Top 5 Best Pre-Modern Republican Era Chinese Dramas

W197jaD3_2fea13_f.jpg

I love Historical Asian Dramas. They not only allow you to travel in time far from your modern life worries, but they are also a visual delight. The costumes, the gorgeous settings and the beautifully styled actors make me want to snapshot almost every scene and fill my room with posters from the dramas. Also everything seems more intense. Intrigues are bloodthirsty, battles are epic and of course love is powerful and everlasting. Not to mention the love triangles, my personal favorite Asian drama cliches, that are deadly and excessive. I also like historical dramas for the guaranteed eye candy, and handsome men running around with swords is something worth a look. 

But let’s face it, the traditional long black hats and pink robes make men look like crazy witches in Joseon-era historical Korean dramas, and even Hawick Lau can’t seriously rock a half-bald Qing dynasty hairstyle. Thus, I was always avidly hunting for pre-Joseon, or Goryeo era Korean Dramas (such as Empress Ki) or pre-Qing historical Chinese dramas. But that was before. Before I discovered the magical world of pre-modern, or Republican era Chinese dramas! 

A few words of context: the so-called Republican era in China spans roughly between 1912, following the fall of the last imperial dynasty of the Qing, up to 1949 marked by the civil war and the arrival to power of the communist party. It was a turbulent era that followed over two thousands years of imperial rule in China. An era where the reminiscence of the past was confronted with the reality of war, political turmoil and instability. Chinese dramas set in this period, will either focus on some noble family difficult transition into modernity or stories of young officers raising to military power through wars and revolutions. I also include in this category some beautifully crafted dramas set in the Roaring twenties (1920 & 30) in Shanghai bathed in Fox Trot music, cabaret style singing, short female haircuts and gorgeous decadent dresses (imagine the Great Gatsby visiting China). Needless to say, these pre-modern dramas capitalize on everything we love in historical dramas, minus the dreadful Korean hats and half-bald hairstyles. 

If you have not yet entered the world of Republican era Chinese dramas: stop whatever you are doing and get started! Binge watching is guaranteed! I will introduce you to my current top 5 favorite pre-modern, Republican era Chinese dramas. 

#5) THE CAGE OF LOVE 

D3mjPvY4_fbd93c_f.jpg

Pictures from ‘The Cage of Love’, a 2015 ZJTV drama.

'The Cage of Love' is a story of revenge that puts our upper-society characters in a perilous situation, stuck between family duties and love. The drama has authentically portrayed privileged families working in the textile business in the early Republican era. They are haunted by family grudges, suspicions of murder and treason. Within all this chaos, Wu Cai Hong, the daughter of a previously powerful textile tycoon, meets Jiang Yu, a ruthless businessmen consumed by revenge. Trusting of each other's real identity, the two lovebirds embark on a Romeo and Juliet style romance, tainted by Wu Cai Hong father’s murder investigation.

M4P7GEj3_65c7c4_f.jpg

The drama is visually stunning, authentic as it depicts the world of textile makers, full of angst yet funny and light at the same time. There are love triangles on both sides, even amidst unforgiving family figures. The drama goes beyond revenge and love, as it centers around the investigation of who killed Wu Cai Hong‘s father. And trust me – the answer doesn’t come easily. The drama does has its flaws, such as the  main's female lead's acting skills, which leave much to be desired. On the other hand, the brilliant Hawick Lau does a masterful job. Overall, this is a very enjoyable and entertaining drama. 

For who? If you like revenge dramas spiced by forbidden love, this one is worth a try.


#4) BATTLE OF CHANGSHA

Y4BERWD3_10f7a4_f.jpg

Pictures from ‘Battle of Changsha’ a 2014 BTV drama.

‘Battle of Changsha’ is a family drama that perfectly illustrates the ‘slice of life’ genre. It is set up during the Second World War in 1942, at the peak of Imperial Japan's offensive in China and towards the end of the Republican era. It comes as no surprise, that this particular battle marks a great victory of Chinese forces, and is thus further romanticized through novels and TV. The drama follows the life of Xiang Xiang and her family during the war. It starts with a very unruly and immature female heroine, who along with her twin brother, always get into trouble to the great despair of their parents and grandmother. But the reality of war, and the drama faced by her family will deeply affect and change her.

