Brilliant From Start to Finish

This was a superbly directed, excellently acted, perfectly paced, satisfyingly finished, extremely well-told story.

Being someone who prefers a well-told story over one filled with unnecessary filler dialogue, gore, action, romance, and sidekick characters, I have to give this a 10/10 for having absolutely none of those things. Everything, every scene, every character had a story and a purpose that you weren’t left hanging too long to find out what that was.

I’d like to see much more of this type of directing in the future.

If you are after non-stop action, this probably isn’t for you. If you like a well told story, it most definitely is.

Read More

Beautiful Blend of Genres

Though the ML got on my nerves at times, and the FL was good, but not as good as her childhood character, this series manages to blend sports, murder mystery, romance, small town beauty and drama, friendship, and past secrets seamlessly. It’s not too much of anything, and just the right amount of everything.

I was completely wowed by the sportsmanship of the ML (and supporting characters). They made every match interesting and engaging, but it was not the total focus of the show. I still can’t believe they were able to mix all these things in without creating a total mess. Color me extremely impressed.

The entire cast was amazing, but the child actors really did me in. They were outstanding.

Read More

Captivating

I found myself captivated from the start due to Kim Seo Hyung’s sheer presence. She’s a favorite actress of mine anyway, but her portrayal of a self-esteem stripped demure housewife at the outset was believable and quite jarring. Her character’s development and actions were an understandable and seamlessly woven together tapestry of chain events.

The husband, (played brilliantly by Gong Jung Hwan), was astonishingly one of of the most calm (usually), callous and selfish characters I’ve ever seen. At one point I became convinced that the character had to have studied all the ways to strip a person’s soul of any self-worth.

Lee Shi Hoo was another important character, and his arc was poignant, though disappointingly familiar.

I felt the elder actor’s performances shone brightly and I appreciated the sympathy or lack of sympathy each invoked due to their role’s character.

I now realize this is a remake, so as such, my only criticism is probably not valid: I would have preferred a more complete ending. We do get a lot of closure, so I am thankful for that. But I still have questions. That said, I definitely recommend this and would watch again.

*Be aware of a couple of racy scenes that are brief, and in my opinion, shouldn’t shock the senses of your average adult who recognizes and appreciates that attraction and intimacy are things that don’t belong to only one gender or age group.

Read More

Inescapable Consequences

I adore Yoo Seung Ho, and his performance in this did not disappoint. His embodiment of his character was so raw and poignant. I have to say that he pulls off the most anguish-filled scenes with the most earnestness and gut-wrenching acting I’ve ever seen and heard. That’s right, “heard.” His cries of anger, of sadness, of sheer frustration always manage to bring tears to my eyes and pain to my soul. He’s an underutilized gem of the industry and I wish I could see more of him, more often.

My praise of his talent isn’t the only reason I loved this drama, though. Kim Dong Hwi and Yoo Su Bin, (the latter of which’s heartwrending scenes were almost too much to bear), both brought their A-game as well. I was impressed by the entourage of characters who also brought this tragedy of judgement errors to life.

It’s a tale of common enough desperation leading to fortunately not so common actions and the toll those actions inevitably bring to bear on all. I actually even enjoyed the opening sequence(s), (rare for me), and the subtle yet haunting music score. Highly recommend, and will definitely watch again.

Read More

Missed Potential

Pros:
Loved the cast
Liked the soundtrack
Found the premise interesting

Cons:
Plot holes
Sometimes disjointed editing / scene jumping
Adding new questions without answering the old questions
Adding new characters at the end
Leaving too much to a potential S2, instead of a safe 99% conclusion with a slight hint of potential for more

I have been disappointed in the finales in Kdramas the majority of the time for years now. I can usually handle it as a mild frustration. This one left me shaking my head in wonder and for a while, I had no words…

I hope the director learned that you have got to provide your audience with actual answers that they have been faithfully watching for weeks and waiting for.

Read More

Intriguing & Suspenseful

I have not watched the original, but I found this absolutely engaging from start to finish. I’m shocked at the excessively mixed reviews. I haven’t seen reviews this mixed about a show I liked since…ever.

I’ve seen rave reviews of shows I’m lukewarm about (10 when I think it’s a 5), and poor reviews of shows I’ve loved (5 when I think it’s at least 8-10). But never have I seen a show that I was this impressed with range between a 2 and 10. That’s an abnormal range for something of this quality.

