alon-luna
'Makjang' or melodrama is either a hit or miss genre for a lot of people. If viewers are aware that Brilliant Legacy falls under this category and know exactly what to expect (frustrating events and character actions, over the top plot twists, etc.) - better yet, if they don't mind or even look forward to watching these extremes, I think this drama may be well liked. It has the added bonus of being not just a makjang but also a romance and a heartwarming family drama. As a result, the frustrating elements are balanced out by the enjoyable ones.
I wanted to give this a higher rating because it is a good drama but I couldn't due to certain flaws.
- I found the heroine too stupid (even for drama land!); normally in these Asian dramas a lot of the female leads are depicted as naive and innocent. Eun Sung IS a likable heroine- she's cheerful, hardworking and resilient. But I have a personal limit as to how ignorant I am willing for my leads to be and unfortunately, Eun Sung went beyond it. Not only did she make the same mistake once or even twice (my limit) she made it around three or four times. It was frustrating for her to make the same mistakes, for these mistakes to blow up in her face, and for her not to learn a thing from the experience and just do it all over again. I wasn't sure what was wrong with her. Even the most naive person would not have made the same error. It made her mentally handicapped brother seem even more intelligent than her at times. I liked her overall, but her characterization was disappointing. If she had at least learned from her first few mistakes and shown some improvement, I would have forgiven her initial stupidity- I have a pretty high tolerance for erring characters who take awhile to grow into better people. I can be patient enough when these characters get better as the show goes on. But in most cases, Eun Sung was saved by plot armor or the characters around her were there to save her from her mistakes. I wasn't even expecting her to be this badass heroine (although I have my favorites for this type as well) just someone who got better after being exposed to harsh realities.
-Her dad was just as dumb as she was. I guess the apple does not fall far from the tree. It's funny how similar these characters are. Well meaning and kind but with no common sense or foresight.
-Her kid brother had only one purpose in the story. To get lost. I guess I can't consider this as a flaw since this is typical makjang. The actor playing the mentally handicapped Eun Woo does a very good job.
- Moon Chae Won is a much better actress than Hyo Joo IMHO, but the way her second female lead was written was a letdown. Since her character was one of the more interesting ones (being the daughter of a wicked witch isn't easy) I had higher expectations for her...I spent most of the drama wishing that Seung Mi would go from merely feeling guilty about what was happening to Eun Sung/Eun Woo, to taking an actual step in doing the right thing. But she never did. In fact, she takes a turn for the worse.. Seung Mi's characterization makes me think of how unfairly female characters are written at times. Often, when a story shows two men fighting for the affections of one woman, the man who loses out is still depicted as noble, good hearted and even willing to help out. But more often than not, a different approach is taken when it comes to two women fighting for one man. Back stabbing, dishonorable behavior (especially on the part of the second female lead/other woman)...while I am aware of the sexism in writing that brings about these differences...the fact that this sexism exists DOES NOT justify any of the resulting actions anyway. Knowing that Seung Mi was depicted unfairly DID NOT make her likeable all of a sudden for me. Nor did I excuse her behavior. True to form- second male lead Jun Se does not get the girl (as expected) but comparatively speaking, he still makes very different decisions at some point in the drama.
- racist comment in the very first episode. I wish they could remove this.
Despite all that, there were a lot of good things I loved about Brilliant Legacy. I normally don't like to watch dramas with more than 20 episodes but this one was enjoyable and fast paced. No boring or dragging moments. No slowing down of the plot midway. It's not everyday I am able to finish a 20 something drama in just a couple of days.
I think what I really loved about this was the relationship of the Grandmother character with the rest of the other characters. I just loved Granny. She was the boss and at the same time, she was what tied everything and everyone together. Brilliant Legacy, Shining Inheritance isn't just about the romance that develops between the leads- it's about how something (in this case, Granny's will/inheritance) brings people together and makes them better. Hwan (the male lead) becomes a much better person -not just because he falls in love with Eun Sung, but because he wants to prove to his grandmother that he is capable of caring for her legacy. He starts out as the most frustrating character at first (I wanted to strangle him) but later on, he goes through one of the most believable character developments I've seen. I wondered at first how on earth Eun Sung could choose him over Jun Se (played very well by Bae Soo Bin, who I know does a fantastic villain in Secret- it was wonderful to see him so good at playing good for once!) but by the end of the show I thought it all made sense. Hwan was probably my second favorite character, after Granny. The growth and realizations he went through were truly inspiring. They were not abrupt in that they did not seem like they came out of nowhere. The way he fell in love with Eun Sung and the good effect she had on his character was a natural progression of that.
The side characters were enjoyable to watch. The butler, Hwan's airheaded mother and sister and even the restaurant staff and manager were all endearing. As for the main villainess...Kim Mi Sook is really good playing the evil stepmother. She is caricature like but this is the norm for a lot of kdramas with villainesses OR villains. No double standards there. They are truly despicable and you love to hate them.