O3o8Gj04_c97800_f.jpg

The drama is very well made. It even features some black and white, authentic documentary material beautifully integrated into the drama’s plot. The settings are meticulously created and all the actors did an amazing job. There is love, although it is not the central focus of the drama. But let me just say five words on that: Wallace Huo in a uniform!

 Wallace Huo plays a high ranking military officer from a privileged family. He is both respected and righteous. Watching him running around covered in dust, carrying an antique gun in the name of freedom, makes this a must watch. I won’t lie to you, the drama is dark and sad at times. But there is an epic feel to it, that keeps you coming for more. 

For who? If you're looking for a more mature and deep family drama, with war and complicated characters. 


#3) TOO LATE TO SAY I LOVE YOU

PLpnzvE4_c7ff7e_f.jpg

Pictures from 'Too Late to Say I Love You', a 2010 HBTV drama.

‘Too Late to Say I Love You’ is a powerful and often violent drama. Set amidst a period of civil war and military unrest, it is the story of a rich merchant's daughter who falls into the grasp of a powerful and strong-willed, high ranking military officer, all while trying to save her childhood sweetheart and fiancé.

Wallace Chung plays an officer blinded by desire, who goes to great extremes to get the woman he wants.

mLn6xVOL_8880a0_f.jpg

The drama doesn’t feature a love triangle, but is instead closer to a love square or pentagon. The love story is spicy and as explosive as one can hope. Even for me, some scenes and plot developments were borderline shocking, so sensitive people should watch this with caution. You've been warned!

For me, the biggest flaw of this drama is its main heroine. Both the actress and the character she plays are slightly annoying. In her defense, I should mention that she is surrounded by characters with big egos and overwhelming personalities, which honestly can be stressful. 

For who? This is great for those looking for obsessive, overbearing love in a violent setting. 


#2) CRUEL ROMANCE

61G7rj91_adf6d2_f.jpg

Pictures from ‘Cruel Romance’, a 2015 Hunan TV drama.

Despite the title, the love story in ‘Cruel Romance’ is rather gentle and romantic. In this drama we enter the dark world of Chinese gangsters and their internal war for power. The drama tells the story of Rong Jinxiu, an ordinary country girl who travels to Shanghai, after barely escaping from the brutal murder of her entire family. In Shanghai, she meets the devilishly attractive and dangerous, gangster leader, Zuo Zhen. Of course, they both fall in love. Set next to Zuo Zhen, who is an old style bad boy with a tender heart, the main girl is surprisingly not your usual, naive girl-next-door type. She has her weaknesses, but overall she handles her role well, while also being easy on the eyes. This drama is never boring because there is so much going on along with many plot twists that spice things up. 

V3WjKmZL_def826_f.jpg

Apart from the main OTP, the characters of Yin Ming Zhu - an attractive Shanghai singer, and the murderous Japanese officer Maeda Ryuichi, lift the drama to new heights. Maeda Ryuchi is officially one of my favorite evil drama characters. He's both manipulative and insane. Not only is he the psycho of the drama, but he is also ‘romantically’ involved. Tension guaranteed!

For who? Those who like dramas with lots of action, plot development and intense love. 


#1) LADY AND THE LIAR

81y8k6Y4_df0704_f.jpg

Pictures from ‘Lady and the Liar’, a 2015 JSTV drama.

I wonder why among all these great dramas, ‘Lady and the Liar’ is still my favorite. Maybe it's because of its beautiful costumes and appealing setting of the still vain and carefree, pre-war Shanghai. Or maybe it's because my beloved Hawick Lau plays the role of a powerful gangster lord, nicknamed the ‘ Wolf’. 

Also, despite the naive plot elements, the story flows naturally. ‘Lady and the Liar’ is set in 1930 Shanghai. It shows the story of Jiang Xin, a wealthy heiress who disappeared as a child and grew up in poverty. On the verge of finally being reunited with her loving, rich family, she gets into an accident. Not only does she lose her memory, but she also gets her identity stolen by a scheming female thief, Du Xiao Han. In the midst of this family drama, the ‘Wolf’, bewitched by our main girl, will take advantage of the situation. 

l4j9X0P3_94ab9b_f.jpg

For who? This is perfect for those who have a weakness for gangsters and visually pleasing dramas that contain elements of obsessive love. 

I can’t finish this top Pre-modern Republican era drama list without mentioning two dramas that are still on my 'Plan to Watch' list. I haven’t seen them yet because either they haven’t aired yet or no subtitles are available for them. 

