The story was executed very well, the love story is exquisite, the way it begins and progresses is all very satisfying, the ending is very well done too. I must point out though that there were certain plot elements such as the mechanism of Do Min Joon's ability to return to earth that were not explained satisfactorily, also the fact that kissing made him ill, that was never explained enough and we're never told whether it was resolved in the end, and for that matter how will they have kids if he can't even kiss her without falling ill? anyway I mean to say that these plot holes were slightly irritating but I was able to suspend logic and enjoyed the show very much.
The casting and acting in this show is excellent, I believe that's it's main advantage even more than the story itself. the main leads are spot on, Kim Soo Hyun was suitably grave and stuffy with flashes of childish pettiness here and there which is absolutely fitting for a 400 year old alien who has had very few human relationships and no romantic ones.
Jun Ji Hyun for me was the star of this show, why isn't she in more dramas? She is absolutely perfect in this role, I'll even venture to say that Cheon Song Yi gives my all time favourite kdrama female lead Kim Sam Soon a very serious run for her money. I enjoyed her acting so much, her vulnerability, her maniacal egotism which reminded me of Dokko Jin was hilarious to watch; I enjoyed all the little monologues she had whether internal or external, I especially loved the way Cheon Song Yi had many moments where she displayed a great depth of feeling, when she expressed how much she loves Do Min Joon either to himself or to other people, she manages to transcend her goofiness and articulates her feelings in the most mature, insightful and heartfelt manner.
The second leads are also very good, I find Yoo In Na almost the same in every role she plays, she's a good actress but I don't see a lot of range in her abilities, maybe that's why she's usually the second lead.
Park Hae Jin on the other hand is a revelation, I've never seen him in anything else so I was very pleased to discover him here. His portrayal of Lee Hui Kyung is very good, for once the second male lead serves to drive the story forward and not to put spanners in the works just because.
His evil older brother was also well acted and was suitably villainish.
The supporting cast was great, Song Yi's family is well portrayed, the detectives are good, and Se Mi's mother also adds a nice touch to the story by providing a contrast to Song Yi's mother.
Overall the casting is a 10 for me.
The music is not prolific, there's just one song that stands out, but that doesn't affect anything for me because my attention was always focused on the story.
Rewatch value is 8, I'm not big on rewatching shows so this is very high coming from me.
Overall is 9, this is a great drama and I only regret that I didn't watch it sooner.
Was this review helpful to you?
"If I could stop the time so we can stay together forever, I would even sell my soul.Because it's so hard for me to feel this way.I had once wished that I had never met you.But even if I could turn back the time, I would meet you again. We would have the same arguments again.You would have fallen in love with me again.I would love you again." ~Cheon Song Yi
Sometimes i wonder if it`s only dramas that can make me so emotional like this,unlike reality.This romantic fantasy drama was a major hit in South Korea and received immense popularity across Asia,starring the great korean stars Jun Ji-hyun and Kim Soo-hyun as the made leads,they instantly brain-wash you into this one amazing impossible Love-story..ahh one of the greatest.I adore both the hero and heroine.Fate was always behind them,and it was time for them to madly fall in love with each other.Song Yi was a very self-loving actress from the start,but really came to be a worthy heroine.Her crazy humor just made me laugh out many times and i just rooted for her with all my heart.As for Do Min-joon (remember the actor from "Dream High",oh he was such a sweetheart),how could you not fall in love with him,when he is the hero every girl wish for.He was doomed when it came to Song Yi already from the start..the power of love.I also very much adored the second male-lead Hee-kyung played by Park Hae-jin are very irresistible too with his charming Golden Boy looks and attitude."My Love from the Star" will make you feel every possible emotion you can feel,ladies and gentlemen!..and get ready for it!
Was this review helpful to you?
And i felt like it was really good. Not the best drama i have seen , but something that would be memorable to me. It has a very deep storyline. I felt like the message which is portrayed is that people can love each other irrespective of who they are.
The journey of Doh Min-Joon and Chun Song-Yi is intriguing and worth watching. Kim Soo-Hyun's portrayal of being an alien was so perfect. He was looking so cute while being enormously handsome. Jun Ji-Hyun also did so good at playing the troublesome actress always being in trouble and having Doh Min-Joon to her rescue. And also i was kind of annoyed by Chun Song Yi's mom but in the end i came to like her.
Now about the OSTs , i am not a big fan of it . Yes , it's good but i didnt like it much. It mostly depends on personal preference
Overall its very good and worth watching in my opinion.
Was this review helpful to you?
Cute story with very engaging leads.
Cute story with very engaging leads. Just don't focus too hard on the plot which has a few holes in it. Jun Ji Hyun is gorgeous and absolutely delightful. Her ability to play goofiness and physical comedy is reminiscent of Sandra Bullock at the same age. Kim Soo Hyun plays quiet strength and vulnerability very well too. The script is by Park Ji Eun who also wrote "The Legend of the Blue Sea" and "Crash Landing on You", and it shares a lot of the feel-good elements of those. Definitely worth a watch!Was this review helpful to you?
The acting for each role is great, you can really tell that all the actors fit their character pretty well.
I liked this drama because:
1) The cast; Mainly Kim Soo Hyun and Jun ji-hyun. I have been a Kim soo hyun fan since "Dream High" so that's how I found out about this drama. I also loved the actor who played the villain in this drama (Shin Sung Rok) because he portrayed the antagonist very well.
2) The story; I do admit that this plot was a unique one. For the people who read the summary and are skeptical, DON'T BE. At first glance, you might find the plot weird and not your style (trust me, that's what I thought), but once you see the first episode and keep going on, it will definitely exceed your expectations.
