own, which I found interesting. The ML, is probably one of the least attractive actors in Chinese dramaland, and subsequently wouldn't be cast in leading roles under the current casting trend, but this is a 2011 drama, and acting skills are still rated higher than marketability and popularity (and looks by default, IF you are a male actor). The FL, by contrast, is more beautiful than seen in most contemporary dramas, and can actually act! An interesting duality when it comes to casting trends. I don't believe any of these actors are Chinese pop singers either, which makes the casting ideal.
Anyway, the story is, for the most part, historically accurate, no crappy CGI, no over-the-top melodrama. A really well written script that takes you back in time with the FL, as if you are following in her footsteps. Yes, it's not a perfect drama. I remember there are some really crappy, fake screen backgrounds with actors riding fake horses in the foreground, but you know what? An excellent effort all in all. I was so vested in the characters, that when the ML started to show the signs of carrying the world on his shoulders, I did skip a bunch of episodes, as I felt a mixture of dread and boredom, and the darkness was overpowering after the positivity of the "first half" of the drama, but I understood the necessity of the character development with the plot, and the happiness turning to tragedy by the end, just like it did in history.
Overall, what a journey! What a treasure of a Chinese costume drama! If you haven't seen it, please do give it a go, as long as you have an interest in historical fiction and romance together.
Was this review helpful to you?
I'm a sucker for historical drama, especially when it involves time traveling! This drama totally got me hooked to the point that I didn't wanted to sleep because I needed to know what would happen next. 9/10
Plot:
The story overall is very well written. It keeps me on top of my game as there are so many plot twists. However, there are certain parts where I don't really feel the flow of the story. It could have been due to the lack of transitions that make some parts feel like things happen so suddenly and disconnected. Also, I didn't really like the fact that Ruo Xi's actions don't seem to affect the major outcomes of history, which makes the story slightly more predictable as we already know in the beginning which prince will become king. There are other historical dramas with a better plot for time traveling. But nevertheless, the political conflict for the thrones between the princes always put me in suspense. I like the humor every once in a while to help lighten up the mood so the plot doesn't feel so painful to watch. It's not that the plot is bad, but all the drama in this can makes things seem heavy to experience. 8/10
Acting:
The acting is superb I might say. The casts have performed their roles perfectly. I love the little details such all the actors/actresses did to give their characters a distinct personalities. I often found myself crying because I was so submerged into their acting. I'm going to be a little bias, but I really like Wu Nicky's acting. His portrayal of the calm and collective 4th prince has me rooting for him the entire way. 10/10
Music:
I actually started watching this drama because my friend showed me the opening song of this drama. But overall, the drama's music is the biggest factor in making me having these emotional roller coasters. Without it, some scenes won't be as intense as they should be. The main theme song is absolutely fantastic. It is simple but it definitely captures the entire meaning of the story. 10/10
Rewatch value:
I feel some scenes are a bit redundant but I guess they all help creating the intended atmosphere. There are a lot of greenscreen popping up in this drama either due to low budget or other reasons. But I won't say that the greenscreen is that horrible if you don't look closely. If you can get pass that then everything else should be fine. I wouldn't mind rewatching the drama, but the political intensity makes the entire drama seems quite long. 8/10
Was this review helpful to you?
Some of the characters I liked at 1st ended up being disliked, and the ones I disliked ended up being liked very much more than the original ones. The unexpected deaths, though, those were really what caught me off guard. Still, this is a good drama I'd recommend to anybody who likes historical fiction.
10/10 from me!
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
To be honest this drama has traumatised me, it took me a week to try to forget about it. The struggle between all princes to get the throne is so intense at some point that you can't help being taken into it. And of course, Ruoxi can't help being in the middle of it, knowing perfectly what would go on which will motivate her choices and decision to leave 8th Prince and favour 4th Prince who is kind of cold hearted guy at first but is madly in love with her until the end but denies it, until he realizes he ends up alone, all his brothers gone or put in jail. I also watched the sequel which is quite interesting as it takes place in the modern world and the love between both Ruoxi and 4th Prince (now Yizheng) never ended. It goes together with the message written on the ring he is wearing in both dramas, saying that he will find her into her world as he could not in his! so enjoyable dramas which haunted me for a few days after viewing them!Was this review helpful to you?
IMO, the 2016 K-drama version (Moon Lovers: Scarlet Heart Goryeo) doesn't hold a candle to this Chinese original. Scarlet Heart (aka Startling by Each Step and Bu Bu Jing Xin) was The Untamed before The Untamed. This is a beautiful, heart-wrenching, completely engrossing drama with great acting. The 35 episodes were over before I knew it. I loved it.
