This discussion just came up on the drama Hit the Spot, which has been labelled "extreme sexual content" and I disagree with that usage, the "sexual content" tag seems more than sufficent. 

It seems to me that these tags are used inconsistently and the defintions aren't clear on what counts as what. What do we consider "extreme" and "very explicit". (outside of "oh this is obviously pornography" or should the extreme sexual content tag only be for erotica/porn?)

For example the movie Love Clinic has the same level of sex scenes that Hit the Spot does but only has the "sexual content" tag.  The Handmaiden is another example which only has the "sexual content" tag.  Should those tags be amended? 

I think given that what's considered "extreme" sexual content may vary by person it may help to have clearer definitions of how we want these tags to be used on the site to help people in choosing what tags to add to a work. And to help other users in finding the kind of content they want to watch (or avoid).

These are the definitions we're currently working with:

Mild Sexual Content
The show depicts sexual behavior which is not very explicit.

Sexual Content
Material depicting sexual behavior which may be explicit.

Extreme Sexual Content
The depicting extreme sexual behavior which may be very explicit.

I suppose what I'm trying to understand is how are we  defining "sexual behaviour" vs "extreme sexual behaviour" and "may be explicit" vs. "may be very explicit".  Does simulated sex without clothing automatically put us into the extreme here? I imagine if I'm confused maybe others are as well?

4votes

The MDL Approval Staff team are currently in the midst of re-organising, re-defining and cleaning up the tags, particularly the trigger and content-related tags (of which the Sexual Content tags are among them). So, your patience is kindly appreciated as we gradually address these one-by-one in turn.

We have already started canvassing for feedback from MDL users for some of these type of tags to get a feel of various user perceptions on them in order to help the MDL Approval Staff come up with appropriate definitions and apply a consistent roll-out. 

Examples:-

1) Brief & Prolonged Nudity: https://mydramalist.com/profile/Suegarbaby/feeds/BK2x2sE

2) Blood & Gore: https://mydramalist.com/profile/chunyu/feeds/jPV4mhj

3) Full & Partial Nudity: https://mydramalist.com/profile/NoirRoseHeart/feeds/4l63pCA

Therefore, please do be on the lookout on the Feeds if this sort of discussion and topics are of interest to you. Feedback is always welcome, and patience & cooperation in these matters are greatly valued. 

Thank you. 

Thank you! Nice to know this is on the docket, I'll keep my eyes peeled for those roll outs.