Overall, this was a fun watch with a lot of life lessons. I wouldn't watch it again, but I'm really glad I took the chance to get into something longer than I am used to.
I wanted to give this a higher rating because it is a good drama but I couldn't due to certain flaws.
- I found the heroine too stupid (even for drama land!); normally in these Asian dramas a lot of the female leads are depicted as naive and innocent. Eun Sung IS a likable heroine- she's cheerful, hardworking and resilient. But I have a personal limit as to how ignorant I am willing for my leads to be and unfortunately, Eun Sung went beyond it. Not only did she make the same mistake once or even twice (my limit) she made it around three or four times. It was frustrating for her to make the same mistakes, for these mistakes to blow up in her face, and for her not to learn a thing from the experience and just do it all over again. I wasn't sure what was wrong with her. Even the most naive person would not have made the same error. It made her mentally handicapped brother seem even more intelligent than her at times. I liked her overall, but her characterization was disappointing. If she had at least learned from her first few mistakes and shown some improvement, I would have forgiven her initial stupidity- I have a pretty high tolerance for erring characters who take awhile to grow into better people. I can be patient enough when these characters get better as the show goes on. But in most cases, Eun Sung was saved by plot armor or the characters around her were there to save her from her mistakes. I wasn't even expecting her to be this badass heroine (although I have my favorites for this type as well) just someone who got better after being exposed to harsh realities.
-Her dad was just as dumb as she was. I guess the apple does not fall far from the tree. It's funny how similar these characters are. Well meaning and kind but with no common sense or foresight.
-Her kid brother had only one purpose in the story. To get lost. I guess I can't consider this as a flaw since this is typical makjang. The actor playing the mentally handicapped Eun Woo does a very good job.
- Moon Chae Won is a much better actress than Hyo Joo IMHO, but the way her second female lead was written was a letdown. Since her character was one of the more interesting ones (being the daughter of a wicked witch isn't easy) I had higher expectations for her...I spent most of the drama wishing that Seung Mi would go from merely feeling guilty about what was happening to Eun Sung/Eun Woo, to taking an actual step in doing the right thing. But she never did. In fact, she takes a turn for the worse.. Seung Mi's characterization makes me think of how unfairly female characters are written at times. Often, when a story shows two men fighting for the affections of one woman, the man who loses out is still depicted as noble, good hearted and even willing to help out. But more often than not, a different approach is taken when it comes to two women fighting for one man. Back stabbing, dishonorable behavior (especially on the part of the second female lead/other woman)...while I am aware of the sexism in writing that brings about these differences...the fact that this sexism exists DOES NOT justify any of the resulting actions anyway. Knowing that Seung Mi was depicted unfairly DID NOT make her likeable all of a sudden for me. Nor did I excuse her behavior. True to form- second male lead Jun Se does not get the girl (as expected) but comparatively speaking, he still makes very different decisions at some point in the drama.
- racist comment in the very first episode. I wish they could remove this.
Despite all that, there were a lot of good things I loved about Brilliant Legacy. I normally don't like to watch dramas with more than 20 episodes but this one was enjoyable and fast paced. No boring or dragging moments. No slowing down of the plot midway. It's not everyday I am able to finish a 20 something drama in just a couple of days.
I think what I really loved about this was the relationship of the Grandmother character with the rest of the other characters. I just loved Granny. She was the boss and at the same time, she was what tied everything and everyone together. Brilliant Legacy, Shining Inheritance isn't just about the romance that develops between the leads- it's about how something (in this case, Granny's will/inheritance) brings people together and makes them better. Hwan (the male lead) becomes a much better person -not just because he falls in love with Eun Sung, but because he wants to prove to his grandmother that he is capable of caring for her legacy. He starts out as the most frustrating character at first (I wanted to strangle him) but later on, he goes through one of the most believable character developments I've seen. I wondered at first how on earth Eun Sung could choose him over Jun Se (played very well by Bae Soo Bin, who I know does a fantastic villain in Secret- it was wonderful to see him so good at playing good for once!) but by the end of the show I thought it all made sense. Hwan was probably my second favorite character, after Granny. The growth and realizations he went through were truly inspiring. They were not abrupt in that they did not seem like they came out of nowhere. The way he fell in love with Eun Sung and the good effect she had on his character was a natural progression of that.
The side characters were enjoyable to watch. The butler, Hwan's airheaded mother and sister and even the restaurant staff and manager were all endearing. As for the main villainess...Kim Mi Sook is really good playing the evil stepmother. She is caricature like but this is the norm for a lot of kdramas with villainesses OR villains. No double standards there. They are truly despicable and you love to hate them.
Overall, this was a fun watch with a lot of life lessons. I wouldn't watch it again, but I'm really glad I took the chance to get into something longer than I am used to.
Was this review helpful to you?