Plan to Watch List: A Beauty in Troubled TimesSparrow

d3krlw0L_687501_f.jpg

I watched only one episode of A Beauty in Troubled Times (or Luan Shi Jia Ren). It's a drama starring set in 1930 Shanghai. It is definitely promising. It is supposedly a drama of complicated love plots and hardships. But the promise of intense love and the pre-modern setting is what appealed to me. It is either an underrated, or a disappointing drama, because the subtitles for it are still nowhere to be found. As for Sparrow, I recently saw a trailer for it and it looked EXTREMELY good. The drama is set in revolutionary Shanghai, and follows a secret agent called ‘the Sparrow’.

84J7nbN1_8ebdc0_f.jpg

Screenshots from ‘Sparrow’ a 2016 Hunan TV drama.

For more top 5 drama recommendations, check out my KBeauty and Asian Dramas blog – Korea in Beauty

Have you watched any dramas from this list? Which one is your favourite and why? Any other pre-modern Chinese dramas you loved?

Comments (26)

  • Login or Register to post comments
  • Reply
    Myauntmary 11 days ago - edited

    Among those mentioned, I've watched Battle of Changsha and Too Late to say i love you.

    Both are really good.

  • Reply
    Mighty_Brosia 11 days ago

    Im loving sooo much the Battle of Changsha.. My first war drama and I must say. hats down to all the characters.. Jun Shan was the best..

  • Reply
    KAPP70 Jan 25, 2017

    I've seen 4 out of the five and liked them all. That being said The Disguiser definitely needs to be on the list.

  • Reply
    Osukayun Jan 9, 2017
    Reveal Spoiler »
  • Reply
    PickyMcpickleton Jan 3, 2017

    The Disguiser is the only one I've watched. I'm not sure I like these historicals or I simply haven't warmed up to it. In Western shows, I love it but in Asian dramas it's a little jarring. I did enjoy The Disguiser purely for entertainment value and it was at times so beautifully filmed.

  • Reply
    alice Oct 23, 2016

    This post is more than two months old. I hope OP see this, coz if you like Republican era, you should also watch Rookie Agent Rouge. I just recently finished watching. You will definitely love it. It's available on Viki. I wasn't expecting it to be that intriguing but i love watching all 45 ep. The casts are my favorite too, Zhao Li Ying and Lu Yi.

  • Reply
    rainruma Aug 16, 2016 - edited

    Unlike others, I din't think Too Late to Say I Love You was particularly more violent or more bloody than similar C-dramas ... Did anyone see Scarlet Heart? Or any Palace movie?

    Battle of Changsha is historical and about war, of course war is ugly!..(excellent, btw)

    Similarly, TLTSILY is also historicaly-based about Chinese Civil war ... Murong Feng's based on real person (w/ alterations to history)... Murong Feng is a "Warlord", he governs the Northern provinces . He has duty and responsibility for all the citizens, can't just do what he wants.... thousands may die if he messes up.
    He's an anti-hero, has flaws, ambitions, selfishness, duty, loyalty, etc... That should explain many of his actions/decisions.
    Also, It is a historical law in China, to punish the three generations of kin of offender, sometimes even more extended family... that's normal.
    As for him pulling a gun on her in 1st 2 minutes of drama, it was to show his pain, passion and how important she/they are to him ... I think it makes him a believable character, as the governor, always wary of the next traitor, enemy coming from w/in... he was in a constantly heightened aggravated state at that time.... It fits his character.

    Anyway, a lot more interesting than the other gangster heroes who never actually commit any violence. For me, there is one WTH moment towards the end, but it soon blew over.
    It's not a drama about cute moments...it's about real flawed people, about their growth ... and above all, about their PASSIONATE Love!

    In Cruel Romance, Maeda is my favorite, one hot villain...maybe that's my taste...lol!

  • Reply
    Trouble-chan Aug 15, 2016 - edited

    I've watched a few of these and my all time favourite was 'Cruel Romance' - acting was a bit OTT in places, but it really had the spirit of the 30s era movies as well as being set in that era. I thought the 'antiheroes' were exceptionally well done and you were really rooting for them - along with the (very) bad guys who you were desperate to see die; preferably with great pain and suffering.

