Kate

well Beautiful Minds is melodrama. It's stated as melodrama. And cool for you, you googled stuff and learn a little bit here and there. Does not change the fact that the whole psychological part of the plot is bullshit and it looks like the director of the drama did exactly what you did: googled some stuff and added them without doing some proper research on the topic. It's almost as bad as 'madame antoine' in portraying the psychology.And I doubt they target the same audience: people who like rom-coms watch Doctors, people who like crime-driven stories watch Beautiful Mind. debis said it right: except from the 'medical' aspect (more of 'most of the plot happening in hospital), they have nothing in common. so there's no point in comparing them.

honestly both Doctors and this one is terms of medical aspects are bad shit. The only difference is: Doctors is promoted as a generic rom-com and no one ever said it's some serious shit, while Beautiful Mind was meant to be this deep medical crime melodrama and it fails. Both dramas has some good and bad points. Honestly no idea why you even bring Doctors here.

Ji Hong is such a smooth motherfucker. Every line he says is melting me. The scene where he told Hye Jung he likes her was just way too smooth, I died.

Honestly it's so obvious why Kim Min Jae did what she did. She's so gonna get that professor position she wanted so badly thanks to ratting on Yeong Oh at the end of 5th ep.

I don;t care much about her character at all. this drama would be much better without her... I kind of get Jeong Do's reasons, but Seong Hee is all over ridiculous

1st of all she doesn't know teh basics of her own field. She can't just go around arresting whoever she wants. She does not have any concrete evidence so she can't really arrest anyone. And what's most important: there is no case open... and if there is no case for murder you can't arrest anyone EVER. I might be picky since I'm quite familiar with justice system but with the knowledge she has... she would never be able to pass any exams to be a cop... and it really annoys me

maybe.. maybe not. But the fact she hate's him so much just because he broke heart hurt when she was in high school is ridiculous. In real life people break your heart a lot and you just hate them for a while and then just forget them. I just thought it would be something more serious than teenager's broken heart...

I get it now. Jin Sung is not going to miraculously 'cure' Yeong Oh with a power of love. The 1st thing he will ever feel... 1st emotion will be anger and frustration BECAUSE OF HOW FUCKING DUMB SHE IS.

I can't with Gye Jin Sung. At the beginning I thought it was a good call for her to be a little bit naive (aka believing Suk Joo is innocent no matter what) and inexperienced but the ending of 4th ep killed me... she's just stupid. How did she passed all the tests to be a cop?

well he didn't do anything wrong because he didn't do anything at all hahaha nothing really happened between them in the past when she was his student so I don't see why he wouldn't go after her right now. Now that she is 31 and he is 40... there's nothing wrong with them getting together.

'Are you married yet? Do you have a boyfriend?' THIS SMOOTH MOTHERFUCKER HAHAHAHA I loved this

I agree with everything you said except from the last point. Not many police officers come face to face with real psychopaths and murderers and it is terrifying. It's not something that training can get you ready for. Especially since she was just a normal police woman, who at most had to deal with some drunk dudes or write a ticket for wrong parking. AND she is really young and inexperienced... which makes it more real tbh. If she would just fight him like there's no tomorrow with some mad fighting skills, I would roll my eyes... Coz stuff like that barely happens in real life.

If I have to pick only one drama I have to say: I Hear Your Voice

Honestly I do love this drama so far BUT the back story of Jeong Do and Seong Hee is weak. I was ready for something serious, but it turns out he just broke her heart... It's definitely not satisfying

I think it's matter of personal sense of humor I guess. Coz I find many scenes in this drama funny but I did not laugh much watching You're All Surrounded...

how is this like 'Neighborhood Hero'? It's way more realistic (and not some revenge bond unrealistic story), characters are on point ad believable. It deals with a new topic that hasn't been used in many dramas. Could you explain how it;s like 'Neighborhood Hero' coz I really don't see it?

really? coz I feel like they have great chemistry. Not in a romantic way (at least for now, it would be ridiculous, she's kind of afraid of him) but simply as actors. Does she look a bit young? yeah, but it fits perfectly with how her character is: naive, idealistic and full of passion to change the world.

don't know how it is in Korea but in Poland you have psychological evaluation even to be a driver so...

don't know if you saw the 2nd ep but he was like that since he was a kid. so that's not the case...

don't neurosurgeons have psychological evaluation before they get their license tho? there's no way he would pass it. Anyway, saw 2 episodes, sounds really interesting :)