Closed

Issues regarding fake ratings and reviews

This discussion has been closed.

Hello admin,

There's an issue that a lot of us have been noticing, especially in these last 2-3 months.  Apparently, lots of spam accounts have been downrating and posting fake reviews on dramas that have not aired yet or are in currently airing list.

There are lots of fake reviews being posted in the drama pages with 'completed' status when the dramas have just started airing. People are creating spam accounts to write hate comments on actors/actress and downrate their works intentionally, to vent their hate.

So this is a sincere request. Is it possible to have the review and rating system of overall drama closed until the drama has completed airing.

A lots of us international fans rely on this website for ratings and reviews of dramas. So these manipulated ratings are very unhelpful for us. So could please take action, in order to ensure better reviews and ratings by closing the review and rating system until complete airing of all episodes in every drama.

we all international fans are relying on MDL  for drama rating so please understand our situation ...drama like SAF 6  with good script , cast and high budget  is rated so low , that i really can not believe on MDL in future ...

i also wants that ratings and reviews should start when 2/3 drama completed airing ...  and also please check if there is a malfunction going on with drama page of SAF  ....

thanks 

Just replying to show my support for this as well. It's annoying to see certain dramas constantly reviewed and rating bombed just because people don't like a certain actor or whatever (or the opposite).

Aayushblink04's suggestion of allowing ratings and reviews when the drama is 2/3 done airing is perfectly reasonable I think. 

Please Mdl do something about your rating and review system , haters are spoiling our total mood of drama and many of viewers also hesitate to start dramas because of low ratings ...

because of haters can make many accounts , rating on MDL  are no longer reliable ....

it is really a good suggestion to start rating and review after 2/3 of drama completes airing ...

MDL should hide the ratings until the drama end. Otherwise haters can easily target the drama and bring down the ratings. And it should stop the review section until all the episodes are out.

And I believe there is something wrong with ratings of Sword And Fairy (By Xukai and Esther Yu). Overall rating is 7.7 which is lower than the "Currently watching rating" and "Verified stars rating". And the drama hasn't ended yet. But some percentage of  rating by "completed" viewers were seen which was low.

MDL should fix this.

Aoi Community Manager

Reviews don't impact the rating directly, and we have measures in place to combat fake ratings. While we're in the process of developing a solution for ongoing reviews, it's still a work in progress. Restricting users from reviewing ongoing shows could potentially disrupt the experience for long-running dramas, as users might forget to review them after they finish.

can you please check , if there is a problem on drama page of SAF ...

all the comments and reviews are positive but ratings are very bad and stuck for several days ...

i understand your point but the problem of SAF  should be resolved quickly ...it spoiling my mood to see 7.7 rating everyday ...

 Aoi:

Reviews don't impact the rating directly, and we have measures in place to combat fake ratings. While we're in the process of developing a solution for ongoing reviews, it's still a work in progress. Restricting users from reviewing ongoing shows could potentially disrupt the experience for long-running dramas, as users might forget to review them after they finish. 

Check out the rating of Sword and Fairy 6.

There is definitely a bug that you have to fix. Overall rating is 7.7 which is low compared to the other indicator. We didn't see this problem with other dramas.

 Aoi:

Reviews don't impact the rating directly, and we have measures in place to combat fake ratings. While we're in the process of developing a solution for ongoing reviews, it's still a work in progress. Restricting users from reviewing ongoing shows could potentially disrupt the experience for long-running dramas, as users might forget to review them after they finish. 

So is there any possible way to prevent these fake ratings or report them. Cause we don't even know who gives these fake ratings. So we can't even point out  spam accounts that are being created just to lower the ratings.

Aoi Community Manager
 Xu Yi:
Check out the rating of Sword and Fairy 6.

There is definitely a bug that you have to fix. Overall rating is 7.7 which is low compared to the other indicator. We didn't see this problem with other dramas.

Which other indicators are you referring to?


 nightdews:
So is there any possible way to prevent these fake ratings or report them. Cause we don't even know who gives these fake ratings. So we can't even point out  spam accounts that are being created just to lower the ratings.

We have systems in place to address fake ratings, both for ratings of 1 and 10, and we also have measures in place for new accounts. The main issue we observe is a lack of ratings, especially for newer shows.

 Aoi:

Which other indicators are you referring to?


We have systems in place to address fake ratings, both for ratings of 1 and 10, and we also have measures in place for new accounts. The main issue we observe is a lack of ratings, especially for newer shows. 

Like the rating for "Currently watching is 8.54" and "Verified star rating is 7.98"

But the drama has overall 7.7

The dropped percentage is around 1%. So it won't affect much.

Other dramas have overall ratings higher than the Verified star rating. But how come the rating is low in this drama.

i have the same point as Xu yi ...

SAF 4 has verified rating 7.5 but total rating is 7.8 ....how can it be justified , there is definitely a problem going on this page ...

Aoi Community Manager

Yes, that's approximately 1% of 6000. The "Currently watching" and "Verified rating" don't include dropped viewers, so their average would be higher. If you calculate (7.56 + 2.98 + 7.98 + 8.53) / 4, it would be 6.7 (though this is not the correct way to average, it serves as an example). The overall rating takes into account all viewers, including those who dropped it, which contributes to the lower overall rating. The main problem we observe is the limited number of ratings or credible user ratings.

There's a flaw on mdl that let people rate drama ahead of drama completion, this can be abuse by haters of new dramas to bring down their rating.