I can only guess that perhaps some of the undeserved poorest ratings stem from this not being the original, instead of judging this series on its own considerable merits. Based on the quality of this remake, I’m even more inclined to watch the original La Casa del Papel.

All that said, I had to come lend support through review. This is a high quality, suspenseful, thought-provoking, social commentary series that will have you wondering who you’re supposed to be rooting for, because life is actually just not that black and white.

I really appreciated the aspect that this whole fictional scenario, set in 2025, is not out of the realm of possibility between North and South Korea when money is the object and point. It’s completely feasible that the longing for reunification by the people might make them overlook what could be ulterior motives at the root.

Fair warning: There are a couple of s*x scenes, but they’re not anything to be overly offended by in my opinion, and they don’t last too long. Of course there is a lot of fighting and shooting, but nothing gory or over the top.

I do recommend this drama. I would watch it again and will. And I commend the entire cast for their very apparent hard work.

Read More

Very Enlightening

I’ve read some of the negative reviews and I guess I didn’t see what they saw.

I was very impressed with the FL from start to finish. She showed all the emotions, all the attitude, all the despair, all the determination, never came across as too over the top, ever. Loved her.

Some characters were a little much at times, but those behaviors fit those characters.

I enjoyed the story, though it was often quite disheartening, and really enjoyed the well executed plot twists. Could have had a slightly better ending, but I’ve endured much worse ones - this was fine.

I would recommend and would watch again.

Read More

Emotional Reflection of Life

This is not a romcom, in my opinion. This is a romance-melodrama with some nice touches of well done humor. It’s far more than the slice-of-life I was anticipating. I’m trying hard to not give anything away. I’ve seen some very touching stories before, and even shed a few tears - but I’ve never felt this emotionally invested, with lasting after-affects, as I’ve experienced with QoT. No, not everything was perfect, but neither is life, so I found this drama to be perfectly imperfect. This drama brings powerful performances from the entire cast, a poignant storyline, breathtaking scenery and cinematography throughout, an outstanding OST, and brings out personal reflection about life and love.

I consider a show rewatchable if I want to see it again “sometime soon”. With this, I’m ready to rewatch it right now, have played the last 15 minutes at least 7 times already, and have the last song on repeat on Spotify. I NEVER do this. Kdrama endings are often cute, sometimes rewarding, but usually dissatisfying for me. This one has some controversy, but for me, it was complete.

Read More

Disappointing Finale

Though I enjoyed the show for what it was, and the ML is a personal favorite, and the acting of most of the other characters was top notch, I was a little bored at times with this dialogue heavy and slow-rolling series. There was so much reading of the subtitles only for them to not have actually said much to advance the story, that I just felt weary after each episode. I can't say much one way or the other about the FL. She just seemed stuck on one expression, and frankly looked way too feminine to be convincing as a man, no matter how hard I tried to suspend disbelief. If they are going to keep making shows about women convincingly dressing as a man in the Joseon era, they ought to try with someone taller than 5'4" and a little more body presence than the fraily built supermodel types they keep casting.

Episodes 14 and 15 were quite good, so I was expecting some good wrap up of the main "problem", but alas, they just wouldn't do it. The finale was either rushing you through time with narratives from side characters, or plodding through nonsensical scenes from the leads. It's absolutely unclear why she'd be avoiding him, the queen dowager's issues never get resolved, the maidservant clearly has a crush but we never see anything come of it, and the overarching dilemma never gets addressed at all - how will they reintroduce this person as a woman who the king wants as his queen. I mean, sure, the villains getting their due was interesting and all, but the woman dressed as a man issue was the main point of interest and I feel emotionally ripped off by them not properly tying that up.

Read More

Just Too Much

I’m American, so it’s not like I’ve never seen all the R-rated stuff in nearly everything produced over here. But I’ve had enough of all that, which is why I mostly watch Kdramas now.

I’m unhappy to see any westernization of the genre, but I’m not saying that these types of dramas can’t be made. I AM saying that anything with the degree of depicted animal cruelty and disturbingly vivid forced intercourse needs a substantially stronger warning about content than I understood from the rather tame description.

Yes, I know that shows put a little blurb top left at the beginning to list the possibly offensive stuff to the audience, but with Kdramas, I’ve never felt like I had to actually pay much attention to those. Guess that’s changing…

Read More