I didn't like this drama because:
uh...... I can't really find a reason not to like it. I do think that it has a bit too much of crying, but then again, all kdramas have tons of crying. It's just personal preference, though I just feel awkward when i see someone cry.
Hopefully this helped
Was this review helpful to you?
This is one show that made me laugh, then cry, then swoon, then fall in love and dreamed the impossible.
Good looking cast of characters who were so into their role that you believed that they were exactly who they were portraying on the small screen.
And the lipstick that sold out every time they put it on the market. Jun Ji Hyun is exceptionally pretty with her flawless skin and no make up look that I you can just stare at her on screen for hours on end. Kim So Hyun makes man bangs look so devastatingly handsome and IMHO the best looking crying man ever!
Was this review helpful to you?
Some fans didn't care for the ending because it didn't seem complete. I think it was great it left the audience to imagine they are can work around this tricky situation. I would re-watch this drama if I had someone who has never seen it before because it was so good the first time I don't need to do it all over again, if you know what I mean? I have to say I would recommend anybody who loves Korean Drama this is on the top of my list for 2014. I can't wait for their next collaboration. If they have another one.
Was this review helpful to you?
Eventually it became one of my favourite dramas ever! Story wise the drama did have some cliches but the writers did know how to re-write the cliches in a way that was new and fresh using humour and the unique concept of falling in love with an alien.
What sold it for me were the actors, they were refreshing and made each of the characters have a lot of depth. Before this drama I had only ever seen Kim Soo Hyun as the country boy Samdong in Dream High and thought I would find it hard to see him as a manly, cold but good looking alien. Watching this drama made me forget his previous role and his character drew me in. Jun Ji Hyun played her role as a hallyu star in a way which made her seem absolutely crazy but still relatable and loveable. Whilst some may think that her character was too over the top, you have to remember that the drama is about an alien falling in love with a human. So yes there are other aspects that will make it slightly 'out there' but the writers worked hard to still make the realistic and relatable.
Initially I did think that Jun Ji Hyun and Kim Soo Hyun did look slightly strange together, like an aunt and her nephew. But the chemistry won me over and pretty soon I was rooting the two on! :)
Even the villain was great! Just the right among of evil without going too overboard. Shin Sung Rok definitely made me hate him in a good way and I was impressed with his acting skills.
One thing I will say is that Yoo In Naa's character did not have as much of a development that I would have liked.
Music wise, there was nothing too special or memorable. The songs were nice to listen to at the time but I wouldn't find myself listening to the OST again and again.
As for whether I would rematch this again… I already have… 3 times! The humour, the characters and the romance definitely are the things that always make me rematch this drama. This drama is always one that I miss and get a 'drama heartache' because I love it so much. Watch it guys! You won't regret it!
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Not the review you'd be hoping for...
It's been years since I watched this series, and it was the second kdrama I've watched. However, nothing has changed about how I felt about this series.I'm not one to write reviews, so don't expect much from it haha
But in all honesty, the series was a little disappointing and overrated in my opinion. Especially with how it ended.
Though I may be going against the majority of those who loved the series, I was just not sure what the hypes about..nor did I know what to feel about the series, but I really tried to love it.
All in all, the series was alright, it started off great, but it lost me further down the road, and I'm one who tried to finish whatever it is I'm watching, so made it to the end of the series.
I love the lead actors, but their characters weren't the best..I felt no chemistry between the leads.
Wouldn't really watch it again though nor recommend it.
*SPOILER ALERT*
Was disappointed at the end.
I understand that he couldn't stay on Earth because he was dying but like why put the girl in such a situation when he knows he could outlive her or like have to leave?
And she's just waiting for him to come back and she'll never know when he actually can but when he does he decided to pop up to put on a jacket on her because he thought she was showing too much skin and LEFT?! And that's how it ENDED?!
Enough said.
Was this review helpful to you?
The villian's character is well done. Equally creepy and scary. This drama also introduced me to Park Hye Jin. Anyways because people love it so much and I'm in the minority, I would say watch it then judge.
Was this review helpful to you?
Aliens invade my planet! YAY OR NAY!! Well if it's Kim soo Hyun then HURRAY!!
I never realized how sexy he is. He's so flawless. He's like the perfect man anyone would desire.
Sorry guyz, but I'm fangirling here like crazy.
How can u resist a guy who seems so nonchalantly cold but he's so caring n he saves u every time u r in trouble n protects u w all his powers n sacrifice for you no matter what. Well, I m willing to love him!!
Kim soo Hyun and Jeon ji hyeon jst never disappoints!! They are the true famous celebrities!!
Can I jst appreciate the evil villain!! Hahahha he's so daebak being malicious!! Very impressive. Very.
How can anyone possible not watch this? He flies, teleports, super strength, any power, very very good kisses!! Yeahhhh stop hesitating n go meet your alien hubby like right now!!
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Interesting, romantic drama, great actors
Hands down, My Love from the Star is still the best drama I’ve ever watched. Personally, I really like storys which are a bit supernatural, especially with abilities like mind reading etc. This drama was so touching, well written and well acted, that I could watch it countless times. I am so thrilled by the acting, especially of the main lead Kim Soo-hyun. You wouldn’t doubt his sincerity while crying only a second, it basically breaks your heart too. I’ve never seen an actor who conveys such deep feelings while crying. Other than that, the other actors also are really amazing and all the characters were acted out so good. The story was absolutely well written, interesting, romantic, funny and - of course, sad too. Despite I’m not a fan of long-suffering, sad stories, this drama is absolutely worth it! Just make sure you watch it till the very end :) I can recommend it 100 %!Was this review helpful to you?