Was this review helpful to you?
Story:
Not the most original story but, the execution was perfect. This was my first Chinese historical drama but the amazing thing was that, I got sucked into it from the first episode. Somehow, it didn't feel foreign at all. Scarlet Heart deals with a throne succession and the complex political factions within the royal family. However, this drama is more about the people and their relationships. I think this was the reason why it was so addictive and compelling.
Acting/Cast:
Most of the cast portrayed their characters brilliantly. I've never cried as much as I did watching this drama. The actors were so good that whenever they cried, I cried with them. I know that often dramas use many tactics to make the audience cry but at no point did I feel like I was being manipulated into crying.
Writing:
Gosh, this is one drama I wished that I could understand Chinese. Even though I watched it with subtitles, the dialogues were simply beautiful. I can only imagine how much was lost in translation. I often teared up just from the things that the characters said. The characters were developed really well and so none of them were just good or bad. They were more like people who made bad choices sometimes due to circumstances or misunderstandings.
I found this drama to be incredible moving, because I could actually feel the love and the warm friendships between the characters.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Time Travel Romance Classic
SCARLET HEART (Bu Bu Jing Xin / Startling by Each Step) was such a great show. Once I got sucked in, I could not stop. I really liked the concept of traveling back in time from modern day times to the historical Qing Dynasty era via an accident. Such a great plot and I'm now dying to read the novel which inspired it. There was some truly brilliant acting in this series. Everyone was so interesting and extremely well-casted. Unforgettable.Actress Lui Shi Shi a.k.a. Cecilia Liu was really great as the spunky modern heroine Ma'ertai Ruo Xi (Zhang Xiao) and her wit, charm and personality really brings her character to life. Even when I disagreed with some of her choices, I couldn't help but love her and admire her strength and heart. She is just a character that one can relate with and feel for. Imperfect and sometimes reckless but lovable and well-meaning.
4th Prince (Yinzhen) fascinated me from the very beginning, because he's just that kinda guy, but I did not expect to LOVE LOVE him so much by the end. 4th Prince was so dynamic a character, cold and aloof yet somehow so very expressive; cunning and pragmatic, yet loyal and sincere. Such an intense character. Yes, 4th Prince slayed me. Nicky Wu is such an amazing actor. He rocks and was totally awesome in this role, completely captivating and compelling.
The onscreen chemistry between Ruo Xi and 4th Prince was electric and yet so very tragic. (So sweet to learn the two actors married in real life. The love was visibly real. <3 ) An unforgettable pair, and a truly haunting tragic love...
TEAM 4th PRINCE!! ?
Among my other favorite characters were 13th Prince (Yinxiang), 14th Prince (Yinti), 10th Prince (Yin'e), Emperor Kangxi and Eunuch Li. Many of the female characters were outstanding as well, such as Ma'ertai Ruolan, Lüwu, Gogoro Minghui, Gororo Mingyu, Princess Suwan Guwalgiya-Minmin, Qiao Hui and even Yutan.
8th Prince (Yinsi) was well acted but I could not bring myself to really like his character, or accept his relationship with Rou Xi. His "love" for Rou Xi felt creepy and superficial. 9th Prince (Yintang) was just plain unlikeable. Even still, I enjoyed how diverse and unique each prince and character was. Not a single character felt 2D. In my book, that is great writing and character development. And although the plot is a bit slow at the start it really picks up. Scarlet Heart is so addictive. <3
The whole series was very well done, beautiful sets, intriguing plot, gorgeous costumes, interesting historical portrayals, and amazing , heart-wrenching music. While there is comedy and heavy elements of romance, it is never as heavy as the drama, political intrigue and the ultimate tragedy. This show ripped out my my heart, and then fed it to me, multiple times. The ending, although haunting and moving was very painful. I sincerely loved it though... <3 ((BEWARE: PARTIAL HEA...))
Was this review helpful to you?
I would recommend that you watch this show because it is very well done and has a beautiful story.
Story
The story is about a girl that travels back in time and ends up in her past life. This is a story that is not terribly original but the way the story plays out is unlike any show I've ever seen before. Even now a few weeks after I finished it it is still fresh in my mind.
Acting
The acting was very good. I truly felt like the main girl Riuxi really had these genuine relationships with the princes and her sister. All the actors/actresses did great.
Music
The music was good
Rewatch
I would definitely rewatch this show. In fact, I'm thinking about re-watching it with my mom and sister.
Was this review helpful to you?
Let me tell you why this drama is a masterpiece
This is one the few C-dramas that left a strong impression on me. The other one is Nirvana in Fire.Certain drama next door reminds me why this one is a masterpiece.