    Huang Xiao Ming was absolutely brilliant as Zou Zhen; his utterly focused and unwavering love for Rong Jin Xiu was breathtaking (especially as she as an utter moron when it came to her own safety and those who meant her harm). It had a few slow moments, but overall I thoroughly enjoyed it and will be watching it more than once I can guarantee - in fact if I can find a region free, English subbed DVD I will also be buying it! I'd give a 9.5/10.

    'Battle for Changsha' was my next favourite - I'm a sucker for Huo Wallace and usually find if he's in it then it's usually pretty good. Once again I was not disappointed. This didn't really have the old time elegance and plot of 'Cruel Romance' - it was more like an historical 'docudrama' and so could be quite slow in places. But the characters were believable, the setting suitably bleak and the story more than watchable. I'd give it 8/10.

    As for the others - Hawick Lau steals the whole show in 'The Cage of Love' - I'd give it 7/10 because it seemed more obsessed with (admittedly gorgeous) cinematography than the plot which meant the latter lagged a lot in places.

    As for 'Too Late to Say I Love You' - Wallace Chung once again excels as the obsessively in love main lead; although this time his character is much darker and much less sympathetic than the one he played in 'My Sunshine'. Overall it had many 'oh my!' moments and not a few 'bl**dy hell!' ones too. But the shock factor doesn't always make something good, so I give it 7/10.

  • Reply
    silvermcv Aug 15, 2016

    I am going to check a few of these out. I am watching They Mystic Nine right now and I love the costumes and setting.

  • Reply
    IAmNikkyG Aug 14, 2016

    Battle of Changsha FTW!

  • Reply
    JaebumIsMyLife Aug 14, 2016

    i freaking love watching pre modern drama, and I have watch cruel romance, lady and the liar, the girl who wear earring, and destined to love you... omg it was all good, I have to said pre modern drama is my type of drama, the clothes and everything is just to beautiful..
    

  • Reply
    KMR Aug 14, 2016 - edited

    Wow. I agree with so many things. I think what I like the most in republican era drama is the visuals: the settings, costumes (LOVE the fashion of this period), colors.
    My favorite in the list is Cruel romance...only the first part though...the second half of the drama was ruined.
    I dropped The cage of love but don't remember why. Battle of Changsha is truly good but the ending was too much...I like the realism in the depiction of war and its impact on people's everyday life but at the same time it was just so :((((( Same for Too late to say I love you...can't handle too much violence. I didn't enjoy lady an liar because of the cliché and I was really looking for something different at the time, but still it's a nice drama I think.

    I recently watched THE DISGUISER and it's really good too.

    • Reply
      Akudie Aug 14, 2016

      True, Lady and the Liar is a bit cliche, and Tiffany Tang is so annoying at times hahah (and sooooo thin! a bit too much) but it is still so sweet cause Hawick Lau is mega sexy in it hahaha ;) Cage of love I have put on hold for a long time because of the subtitles - but then picked it back up and liked it - the OST was beautiful (ending song)

  • Reply
    marisols12 Aug 14, 2016 - edited

    I agree with you 100%, I have seen them all and I believe that there all great, they each have it's own beauty. I can't pick which one is my favorite. If you haven't seen any of these give them a try, even though they have quite a few episodes, they're worth it.

  • Reply
    BJW Aug 14, 2016

    Thank you for this blog. I agree with you. These are all great examples .

  • Reply
    sunflower63 Aug 14, 2016 - edited

    Thanks for writing this article. I happened to discover C dramas by chance and my first one was Cruel Romance...I was absolutely fascinated by the time period represented and by the sceneries and the costumes too.
    Out of the dramas that you listed I also watched Battle of Changsha, Too Late to Say I love You and most of Lady and the Liar (which I couldn't finish as complete subs were missing). All of them are amazing dramas.
    I will keep an eye on the two new ones that you mention, mostly because the subbing situation is always a little tricky.

    • Reply
      Akudie Aug 14, 2016

      hi! Happy you liked it! For Luan Shi Jia Ren (beauty in troubled times) it used to be translated in Viki but then was taken down and never put up again :/ It is also the reason I included it in this list, as to draw more people attention on this promising drama and maybe finally be able to watch it (if some charitable soul helps us out here ;)

    • Reply
      Katelynn Brooks Dec 9, 2016

      haha Cruel Romance is my first one too and now I want to watch them all. And of course I can't and I have too many choices and I'm spinning in circles like a puppy with too man toys.

  • 0Articles
  • 0Likes
  • 0Follows

Akudie's most recent articles...

Newest Articles

Most Popular Articles