Let me tell you what would happen if this drama is filmed in 2023 by capitalist company:
- The princes would be 35 at most.
- The princes wouldn't have any wife.
- The girl only gave her feelings for 1 man. Likely 8th, and stick with him till the end.
Basically, ruin everything that made this story so good because they don't have balls, because they want to use this to promote actors, because they are afraid to be criticized by moral police. Just like Tong Hua's self-produced drama...
Was this review helpful to you?
Worth a watch
Watched this series some time back. It caught my interest because of Damian Lau, Kevin Cheng and Nicky Wu. Initially, I was expecting it to be in Cantonese, so I was mildly surprise to hear it in Mandarin. Have never watched any series with Damian Lau and Kevin Cheng in Mandarin - seen them mostly in TVB. Was a first. But I still love the series. The storyline is, in my opinion, very interesting and intriguing and in certain episodes teeth gritting and frustrating. The entire cast of this series did an extremely great job filming this series - definitely great job! The songs are very beautifully paired with the series.Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
If you're looking for a nice heart warning drama that makes you feel light...let me just stop you right there and tell you that you're not only looking at the wrong show but the wrong genre as well. Exit stage right immediately.This drama was definitely good, I enjoyed it. Right away you fall in love with the story however it does lag a bit around some parts. I really liked it...I finished it in 2 days...HOWEVERR be warned that this drama has a love triangle of sorts and its not the casual one either.
One of the things I absolutely loved about this drama was although politics was obviously involved, it wasn't the typical continuous plotting and scheming and backstabbing and twists and turns...Don't get me wrong plotting and scheming occurred...just not on the down-low. In most cases, everyone was always aware of what was happening. Another thing I loved was the women weren't the villains who were plotting and scheming in this drama or whispering into their men's ear to control them. The men did their own thing and the woman had their own thing happening (I say this because in most cases when the drama did focus on the women it was in relation to their station in life for e.g the wives not getting along...but not in the extreme drama sense where they are always trying to get rid of each other).
Be prepared to cry or at least sniffle. I almost forgot...This drama gets a little dark depending on your preferences...but for me, those dark moments were some of the best scenes in the show...it just added to everything. You'll get used to the hair eventually.
I thought the drama was good overall.I saw a lot of people raving about it and decided to give it a chance but I wont say it was exceptional for me it was just good.
*SPOILERS BELOW*
1. One of the main issues I had with this drama was the love triangle. Initially, the main female lead falls in love with the 8th prince who is married to her sister. Them falling in love was so uncomfortable to watch for me (I watched this drama on Viki and I noticed in the comments a lot of people felt the same way). The female lead prides herself on being modern and she absolutely hates the idea of women sharing men...however, she still manages to fall in love with her sister's husband..it was weird to watch because the writers really explored their relationship it wasn't the usual oh they like each other but she's only with him because he's a rebound and always loved her troupe. They genuinely loved each other. Anyway, if things like that don't bother you then jump right into this drama because this was the only issue I had with it but after this storyline ends (ep 14) it really picks up full steam ahead.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
At first glance, there was nothing interesting about this series. It was just another period romance with a political angle. There was the time travelling, which was totally random and made no sense in the context of the theme. But somehow, halfway through, the series turned into something special. Liu Shi Shi’s Ruoxi was the reason why the first part of the series was so bad. She was also the reason why the second part was so good. Ruoxi took up about 99% of the screen time, a huge burden for any actress to carry. Liu Shi Shi did not have a good grasp of her character in the beginning. She played a modern woman transported into the body of a sixteen-years-old girl, then proceeded to act cute, childish, and completely unlike her real 20-something self. She didn’t give the impression of someone lost in time, trying to a survive in a completely new world. Her worst scenes were the lighthearted ones, like when she was bickering with Mingyu or teasing the princes. Liu just didn’t have that sparkle. She was very pretty, but once she smiled and showed her teeth, the magic was lost. It wasn’t until the second half that you start to appreciate her. She was at her best in scenes that called for anguish and tears. There was a restrained, elegant quality to her acting that fit with the pensive mood of the series. Most importantly, she finally clicked with Nicky Wu’s 4th prince.
The show was excellent in showing the slow and painful breakdown of Ruoxi and the 4th prince’s relationship. There was no stupid misunderstanding, no disapproving parents, no evil people to split them up. These were two people who loved each other deeply, but can’t bring themselves to accept each other’s failings and flaws. It was achingly sad and beautifully acted.
The whole time travel thing was just a gimmick and a really bad one. This was a story about relationships and how love was not always as simple as we wished it to be. Love was not ideal, but still beautiful nonetheless.
Was this review helpful to you?
